I love Zaffiro's: so many of my friends think only of pizza but the menu is so much more! There are options for dining (room or by and at the bar) and a full bar. Every time I go, I always think, "They come to take orders or simply check on us the perfect amount"--I know they want to ensure I've got everything I need but they don't feel overbearing (this is regarding servers or the bartender). Finally, I order the same thing each time: garden salad with house Italian dressing and the special pizza (sausage, mushroom, onion). Salad is crisp and the pizza is consistent--the best. read more

These assholes fuckin suck!!! Gave me the wrong pie after I waited for an hour... and it was cold. read more

Awesome service, food and the vibe was fantastic. Definitely a local establishment that has been here for years. read more

See all

Definitely one of the best pizzas I've ever had! The crust is cracker thin and the ingredients are super high quality and delicious. My favorite appetizer is the fried eggplant, they are shaped sort of like French fries and my friend and I could not stop eating them! The menu, including wine, is super affordable and the decor is very vintage and nostalgic. The staff is great and super friendly. This is definitely one of my go-to spots and I highly recommend as a must try! read more

Tops for a thin crust pie in the the most real-deal, traditional Milwaukee bar setting. I was hustling to catch a flight and had the urge to detour for pizza. The Zaffiro team of Kyle at the bar, and host/server Sydney graciously served me a small pepperoni pie which was perfect for solo dining. Also, I had a brief chat w the pizza chef on a previous visit. Kudos to him for the quality of fare! I requested extra crispy and indeed it was. Perfectly done w char on edge and bottom. The cozy atmosphere adds character. I love the handwashing sink adjacent to the bar (then you know which patrons have good dining manners!) Def worth repeat visits when I'm in my hometown. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Personal pepperoni pie (10 inch) - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Bay View is outside the delivery zone we ordered a large, pepperoni pizza and cheese bread for pick up. It was still fairly early for a Friday so they said it would be ready in 20 minutes. Plenty of street parking when I got there. I liked the cracker thin crust but think this pizza is probably best eaten right away. The cheese bread didn't appear to have any cheese on it so I think we might have been given regular garlic bread by mistake. The hostesses were also taking the phone orders. One had an ear bud in so I didn't realize she was talking to someone. When I heard her say a total I told her I already paid the other hostess. That's when I she motioned she was on the phone. So just be cautious haha. I'd go back to try the pizza dining in. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Zaffiros is our go to special occasion pizza. We love that they offer green olives and that the crust is so cracker thin. Their large pizza is a bit smaller than most and I do wish they had a XL, as one pizza is barely enough for two adults without additional apps. However, the pizza is amazing and never really disappoints. We eat in and take out, both of which are green choices. Eating in can take a while though, they're usually swamped, but in the best way. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

When you walk into Zaffiro's you walk into a Time Machine! The pizza is cracker crust- we chose a pizza with too many toppings so the crust was a little soft so I suggest less toppings. The cheese bread is what dreams are made of- light big and fluffy. Full of cheese and comes with red sauce to dip. We sat at the bar because the wait time was too long for table service- so go before 5 pm to get a table or expect to wait! We had so much fun and enough to take home. read more

See all

Very disappointed. I used to Love Zaffiros. We are in an air B&B, 11 blocks away. And after ordering, we are called back, and told that they do not deliver to the home that we are in. Holy Smokes! Did not expect being denied delivery for a 7 minute drive. We will not be supporting the Zaffiros anymore. Terrible way to treat such a generational customer. read more

It's a Milwaukee icon! Parking is not great... It's only street parking so that is my only issue but they can't do anything about it. It's great pizza. Sauce is definitely a 10 because it's got a little zip to it. Toppings are an 8 and crust was an 8 but I did to go so maybe this impacted the crispiness of the crust. Overall price I rate at a 9. Definitely hit the original one because I do think the pizza is much better than their other locations. read more

The service was just as good as the pizza. We went in the late afternoon and it filled up quickly. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - The cracker thin Za was perfect! We also enjoyed the eggplant. If you're looking for crispy thin , this is the place for you! - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Frank Crivello is the best bartender ever! Always get pizzas every time I come to Milwaukee to visit family.

