My wife and I went into Brady's Pub with low expectations. We had gone for an upscale brunch early in the day, and wanted a "close and easy" option for dinner. Since we are staying on Smathers Beach, "close" is an issue. The feel of the place is definitely pub - nice large bar, mostly low table seating, dart board, etc. Nothing fancy, but functional and clean. Decent draft beer list - I was especially pleased to see a REAL Czech Pilsner (Pilsner Urquell). Great choice! The menu had a multitude of Irish-ish choices and some nice apps. Even though it was Easter Sunday they were offering a Happy Hour, so we started with some sweet chili wings. Not super spicy, not super sweet, very nice. Big wings. We split a Rueben for our main, and the house-made corned beef was EXCELLENT (albeit REALLY salty). We walked out full and happy, achieving our "close and easy" goal and enjoying the experience as well. We sat at the bar where Cheryl was our bartender and server. She was very efficient and very friendly. We really enjoyed talking with her and watching her interact with the really diverse group at the bar. Fun times! read more

When you walk in you may think, dive bar. Don't leave. If you're hungry and you came to eat, eat. The food is excellent and well worth it. The menu is not huge and that's fine. More attention is paid to what's offered. We had the potato leak soup with bacon and cheddar cheese. Rich and delicious. You might want to split it as it's very satisfying. My love had the chili lime wings. Ad says always fresh never frozen. I believe. Fat, juicy wings crunchy on the outside. Great stuff. I risked the classic reuben. As a NY Jew you've got to impress me with corned beef. They got it right. Really right. Ok? So its recommended. Not a dive bar, a towny bar. Well done. read more

We stayed on Josephine St.for the month of March 2026.....Brady's Pub food was excellent but what really shined was the staff,but who really stood out was Cheryl and Ruthie....they always made us feel so welcomed and the service was way above par!!!! This became a favorite!!! And so close to Josephine St. Can't wait to get back there in 2027!!! Miss you ladies!! Love from the Maine gang!!!! read more

This is great Irish dive bar that has changed names a few times the last few years but remains unchanged. The food is always great. They have a variety of specials and Irish dishes including an awesome Irish breakfast anytime! The bartenders are very friendly and one is actually Irish. It is off the beaten path and is a mostly local crowd some from other bars. read more

2nd year for corned beef dinner on St Patrick's day. Great service. Excellent food others in our party got other dishes and they were just outstanding. Wonderful Irish music full band playing. Fiddle accordion bodhran . Yes it is a bar, but the restrooms were clean. The place is clean. The owner is friendly. Staff is wonderful. read more

I have to say something about Brady and the fact that all the people that work there are very, very sweet and all the people that go there are very local. The food is really good. The atmosphere is really good especially if you're a sports fan there's a lot of Irish people or Scottish. I don't know. I met a guy gilly and his girlfriend Regan, who is a very nice person what I really like about Brady's as it stays open till 4 o'clock in the morning and if you're a person like me and you can't sleep till all hours of the night and there's a place to go they're very welcoming. It's very safe. I had multiple good times though. read more

Decent bar food. They were very busy when we went there because of football playoffs. Staff worked very hard to keep up. Pizza was pretty good and my husband liked the wings. Local rustic bar ambience. Looked like a locals hangout read more

Amazing pizza and staff love going there for happy hour . Highly recommend it used to be Shanna key which I loved read more

Great local place with darts and good food and drinks. Nothing fancy but one of those great local spots with lots of locals. And they have DARTS. read more

Best damn cheese curds on the east coast. Also the beer tastes cold and good, thank you

We were a group of six that walked to dinner. The food was good and the establishment enjoyable. A good night out eating and enjoying company. We would return! read more

Meh Bad service - cranky drunken older lady that served us, well barely served us Drinks were ok Place smelled like a sewer The food was atrocious We need this place to be around for a long while- Let's hope they get it together Shannon Key was amazing This place is just in need of some good management and staff And a new chef read more

Decent food for a dive bar, where the best part is the customers that come in and the servers. This isn't a fancy place so don't come expecting 5 star gourmet food, but has great drink specials and fun atmosphere. The best food option is the tater tot nachos, sooooo good! Plenty of TVs in to watch sports, this place plays a lot of international soccer so grab a pint and enjoy! read more

