Great pizza HORRIBLE service. Came this evening and ordered 6 slice and a pie. Everything was ordered together. Slices came out in 5 minutes. The pizza after 20 minutes of waiting asked where it was we told still on the way there were tickets in front. Asked to at a minimum get a slice for our 1 year old and 6 year old and was ignored. Threw tickets in my face showing me other pizza that were put in at 6:27 and ours was at 6:31. I explained how he further proved my point as those came out of the oven 5 minutes earlier. He continued to not care and decide to open the public trash is as customers and how wrong we were. A shameful respect for customers. read more

Solid take out large cheese pizza, reasonably priced, lots of cheese good crust Friendly takeout counter help read more

Surf City Pizza - 16" Large Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

For starters Surf city is always difficult to deal with on the phone. They also disregard any special requests for individual pies. Want a pie extra crispy? NO! They don't do that here. No crunch! Just because they have monopolized the pizza space north of the bridge does not mean they should be rated anything higher than a 4/10. read more

Stop here if you have a group that everyone needs a different topping ij their pizza. So many different slices available at the counter. Something for everyone. They have a full menu too but we go her bc our crowd all likes different toppings. Easy lunch and delicious. Tables are usually available, not too crowded. read more

We got surf city pizza last weekend and it was pretty good! We ordered a standard cheese pizza and 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 mushroom pizza. The cheese pizza was good but the crust didn't have much flavor. It is all cash there so keep that in mind. We called ahead and the pizza was ready in 20 minutes, which was great! read more

Very good pizza and boy can it get crowded in here during the summer. Try to come during the off season. Buy a whole pie or a slice. Around $5 a slice. read more

Surf City Pizza is you're typical Jersey Shore Pizza Joint. It has a small indoor dining area, but let's be honest, you're probably picking up, getting delivery, or just grabbing a slice to go anyway. The standard plain slice features a fluffy dough with a crisp base and good structure. The cheese is good, the sauce is slightly bitter with mild acidity. Overall, nothing to complain about. read more

Surf City Pizza - A plain slice - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

See all

This is one of the best pizzas on the island. Unfortunately, it is so hard to order other food that we will not be going here again this summer. Maybe not ever. Trying to order there, we parked next to the building but were told they would not take our order unless we called it in. We went back to the car and pulled up the menu online. Ordering from the menu on our cell phone we were told things we read off the menu were not available because they are using a reduced menu due to COVID. That's fine, and common place these days, but this is the only place that I've seen that didn't update the menu online to make ordering easier for their customers. My family are all picky eaters. In trying to order we made some requests for substitutions. Apparently, because of COVID restrictions, only one of these requests was agreed to. I've worked in two pizza places and I know these requests were simple everyday changes. Many pizza places have accommodated these requests since they were allowed to reopen. The person taking the order was clearly not a cook so I asked to speak to one. The person who came onto the phone was rude and basically said that he wouldn't do what we asked. We went to Panzone's. read more

Awesome place and it's open year round. Great cheesesteaks, mussels and of course Pizza.

Always great food. Never disappointed with anything on the menu. Family run, Tony and daughters are great friendly people. Best pizza on North end. read more

These guys were cool and they made me a huge Philly Cheese !! I will go back and try something different next time

We've been ordering pizza from here for many years and it's consistently great pizza!

Great food, timely service and great people. Highly recommend. Have been enjoying Surf City Pizza for many years and have never been disappointed. read more

Not sure why there are people who are leaving negative reviews for this place. It hit the spot for us. When we get to the shores, we crave a BEACH PIZZA, and this place made the perfect one. Ready in 15 minutes, and the owner even knocked 18 cents off to make it an even dollar amount. The best part? Next day leftovers! Anyway... perfection in my book. read more

Stopped in with my business partner to grab lunch, we both had the Garden salad and garlic bread. It was a nice size salad and super fresh. Garlic bread was really good as well. We will stop in next time we are in the area! read more

Surf City Pizza - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

Ordered a pizza for pick up. The cheese slid right off the pie! Pizza was doughy. First & last time ordering from here! Very disappointed read more

Surf City Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

See all

Good pizza that was well liked by our group of six adults and five children. We highly recommend them!