From the outside, you'd never expect much, but stepping inside feels like walking into a cozy little tavern that's full of character. It has that classic, welcoming vibe where you instantly feel comfortable. The pizza was exactly what you'd hope for from a tavern-style spot -- thin crust, cut into perfect pieces,and absolutely delicious. We're from New Jersey, so we've had our fair share of great pizza, and I can honestly say this was really, really good. A hidden gem worth finding! read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

After not having it for over 5 years I just thought why not get one of the best thin crust pizzas in town and it did not disappoint. From the cheese to the sauce to the thin crust, it doesn't get much better. One of the best pizza spots in town and for 12$ for 10 inch cheese onion pizza at lunch not bad for your buck either! read more

See all

We got seated right away which was a plus at 7:30 pm. Zaffiro's has a cozy feel and love the artwork on the walls. The waitress was fantastic and food came out in a timely manner. The EBF (Everything But Fish) pizza came out perfect. My husband raved that the crust was so crispy and thin even with all the toppings on it. The toppings go to the edge and the sauce was more savory than sweet. We loved it!! read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - EBF Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

My friend and I arrived at the restaurant probably shortly after 130 on Sunday afternoon. It was extremely quiet with maybe only a couple people sitting at the bar. We opted to sit at a red checker cloth table. Super cute place with very classic Italian old-school restaurant feel. Our waitress was nice and accommodating, I don't remember her name. My friend had a red wine and I had Prosecco. We both ordered pizzas because of course you have to have the pizza!! it was delicious and I cannot wait to go back! The crust and sauce are the star of the show. The crust is cracker, thin style, and the sauce is acidic and has a kick, just as I like it. I ordered my pizza with extra sauce, but because of the cracker thin crust, it does not necessarily stand up to extra sauce, so I'm not sure I would do that the next time I went. They do not skimp on toppings at this place. We also had the deep fried mushrooms that are served with a red sauce and they were divine. I really can't wait to go to this establishment again.! read more

See all

Hey! What do you want? Classic Milwaukee cracker thin pizza with good quality and fair price? Zaffiro's provides that. Ally provided good service and the food and wine were solid. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - $38 bottle of Montelpulciano - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Super wafer thin crust old school pizza to die for. So so good. Was a bit concerned seeing all the pies come out well done with maybe burnt edges but it didn't matter, the flavor was so good and the CRUNCH through every bite no exaggeration. The light toppings high oven heat and wafer thin crust was perfect, never had a crispier pizza and I've had a lot. Can't wait to return read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

First time back in almost 2 decades. While a table was open, I waited 40+ minutes to be seated. Took over an hour to get my pizza. Waiter came to my table a total of 4 times (one of the times was immediately as I took my last bite of pizza to collect the money for the bill). Worst service I've ever experienced. Pizza wasn't as good as I remembered from years ago. read more

So so pizza with unapologetically slow service. Due to 20% mandatory gratuity, we paid $33 for this service. We arrived at 12pm, and (most of) the pizzas didn't arrive until 1pm. At each step - drink orders, drinks dropped off, ordering food- we waited 10-15 min for the waiter to come back to our table. At one point, I had to get up and chase down our server to ask him to come take our order. The guy who clears tables was leaning against the wall and we sat there waiting maybe 10-15 min for him to realize we were done and to clear the plates. They also forgot my pizza order that arrived when the rest of the table was mostly done eating. The restaurant was only maybe half full and at certain points only 1 other table was occupied. You have been warned: have anything else to do after your meal? Good luck with that. read more

The most flavorful microwaveable crust flavored pizza. Old school vibe, celebrating 70 years. Very Italian. Small place. Tiniest stage and no sink in the bathroom (it's outside the bathroom.) Overall, it's worth trying Milwaukee style crust (I did like the burnt edges.) read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Mozz - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Not sure what I was thinking before but this pizza is a solid 5 Stars. My favorite pub and cracker style pizza in Milwaukee. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Pepperoni with Jalapeños: 4.25 Rating - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

First time at Zaffiro's trying to see what the hype is all about. Since it is know to have cracker thin crust. I went ez on the toppings. Sausage, onion, green peppers. But really wanted to get the EBF thinking it might fall apart. Sauce is different. Too little cheese on it. Mostly tasted the sausage which had a spicy hint to it. And crust lived up to its hype. Almost like a very thin version on Ned's. Would I come back maybe. But still have not found that ummpf flavor yet that causes cravings. read more

