We came here on a Saturday night for dinner. There was a good amount of people but it wasn't busy. They had lots of TVs on playing the hockey game. The service was a bit slow in the beginning, we had to wait a while to place our orders. But we had no issues after that and the staff was friendly. The menu consists of what you would expect from a pub. We ordered breaded mushrooms to start and they came out really hot! They were okay but we probably wouldn't order them next time. I ordered the gar par chicken wings. We enjoyed our meals and were definitely full afterwards. read more

See all

Nice and cosy casual place for dining in.We had late lunch, but it's pretty good. our server was super nice and the food came fairly quick. I had firecracker burger and it was really good. I found it very reasonably priced. read more

Our last 2 visits at Brewery Bay have been DISAPPOINTING. Our recent visit we arrived prior to 5:30, ordered a little after 5:30. Thought we had left lots of time for our 7pm show at the Opera House. Ended up wolfing down our dinner at 6:30. Have waited a week and no response from BB. Guess they just don't care. read more

Busy restaurant with patio. We were seated in a booth indoors. Really like our seating. Service was good in spite of the rush. I had fish tacos with beet salad substituted for fries. Big portion and very good. I enjoyed both items. My husband had the Buffalo chicken wrap with house salad substituted for fries and he liked it. I would recommend! read more

Had dinner in March 2022 Apps and beer came right away. was ok, what to be expected. Server said we should order mains now as they are getting full and very short staffed? 55 minutes later my wife's food finally came, minutes later my main arrived stone fridge cold! Asked server to redo she said right away, 22 minutes later still no redo on my main order? Asked server for the bill stating we're done... She said its coming out now, I said we're leaving now! I understand post pandemic its hard to maintain full staff BUT please THEN do not take on MORE customers than you can serve in a timely manner just for the bottom line. This place was always full in the summertime especially the large patio, so I was compelled to try it , my mistake. (IMPORTANT SIDE NOTE) Downtown Orillia is going through a transformation from Old school standard fair to new Millennial driven clientele. From Artisan Cheese stores to Craft Breweries This town is beginning to Understand that the summer crowd especially the boating crowd, would prefer to dine in more upscale at least updated establishments and not have to pass by the less appealing seedier aspect of Old Mississauga street. I will support Orillia best I can and look forward to dispelling the reputation of old and proudly invite people to see its transformation for themselves. read more

Nice place in Orillia, the service is exceptional. The food was good, with a large portions. Overall good place would recommend it. read more

Always been great food and service tgere. The food is very tasty and service is always pleasant

I felt like hitting a pub for supper so I headed to the Brewery Bay Food Company which is just a couple blocks from my hotel. It's a cute place. There is a restaurant on one side and a bar on the other ... I sat on the bar side. According to the menu, the wings are "terrific" ... I decided to check them out. I ordered them with medium sauce ... Kira, my server, said she found medium too spicy. I usually like wings with hot sauce. For $11.97, it was a good portion. The wings were fairly large, as promised. The fries were good. The wings were okay. I don't like wings with breading so wouldn't consider them "terrific". Plus there wasn't a lot of sauce on them. Kira was very friendly and took good care of me. The manager came by at one point and asked me how everything was. read more

See all

Situated right in the main street of Orillia, there is a beautiful indoor dining room, and a large outside front patio. Our server was pleasant and efficient. The Caesar cocktail was very well prepared. The menu is large, with more of a pub food fare, with some options for salads, and a couple of entrees. The wings were well prepared: crispy and not greasy. The Rosè Cappeletti pasta had a good mild flavor, yet a little too much melted cheese on it. Pizza is thin crust and crispy. read more

See all

I came here last night with my parents, both of which don't drink but luckily there was a bar side and a restaurant side to this place. We arrived at 4:30 as the place was just starting to pick up but the service was welcoming and friendly throughout our time there. When I think of Orillia in general; it has that laid back cottage town atmosphere and Brewery Bay seems to know their target market. The decor is slightly rustic and the booths are rather large and spacious - so it is perfect for larger groups. I ordered the pitachos (fried pita chips with the classic nacho fixings) and those were really good. Both of my parents ordered meals rather than bar food and were not too pleased with their food. Conclusion, if you're looking for a laid back place to hang out after a hockey game than Brewery Bay is great! I would say you're safe to order the bar type food and stear clear of the restaurant type food. read more

Brewery Bay Food - Pitachos - Breweries Near Me - Orillia, Ontario

Poutine! Some friends and I spent a month in Orillia, and Brewery Bay quickly became my favorite spot in town! And believe me, we tried everything! Brewery Bay offers some wonderful sandwich options - some vegetarian! And then there's the poutine - OMG! Oh, and their homemade cider! Go check out the casual atmosphere and fantastic food at Brewery Bay! read more

