Absolutely terrible. This place operates online under many different names but all of them are uniformly bad - the food is slop and the service? They apparently just don't make orders if they don't feel like it. This is clearly some sort of scam going on and the ambiance of the place seems to confirm that - it's a takeout operation that pretends to be a "restaurant" but must be a front for some sort of money laundering. Stay FAR away. read more

Average pizza, prices are way too high, we're talking $20 bucks for a small that is dominoes quality at best, Even with Chicago prices that ain't it. Have ordered delivery and been forced to Venmo the driver for a "cancelled" order. Not worth it, there's a Pizza Hut and a dominos a block away, and better local pizza across the street read more

I ordered off of Uber eats at 11:30-11:55pm. It said it would take about 30 minutes for my pizza to be delivered by an in house delivery guy. I waited over an hour. When I called for an update he told me 20 more minutes the driver just left. That was 45 minutes after the original time to be delivered. I called again at 1:10 am and was told a couple more minute, the driver was almost to my location. I waited in the lobby of my hotel and after 10 more minutes went back to my room. as soon as I got to my room my food arrived. My pizza was cold and my drinks were warm. Crazy part...at 3:30 in the morning the phone calls started. I received 5 from the restaurant number and after I blocked it 1 from a different Chicago based number. After I blocked that number I got a text message from an email stating "The Son of a B!tch". I would say that not how you handle customer service. read more

Food is excellent. Service is probably the worst in Chicago....If you ever Doordash, your order can possibly be anywhere from 2-4 hours late...I still order from there because most likely I'm going to get my money back......I literally will cancel and then have to wake up in the middle of the night to a delivery, because that's how terrible their mamanagement is. Great food but a 40/60 roll of the dice with service read more

Broadway Pizza also operates under the umbrella of pasta Italia. Twice now, I tried to order from them and had a beyond horrible experience. The first time the order took almost 2 hours to be delivered and was ice cold. I gave them a second chance and had a worse experience, and then they tried to commit fraud by claiming my order had been delivered, and the GrubHub tracking was not working per them. I did get a full credit, but they tried to scam me. Maybe you can order and pick up, but delivery through any kind of app I would avoid without fail. Zero stars! read more

We arrived late one evening to grab a bite to eat and unwind. I want to mention that it was a cool summer night. I'm unsure why they had the door and all the windows open. While waiting for our food, we were swarmed by bugs and mosquitoes. The staff watched us being attacked and didn't try to address the issue; I even saw one of them chuckle. I had to wait outside for my food because it was terrible. The bugs were all over us and our table. Another thing to mention is that the bathroom was gross, with stuff all over the toilet. I wish I could rate this on the food alone, but the service was horrible. 0 stars read more

Broadway Pizza - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

We were in town for a Christmas party. We ordered our food and unfortunately too 2-3 hours before getting to us. The food did still come hot and was delicious. The person over the phone apologized and reassured us the food was in route. read more

I'm glad that there's a great new pizza spot in Lakeview East that offers something a little different from the usual tavern-style or Neapolitan-style options around here. I ordered a medium build your own with mushrooms, and it was delicious - I love the crispy, yet pillowy-soft crust and flavor of the sauce, and I can tell they use high quality cheese and toppings with how flavorful everything is. Staff is very friendly too! Highly recommend this place. read more

Broadway Pizza - Crust has a great texture - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Adjusted review to respond to the owners comments on google maps. As a customer every couple weeks for the last year, I've accrued a free pizza using the ordering platform of the restaurant - Slice. When I went to redeem it the company Broadway Pizza contracts with - Slice - did not have it on file and refuses to restore it. As Broadway Pizza owns the experience from ordering to pickup, they get the one-star review. I have spoke to Slice and they are unhelpful, and as this is how one orders from Broadway Pizza, I can not in good conscience recommend ordering from them. If they switch to, say, Toast, I'll be happy to order again and revisit my review. read more

good eats. bbq chicken pizza was immaculate. service was quick, little weird that there was a tv in the dining room with them live making the food.. but go off i guess. decor was cool. read more

Broadway Pizza - Interior - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Got takeout and the pizza is very average. Staff was very kind. But the ambiance of the restaurant is also very average and with other pizza spots with more personality around the neighborhood I worry they won't be able to pull in customers. For the price, I don't think the pizza was worth it, unfortunately. I hope they find their groove! read more

Broadway Pizza - Italian Style Pizza and BBQ Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Great new place. Ordered carry out for 8 people including 3 kids and everyone enjoyed it all. The fried mushrooms were a huge hit. I should have ordered double of those. The garlic sauce is a nice touch too that comes with all the pizzas on the side. The pizza is a little doughier than I normally get but I know people dig this style. And it was tasty. Good to see more pizza on Broadway. read more

See all

Not too bad at all. Price is right too. I'll be going there again. Might try something different next time.

