We have been coming to treasure island for over 30 years. Somehow, we have never stopped by Britt's. After driving around trying to find parking, and a place open past 9 or 10, we found Britt's Pizza. Everything we had here was so so so good! Three of us had pizzas. Crust, sauce, made fresh by them. The fettuccine Alfredo was garlicky and delicious. Definitely going to be adding this to our list of restaurants to visit when we come back to Treasure Island. No pictures, because I literally never leave reviews, but truly worth it. read more

Wonderful spot with vegan cheese option-- and it's delicious! Outside bar/dining area has great ambiance. read more

See all

Nice outdoor covered patio area. Service was a little slow but everyone was nice. We ordered the pepperoni pizza and garlic knots and both were very good. We ate for lunch and it wasn't busy at all. I would go back. read more

Had to cancel our dinner plans at the last minute so we ended up ordering 2 pizzas from Britt's. BIG MISTAKE! Placed the order at 8:30pm and were told we couldn't get delivery because they close at 10pm. This statement made no sense to me, especially since we were ordering from a condo that was less than a field goal kick away from the restaurant. We were also told it would take 60 minutes for 2 pizzas to be ready for pickup. That seemed like a long time to me but you can't hurry good food. Since the pizzas were terrible the good food line doesn't work either. These 2 pizzas take the prize for the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. M&M size pieces of sausage unevenly scattered only in the center of the pie. The pepperoni was more evenly placed, but the crust was literally burnt to a crisp on the edges and soggy in the middle, which is difficult to do so I guess that's why it took so long to make them. We also ordered an antipasto salad. If you look closely you can see the single piece of onion near the top of the picture. The meat and cheese were ok, for processed meat and cheese. A few slices of tomato and a handful of Kalamata olives on a bed of greens and a 1 ounce container of Italian dressing. Very disappointing, but compared to the pizza it was the best part of the meal. The worst part of this catastrophe was that this is from a Gulf Blvd restaurant in a resort town. Prices are resort town prices, but service and quality are way below average. Never again! read more

See all

VERY disappointed with our experience at Brit's. Our family arrived with a party of 15 and were told they could not serve us because the kitchen was "messed up." While we understand that unexpected issues can happen, the explanation felt vague and the staff seemed more interested in closing up than trying to accommodate a large group of paying customers. No effort was made to offer alternatives, estimate a wait time, or help us understand the situation. After bringing a large family together and choosing this restaurant, being turned away at the door was frustrating and embarrassing. Customer service goes a long way, especially when dealing with large parties. Unfortunately, this experience left us feeling unwelcome and unappreciated. We ended up taking our business elsewhere. Mind you we come here every year. And they refuse service because they don't feel like serving us. Ridiculous. Won't be back. After coming here for 15 years read more

Thank you for being open Christmas Day when there was a craving for pizza! It turned out to be a tasty mushroom, basil with gorgonzola and for desert a lemonchello, pistacio ricotta and a cheesecake. Service was prompt and helpful. Took about 20 minutes for the go order to be ready. Waited at the outside bar staffed with the biggest smile. Inside and outside seating is comfortable and nice. Thank you again and Happy Holidays to all that worked on this special day! read more

See all

Came here for a dinner with my family. The food was pretty darn good! the pizza crust had a great fluffy texture, and the toppings were great. I also tried the pesto pasta which didn't disappoint. I would only ask for more pesto. Generous portions and good flavor! They have inside and outside seating, and the vibe is a chill beach type of pizza place. ''Twas good! read more

See all

Ahhhhhh. We had the white pizza and garlic knots. We didn't waste any food. Everyone was super friendly and they let us pick the music we wanted! We will be back on our next visit! read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

we've been looking for a good pizza place since the hurricanes and our go to is apparently gone for good. Saw the review by Dave Portnoy on Britt's and tried it tonight. The patio is still being rebuilt, but the inside is fresh and clean with pretty much new everything. Service was quick and attentive on a Wednesday night. Both pizzas were very good. In my opinion the crust could've done with another 30 seconds in the oven, but that's just me. The star of the show tonight was the bruschetta -Tangy sweet goodness on perfectly done toast points. I kept going back to that dish throughout the meal. The naked wings were fantastic. We got them with a side of Buffalo sauce and blue cheese. Juicy,meaty but crispy skin. Will definitely be back. read more

See all

We called ahead to order 2 pizzas and 10 wings. We were told it would be 30 minutes for takeout. We arrived approximately 30 minutes later and were told it would be a little longer. They continued to tell us that until we received the order over an hour after we placed it. There was no adjustment in the price or anything after keeping us there for so long. We had 3 kids in the car waiting. We highly recommend you don't order takeout from here. They do not care about their customers! read more

Service was less than expectations, she forgot our fries until we reminded her after our pizza came out. And we were given water cups with gunk inside, and instead of offering us anything for free for the dirty inconvenience we just got new water cups. Felt like their AC was broken which isn't ideal in FL, it was way too hot inside. Pizza was okay, but we won't be returning. read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Dirty dishware - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

Got the pizza to go and it was delicious!! So good we ordered another pizza again for lunch the next day. Would highly recommend!

