We have been going to Black Eyed Susans since it first opened on the other side of the street many…read moreyears ago. At that point it was a small restaurant, BYOB, but it was immediately apparent that real gourmet food had finally arrived on LBI. (I still remember their version of shrimp and grits from that time.) We no longer had to put up with the prevailing surf and turf that we had unfortunately become accustomed to. Since then they've moved to their current, much bigger space and have created a beautiful, vibrant, inside-ourside restaurant that still serves excellent food (their lumache is terrific--we try not to order it every time) and has expanded to include pizzas--thin crust and very tasty; every one we've tried has been delicious. So we would definitely recommend Black Eyed Susans. The staff is welcoming, friendly, well trained. This is now a big, beautiful destination restaurant. The pizzas and beer lower the price point.

Local spot in north LBI with high quality food and ambiance…read more Ate at the counter and loved the pizza, fish, and cocktails. Friendly service, great vibes, higher end clientele.

Very good pizza on the island. Also had a nice ceasar salad. I went to order take out. I'd love…read moreto eat there next time seating permitting. Not a sit down location.

Ordered the grandma pie. Half regular and half pepperoni and hot honey. The sauce was super tasty.read more

Solid take out large cheese pizza, reasonably priced, lots of cheese good crust…read more Friendly takeout counter help

Great pizza HORRIBLE service…read more Came this evening and ordered 6 slice and a pie. Everything was ordered together. Slices came out in 5 minutes. The pizza after 20 minutes of waiting asked where it was we told still on the way there were tickets in front. Asked to at a minimum get a slice for our 1 year old and 6 year old and was ignored. Threw tickets in my face showing me other pizza that were put in at 6:27 and ours was at 6:31. I explained how he further proved my point as those came out of the oven 5 minutes earlier. He continued to not care and decide to open the public trash is as customers and how wrong we were. A shameful respect for customers.

KEEP THE PICKLE BOMB!!!!…read more We love this place. BEST PIZZA .. Nothing bad to about the food service or the place.

We love the pizza and the garlic knots! We make sure to stop here every year. The cheesesteaks…read moreare a hit as well!

Amazing pizza - worth the price! Best on the island. One of the best in NJ. Great customer…read moreservice. Has a tomato pie with no cheese which is perfect for vegans or those with dairy allergies.

Tried this place for the first time and really enjoyed it!…read moreOne of the best pizzas on LBI.

Consistently good. Great staff and service but one server stood out. We came in for dinner on…read morereopening day, 2 weeks ago. Our server, Olivia, was exceptional. Attentive without being overbearing. Lucky you if you get her. No

Highly recommend! Great food, great neighborhood, great service! Definitely a family spot! Don't…read moreforget to get the crumb cake! Our server was Eric! He went above and beyond! We'll be back Wally

My friend and I were exhausted and craving a smoothie after a long, hot sunny day. What's that over…read morethere? Oh! A sign for smoothies. How amazing. So we walk in. Weird vibe, but we don't judge. So we look at the smoothie options at the far corner in the back of the store and decide to order--ooo strawberry banana looks good! We order and get ready to pay. The cashier types in a 1...and then a 5. Oh! $1.50? That's not bad at all. Wait...0. Wait...another 0. $15 for two? I guess that's doable. But no. Little did we know, we had just been scammed and the smoothies were $15 each. We were both furious, but decided to try it before we declare it a waste of money. Well, try it we did, and it wasn't just a waste of money--it was a disgrace to the idea of a smoothie and an insult to our hourly wage. We left still craving a smoothie and with $30 less in our wallets. FUCK FOODIES！

This place is fantastic. Great selection of homemade muffins, pizza, bagels and pastry. I…read moreexpected it to have all 5 star reviews when I looked it up. guessing the lower scores may be from high falutent types