Coming from the East Coast, my standards for NY style pizza are pretty high. I struggled to find anything close to home after moving to Milwaukee - until I tried Brick 3. This is the closest to authentic NY style pizza I've tried so far and man it's good! The ingredients taste fresh and high-quality, they offer a great selection of specialty pies, and the staff is so nice. Will for sure be my go-to for pizza moving forward. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - California - 14" w/pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

As a born and bred New Yorker, when I relocated to the Milwaukee area I was determined to find great pizza at some point. i stopped into Brick 3 while I was out and about, and I LOVED the pizza I had. The service was fast, and the slices I had were just delicious. This is exactly the kind of pizza I was searching for, and reminded me of home. I only tried two slices: Loaded Mac-n-Cheese and BBQ Chicken & Bacon, so I definitely plan to be back to try more of the menu. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - BBQ Chicken and Bacon - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

my favorite pizza in the area. crust is the perfect medium thickness... thin enough where it's not all you taste, but thick enough that it has some fluff & firmness. the loaded Mac and cheese is unlike any other pizza I've tried -- great Mac and cheese with some bonus flavor of pepperoni & bacon. huge slices too. simple interior with some tables to eat it, and staff is always really nice too. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Loaded mac & cheese - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

What a happy accident. We were purchasing some cheese at the mart across this pizza shop and wanted a slice. The pizza had a nice thinner and crispy crust. If you're a local, saw a poster about the Bucks winning, they offer something--worth checking out. Plenty of places for booth seating. The service was quick and the food made me wish I could stay one more day to try more. read more

See all

I'm not a pizza guru but this place was amazing. One of the best slices of pizza I've ever had. It was crispy, and delicious. The guys working were very friendly and helpful. Cool atmosphere. It was the whole package. read more

Excellent food and excellent service. Everything we ordered was spot on, and we even grabbed some par-bake pizzas to take home. Highly recommend--can't wait to come back. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Friendly service, I just don't think the pizza itself was quite up to scratch. It was pretty basic-tasting pizza. Not bad at all, just very...standard. read more

Went for a much needed slice on a night out! It was very good. Got a slice of the chicken bacon bbq, was surprised by how light it was, the slice was just right. read more

First things first Bucks won! Second things second... this pizza was amazing. We got in line with eight people in front of us and had our pizza within minutes. It's a small dining area but there were tables open. The pizza hit the spot. The buffalo chicken pizza was the obvious winner and I will be craving this pizza for months to come. I'll have to make a special road trip back this summer. I almost wish I would have never tried it because now I know what I am missing out on. Thus is life. Insider Tip: Get the banana pudding you will not regret it. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

In town for a baseball game and wanted a bite around 9pm and was very surprised to find out a lot of kitchens close at 9. Luckily for me I wanted pizza and Brick 3 is open late. I was willing to take a risk like I usually do with people comments. Place is clean staff is friendly and the pizza was delicious! That's it no other things to think about and give this place a chance read more

See all

This pizza is GREAT. We occasionally pop up to Milwaukee from Chicago for a quick getaway in a fun town with nice people and as we stumble back to our hotel after a day of drinks and food we always get a pie from Brick 3. It's delicious NY style and the leftover slices taste as good the next morning as the night before. Highly recommended! read more

(From September 2021) Nothing like pizza after an escapade of drinking and imbibing. And this spot is right on MLK drive where it's easy to access after you've hit up every bar and saloon on the street and fixing for your drunk munchies. I give them credit for being able to handle large crowds by having a various selection of slices to choose from. Reheated slices aren't the best in terms of taste usually which is what this place does. Went with the plain cheese and sausage four cheese; both had the taste and texture that you could tell was reheated. Nevertheless it's hard to go wrong with reheated pizza when you've had one too many beers. They got the location and operations to handle volume not to mention the selection on a busy night such as Friday or after an event at the forum. So they'll always be serving up slices for you. Plus they're open real late if it's that kind of evening for you. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Four cheese sausage, plain cheese - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

This place had me in awe I ordered a loaded Mac and cheese pizza (bacon,pepperoni, and Mac and cheese) absolutely fire, prices were fair, the service was really good as well as the restaurant was clean and was great vibes. I would come back all the way from Chicago!!. Definitely give them a shot! read more

We ordered two pieces of pizza to go (one cheese, one macaroni) and they asked if we wanted it warmed up and we said no, because shouldn't pizza that's left out be on some sort of warmer so it stays hot? It was ICE COLD when we went to take a bite and was absolutely digusting. Unless you like cold pizza that's been sitting out for who knows how long, do NOT go here. read more

Delicious! Great spot before a Bucks game! Quick service and an enjoyable atmosphere!