Brewery Bay Food - Breweries Near Me - Orillia, Ontario

Great place and food. We had Stinky cheeseburger and the beef dip. You gotta eat there. Service was excellent! read more

Went here based on so many of my friend's recommendations. I was not disappointed. I sat on the bar side and had a Creemore Springs lager. I would have liked to see more of the microbrews on tap and not just the big brands. I went at lunchtime and ordered the 1 lb wings I was offered 2 extra wings instead of fries.(Bartender must have read my mind) I went with the dry Cajun. Just spicy enough for me and big juicy and piping hot, Very friendly staff, excellent wings and the tunes (Asia, Wings, Scorpions, Journey etc.) was perfect. read more

This is a cool place dark with a variety of seating. The selections are fine with many options. The soup and salad were very good. The poutine tasty! The waitress was friendly and helpful. read more

See all

I love the food at the bay! Tasty & fresh ingredients and a pretty great selection of beers on tap. A staple in Orillia for sure read more

The wait staff was really great and pleasant, the food was not. My wife's sandwich was a chicken thigh flattened with the fat not removed. The coating slid off the meat onto the plate. My toasted Club sandwich was quartered and the slice of bacon and sliver of meat was barely visible. My Poutine fries were good and hot as was the gravy BUT they were not cheese curds. read more

The service is GREAT!!! Food was pretty decent. Atmosphere is nice and relaxing! Nice for a small town! I would come back! The fries are crazy delicious! read more

See all

Fast, friendly service. Top quality ingredients. I can't wait to come back again. Very clean. Good deal on a full pizza.

Nice waitress, food came out quickly and on cute little street in Orillia. Several nice little shops to check out but they close early so check out stores before you eat. read more

If I could give NO stars I would, however the server wasn't completely horrible so I suppose they deserve one star for that. Went for Dinner last night (Wednesday) so it wasn't overly busy and I had to ask someone if they could clear a table so we could sit down. The server was friendly enough but we had to wait what seemed like forever to get our food. The bruschetta was OK - nothing to rave about and I ordered their "signature dish" Chicken Parm for dinner with fettuccine alfredo. The noodles were undercooked and drowning in alfredo sauce. The chicken was the most disgusting thing I can imagine. A flattened piece of meat, you could not only taste the freezer burn on it but it looked (and tasted) like it had been cooked the day before and then just reheated in the oven. The sauce on the chicken was hard and burnt. not sure how you even even manage to do that. without any alcohol the meal was still over $40. Needless to say it was my first and last trip to this place. Disgusting food and completely over priced. read more

I find myself here every single time I come to Orillia. It seems to be the go-to place for my husband's crew and he always runs into people he knows there. The atmosphere is friendly and fun. There's tons of booths and large seating, which is great because it seems that everyone is there in groups of 6 or more. I'm thinking that most of the people there are regulars, as there is a rotating rack of 100 or so personalized beer steins above the bar that people can use. We very rarely order any food there, so I can't really speak to the quality, but the service is great, the beer is cold and I always have a great time. read more

We came here as a family during this past summer based on the reviews here on Yelp. While the service was good and we were served in good time, which is important with young kids, the food assured that we would not be back. Everything was under seasoned unless you love dried oregano which was layered on everything we ordered. I am afraid we won't be back. read more

Came here after reading good review and wasn't disappointed at all. Staff were nice even though we arrived at the busiest time as a big group and requested patio seating, they did their best to accommodate our request and treated us professionally. The food was superb. Everything I had was just beyond my expectation. Pizza crust was soft kind which I usually do not prefer, but theirs was heavenly delicious. The best thing was the onion ring. Incredibly crunchy and no sogginess inside. Perfect. I'd love to see more local craft beer on tap at this restaurant. But overall I was more than satisfied. I'll definitely go back again. read more

Visited on a Saturday night, super quiet night life and not a lot happening. Server was great but food was just ok. Apps were good, burger was not the best quality, tasted like a lot of filler and for it being a super spicy firecracker burger it wasn't spicy at all. Greek salad had next to no dressing so very bland. I wouldn't go back. I expected a nicer ambience. read more

This place is a fairly decent pub. Service is slow. Glacially slow. We sat for about fifteen minutes while our eventual server chatted with her friends/regulars. When she did finally come to our table to take our drink orders, there was no acknowledgment of the fact that she made us wait a pretty long time while she chit-chatted. The food was okay. The burger was unfortunately overcooked so it was a tad dry. The sweet potato fries were standard. They came with a curry dip that had a fairly pleasant flavour, but an unfortunately gummy texture (too much cornstarch perhaps?). read more

The food here is amazing! Been here a few times before. Had the Grilled Cheese Lovers with a side Cesar salad and a Pepsi. So good!

