Very good spot for Mediterranean bites and I always get their juicy Souvlakis. Staff is always friendly and situated in a nice neighborhood with ample private lot. read more

See all

Catered from Yummy Gyro for a party of 40 people and everyone loved it. Nesi made it super easy to place the catering order. We had tzatziki dips, spanakopita, zucchini fritters, two types of salads (villager was a hit) chicken skewers, beef and lamb shawarma, broccoli rice and pitas. The food arrived piping hot as well so easy to keep warm in warming trays before people dove in. Will definitely be ordering from again. read more

Yummy Gyro - The spread - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

Decided to visit this local Greek spot because so many others in the area are just too overpriced, especially for a simple gyro. We usually online order and the food is always ready on time. My wife enjoys a simple gyro pita sandwich or chicken souvlaki sandwich. My go to is usually a chicken souvlaki platter with rice. My one standout item was the weekly special of an entire rotisserie chicken for $10. I thought it would be a small chicken but it was a huge portion enough to feed the whole family. That was impressive. I've also ordered their family trays with a variety of meat and pitas and potato's to share and the portions are super generous. There may be better Greek spots but for the flavors, price, and portion, yummy gyro is a good option. read more

Tried yummy gyro again and yes, they are still yummy. They cleaned up the menu and I seem to understand it now and I ordered correctly. They still haven't cleaned up their production capacity. You still wait a reasonably long time to get a Gyro sandwich but it was worth it. It was tasty, hot and delicious. Sometimes you just have to have a little patience. Will come back. read more

Yummy Gyro - Awesome spring day with their outdoor seating - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

I ordered a $65 meal because I had to pay extra for stuff and well the tip of course was included...and after picking it up and opening it at home I realized that they gave me the wrong order so I called right away and the boss told me don't worry that's their fault give him 10 mins and he'll send my order with his driver but it never came and we never got our food. This place is not recommended by me at all! they're the worst and they're liars!!! read more

I ordered from Uber Eats and this was my first time getting Greek from here! I got a chicken gyro combo with rice pilaf. unfortunately the rice was a little dry but the gyro was DELICIOUS! the chicken was juicy and plentiful on the gyro and the gyro wasn't overflowing with taziki sauce (it had just the right amount for me). would definitely order again! read more

A delicious convenient way to get your Greek on... tzatziki and babaganoush had plenty of garlic like they are supposed to. Th lamb/beef gyro was tender and generous, the salads had plenty of feta. Even the burger was good! Kali Oreksi! read more

Yummy Gyro - Greek Salad - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

See all

Dinner time for the kids! We tried a local gyro shop: Yummy Gyro. Ambience: a small takeout type place with limited seating. Food: we ordered the Gyro family pack which consisted of: Pork Donner: chunks of savory roasted pork. 4/5 Chicken Gyro - I wasn't a fan of this as it felt like eating a roasted slices of processed cold cuts instead of slices of chicken. 3/5 Lemon potatoes - lemony starch to complement the protein. 4/5 read more

See all

I recently had major knee surgery so have had to order a lot of take out. I had a terrible experience with YUMMY GYRO on Willis A-ve . They are about 4-5 blocks from my home After waiting for 1 & 1/4 hour I was called by their delivery person who said they couldn't find my home - after questioning him he told me he was in New Hyde Park -I have ordered from them many times and my address in WP was in their system associated with my phone number. I spoke with the owner when I called and explained the food was late and came cold -he offered to REFUND 4 $ for the cold food on a nearly 40$ order,. I'm writing to let you know about this experience in the hopes you don't have a similar experience should you choose to order from them, His response did not strike me as appropriate when I was told the food would arrive in under 1/2 hour and when it finally did come it was ice cold. read more

Generally OK. Food very tasty. Prices top of the line for takeout. Watch out ordering online they add themselves a substantial tip if you're not observant. read more

We needed a quick meal late one weekend and yummy gyro came through. We ordered Greek salad and gyro. Both were fine, lettuce wasn't the freshest. Very average read more