Awesome coal fired pizza at a great price. The tiramisu was fabulous too. This is the only restaurant that we ate at more than once while on vacation because the pizza was so good. read more

Delicious food and great atmosphere. Very homey and cute! We had our 2 year old with us, and he spilled his drink. The server cleaned it up for is with no complaints and was very nice about it. read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

Liked the bar! You would think it's a tourist trap with the location but the drinks are good, pizza is done well and the atmosphere is nice. Not very crowded, def underrated. Will be coming back! read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Laguna Special - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

See all

Best buffalo chicken wings I've ever had and incredible service. Place was clean and a nice amount of space!

Outstanding pizza. Best gluten free I've had in 20 years. Also had gf pepperoni. Prompt service too. read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Gf Pesto pizza - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

Good pizza. They have few vegan options and some you can customize to be vegan. We started with garlic knots without parmesan (vegan) and they were very good. Crunchy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Very garlicky. Reminded me of Italian focaccia. The marinara sauce was very flavorful. Then we got two small pizza, one veggie without cheese (they do offer vegan cheese but I decided not to have any), and one supreme. Both were good and small is enough for one person. I wish they had more tomato sauce. Also, the supreme seemed to be lacking in cheese. For dessert hubby got their chocolate mousse cake and it was very good. Service was ok. read more

See all

We came on a Saturday around 5ish, there was parking right in front which belongs to the restaurant. We got seated right away. We got a small half pepperoni and half cheese and a Margherita. The half pepperoni and half cheese was okay, I wish it would have been more crispy but did like the pepperoni they used. The famous Margherita was flavorful however it was on the more saucey size and not crispy on the bottom so when you pick it up, everything was falling. We also got buffalo wings which we got regular and then they took it back and put the sauce on it, the wings were okay and not hot. The tiramissu which i read on another review to try it, I would skip it. I had better. The service was okay, I don't want to express more about it. If you decide to venture and like your pizza crispy ask for it. read more

See all

The flavor was absolutely delicious--crispy crust, fresh toppings, and that smoky char you can only get from a real coal oven. It was slightly overcooked around the edges, but not enough to take away from how good the pizza was overall. If you love bold flavor and that classic coal-fired crunch, this place is worth a visit! read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Pepperoni and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

Wyatt was super courteous, very friendly and attentive! The food was fire too! Thank you for the great service Wyatt

I wasn't so sure about stopping here because of the 3.7 score but my family and I were very pleasantly surprised. The pizza was delicious!

Great food! The meatballs were divine. House wine was okay. The rest was great. Good service too. read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Pepperoni & Bacon Pizza - Large - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

See all

BECAREFUL!! Check their math or they just choose to tip themselves, and makeup numbers as they go. I called to order 2 small pizzas for pickup, and on their website the subtotal was $23.9. When I called to place the order I was told that the total was $27.90, which I thought was on the high. When I went to pick it up they told me $26.60, which made a little more sense-ish for taxes. So I gave them $40 and they gave me back $13 with no receipt. When I got back home, I realized it seemed a little sketch and called to notify the manager. I asked her what my total was and she told me $25 something and I stated I was told different totals every time, and none resulted in only receiving back $13. She said that I should've got back 0.22 more cents (which still doesn't add up) and no apology about their incorrect math. All in all be careful as that was very shady. I know it was only a dollar and some change, but I can only imagine what's done to others with larger bills not paying attention. Plus the two 10 inch pizzas (cheese and Hawaiian) were pretty mid. read more

Service was very friendly and around 5 pm on a Sunday we were seated right away. The large pizza option allowed us to do a half and half split of two types of pizza. We also shared a small portion of the house salad. The pizza and salad were nothing we'd rave about and tasted pretty mediocre. Parking is also very difficult in this area, despite them having a a few spots on the Main Street and around the side. They share a lot with the resort across the street fyi and they were pretty vocal that towing is enforced. It definitely got busy after the sun went down and all the beach goers were looking for dinner. read more

See all

Came in wanting a slice and since they don't have that, we sat and shared a small Greek pizza, which was the best I'd ever had. The pizza had Kalamata olives baked into the crust. Love that there was a full bar available too. Will definitely be back next time we're in the area. read more

Meh! Took a long time to get our carry out order and our large shrimp pizza had a total of 11 shrimp! Not worth the money or the wait.

