The salad was onions and croutons. I ordered penne, à la vodka. The noodles are ziti noodles. They are the mushiest noodles I've ever eaten. And the sauce does not taste like vodka sauce at all. The staff was kind. read more

My partner has ordered delivery from here before, and she has always been very happy. Today I picked up food for us. The lady who helped me was friendly and helpful. It doesn't look like much on the inside. They do not have any inside seating, but there are two tables on the outside if you want to eat There. This is primarily at a to go spot. However, one thing that is cool, they actually have a working "space invaders" machine in a corner of the shop. My partner wanted a meatball slice, but they didn't have it that day, so, the lady offered to put meatballs on a garlic and mushroom slice. It was a big slice, too! My partner liked it very much. She said it was delicious. For dessert, she had a slice of the Godiva chocolate cake, or as we like to jokingly call it, the Godiva, death by chocolate cake. I haven't had it yet, but she says it is so rich and so very delicious! I wasn't very hungry today, so I just had the garlic knot meatball sliders. Excellent! You can definitely smell and taste the garlic, the garlic knots, themselves are tender, and the meatball in the middle is tender and very tasty. They also come with a good amount of cheese. There was a marinara sauce/gravy for dipping, that was also excellent. It was just an appetizer, but it filled me up. I ordered from them again, and I had the mushroom/meatball pizza that my partner had yesterday. It was delicious! For dessert, I had the fried dough, basically deep fried dough balls covered with powdered sugar. No, not diet food, but they are delicious. The price was very reasonable, and they even offer a military/veterans discount. There is a 4% "upcharge", to cover their costs if you are paying with plastic instead of cash. Not a big deal to us. We will definitely order from here again. Thank you! read more

See all

Sometimes one only needs a pizza and salad. One slice or pie it's always good. I love to order online BAM it's ready with messages for the sleepers hahaha. read more

I would not be surprised to learn they buy their pizza dough from the back of a Sysco food service truck or Costco. Or, perhaps, they purchase the most processed, cheapest bread they can find, lay it on the floor, stomp it into shape with their feet and go from there. There is not the remotest of pizza dough flavor to their yeasty, flavorless, commercial processed dough. Imagine smooshed Wonder Bread. Decent marinara. Avoid. Sadly, there is absolutely no decent pizza in the area despite being a mere 100 miles from some of the best pizza on earth in the city. read more

0 for review. after waithing 2 1/2 hours for delivery. i had gotten to work already before the food showed up. not only rude, not food . Not for anybody! after calling we got a sorry, bye. Get out this buisness please with that attitude... soggy subs, the salad wasn't food. about to cancel a payment after i make a face to face complaint!. 20 years in hospitality here. read more

I placed an order day of blizzard. I figured it was a good day for pizza. Upon going at the time requested. I find they are closed so in the meantime they bill me twice. And no one is there go figure. I will not be a return customer in the future. Bad business in my world. read more

Update to the update - Picked up my pie: peppers, onions, black olives and meatless crumbles. Don't forget the crushed red pepper. I prefer to stick with fresh veggies only on pizza, but will try the vegan sausage next. Probably won't get the crumbles again. Note, they do use daiya, so if you're not a fan, ask for a small amount of daiya or none at all and add your own plant based cheese at home. I did that on one order and added more plant based mozz and kite hill ricotta at home and next day it was so killer- that NY - next day - cold or reheated pizza - the bomb. Vegan menu included in this review. Updating to 5 stars for the vegan pizza. I so appreciate a local spot that can deliver a vegan pizza that tastes delicious. Even the non-vegans were satisfied :) read more

Brickyard Pizza - Vegan Menu!! - Pizza Near Me - Saugerties, New York

They fell off. Their first year open they were good and I had high hopes but the last few times I tried this place it fell flat. The final straw was ordering 3 meals and one plain pizza pie and the pizza was so undercooked and doughy I was in amazement. Seriously if you are a pizza place and you place an undercooked regular pie in a box and give it to a customer then you might as well start looking on career builders for new employment because it is only a matter of time before you close up shop. Sorry you jumped the shark. You are a pizzeria that can't make and cook a pizza properly. As for the meals? Who cares they ruin pizza. read more

Brickyard Pizza - If this looks undercooked and doughy that's because it is. These became raccoon food. The rest I cooked in my oven to a decent crisp. - Pizza Near Me - Saugerties, New York