I was disappointed to find that all the lettuce in the greek salad was completely brown. When I called to let them know, they neither answered or returned my call. Serving customers rotten lettuce, and then not acknowledging it, is unacceptable. read more

Best Gyro on Long Island! They absolutely stuff the pitas with loads of gyro meat, sauce, and cheese so there is zero room for complaint when it comes to getting great value for your dollars. The gyro meat itself is fresh and juicy but the tzatziki sauce is where it's at -- dip your fries, your pita, your fingers, you name it! Owner is a nice guy who's been here for almost 15 years so he knows the keys to success are great food, great value and great customer service. At $9.95 the gyro is a great deal. $12.95 gets you delicious fries and a can of soda. When in Williston, do as Willistons do! Head to Yummy Gyro! read more

Yummy Gyro - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

Perfect gyro Gone here 3 times so far and each time the gyro has been perfect. Best gyro spot in the area. The people that work here take their job seriously and you can tell. read more

This almost feels like I'm writing my first review. I say that because Yummy Gyro was (basically) the initial place I picked up an order from during these new days that we're unfortunately living in. But hey, it was tasty nonetheless! A few weeks ago, when pick-ups and curbsides and deliveries started becoming all the rage (out of necessity) Yummy Gyro was the place to order from...well, actually we had an original first-choice (The Greek Place), but after countless calls with no answer and nothing on social media, we figured they had closed up shop while we live through corona-ville. Totally understandable, but due to that, Yummy Gyro was the next restaurant up and met most of our Greek/Mediterranean-ish needs. Even if the world was right and we could dine where we wanted, Yummy Gyro is a takeout first-eat there if you must kind of place. No seriously, they have like two tables (and a couple outside) so it's not like you're missing much. The place was cramped with three people inside it making social distancing that much more problematic. Luckily, when we showed up to grab our order, it was ready to roll. Paying in advance would've been nice though, but I'm not gonna nitpick. Once back home, we dove into our savory selections. My girlfriend went with a basic gyro (side salad included) that hit the spot for her. For me, I can't help but go after crazy concoctions of sandwiches. You tell me you have "Pitas of the Gods" then I shall be getting one of those (plus this isn't too far off from what The Greek Place does so it almost made up for missing out on them). I went with the Hades which consisted of lamb and beef gyro meat, tomato, onion, spicy feta, tzatziki, and fries (yes in it!) all on pita bread. Needless to say, this was delicious. Did it live up to some other godly items? Perhaps not, but it did the trick. My side salad was also acceptable as were the side of lemon potatoes we indulged in. Overall, Yummy Gyro is pretty darn...yummy (it was there, I had to do it). The food isn't out of this world, but it fills the gyro needs well. They're also not really meant to eat at so they fit nicely into this current climate of available food choices due to corona. Might I add you'll get 10% off for pick up or delivery. Not too shabby, I must say. So if you're looking for a meal to-go right now, Yummy Gyro isn't a bad option. Perhaps it'll get another review once things go back to normal and this doesn't feel like a first time! read more

See all

Perfectly made. Quite Yummy. Serving amount was more than adequate. Will definitely be returning. Just might ask for an extra helping of tzatziki read more

Came across Yummy Gyro for the first time today and I was definitely blown away by the quality of food they serve. Right in the heart of nassau county, Yummy Gyro is serving one of the most yummiest Greek food I've ever had. I was in town because I had a flat tire so I went to Mavis right next door and I had an empty stomach. I ordered their Lamb Souvlaki platter which came with delicious, grilled tender, Smokey lamb kebab with their over the top tzaztzki sauce! The platter came with your choice of either French fries, salad or lemon potatoes, I would HIGHLY recommend the Lemon potatoes. Holy cow they were mind blowing! I literally got inside my car and definitely made a mess because everything was cooked perfectly and was soooo plentiful. I was not expecting this great of quality food but I definitely got my bang for my buck. Service was great! Yeah I waited 20 minutes for my food but it was definitely worth it. So if you're in town, if you're driving through Williston Park, I would recommend stopping by here and having yourself a cold one while enjoying a lamb souvlaki. read more