It was just ok. The pizza was mediocre and no one inside but us. The waiter tried to make it better but there was nothing I liked.

We thought this pizza was really good! We'll definitely be back. We got it to go but they do have a nice restaurant that is BYOB. read more

See all

Actually some of the best gluten free pizza i have had in Chicago! Owners are SO friendly!!

The people are so friendly! The food isn't bad, but it isn't good. The pizza is doughy and could easily be a thinner crust to be tastier. It's kinda like a Dominos pizza. I fear they will be out of business in a few months if they can't get the atmosphere right and offer more fresh options. Paid 8.00 for fried mushrooms-got about 11 of them and the ranch dressing is clearly bottled. It's lit like a gymnasium. You're trying to be an Italian place in Chicago-even if it's a fast food Italian place, lower the lighting and create some ambiance. I promise you'll have more business just getting the room right. It was empty. read more

Shout out to Ben! Ben is a dawg. His service was great and made me feel at home. The pizza was fantastic as well. Being someone that comes from the deep suburbs it was the first time I felt totally welcomed and comfortable at a restaurant since moving to the city. But for real Ben is doing a fantastic job! read more

Great food and service !!! Reasonable prices. Pizza was especially delicious. Great location read more

Flavors are pretty good but I won't be coming back. I had the calzone and chef's special pasta. The calzone was supposed to have ricotta cheese, ham and black olives. It had zero ricotta cheese (that's not hyperbole, it did not have a key ingredient that's listed on the menu) and the amount of ham was ridiculous. There were ham flakes and not many of them. The pasta was better than average. The parking situation? A nightmare. The place would have to be a lot better to ever make it worth visiting because of parking alone. read more

We stopped in for lunch and tried their BBQ chicken pizza, half without the bacon. It was very good, especially the crispy crust. The service is friendly and attentive. We will return and try some of their other menu items. read more

Good pizza. Good Italian food. Nice addition to the area. They are new. You can bring your own bottle. No cork fee.

Ordered pizza and wings. Impressive fast delivery, excellent pizza and chicken wings. Fresh ingredients and not too heavy of a crust altho would love a thin crust with rice flour option. Wings were crispy on outside and nice and juicy on inside. Great new addition to the neighborhood and I noticed they stay open late. I think 4 am! read more

They are doing business on Uber Eats as the Italian Slice (exact same address and pretty much the same menu with a different name) and currently have a bunch of buy one, get one free deals. Great right? Maybe until you give it a look - the pastas that are but one get one free are almost twice the price of the pastas not on the special even when those other pastas have more expensive ingredients. And at least some of them are significantly more than the price on Broadway Pizza's menu. I understand a bit of an up charge on a delivery menu but this is insane. Cheese or meat tortellini on Broadway Pizza's menu is $8.99. The same dish is $24 for cheese or $25 for meat on Uber Eats. What a rip off! read more

Very good pizza! We orders a small sausage and a medium supreme. The think crust is delicious We will definitely be back!

If you want 7-11 pizza and pay triple the price this is the spot for you. I don't think they even have an oven. The crust is basically dough with no char at all. I'm sure it's all speed microwaved. read more

So glad this spot is in the neighborhood. We finally tried it for carry out and the pizza is excellent. Very friendly staff and easy to order ahead. I just wish the lighting was a little lower at night. It's just way too bright to sit inside the restaurant and eat, even though it is nicely decorated and byob sounds great. read more

All around great food and service! The baked ziti was wonderful and inexpensive. The staff were nice and attentive, we will be coming back!

It's okay it's just a very very doughy pie and doesn't have a good crust. It was quick to pick up though but probably wouldn't be back.

Really great pizza, more of a New York style than most places in the hood. Their pepperoni is epic--thick and crispy. A bit greasy to start with, but after a little napkin work it was fine. read more

great people and awesome pizza!! would definitely recommend, it's also in a prime spot on broadway which is super convenient