I do intend to try more variety of things, but I wanted to do a review because they have gluten free pizza! The gluten free pizza was a rice and tapioca crust, which was important because our party had nut allergies as well. We were surprised that the crust wasn't super thin and crispy, it had decent flavor and was super filling. I would prefer it if the crust was a little thinner OR they par-baked the crust before topping it, because it got a little gluey where the sauce met the crust. We also got a pizza, nacho tots, Buffalo chicken tenders, and garlic parm fries. The fries came in a quarter inch of oil(?) but they were delicious! We were afraid to eat the very bottom fries, lest we have an Olestra-esque shitting problem (oh man, I'm sure I just dated myself with the Olestra reference!) The tenders and pizza were fine, the nacho tots were the big winner among the group. Thanks for having gluten free pizza! read more

Lovely staff and great food! Tried the bone in wings, garlic knots, and burger. Very tasty! read more

Brickyard Pizza - chicken wings with ranch dip - Pizza Near Me - Saugerties, New York

See all

I normally do not post bad reviews ,but I am compelled to save people from wasting their time with this place. 5 separate occasions of receiving my food made incorrectly. I guess it's partially on me for going back so many times in hopes they would finally get an order correct. read more

Pizza was delicious. Big slices and priced very good. Only thing is I wish there was more space to sit. Not just 2 little tables and chairs Right outside the door. read more

Ordered on a Tuesday and didn't realize they had a boneless wing deal--was pleasantly surprised! I got the honey mustard wings and they were absolutely delicious. It seems like they hand-bread their chicken too rather than use the frozen stuff. I also ordered a plain pizza and it was delicious--even good as leftovers a couple days later. I ordered delivery and it came quickly and brought by a very friendly driver. Their weekly deals, large menu, and delicious food make this place a no-brainer. Can't recommend it enough!! read more

We tried to give this place another try and the only thing consistent is terrible rude customer service and incorrect orders. I'm not one to write bad reviews but i've had enough and want to spare people the hassle of trying to deal with people who have no empathy or consideration for the customer. We have four young children. We placed an order received a notification that our order was ready for delivery. We waited and waited and our food never arrived. I called to check on the status and were told that it had been delivered however the delivery driver must have delivered to the wrong address. We used to order every week until frequent errors caused us to go elsewhere.The man on the phone whom I believe to be the owner was completely unapologetic and annoyed stating " I guess we will have to make it again". Another hour passes... I called again to check on the status of the order and was told that it had gone out but there were a few stops before us. Before us? When I questioned why we were continuing to wait even longer due to an error by their delivery driver he basically made it sound like we were lucky they remade it at all. At this point, we had already waited literally two hours for our delivery with hungry kiddos and anyone who is a parent knows what that is like. We eventually did receive our order. the cheese was barely melted and it was thrown together haphazardly. I was absolutely disgusted by the lack of empathy or consideration or even an apology. Not once were we ever told sorry for the inconvenience. Any decent business owner would at the very least apologize or offer some kind of compensation if not a full refund for the problems of which they were fully responsible. With so many other pizza places with people who actually appreciate the business - there is no reason to waste your time and money here. read more

The best vegan pizza pie in town and beyond. I really appreciate them for keeping vegan cheese on their menu. It's so good! We order take out at least once a week. Thank you Brickyard! read more

Almost a year has passed, so we decided to give Brickyard another try. Ordered a veggie pizza w/ a side of calamari. The pizza arrived on time and was right side up. It was just OK - short on mushrooms and heavy on the shredded green peppers. Again the crust was disappointing, limp and doughy. The fried calamari was tough & chewy, w/ a bland marinara dipping sauce. That evening, we both got indigestion and for the next 36 hours, were grateful that our home has two bathrooms. read more

Huge portions of pasta with salad each. Didn't need to buy an extra salad . We will have leftovers for dinner tomorrow. Delicious food! And they have doordash delivery. Excellent! Will definitely see us again. read more