We moved to Wisconsin 6 years ago and it's been really hard to find good pizza like we always had back in the Philly area. Midwest pizza is generally mediocre at best. There are only a couple places in Milwaukee that offer authentic NY style pizza, and this is by far the best we've had so far. It's also great to have slices available to try different pizza varieties, as it should be! I wish it was a little closer to my home, but it's worth the drive to go get some really good Pizza. We will definitely be back to get our REAL Pizza fix anytime we can. Thank you Brick 3!! read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Cheese slice and BBQ Chicken slice. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

We had it at work and I was blown away by the veggie pizza. I've never had it before and it was supreme! On my second time I had the Caprese, which happens to be the house specialty and, again, I was blown away! Fresh ingredients on a big Ny style slice. I'll come back for more! read more

See all

Pizza choices and cheese bread were delicious! A lot of food for a good price, especially in the Deer District. Customer service was lovely, will be coming back soon. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - BBQ Chicken & Bacon Pizza Mac & Cheese Pizza Loaded Mac & Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

UH-MAZING pizza!!!! Came here before having a girls night and the pizza was so delicious!! Made to perfection! The right crisp, flavor, and taste! I had their wings as well, even more delicious! If you're looking for a good size slice of pizza that tastes amazing, paired with wings this is your go to spot! I will be back! read more

If I'm on Old World Third and craving late-night food, Brick 3 is the place to go. A lot of the nearby bars have food and the kitchens are open pretty late, but sometimes that late-night pizza experience is worth it in itself. Some people go to Ian's, which is nearby, but I like Brick 3 a little better. These are slices. They're essentially served on paper plates. The Caprese and lasagna pizzas might be my favorite. I usually get 3 slices so I can take one home for in the morning. 2 large slices is plenty of food for one meal. They're not open super late during the week, as I was disappointed to learn one evening. But on the weekends when they are open into the wee hours there seem to be a lot of people. The staff has always been pleasant. Great place to end a night out. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Lasagna pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I was in town staying at the Hyatt Place near the Buck's arena. I had a Pizza craving. I always look for some NY style Pizza. I was took a chance on Brick's and wasn't disappointed. It was very busy with college students getting Pizza's to go. I had a classic cheese pizza because that's the true test of any Pizza. The crust had a nice chewyness to it, the sauce was fresh and light and the cheese had a nice amount of saltiness to it. They were generous with the cheese and I actually would have preferred just a little less, but that's just me. I would get it again. read more

It's been a long time since I've been here and it deserves an update. It really is New York style counter pizza in the mke. I went with just a cheese slice and a garlic knot and I think my total was $3.5 or $3.75. You really can't go wrong. I had a huge foldable slice and while I went with basic cheese they had other fun flavors like bbq chicken, mac and cheese and caprese. It's got a great location just south of the entrance to the fiserv plaza off north old world third. I'll have to remember this place once basketball season starts. Staff is always really nice. Also, check out the bobblehead collection near the ceiling while they heat your slice. Impressive! read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Caprese minus that first bite - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Good afternoon! Just a quick note to let your team know that I stopped in for dinner the other night. Thursday the 19th, to be exact. While I'd been there several times, my friend, Andrew, hadn't. Being that I'm from Chicago, I tend to be somewhat skeptical about my pizza choices. It's been my experience since moving here that when they hear Chicago and pizza in the same sentence, they immediately assume deep-dish pizza. Not for me. Deep-dish is too doughy. It's good, but I much prefer thin crust. In Chicago's Rogers Park neighborhood, there is a pizza place that is excellent! It's called, Nueva Italy. Their butter crust is out of this world! That place is one of probably 4-6 places I tended to go to for pizza. I've now lived in Milwaukee for just over two years and I'm still adjusting. I still find it frustrating that I have yet to find a decent Chinese restaurant. For a long time it was pizza as well. Not anymore. The pizza at Brick 3 is fantastic! I'd been suggesting to my friend that he try it and, well, there we were. He not only thought that the pizza was great, he also thought the service from the two guys behind the counter were equally as great! To me, since I've been in the hospitality industry for some time now, is of equal importance. Both Rufus and Shane were super friendly, and displayed a loyal and genuine customer satisfaction attitude. While I will always go back, It made me happy to hear that at the end of our meal, my friend Andrew will also go back. Excellent! The only regret I have is that I forgot to purchase a garlic knot as we were leaving since I'd been raving about those as well. But there will be another time, for sure. So, thank you to Brick 3, Shane and Rufus, and every BOH member for making my friend's experience a memorable one. Also, thank you from my deepest of Chicago heart, that I finally found a pizza place that is on par with my home town. You now have a guaranteed repeat customer in me. My friend Andrew, too! Thank you again. Warm regards, David M. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Brick 3 "14 supreme pizza. Excellent! Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Man where do I start. They have some of the best pizza I have ever tried. before coming here I had no Idea Dave Portnoy had came and rated their pizza. he gave this place a 7.1 and to my taste buds that's completely disrespectful! if you want a 8.5+ slice you need to check out Bricks!! read more

Pizza was delicious and the staff was awesome! I would definitely go back and recommend!