See all

Zaffiro's is a classic! Went on Monday to get their $15 large two topping pizza deal, we got onion and green peppers. It was delicious as always, the inside is such a vibe, think old school pizza place. Our server was awesome, good banter and very quick! read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I was looking for a place to grab a bite with a friend on New Year's Day before dropping him off and was glad to find Zaffiro's open. I had heard of the place before but this ranks at the very top of the Wisconsin-style that I have had in at least the past 15-20 years. Perfectly executed. I could eat there at least twice a week. read more

Zaffiro's was recommended by a Milwaukee local who told me it was "the best pizza in the city." Naturally I had to see what all the fuss was about. If you aren't a fan of super thin crust pizza, this won't be your cup of tea. We started with a bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon. We didn't realize it, but our server brought us the wrong bottle. She realized it before she brought us the bill. The one she brought us was a cheaper bottle and she gave us like $10 off for the mistake, so we didn't really care because the wine we drank was still tasty. We ordered a half salad which was still too big for two people. It didn't taste like any dressing was on the salad so our server brought us a little bowl of dressing and all was good. We ordered the pepperoni special pizza which is the exact setup of virtually every pizza we like ordering so it worked out well. Hubby and I were both impressed with the cracker-like crunch of the crust. The pie was topped with a generous amount of toppings. I wasn't a huge fan of the sauce. I felt like flavor was lacking. Overall, it was a tasty meal with a funny server that was having an off day, but it didn't bring down her mood at all. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - The exact pizza we always get so it was a done deal - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Can't say anything bad about this place. All,is good. BUT.....why is the other one in New Berlin so awfull?. Pizza is bad, thick waxy cheese and thick crust. We went there and asked for a pizza thinking we would get one like the ones you get here, after all the name is the same. Noooooo, we had to complain, they gave us another and when we got into the car it was exactly the same way. This is the only Zaffiro's that I will go to, but their name shouldn't be on another site. read more

Somehow I haven't been inside the original Zaffiro's in years. I love being able to get it at the movies, but I've been annoyed that I'm not in their delivery zone. Nothing has changed in the interior - possibly ever. This is a straight up old school Wisconsin tavern with a small dining room on the side. Service was very friendly. The place was packed with people waiting in line to be seated or to pick up to go orders. The pizza was predictably great - slightly charred cracker crust, plenty of toppings, good sauce proportion. We had three different types at the table and everyone was happy. Why four stars? Getting the food on our table took a really, really long time. Still a classic though. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Line - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Zaffiro's definitely lives up to the hype! I normally am not a fan of thin crust pizza, but Zaffiro's changed my whole outlook!! I loved the pepperoni and sausage. Next time I would get both on the whole pizza (rather than getting sausage on just half). The cheese bread was good, but a little too thick. Also the sauce that came on the side was not good at all. It tasted and smelled like dates... not good. I wish they would have given us a side of their marinara. Other than the sauce that came with the cheese bread, we really enjoyed everything else. We will totally be coming back for more pizza!!! read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Cheese Bread - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

terrible service, pizza is good, chicken fettuccine not good. The service was so bad, I don't think I'll ever go again!!!

They're pretty good! They do the unique Milwaukee style of pizza where it's very thin, very crispy crust, so when you fold it it's almost like eating a quesabirria. read more

I visited Zaffiro's while in Milwaukee on business after seeing it on the list of Top 100 pizza places in the US. Does it deserve to be on the list? If it was solely based on flavor, the answer is "no", but it is a very unique pizza place. Zaffiro's is known for their thin crust pizza. I grew up on New Haven style pizza, which is very thin, but this pizza is thinner than that to put it in context. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was extremely tasty. The pizza had a generous amount of toppings, really good sauce to cheese ratio, and the crust was super crispy. It was cooked perfectly with the right amount of char and doneness. I personally have never encountered a pizza that thin and able to maintain it's integrity while eating it without some type of fold...that's pretty special. The staff working at the restaurant is phenomenal. Most of them have been there a long time and I love the rapport they have with each other. The regulars were really nice too. Good vibes all around. Great atmosphere! Definitely worth a visit! read more