Listen... I am on vacation and went to treasure island beach. Got a ham and cheese sandwich from here. Have been eating ham and cheese sandwitches for a long time. I'm 35 years old. Hands down the best ham and cheese I've ever had in my entire life and I mean that. The fact I tasted that will forever haunt me because I know I'll never taste one that even comes close again. Get it hot. The chipotle mayo that comes on it is INSANE. Pizza was really good too. I will remember this sandwich my entire life until the day I die. I'm from Indiana and will think of this often. read more

That was the best pizza !! Delivered fast & hot! I highly recommend Brit's ! Much better than the chain store pizza read more

I ordered the shrimp scampi small and it was delicious my husband ordered the meat lovers and my son ordered their Hawaiian all equally delicious & crispy. You have to try their cheese sticks. They're two big triangles, but extremely delicious. read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Shrimp, scampi pizza delicious - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

Carry out pizzas (supreme and build-your-own) and they were so good I knew I had to write a review. The place looks like a disaster from the front. No way around it. But let me tell you the pizza hit right. The crust is a perfect consistency and the cheese was great too. My wife is lactose intolerant so she got a pizza with no cheese and really really enjoyed it as well. I am usually pretty wary of local pizza places when in high-tourist areas, but Britt's nailed it. 10/10 would recommend. read more

Went to Treasure Island Beach today and afterwards we stopped in to have a nice cold beer and margarita outside! One of the best margaritas I've ever had! Yum! Next time we're gonna try the pizza! Looked delicious! read more

Service was really good. Attentive and funny hosts that were knowledgeable. Food was very good in my opinion. I had a medium calzone and it was massive! Delicious too. Even the fries were done very well. No complaints here and would definitely eat there again!! read more

Ordered two pizzas pepperoni and margherita, got one delivered and the manager accused me of lying that I didn't order 2 pizzas when my kids would never eat a Margherita pizza. Super great first impression. I never said I wouldn't pay for a 2nd pizza I just wanted it in 15 minutes so my kids could eat since we had waited 40 minutes already. On top of that the only pizza we received in 40 minutes was a cold, sub par margherita. $7 for 4 cans of coke when they were out of 2 liters. Will NEVER support this place again. What a nightmare! Should be ashamed how they treat customers at their prices and their quality!! read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Abysmal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

Love trying local pizza while on vacation. We got the veggie pizza and added Italian sausage to half. The toppings were plentiful and delicious, as were the sauce and cheese. There was nice char on the crust, albeit a little thin and crunchy for my taste. Overall, still a good pie. read more

great pizza!! We were in Tampa for a week and my family wanted Britts pizza 4x. Enough said

The Steak&Cheese is Slap City, OPT for Pizza Cheese baked on it instead of provolone, EXTRA MUSHROOMS, ADD Jalapeno And/Or Banana Peppers, Pair with a Fresh Mint Muddled Raspberry Mojito for a refreshing cool down from the spicy for a Properly delicious Delight. Oh, and you HAVE TO GET A TIRAMISU & BLUEBERRY Cheesecake. Trust me , share it with your table, they are imported from Italy, you can taste the love & all natural ingredients, which is such a relief from the typical processed garbage dessert literally anywhere else. Please though, D.Y.O.R & try it for yourself, don't trust some random foodie on the internet Everyone is always in such a jubilant , elevated mood, the servers and support staff go above and beyond, such a beach vibe, which makes this place THE SPOT to take a break from the beautiful gulf & heat of the beach & relax in some A.C, grab a couple Shirley Temples for the Kids , a Rum Runner for yourself & a fresh Caprese Salad for Grandmother That's it, Get Britts read more

Be careful of pricing! Menu prices do not match billing prices--and they charge for the pizza box (!) on to-go orders! And they don't give you an itemized bill--we are "locals," who do question their extra hidden "convenience charge" on mediocre food for to-go orders. The expensive pizza was tasteless and the crust was soggy. The menu indicated Mediterranean pizza was topped with olive oil--no such luck...instead just soupy tomato sauce. There are many wonderful other pizza options, on Treasure Island. Do yourself a favor and try one of those. read more

Great pizza after completing an event photography assignment for me. The staff was wonderful and so the pizza! read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - The Greatest photographer of Tampa Bay was here. Eating excellent pizza is a must. Anchovies and roasted garlic included. Enjoy - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida

Margarita pizza was bomb!!! We were at a hotel and they were here in like 20 min it was fast and the pizza was a good price. read more

Britt's Coal Fire Pizza - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Treasure Island, Florida