The food has always been ok here. Like their salads and tots. Living so close has made it a common choice of ours. However, recently we stopped in after a basketball game around 8:20pm. Their posted and advertised hours are until 9pm. I know that is close to closing time, but since their hours stated they were not closing for another 40 minutes we drove there to order something quick that wouldn't be an annoyance to their cooks. Nothing that takes long to cook and wouldn't require a lot of prep time. Salads with chicken. We were told the fryer was off and they couldn't make it. Then we were offered grilled chicken instead that they could heat in the microwave. My wife declined the very enticing offer for microwaved chicken. We got a slice they had in the window for our child, and left. During this interaction, there were 2 cooks standing at the counter. They were speaking Spanish thinking we didn't understand them. They were saying that we were crazy asking for fried items and laughing. This is not a great way to patronize the people that will be spending money in your establishment. Unbeknownst to them, we are both culinary graduates. My wife being a director of operations for a very large food service establishment, and myself having a Bachelors degree in Food Service Management with a long history of being an executive chef in many establishments across New England. We are very understanding people when it comes to local eateries and know what the industry is like. But from every restaurant we have ever worked in or managed, we never shut down the kitchen until the moment the clock hit closing time. We wanted to, but knew that is not how it is done. Aside from that, if anything was going to be shut down early, it was never the fryer. The quickest cook time and most options to offer for late comers. Overall, the way their staff acted right in front of our faces was not acceptable. I'm not upset about the fact we were not able to get something to eat. Simply the lack of appreciation for your customers. But when people with no experience open ANOTHER pizza place in Saugerties, what should I expect. read more

Not from the area and stumbled across this pizza place after running into Walgreens. Very happy to see vegan options. Great crust! Enjoyed our vegan meatball/sausage/daiya cheese pie. read more

Brickyard Pizza - the vegan menu - Pizza Near Me - Saugerties, New York

See all

Best Pizza around, and easily the best Pizza in Saugerties. Good prices, nice staff, and great cooks!

Food is disgusting horrible customer service! staff is nosy, and all they do is talk behind peoples back I hear

Ordered. Pizza to take home, excellent!! Asked for thin crust and actually got a thin crust! Wonderful balance of sauce and cheese! Very pleasant staff! Very clean. Will definitely go back for our next pizza. read more

I never thought a salad could get screwed up, but I was wrong. My husband and I both ordered a dinner salad with grilled chicken and balsamic vinaigrette dressing for lunch. The chicken was like rubber and flavorless. Couldn't chew it, the only thing to do was spit it out. The dressing was just oil, no vinaigrette. Three bites in and we both gave up. The best part was throwing it away in the 9W Diner's dumpster. It was disgusting for sure. Yuck! read more

There was a hair in my sub The brownie they gave me was ridiculously small old corner piece I kept getting put on hold in the middle of my order because I had trouble figuring out what I wanted I was on the phone for like 10 minutes got disconnected I had to call again the pizza here is great I like the service today just wasn't the best day the chicken bacon ranch is really good pizza I wouldn't get the subs and the brownie looks like it was open read more

Brickyard Pizza - The brownie looks like it's been opened and it's small and crusty - Pizza Near Me - Saugerties, New York

Very friendly! Good food, good service. What's not to like?? They deliver very quickly, ignore the delivery estimate when ordering online, they are way quicker then what it says. We will be going back for sure! Thanks folks! read more

First time trying Brickyard and certainly not our last! Staff was super nice and very friendly. Our service was efficient. The pizza was great, thin crust and large slices! We got a large pie, 18" for an affordable price! Thanks so much read more

Brickyard Pizza - Large cheese pie! Perfect - Pizza Near Me - Saugerties, New York

Excellent Pizza and excellent sauce! Great specials and a hidden jem in Saugerties! I always make a point to stop here. Owners are great. Thanks for a delicious lunch Wanda from SERVPRO read more

I wanted to love this place, but it was just eh. The sauce on the Sicilian had a very strong, sweet, flavor. It was not evenly spread out, so the cheese didn't stick to the pie. The mozz sticks were good, but not warm. 5-6/10 was the agreed upon rating. read more

We called from Formisano Bakery to bring home dinner. When we got home with the order, we noticed that there was no pasta with the entree. When we called, the staff were very friendly and informed us that the meal, Sauted Chicken, did not come with pasta- our mistake. They generously offered to deliver pasta to us, which we were not expecting. The food was really delicious, and the delivery made our night. Thank you! read more

Ordered pizza from here tonight for delivery, was fast and affordable! Loved the pizza, best in town Ive had!

Had a wonderful burger, there. When I went to pick my burger and my wife's meatball parm sub, they were very busy when I arrived. Shortly after I arrived, a person in the back came out to ask me what I needed, and she quickly had my order, told me how much and took my credit card, processed it it handed it back to me and said "good bye and have a nice day"...nothing I said here was extraordinary, this was a routing pickup, but all occurring with more people coming in the phone ringing off the hook, but they never missed a beat! read more