Catching up on Yelp reviews in 2024. I visited Zaffiro's Pizza back in February when I was in town for the Dustin Lynch/Blake Sheldon concert at the Fiserv Forum. Rated as the best pizza in Milwaukee, I had to stop by for a pizza review. The place was old school with a wooden bar and it reminded me of Vito & Nick's and John's Pizzeria in Chicago. I arrived for lunch around 12:30pm on a Saturday and there were only a few other patrons there on a cold midwestern day. I order a garden salad to start for the greens and then a large pepperoni pizza. The salad was fresh and very crisp. The Italian dressing was excellent as it was very flavorful. The pizza was a tavern style pie so an extremely thin and crispy crust. The dough didn't have much flavor and it was the worst part of the pie. The cheese was outstanding as we are in dairy country! Sauce was a little watery, but had solid flavor. Pepperoni was ok and they loaded it up. Crust: 6 Cheese: 10 Sauce: 6 Toppings: 5 Overall: 6.5 Service was good and the waitress was friendly. Prices were cheap as a large 14" pepperoni pizza was $17.25, garden salad was $4.25, and a PBR was $4. I see why Zaffiro's is rated as the best pizza in Milwaukee and it was decent-good. But there are definitely a bunch of better options in Chicago and around the US. I don't think Milwaukee is really known for pizza and I would rather stick to the brats, beer, and cheese curds. Zaffiro's is a cool bar with a cozy vibe and definitely worth a stop if you want some tavern style pizza in Milwaukee! read more

FINALLY tried Zafffiro's pizza. Don't live near East side so not convenient but was over there and thought, let's get one! We loooove MKE style thin crust. This one....was ok. Canned mushrooms?! Are NOT charming. Same style, better options Pizza Man, and Caradaro on Vliet. read more

How have I never been here?? Mysteries of the universe. I came with a pretty large group (10ish people) They have a decent sized bar with a friendly and speedy bar tender as well as TVs showing the bucks game. We didn't have a reservation (not sure if they take them anyhow) so the wait was about an hour. Not bad for primetime ( 630 pm) on a Fri around the holidays. Our group got several pizzas... 2 veggies, a sausage mushroom onion and maybe pepperoni? and the EBTF "everything but the fish" I personally preferred the sausage one to the EBTF one... just too many toppings IMHO for the thin crust. This is square thin crust pizza milwaukee is known for. We also ordered the house salad ( pretty good), fried eggplant (everyone's favorite) and the bread basket ( eh, I'd pass on that) My dining companions all went for brandy old-fashioneds sweet or sour and at about $7 or $8 a pop they were greatly enjoyed. Not sure why it took so long but I had a great meal here! read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - ""Everything but fish" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Great spot right outside downtown MKE off the Brady strip. We got the "everything but fish" pizza, a meatball sandwich, and italian beef sandwich, all which were amazing! The pizza crust was a perfect thin crust and great toppings. we got the largest size after our servers recommendation and that ended up being way too much food because of all the toppings, not a bad issue to have though! Definitely would recommend if you want something local and not too busy. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - EBF "Everything" But Fish Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

We ordered the Monday pizza special and a 1/2 Zaffiro's salad. The pizza was delicious as usual and the salad was good but they really raised their prices. I was just there about two months ago and the Monday special was $15. Now it's $20. The salad was about $3 more as well. That's a big increase! I don't know how a pizza special with two toppings is considered a deal for $20. It's so thin, one hungry person can easily eat it by themselves. Why did the prices jump so much? Unfortunately, I will be dining at other pizza places in the future. read more

The restaurant is clean! The food was absolutely delicious! My pizza honestly was incredible. The service was kind and friendly. I really recommend this place. Honestly best pizza in Milwaukee read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Good Pizza, service was alright. The restaurant itself was a tiny bit run down, but it was cool. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The ultimate neighborhood pizza place. If I lived nearby, I would be there several times a week. On our first trip to Milwaukee, we were wandering around and saw their old school neon sign. With neon like that, how could they not have great pizza? It was about 4 in the afternoon, but we hadn't eaten since morning, so we decided to go for it. Now while it's true that nobody just randomly walks into a pizza place and orders one to go, they didn't act put out or surprised. While we waited we hung out in the-- and I cannot emphasize this enough-- most friendly, neighborhood-y, chill bar area I have ever encountered. We watched the football game for about 20 minutes or so while they made the pizza and the bartender and a server bantered with a regular like they had fallen out of a 1980s sitcom. We got the Special with sausage, mushroom, and onion. Perfection. Great cracker crust and solid toppings. But the real star is that slightly spicy sauce. Friendly service, excellent atmosphere, and the pizza was so, so good. Can't wait to go back. read more

Zaffiro's Pizza - Very chill bar on a Saturday afternoon. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all