I have to say they have greatly improved in the past few years! We order every year for the past several years on our big family vacation. I highly recommend the grandma Sicilian - the sauce used is flavorful and the crust is crazy and buttery. We got our half pepperoni and miss room and half plain - it was amazing. We ordered three other pies and every slice from all the pies was gone! read more

My fiancé and I were hungry after lounging around on the beach at LBI and decided to check out Surf City Pizza for lunch, after reading the good reviews for the place. We found street parking easily and though the place was crowded, we also found a table to sit at. It's very very casual. You go up to the counter and place your order and take the pizza back to your picnic - type table. My fiancé and I both got the cheesesteak pizza. We liked it well enough, but it wasn't extraordinary. It tasted a bit old. For a $4 slice of pizza, I expect more. I also got a slice of what looked like a bruschetta pizza (arugula and tomato slices with garlic on top) and liked it well enough, but it didn't have enough sauce (or any at all) and tasted a bit plain for $4. My fiancé got a meatball pizza and was also meh about it. Overall, filling food, but nothing extraordinary and not worth the prices. Service was alright. Quick, but not the friendliest. And their water machine was not working, so we ended up getting a bottle of water to share. In the future, I wouldn't rule out Surf City Pizza, but it certainly wouldn't be my first choice for lunch on the island. read more

See all

Ordered pizza and meatball park. Food was good and service quick. Staff was friendly

So this was my first summer visiting Lbi Me and my girlfriend made it our mission to look for the the best pizza In town so up and down the strip we went trying all the pizza spots and I have to say surf city was the best! they're crust and sauce is to die for! They're plain slice is the best and freshest but you can't go wrong w a chicken bacon & ranch slice either. The staff is friendly and welcoming they even waited after closing time for us to pick up our pie. I'm here for a week and so far I've been coming in ever day at least twice a day lol read more

Surf City Pizza - Plain slice Nom non nom - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

Pretty much nothing was open except this pizza place but wow am I glad I found it! Pizza was absolutely delicious! Totally hit the spot on this cold fall day. Skip the slices that are sitting there and order a fresh pie! It is definitely the way to go! The man working at the front counter was really friendly and it took about 8-10 minutes for my large pie to finish. I will definitely be back! Highly recommend delicious pizza! read more

Surf City Pizza - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

See all

Delicious NJ tomato pie! Thin crust, cushiony rim, tasty tomatoes! A treat for a Connecticut couple! Highly recommend! Will return often!!

Delicious pizza!! Our favorite place on LBI for pizza!! Open year round-our go to place whenever we are here.

Stopped in for a quick slice while out for a walk with Fido this week. First the good, the pizza wasn't bad. Ordered 2 slices of the Grandmother. They were fresh and tasty although I think it had the wrong cheese for this style of pizza but despite that it wasn't bad. The two stars is for their customer service. I asked for a cup of tap water to offer my dog while we waited for the pizza to be heated. I was told that they didn't have any cups despite the fact that I was standing next to a stack of cups. I get that your trying to make money but as a paying customer I feel this could have been better handled instead of the blatant lie. In better circumstances I would gladly have paid for a cup if they needed but just to lie, just disappointing. read more

Amazing place, amazing food, I've always gone here and I'm obsessed!! The Penne Vodka is out of this world! read more

Surf City Pizza - Penne alla Vodka - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

I get that Covid is happening but that leaves no excuse for not being able to put toppings on a slice. My girlfriend asked for a slice of pizza with pineapple toppings and they said they couldn't do it unless it was a whole pie of pizza. They tried giving the Covid excuse but come on you can do a whole pie but not a slice? That's complete laziness. Go to California Grill & Pizza in Beach Haven just down the road. They'll gladly put whatever topping you want on your pizza. read more