Love this place! My boyfriend and I picked up dinner from here one night. They prepared the food in good timing and the food was fresh and tasty. We both ordered the The Kronos - Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, red onions, tomatoes, spicy mayo, jalapenos, and melted mozzarella cheese. So yummy! read more

We used to order from here but after finding a dead bug in our Greek salad we won't be ordering again. Also looks like there was a second bug in the smaller salad container read more

Yummy Gyro - Greek salad with dead bug - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

See all

I was out in Long Island and visiting my friends for labor day weekend . We were deciding if we wanted to go out for lunch or just order. We decided to order in because it was about 7 adults and six kids so take out would be easier . Food was okay not special . Pita chips was not crunchy enough. Fries were good . My lamb gyro was big and food spilled out of the sandwich. My friend had the Hades and she said it was dry and had to use extra hot sauce on it. They also forgot to include utensils. Overall we would again if it was for a easy lunch . read more

See all

Horrible food. Over cooked. Arrived cold. VERY overpriced! That's a $9.49 bean salad and a $2.99 serving of tzatziki. What an overcharge! read more

See all

I came across this little place as I was going to a bagel place! I decided to have a Gyro instead, and I'm happy I did!! One gentleman was outside cleaning the front of the store. There is an area with two tables, with umbrellas, and chairs. As I walked in, another gentleman greeted me with a smile and a hello. I looked at the menu, on the wall and decided on the beef/lamb gyro. I passed up the offer of fries. A third gentleman asked if I wanted "everything " on it. Yes and thank you to....lettuce, tomatoes, onions and tzatziki sauce! He bought it to my table (three small ones in there). The Gyro was fresh, hot and absolutely delicious!! It stayed hot throughout and it was filled with a lot of meat!! I wish there was a bit more sauce on it but, I will remember to ask for a bit extra, next time. I took off one star...the plate on which it was served on, has seen better days. Don't get me wrong, the place is spotless. I believe the dish was made of melamine resin and it was cracked and looked damaged by heat. Maybe be a small thing to some but, it was something I noticed. All in all, I will return again. read more

See all

I grew up eating gyros from Fontana's in Bayside, Queens. It's the best and hard to beat. Yummy Gyro doesn't come close to a Fontana's gyro but their gyros are still....Yummy! Great find when I don't want to schlep all the way to Queens for a gyro! The restaurant is pretty small with just a couple of tables and a counter by the window. They also have a couple of tables outside if the weather permits. So this is more of a takeout place. Their menu is HUGE!!! I never knew you could so do much with gyros and souvlakis! For my first visit, I stuck with the basic gyro sandwich ($7.49). You have the option of adding a salad and drink for an additional $2,25. I added a greek salad and a bottle of water. The gyro was a bit too salty for my taste but still delicious. LOVE LOVE LOVE their thick tzatziki sauce! And the Greek salad was fresh and tasty, although more like a plain salad with feta thrown in it (no grape leaves or hot peppers, but maybe because I only had a side salad?). A pretty satisfying meal! Service was friendly and quick! Most people called in their orders and went to pick it up themselves. I just walked in and ordered but the wait on a Friday night around 7:30 wasn't bad at all! I will definitely be back to try other menu items. The hard part is picking what you want from the huge menu because everything sound delicious! I guess I'll have to work my way through the menu! hahaha read more

See all

I had the falafel lunch special today. Falafel wrap and green salad or fries (I got the salad). The falafel wrap (8.5/10) was well-seasoned, the falafel was pan fried into an almost patty, yogurt sauce was great and the wrap was fresh. I liked the onions in the wrap. The Greek salad (7.5/10) was good, not great, fresh enough. For the price and the nice staff, definitely a 4 stars. read more

All I know is that I work very hard for my money and I don't like being taken advantage of ,so a $14 large Greek salad with four small pieces of chicken doesn't make any sense. Yet the platter is $12 with a Greek salad and rice , bread etc. I was notified of this after my food arrived ! Food was delicious but ... hands up ! Give me your money ! read more