Great Pizza it reminds my husband of the pizza we had in New York. Good service with a great manager. No place to go on a date just good food. read more

Yes, B3 is the place you go for pizza after you've been drinking. GET OVER IT! They're equipped for (and embrace) volume. As for the pizza, it's solid. Chewy crust and a nice base selection of "greatest hit" pizzas. Service is fast, communicates well, and can even crank out a whole pie if you need it (in under 20 minutes). Cashier is friendly and will quickly steer you in the right direction. What a great way to replace all those calories you burned off at Red, White, and Blue! read more

See all

Eat here!! You won't be disappointed! The pizza is huge and so delicious. We'll be back hopefully weekly :) read more

We went here a couple of times while we were down at the RNC. It was amazing. Shane, Grace and the whole team were very kind and accommodating. God bless you all! read more

We did a GrubHub delivery and the pizza was very delicious. It was a late night and didn't feel to go out in the cold. It arrived quickly and was very good. read more

WOW! Delicious pizza! Full of flavor and crispy but chewy crust. My mouth and tummy are happy! Get a pie or just a slice served with the best Sprecher Fire Brewed Root Beer. read more

Brick 3 Pizza - Pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Brick 3 is some of my favorite pizza by the slice, the staff is so cool and very friendly I would 10/10 recommend anyone to go grab a slice or a whole pizza. Service is fast these guys keep an eye out for you if you drift off so its a great vibe here and the ambiance is safe cute and cozy. read more

Not sure what the "3" is about in the name, but five of us, desperately hungry and led astray by a 9/22 PBS Wisconsin Foodie program that erroneously claimed there was Texas brisket (brisket is beef!) to be had among the booths at the Saturday Deer District Market, we stumbled upon Brick 3 Pizza on Old World Third Street. Sportsbar decoration in the tiny place, it's claim is to resemble New York/Jersey "slice" joints. Maybe 8 kinds of pizza are baked, then stored under glass. Take your pick of very large slices (one is plenty for a person), they will be quickly heated at very high heat. We had two Supremes, two Capreses and a "whatchamacallit". Oh, yeh, there are sandwiches and salads as well. But the pizza is just very good. You can also do take out and order on-line. However, the flavors, the crispy nature of the crust and the ingredients, all compiled by the lady in the back room, are among the best in Milwaukee. Who knew? read more

Thanks Brick 3 for staying open till 3 am on Friday & Saturday nights. Your pizza is damn tasty & the perfect sponge following late night drinking. Best by the slice around! The bbq chicken pizza is my favorite. Loads of grilled chicken chunks with a tangy sauce atop their New York style crust. Sausage or pepperoni are always good choices too. Staff is always happy & helpful. The facility is kept clean & organized. Prices are reasonable & slice size is generous. I dig the new bobblehead collection! read more

Pretty good for by-the-slice pizza. Brick 3 knows what's up - they're right on Old World 3rd, in the middle of a bunch of bars. Sometimes you have drinks and you need a thing to eat - and who doesn't like pizza? There were about a dozen choices on our stop - from plain cheese to more exotic options like buffalo chicken and mac'n'cheese. Slices are $4.50 and are "good sized". Toppings were pretty skimpy honestly but I did like the NY style crust. The dudes working were nice and efficient. They do sell beer and White Claw of you want to keep the party going. I'd imagine it's a total shitshow after 1am. IMO, better than nearby Ian's. read more

Came here after a night out. Typically we stop by Ian's but I had never had Brick 3 before so figured we would stop by. It was similarly priced to Ian's and other local slice places. They had a wide variety of pies - we opted for the bbq chicken and the spinach and feta. Both were decent, but the spinach one was better than expected. We also had a garlic knot and it took all the willpower in the world not to get 3/$3. The garlic knot was the best thing we had from here. Overall a solid stop for old world third nights out. I'm not sure about the crowd late at night as I came by before 10pm and it wasn't busy. read more

Really good pizza, person was not very friendly but, we all have our days. The best crust I've had since I lived in New York. read more

See all

Haven't eaten here but met the owner and a worker from here at another bar! They were pretty cool so I guess this place would be too. Next time I'm up in this spot I will take a chance, he'll Columbus did. read more

Good pizza, nice worker. Quick service as well. Got the pesto one I believe and the slices are quite large, finished like half until I was full. Not bad for 5 dollars. Enjoyed the signs and decor of the place. Could use less harsher lighting, other than that pretty great! read more

Service was great, portions were even better, and the taste was to die for! We had the meat lovers, pepperoni, buffalo chicken, and the macaroni. All were amazing and I'll eat here every time I'm in town. Interior was clean and the atmosphere was inviting. read more