I ordered 2 pies ahead of time and they were ready when I arrived. Delicious too! Among the best pizza on LBI!

The pizza itself was very bland and wasn't anything special. The season fries though, were very flavorful, yet not extremely salty. Service was good and nice seating outdoors. Not sure if I would go back. read more

Had a slices of sausage pizza, hot, yummy, and fast. Staff was friendly and no frills. Was worth stopping for a quick bite on the way out. read more

I ordered a slice of mushroom pizza here and it took about 20 minutes to get it, even though there were only a few people ahead of me. The slice itself was large, but unfortunately it couldn't hold its weight--it was very thin yet not crispy, which made it a bit floppy. I came in craving that classic boardwalk-style pizza, but this just didn't deliver. While it might work if you're looking for a quick bite in the area, it's not the kind of boardwalk pizza I was hoping for. read more

I feel like this place comes and goes with different owners managers and workers. A few years ago this pizza was the bomb big slices cooked a perfection you sit in the little gazebo. Look at the bay. Say how great your vacation is going. This trip 2024, the pizza was crappy. It was dry, lack flavor in the sauce and was just a general letdown. So my advice would be to look at the pizza someone else orders before you and scope it out before you go spending seven dollars or $10 on one slice. It's hit or miss but I don't like that because when I'm hungry, I just wanna know where I'm going, just walk around the corner to panzerotti's read more

See all

Pizza was good. Ready on time. Got takeout. We ordered a cheese pizza and a mushroom pizza. All good. Reasonable as well.

I know what you're thinking. Pizza and bagels south of the Raritan River are mediocre at best. In general I agree with you, but I've found an exception. In a state that has the best pizza in the world, Bay Village Pizza finds a way hang with the best pizza parlors in North Jersey. One of the things that separates good pizza places from great ones are the fries. Bay Village Pizza excels in that regard. The fries are probably the best on the island. It's take-out only, and they get busy so I recommend calling ahead. read more

Best pizza on the island...plain and simple. Ordered half pepperoni / half mushroom pie...thoroughly delicious.

Went to this little walk up pizza shop while visiting some family in LBI and was not disappointed! I only got the fries but they were so crisp, salty, and well-done! For the price of about $8, it was a huge portion so I left all happy and satisfied. Just be warned that the lines can get crazy here so go on off hours! read more

We got a cheese pizza take out from here. It's a cute spot in LBI that was very quick at take out and the staff were very nice. The pizza was good and they were open late which is great. read more

I ordered a plain slice and decided to add a sausage topping after she charged me. The second charge was for over $77. I don't live close by and they are avoiding my calls. Scammers. Avoid tapping your card. read more

Take out only. You can call and order ahead which has been a great way to order food and pick up. One of the best pizzas in Beach Haven in our opinion. read more

Top pizzas on the island! Great place to grab a pie or a slice. Quick service. Calling ahead to place the order is helpful.

Bay Village pizza might easily be one the best za spots in jersey. There's always a line so be prepared. It moves quick and the staff is definitely hard working. They offer fries and pizza. Their fries are magical. I always get the hand cut and it comes with a perfect side of ketchup. They're perfectly fried and seasoned. The pizza? Huge. Delicious. So thin and crispy. I mean it's definitely one of my favorite slices ever. One of my favorite things is that they call out your name for the order and serve you your food through a window on a huge pizza paddle. Best spot on the island for some greasy goods. read more

See all

Only a had slice of pizza here just to check it out and it's just average. Crust had an ok crisp sauce was ok, could not see any oregano, basil or marjoram flakes but they make some spices available on the Togo shelf so I added some oregano and garlic. The place is great for kids and teenagers that lack a discerning palette although at just about 5.00 a slice they might go broke. They have outside covered eating area that looks to be shared. Did not expect much and they did not disappoint. Gave them a 2 because of the crust. read more

Bay Village Pizza - Pizza slice after adding spices - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

I think Bay Village Pizza is the best pizza you can find on LBI. We waited about 10 minutes for our order which came out hot and cooked to perfection. Will definitely go back, read more

We got takeout from Bay Village yesterday and it was very good. We got one cheese and one pepperoni pizza. It was slightly dried out but it could've been because we had to drive it back to the beach house about 10 minutes away. The cheese mixture and sauce were a great combination. The service was fast and efficient and all of the employees were friendly! read more

Go here for large slices of pizza. Typically, I'm a big fan of this pizza establishment because they usually offer cheese fries which are great fresh and delish. They sell two things, pizza and fries and they typically do it well so we plan to eat here at least once during our LBI trips. However, after waiting in line for 30 minutes we get to the front to grab a quick bite to eat and they ran out of cheese fries and the wait is 45 minutes for a pie. Two of us were extremely disappointed because there went half our order. We had to run to a show so we just grabbed a couple of slices. My order included peppers and mushrooms but a rando slice of pepperoni snuck on there. I wiped off a dirty table and we ate our fast food and ran. Still can't believe they ran out of 50/% of their menu product so very disappointed in this experience this time around. I guess get there before 7pm if you want to try the fries which would have made this a 3.5/4 star experience but I had to drop a star for both having product in stock! read more

Bay Village Pizza - Slice with green peppers mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

It costed 95 dollars for three large pizzas which is insane and also it wasn't that great.

