Solid take out large cheese pizza, reasonably priced, lots of cheese good crust…read more Friendly takeout counter help

Stop here if you have a group that everyone needs a different topping ij their pizza. So many…read moredifferent slices available at the counter. Something for everyone. They have a full menu too but we go her bc our crowd all likes different toppings. Easy lunch and delicious. Tables are usually available, not too crowded.

My wife and myself and a friend ate here tonight and the food was great as always and the waiter…read morewas very attentive. The manager as always stopped to say hello.

Great spot for breakfast or lunch. This has a retro style diner feel. It is not as big on the…read moreinside as I thought it would so expect to wait on peak hours. They also have small diner type bar seating stools. The Buffalo chicken salad was big, fresh, and delicious. I had plenty to take home for meal number 2. The chicken fingers and fries were also very good. Not too greasy. The fries had a nice crispy outside. The service was very good too. But beware It can get very loud when it's busy.

KEEP THE PICKLE BOMB!!!!…read more We love this place. BEST PIZZA .. Nothing bad to about the food service or the place.

We went here over the weekend and didn't have a good experience unfortunately. The pizza was…read morereheated and was very hard and crunchy. It also had no flavor in the sauce. The owner yelled at a customer right in front of everyone in the restaurant. Due to the quality of the pizza and the unprofessionalism of the owner, we will not be returning. Editing review based on response: I never feel comfortable saying something is bad when asked "how is everything?" I also was very uncomfortable after the interaction with the owner and customer yelling that I didn't want to cause any more issues.

Family ordered pizzas from here this evening and they were great. Right amount of cheese and…read moreseasoning. Just how a pizza should be

How could you not love Panzones? My whole family and I wait for the moment that beautiful Lucious…read morepizza comes to our door !!!!!!! Food is so food and gud . Give this man a raise! Hooray for the USA

Good pizza but way too much money. Better pies in NYC and Philly for half the price. Not sure if…read morethere's a better pizzeria on the island but I'm up for trying others.

Great pizza and open until December weekends on the Island. Pricey though. Service friendly and…read morewings were meaty.

Always a great time, love the Godfather Pizza, the meatballs, and mostly everything. Great service,…read moretoo.

Amazing in every way! The inside was decorated nicely with lights for Christmas…read more We had 7:00 reservations and we had a to wait a few minutes but we didn't mind, they have complimentary pizza in the waiting area which is a very unique touch. Dinner Portions are big in my opinion. The Brooklyn bolognese and chicken parm were delicious. The chicken cutlet was pounded thin, the sauce in both dishes tasted very good and authentic. The server was excellence! She didn't rush us out and we were the last table. Highly recommend making a reservation! Keep in mind it is BYOB

We did take-out from an online order. The pizza was excellent as was the chicken Caesar wrap. My…read moreson enjoyed the house-made meatballs. Unfortunately, they did not follow the particular change requests that were written in the notes. My nephew enjoyed his hamburger as well.

Stayed a week at LBI and wanted something simple in the area and I have been going to LBI the 3rd…read moreweek in September for 18 years here in Ship Bottom and never entered this place. Always passing it by on my travels. So I made the call to pickup a large thin crust pie with half pepperoni & mushrooms and the other half plain. Easy to order on the phone and was ready to be pickup quickly. Very good pie I have to say me coming from and raised in NYC. Will order again most definitely.

We came to Surf City Bistro for their trivia night after dinner elsewhere. It was a little…read moreconfusing how the whole thing would work at first, but the Emcee/Host explained it all. We started off with some 'doubles' for our drinks as we got settled and ordered a couple of other rounds during the trivia contest...so the bill added up quickly, but we had a blast with the trivia and ended up winning. I know this place has mixed reviews but we had a great time.

We visited Surf City Bistro several times over the past two weeks, and each experience reminded us…read morewhy it has been a go-to spot for our family since the mid '90s. Whether we were dining with a group of 9, an extended party of 16, or just enjoying a casual dinner at the bar, the service was consistently excellent. The staff handled everything with ease and professionalism - especially impressive given that our groups included anywhere from 3 to 6 children. They made sure the kids' meals came out quickly (a huge plus for us), and their attention to detail was excellent, even with the larger parties. The food was solid and well priced across the board. We tried everything from burgers and sushi to flatbreads, chicken, and the raw bar, and everything was fresh and prepared well. Drinks were also a strong point - reasonably priced, delivered promptly, and followed up on without us ever needing to ask. A nice touch during our visits was the live music - it kept the kids entertained and added to the laid-back, fun atmosphere. Even our evening at the bar stood out - we enjoyed the same great service and were able to take advantage of their happy hour specials. The updates that have been made here have only enhanced what was already a reliable, welcoming spot. Surf City Bistro continues to be one of the most family-friendly and consistently enjoyable dining options right in the heart of Surf City. We will be back again soon.

Great place, Food and most of all The Service! Maddy makes…read morethe BEST Cortado, Cheese Steak is HUGE and DELISH. Anthony keeps the place running smoothly from the front door when you arrive to the last Bite. Wait List is Wonderful. only One Prob... its SOOO good, it's also crowded IN SEASON but Worth the Wait! Karen N Mike (cortado woman)

LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!! I can't say enough about this place! Everyone is always so pleasant, the food is…read moreamazing!

We always come away with the same experience every time we try Yellowfin - the food is fantastic,…read moreno question about it. Despite another review, I actually think the food is NYC-quality. They have a solid range of unique menu items, tons of flavor, well-cooked and good portion size. Genuinely no complaints on the food quality, but unfortunately that's where it ends. The food is just beyond overpriced. I understand LBI is pricey, and this place is BYOB so they have to make money somehow, but the paella special (w/ a half lobster) was "idk $70-75 I think" according to the waiter. If you can't justify $50+ on a seafood dish, the MP is your flag that is going to be well over $50 (i.e $52 halibut??). As an NYC resident who enjoys fine dining, I can genuinely say I've never seen ANY fish dish get near $50. More importantly, the waiter got super pushy with us challenging us twice when we decided to grab a bunch of appetizers and a few mains, rather than a main for each of us. After this, he was basically none existent the rest of the meal, which was still over $300 for 4. We had to flag down others to get things like new silverware between courses or dessert. Overall, food is great, so if you want a good meal don't care about mediocre service at best and overpaying, then give it a shot.

Excellent food and wonderful hostess! We had the fried…read moregreen tomatoes and braised short rib appetizer and tuna and Halibut entree. Even though we had more than enough to eat , felt the need to try the tiramisu which was also very good. We will definitely be back!