We stopped here on our way through town and were pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere , food and the service. betwewn us we enjoyed the fish and chips; the pulled pork poutine, cheddar bacon burger and caesar salad; kitchen sink turkey burger with garden salad; and the smokey bacon grilled cheese with sweet potato fries. all were delicious! Server was attentive and responsive. Will def. return. read more

In the heart of Orillia, the Brewery Bay is a good place for comfort food! The menu is large and they have good deals (like the 2 courses menu for 10$!). Staff is nice and caring, food is good and you'll feel like in a cabin in the woods! Don't hesitate to stop by! read more

Atmosphere was pleasant the restaurant is very nice.lots of brick and mirrors ..it's a bit loud but one of the nicer places in town. Started with French onion soup. Was not great . Onions were not cooked through and the cheese was tasteless, croutons? The waitress asked how was it? Then grabbed the bowl off the table and slipped away before I could answer. We ordered burgers Firecracker, turkey, the kitchen sink. Poutine. Turkey burger was more bread than turkey like tasteless dressing fried . Fire cracker was good but like the kitchen sink the beef was dry and tasteless. Poutine was gross . Not real cheese curds and the gravy was bland and lumpy.fries tasted like burnt oil. Bacon and cheese missing in one burger and lettuce comes underneath the burger dripping wet and soggy. So....it's not a burger place . We will be back but next time to try something different . It's real close to home . If I had to drive I would choose one of the other restaurants in the area. read more

It was in early 2018 when we went and I don't know why I didn't finish my review. However it was good food. The Caesar salad was very good with creamy, garlic dressing and real bacon. I had Mac and Cheese with lots of cheese in it. My partner had a hamburger and fries enjoying them very much. read more

Love this place! Lots of veggie options great service kid friendly... The veggie chilli, pitachos and cookie skillet are sooo good!

This is a okay place to stop in Orillia is downtown. Food was okay but not what I expected. Service was slow and never asked for second drink through my meal. read more

Try it you will love it ! One of the Best places in Town.. Food is Excellent with service to match. Im pleased to have given it a chance read more

Brewery Bay deserves 5 stars from me. It's my favourite place in Orillia to go for a pint or a pitcher of beer and some great food. The service is always great and I've never had to wait long for my order. One of my favourite meals is their poutine mixed with strips of chicken and curry flavoured gravy. In the summer, if you're lucky, you can find a prime spot on the outdoor patio. It can get busy at times but worth the wait for a table when it is. read more

Great friendly place with tasty roadhouse style food. Only limited wheelchair accessibility. Level entrance, no access to dining area except for one table next to entrance. Access to bar area. Accessible washroom. No door buttons. read more

Had the Kitchen Sink burger and Bacon Grilled Cheese, both were excellent. Fast and attentive service to boot.

A great, locally owned business that provides tons of delicious options, even for the vegetarian in the group. The only down side to Brewery Bay is that it's so popular that it sometimes gets quite busy. read more

My favourite restaurant in Orillia! Last month I had their Turkey Burger, it was scrumptious! Wish the portions were a bit bigger for the price, but otherwise looove this place... read more

We had reviewed this restaurant on-line before deciding to go here on our second visit, prior to going to the casino. It is definitely more of a pub, but the décor is nice but not overly new. It was clean, although the bathrooms could use some work. Another place where you have to go downstairs to get to the washroom. Our hostess who seated us decided to sit us across from the only large table of almost 20 people rather than sit us at one of the many other tables available. Luckily our server was smart enough to ask if we wanted to sit somewhere else where it was not going to be as loud, and we were glad to have been given the option. It took us a while to decide, and the server was very patient with us after having come back a couple of times. We decided to go with a grilled cheese sandwich and instead of an appetizer got something called "Pitachos" which are kind of like nacho's, but done on baked pita chips. They were quite nice, but a little expensive for what you got. Our grilled cheese was very good, and came with a nice little relish to go along with it. Overall, this wasn't a bad place. We would definitely go here again when we get up there late at night, but not sure it would be our "go to" place in the future. It's got some nice selections, so we could visit again and try something new next time. read more

Brewery Bay has great service at the door and at the table. Make sure to stop by early as the restaurant fills up very quick around dinner time. Be prepared to wait for a table. I had the chicken wings/fries, and must say you get a good portion for a reasonable price and the wings are a good size. The rest of the menu seemed reasonably priced as well, and the only downside was to my memory the drink menu wasn't that expansive. However, having a family-feel the last point can be overlooked. Looking forward to stopping in again next summer. read more