See all

A great dive bar for a quick bite! My friends and I stopped in for a relaxed dinner before a night out. I got the Italian Burger and fries, it was a really unique flavor with it being like a pizza burger. Honestly, I didn't hate it!! It was suuuuper juicy, cooked to how I requested. The fries were super well seasoned & delicious. I also tried some of my friends barbecue wings. Overall, the food wasn't bad but it wasn't the best I've ever had. Our server was super friendly & attentive as well. I would still return back though!! read more

Brady’s Pub - Italian Burger with Fries - Irish Near Me - Key West, Florida

This was close to our condo so we could walk. We ate there twice. Tator Tot Nachos were pretty good. Family loved the fish and chips (not greasy or over breaded) Staff was friendly and attentive. Really good Cosmos and cold beer. If we are in Key West again we will stop. read more

This corner bar is so much fun. Families and friends having a great time. Food was excellent.

Extremely rude staff, very hostile and disrespectful. Cannot get waited on at the bar or sitting down, have to go out of your way to flag them down and get some attention. Newish menu is meh, this place was much better as shanna key. Not sure why they changed it, but it sucks read more

See all

I've been known to hang at Irish pubs, so was happy the find Brady's. Smithwicks on draft and one of the best shepherds pie anywhere. Server was great, I'm sure she's pleased with her tip. read more

This is Ameal's first visit to the newly established Bradys Irish Pub ( formerly Shanna Key). The new Lait (grey) paint work drew me in. The place is cool, and clearly a work in progress. Cheryl the Scottish bartender is outstanding as is the fish n chips. The fries were cooked to perfection and the fish extra moist and yummy all of course paired with a well poured Guinness. Ameal will return to try the Rubin, Shepard Pie and more. So far now a thumbs up for Brady's. Good American patriots too! read more

See all

Beer was good,as was the service. Food was pretty awful. Wife has fish and chips.Mostly cold fries and two pieces of fish. I made the mistake of trying liver and onions. Onions were ok,but the liver was tough as shoe leather. I asked the waitress if the liver was tender and fresh. She said that no one had ever sent it back. Wrong assumption. I are two bites... read more

Kicked out of this bar as a local whilst its raining after ordering a drink because i had food from a different place? Y'all really need to revamp your customer service, its no wonder this bar never stays open for more than a year, i come here and spend money all the time but that will be the last time, and as a tour guide i will suggest now that people stay away from this place read more

Brady’s Pub - Irish Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great food. Made an order To go for an anniversary party. The food was so fresh and delicious.

After a week in Key West and either having food that was just ok or not all it was cracked up to be, we discovered Brady's Pub. This was the best meal and least expensive meal we have had in Key West. Val our server was attentive without being overbearing and the chef Brian came out to speak with the guests. The food was layered with flavor, delicious and expertly handled. The atmosphere was friendly and inviting. It felt like we were at the neighborhood pub. Run don't walk to Brady's Irish Pub! read more

Had lunch at Brady's today. The Ruben was awesome along with the fries and gravy. Ruthie is a great server, very attentive and nice.

Stopped in for a pint or two and a snack. Fun atmosphere. Cheryl the bartender provided excellent service. Had the fish dip for my snack. Very tasty. My pints were served up in a frosty glass! Great spot to watch sporting events on any of the several TVs. Friendly and fun folks hanging out at the bar! I'll be in Key West for a couple of weeks and have found a great place to hang out while in town! read more

The 5 stars are because Brady's is really good at what they do - serve good food and drinks at a great price (especially for KW), offer a decent happy hour and have a friendly, locals vibe. Also, I just had the best clam chowder there that I've ever had anywhere. read more

After changing hands a few times, the have finally got everything right...good food and very good beer.

Great Irish Pub. Food is great, beer is cold and Cheryl is a great bartender! The patron's I met were also fun. Have FUN!

Great spot! Food is always yummy. We honestly keep coming back for the bartender Ainslee. She is AMAZING!!!!!! Wonderful service and such a great welcoming personality. Thank you for everything as always and we will be back not only for the food but especially for one of the best bartenders we have had on this island. Place is always welcoming and clean nice cold AC as well. read more

Good chill Irish bar with Guinness on tap with the best wings. Wait staff was very nice.