Yummy Gyro - $14 for a large Greek salad with 4 small pieces of chicken, really ??? - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

See all

First, let me say that the food is excellent here. Normally I would have given it a higher rating. Aside from a great selection of Greek dishes they also offer a variety of mini-pizzas that are worth trying. So what's the catch? Well, when you order from the online menu you would expect a dish to include what's pictured, plus whatever else the description says is also included. As good as the food is, I always find myself disappointed by one thing or another, unfortunately. This time, it was the babaganoush. I have included two photos, the first showing how the food was presented on the website, exactly as I selected it. It had an olive, some tomato and some cucumber, very much presented as if it was included in the dish. When I picked it up, it was just the babaganoush in a plastic container (not unexpected, as it was takeout), and it did include one pita bread. However, none of the vegetables were included. From previous experience, I knew not to let them staple the bag shut before I checked my order. When I saw what was missing, and asked why the vegetables were missing, all I got was excuses. Previously I've had a promised free delivery explained away. On another occasion, a drink that was supposed to be included was ignored until I mentioned it. Like I said, they make excellent food, but they are not really sharp with the things that are either presented or promised on their website or in their promotional material. read more

Yummy Gyro - But, here's what I was given when I picked it up! - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

See all

Ordered for two people. The lamb was hardly edible, stringy and partially unchewable. When I ordered a Greek salad I was told that what I had already ordered had a Greek salad included. Well, it wasn't much of a salad - tiny. Also, the prices continue to rise dramatically at this establishment. read more

Quick review. Had a hankering for a good old gyro. Ordered a pair of the beef/lamb gyro on whole wheat pita-one without tomatoes. No problem. Got there and food was ready on time. The guy at the front was quick but friendly. Picked up a baklava just because it looked good in the case. And it was sweet and flaky. The gyros were wrapped nicely and clearly labeled. The gyro was constructed very well. I say this because often you find that you eat your way to the end and there's no meat left. But no, plenty of meat throughout and all the way to the end. Classic flavors of the savory meat, fresh veg, tangy tzatziki sauce with the bright taste of the feta cheese. Ps- the phone there was ringing non-stop with orders and internet orders were streaming in. A very good sign that you are about to eat freshly made food. Parking lot is always a plus. Sorry for the crappy picture but you all know what a gyro looks like lol read more

Yummy Gyro - Beef Beef and Lamb Gyro Sandwich with extra tzatziki! - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

As my mom was here visiting she said she wanted a gyro. I thought we should check out this place and yeah this place is amazing. Will now be our go to in the area. Plus online ordering is always awesome especially when you're ordering for 5 different people lol. More places should have the online ordering option. read more

Great take out spot. They only have 2 tables and a few chairs if you wanted to eat inside. Good lunch specials too. I had the chicken souvlaki pita sandwich with a side salad and can of soda for like $10. Food is fresh too!! read more

See all

Updated review, over a year later, still love this place! Hot inside there today, so sat outside. One of my close friends heard about it from someone else and asked if I would go with her to try it. She is so happy to have discovered it :) We each got chicken souvlaki sandwich on wheat pita, made it a combo to add a side and drink. Combo drink options are unsweetened iced tea, sweetened iced tea and lemonade. (Great night for lemonade in this hot weather!) read more

Great food! A little pricy, but with inflation I guess everything has gone up. The staff were fun and engaging. Not much seating, but with just 2 we managed well. Definitely would go back. read more

Yummy Gyro of Williston Park I have been ordering from this place since before the pandemic, yes they make mistakes with your orders most of the time. The only reason I kept going back there, was because the food was really good. Their would be salads missing that were supposed to come with the meal or no pitas. Then when you called them bought this mistake to their attention, they would act like they were doing you a favor. And you should be grateful. Like you were at a soup kitchen and they were feeding the homeless. Not to mention that when they had to bring missing salads or pitas or what ever they screwed up it took them 30mins or more. I don't care how good the food is, I will never order from them again. And if you are smart you will do the same. Don't believe me just take a look at how many times this place has screwed people and orders up read more