Even though we come to LBI every year, we had never been to Bay Village Pizza. The day we arrived this year, we were starving so stopped to grab a couple slices. I got the mushroom and all I can say is YUM! I love a good reheated pizza slice that gets a little crispy on the bottom. We had some more later when we went to Ship Bottom Brewery. My husband wishes that the pepperoni would be cooked a little more, but I thought the mushroom slice was perfect. Definitely a great spot for a quick bite! read more

See all

I hear it's pricey, but you would be shocked to see how much pizza costs in Texas! so for me, I was like..ehhh not so bad. Pepperoni pizza was fantastic - really miss NJ pizza (so much better than NY pizza, just admit it..all of you) read more

Worst pizza ever. No taste, no cheese. What happened they used to be so good. One of our five pizza had a hole in it. Barely any cheese. So disappointed. Do not go here read more

Bay Village Pizza - So little cheese if any. - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Call ahead!!! This place has amazing pizza with huge slices and is absolutely delicious but you will wait in the line to order and then wait again.... If you call ahead it will be ready. College kids working their tails off and still smiling with some of the best pizza on the island - a winning combination read more

Average slice. Tasty sauce; correct proportion of cheese and sauce. A little too much dough around the edges. The mushrooms used are from a can, which surprised me, because where I live they use fresh mushrooms. I was expecting more of a variety of toppings. Pleasant covered area nearby with tables and chairs. read more

This is a pizza place with a window to order and pick up. There is an outdoor area which has seating unfortunately it was not maintained and every table was dirty and the floor covered with litter. We ordered 2 plain slices, 1 sausage, and a basket of Fries. The pizza was ok, the fresh cut fries were very good. The pizza was ready way before the fries so it got cold waiting for the order to complete. The prices very reasonable for the area. The counter staff very friendly and professional. It was crowded so be ready to wait people were being told 30 minutes for whole pies. read more

They are NOT closed. This is my favorite place to get NY style pizza in Beach Haven. The sauce and crust are perfection. It's always my first stop when I get to the island. read more

Pizza. Sure. But $50 for two pies hurts. I get it, NYC has invaded LBI. Just wish care/ concern for quality pizza came with the cost.

Their pizza is amazing! People have said this place is best pizza on the island but I think I can go one step further and say I think they are the best pizza joint in NJ. You can't just have two slices you need to order a whole tomato pie. read more

Bay Village Pizza - Tomato pie - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

My first time trying Bay Village Pizza all we got was a large fry and it was definitely worth the money I loved it. Perfect having the option to put toppings on and the bar stools give you a view that's pretty nice can't wait to go back for the pizza read more

Bay Village Pizza - Large fries ! - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

See all

Good traditional pizza, our go to when ordering out. Can be a long line and wait for pick up so plan ahead. No delivery. read more

Burnt pizza!! Please don't charge for a burnt food item! Disappointing! White pizza was good; plain pie was salty and over cooked. read more

Bay Village Pizza - Really?!?!! - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Dependable pizza on LBI. I haven't found better pizza on the island. Call ahead to order because the lines can be quite long. For great shore pizza you can't do much better. read more

Always a line here during the summer months so decided buy a pie. Service was pretty fast, but I thought the pizza was just ok. Most people in their reviews are mention the fries maybe that's what we need to try. read more

Very good pizza on the island. Quick service and very convenient to bay village. I suppose that's why it's named "Bay Village Pizza"

Bay Village Pizza is my favorite pizza spot on LBI. Every year we come here for our Friday night dinner before going to Fantasy Island with the kids. My mom grew up in New York, so I know good pizza... and this pizza is pretty good. Huge slices. Thin crust. Just the right amount of cheese and sauce. I've tried several other places on LBI and keep coming back to Bay Village Pizza! read more

Bay Village Pizza - A line down the block on a Friday night! - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

This pizza is fair at best, how it got all the good reviews is beyond me. We're from North Jersey and eat NY style pizza all the the time this wasn't even close. If you like tomato sauce and crust this is the place for you! I don't know what they did with the cheese. If this is LBI's best you can keep it we were very disappointed read more

Best pizza on the island! If you live outside of the NJ/NY area and are craving NY style pizza, this IS the place to go. read more

Bay Village Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beach Haven, New Jersey

Sort of pricy, but well worth it for how much you get. Every other place on this island is TERRIBLE, this place is very good. Reminds me of the good pizza back home! Great for a quick slice (roughly $5 with tax but huge) and great for a take-home-and-share pie. read more

Omg! This place has the biggest and best pizza in LBI! The pizza is cheesy and I always order a side of fries because they are fresh cut and delicious! One pizza is big enough for a family.of 4! With a side of fries of course . While waiting for your pizza , take a walk around and enjoy the shops and the view of the bay! read more

See all

Very good pizza. Slices are huge and crust is nice and thin, slightly crispy. Came here on a busy Monday and had our food fairly quickly. Only gripe was that the eating area was not being kept clean at all and was pretty disgusting. Garbage everywhere and the tables were quite dirty. read more