This place was trash and everyone there is completely incompetent. After many issues with placing an order, we finally did. However, when we got there they got the salad wrong and completely omitted the fries we wanted. The owner was rude and aggressive, making fun of us for taking a while to decide (sorry you don't have a menu or a competent ordering system). Then when we told him we had ordered fries, he told us point blank that he didn't care and wouldn't make them for us. Overall the owner was a jackass and the workers were snotty and incompetent. I assume they get so much business from tourists that they don't care if they treat their customers right. read more

Great pizza and wonderful owner and staff. Favorite pizza place on the island! Our favorite pie is either the eggplant parm or surf pizza.

They let hot chicks in, from the beach, with bikinis on. wha wha wha.... Oh yea, the pizza with onions and peppers was dope. read more

Have to give a shout out to this place. Open during the cold winter months when only a few lights can be seen on the Blvd. We've had many tasty pizzas from here. Also enjoyed their hot subs (eggplant parm especially). We've always done takeout but the food is ready promptly and like I said, been a real life saver when nothing else was open. If you think Panzone's is good (and we don't - not sure what all the rave reviews are about - pizza comparable to Dominos), Surf City Pizza is soooooo much better read more

Very good pizza at reasonable prices. Good quality and great selection. I won't say where we got a load of pies from last year... but it was overpriced and horrible. Surf City came to the rescue of our large family pizza night this year. The Buffalo Chicken and Chicken Parm slices are the perfect way to end a long day at the beach! See you next year! read more

By far the worst pizza place on the island go there on a Saturday night at 7:45 and told the only thing I can have is the pizza that was laying around or a cold sub. On the website there hours say they're open till 10 p.m. Buckley went back to panzones pizza and got sandwiches and fries and onion rings it was very delighted with my service and the food.. read more

Tasty, greasy, nice staff. The garlic bread (with cheese of course) was dynamite. Perfect beach house food! read more

Had a good take out experience during the week but called at 6:58 on a Friday and was told 30-35 minutes, showed up 45 minutes after I called, the place was packed with people waiting for orders, disgustingly hot with no AC, and I was told another 10-20 minutes for my pies to be ready. In addition, one of the boys working behind the counter started yelling at a customer who was understandably upset and simply asked a question about the time and price. Terrible business practices and customer service - with so many pizza places on the island we will not be going here again. The pies are way over priced anyway. read more

Pizza is good. Meatballs and meatball subs are good. Grilled chicken is pretty terrible (don't order that on the salads. It's dry and stringy) Unfortunately, they don't how to treat their customers. They made a mistake with our pickup order and treated my wife terribly when she called and had to drag three little kids back with her to pick up the correct order. read more

This place continues to make me angry. I have given it a second, third, fourth chance. They just don't get it. From the big guy sweating over my food to the Styrofoam containers at the beach. The food is OK it's just not a good place to eat from. read more

I picked up 3 pizzas for the family over the weekend - cheese, meatlovers and margharita. The Margharita was the best of the three. All have thin crust and could be cooked a tad bit longer, but are still tasty. Oh yeah, call ahead and make your life easier, especially on a weekend :-) They do take credit cards (over $10 - is this in Island thing?). read more

Owner / manager is friendly and nice. Pizza is okay. Overall your standard pizzeria. One thing that is not good is that their marinara sauce has beef in it. So the pizza is the only thing with sauce you can get that's vegetarian. read more

Surf City Pizza - Garlic bread with cheese - Italian Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

See all

This place is a definite must try if you are staying in Surf City! Not only is the pizza great, the pasta and even the wings are excellent as well. The place gets jam packed so best to put in a take out order. However the staff is friendly and helpful and the prices are decent. Pizza is NY style and the pies are gigantic, extra thick crusts and full of cheese. We always make it a point to stop in here and grab some food at least once on our vacations. read more