Make sure you check your order before you leave or pay. Appetizer missing. An hour after I called still no appetizer. Called again. I was told I had a credit so just tell them next time I order and they will give me the credit off my next order. So I have to remember to tell them that I have the credit. In other words, "you will most likely forget so we have your money and your food - you lose sucker." Hope I remember to never order from them again. read more

Let's be clear, I really like the food at Yummy Gyro (I frequent the Port Washington location often) but today, we decided to get some food to go and it was a massive massive CLUSTERF%^&. The food here is really good and affordable. The platters and sandwiches are great. Their hummus and babaganoush are excellent. This location however, is strictly take out as the restaurant only has 2 tables. We ordered on the Yelp app and we were told to pick it up in 45 minutes (a bit long for gyro but whatever). When I arrived about 40 minutes after placing the order, I knew we made a mistake by ordering here. The restaurant was packed with people, all waiting for pickup. It got to the point that we were all on top of the 2 poor ladies eating in the corner. When I got there, I noticed my order up on the screen but the guy at the counter looked bewildered when I told him I was picking up and then just told me "Yes, your order is being made right now". I figured, ok I'm a few minutes early, let's hang out. One by one, I could tell that all the patrons waiting probably ordered earlier or around the same time as me. To their credit, the patrons all were really patient but one guy waited about 45 minutes for a single gyro sandwich to go (bless that guy, he was really hungry and had the best attitude). About 20 minutes into waiting (and about an hour after I placed the order online) I got a call from Eat24/Yelp who asked me if I was having issues with my order. I was surprised to hear from them and I told them that I was at the restaurant, that they said they had my order, and that I was just waiting around to go. The girl on the phone said that she had been trying to call the restaurant multiple times but could not get anyone to pick up the phone. She asked me to call her back if I had further issues. Again not inspiring the greatest confidence. It became clear to me that there was no system to process orders. Some people walked in and got their food before those that had called or ordered online. Wait times ranged from 15 minutes for some lucky patrons to a whopping 90 minutes for a poor lady next to me who was just getting 2 salads and some chicken (they forgot the souvlaki which added another 15 minutes at least - I don't know exactly how long since I escaped Alcatraz before she did). My total wait time in the store was about another 45 minutes so my total time from order to completion was just about 80 minutes - pretty tough to ask for some gyro off of the spit. What made it worse was that they tried to get me out the door but I insisted on checking my order (I'd waited all that time so I wanted to be sure). Of course, they missed both our desserts, 2 of our dips and put someone else's food in my bag. Luckily that got sorted out in a few minutes but today's experience was a horrible odyssey. The food is good here but they really shouldn't be taking online orders without figuring out some kind of system to process them. Based on this experience, I'll probably stick to the Port Washington location exclusively now. Weak showing. 1 star for the experience but an extra 1 since I know the food is good. read more

Yummy Gyro - Crazy tight space to work in - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

I ordered from here a few times, i like the location but the food and service can be inconsistent. One time it was the best, the other it was ok. Its more of a 3.5 rating than a 4 star. I hope they get better read more

We ordered from this place for the first time yesterday and were pleased with the food overall. We ordered a large Greek salad with chicken souvlaki and the grilled veggies and an order of hummus. All were well made and seemed very fresh. We will order from here again soon read more

The Food was good and I went here because it was close to a doctors appointment I had . I will for sure go back again when I'm near by . Like the food and the staff was very nice and accommodating. 5 starts for me for sure read more

Yummy Gyro - Front of this place - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York

See all

Went in for late lunch/early dinner ordered to go via phone. At home discovered that my gyro meat was black chared. They gave me the meat sitting on the rotisserie for hours instead of shaving off the bad meat to get to the edible portion. It was beyond disgusting. I have never had an issue with them before but this experience was so vile that I will never go back place is ruined for me read more

The falafel sandwich with hummus was delicious. Very flavorful! Their french fries are by far the best fries I have ever eaten. Will order from here again! read more

Yummy Gyro - Greek Near Me - Williston Park, New York