Fantini's Italian Restaurant is an absolute gem and a must-visit for anyone who truly appreciates…read moreauthentic Connecticut-style pizza and classic Italian done right. The pizza is phenomenal--perfectly crisp, thin crust with that unmistakable New Haven-style bite, top-quality ingredients, and incredible flavor in every slice. This is the real deal, not a knockoff. If you know Connecticut-style pizza, you'll recognize immediately that Fantini's nails it. Beyond the food, the atmosphere really sets this place apart. The carriage adds a unique, charming touch that elevates the entire dining experience--comfortable, inviting, and memorable. It's the kind of detail that makes a night out feel special, whether you're there for a casual dinner or a celebration. Service is warm and professional, the menu is rock-solid from start to finish, and everything feels thoughtfully done. Fantini's doesn't just serve food--it delivers an experience. If you love Italian cuisine, great pizza, and a place with character and charm, Fantini's deserves a permanent spot on your go-to list.

I really don't like giving bad reviews but this just did not live up to the hype. We saw a video on…read moreyou tube by the bar rescue guy raving about fanitnis and had to go check it out. We started with the whipped ricotta plate and it was a total let down. It's an appetizer which is usually defined as a small food item that is shareable among guest. The plate came with only one small piece of bread which we were forced to cut in half and then when we asked for more bread we were charged an extra fee for something we should have received with our "shareable" dish. The amount of ricotta was highly disappointing as well. I'm not sure if there is a shortage of ricotta but it was the thinnest layer on the plate we received. Now the presentation was very nice and the mandarins and radish added a beautiful pop of color and flavor to the plate but for the cost the amount felt cheap. The Caesar salad was ok nothing very special just a head of romaine cut in half with dressing poured on and more crostini that I didn't want because I just had to pay for more to go with my whipped ricotta . The chicken parm which we didn't get a photo of was wet and soggy and the sauce was too sweet for me but I heard that's how they do it in New Heaven. Either way it wasn't great and neither was the service. One bartender and she was just spaced out and our main courses didn't come out together and I'm thinking because I ordered a salad as my main but that kind of kink should be worked out system wise by now. The house Montepulcjano wine was in fact great and so see the band that was playing.

Had my first experience with this place today. Ordered an 18" inch supreme pizza. I was not…read moreexpecting to bite into the best pizza I've ever had in my life. The crust was perfect and the toppings were fresh and juicy. Service was good and straight to the point, inside is cozy and smells phenomenal!

Absolutely delicious! Garlic rolls at 3 or 6 = Amazingness…read morein your Mouth! The two pizza slices and drink special?= delicious and amazing!!!!! Pepperoni and sausage pizza slices AMAZING! I'll definitely be back with my husband!

Best pizza in Stuart and Palm City. Home made garlic oil is off the cart. Haven't had a bad Pizza.read more

Michelinas firmly known as Nancy's never disappoints with the quality and prices they have in…read moreplace. I usually get a meatball sub and wings Togo. This time the marinara was a little bland but every other time it's solid. The cashier Cade is also super attentive and helpful. Keep it up!

Margarita pizza is the best I've ever had. Their food is also amazing. If you haven't been there,…read moreyou're missing out on an amazing food experience, a wonderful atmosphere and fantastic service.

FYI- this is my go to Italian restaurant Constantly…read moredelicious food! Good service and a nice atmosphere...you can NEVER go wrong with coming for a delicious meal!! Pictured is the veal chop...We had the other night with chicken franchise! And don't forget their tiramisu for dessert!!

Ordered to go but of course I missed a step. Waiter came outside to my rescue. I paid in cash so…read morebadda bing badda boom. All that just to say the pizza had the most wonderful flavor. I was actually surprised. We've been in the area 2 months, ate at about 5 places they were not tasty at all! ACFP is delish. I wasn't too happy to be. paying 28 bucks for a pizza, but my sis and I agree - worth it!!

I order a pie with Prosciutto. The pie was burnt on one side of the pizza. Burnt to the point,…read morewell, that's what it tasted like; burnt bread. The prosciutto was put on the top by whole slice, so when you took a pie slice the prosciutto on the next slice would flop around. You cant pick up a slice and eat it without worrying about the meat going all over the place. Why not shred the prosciutto up a little into more bit size pieces? I probably won't be returning. Oh, and the pie was done too early. I went out to run some errands and arrived 15 minutes early and the pie was ready. If I had arrived on time the pie would have just been sitting there for 15 minutes.....If management responds and acknowledges this review, I'll take it down.

What a gem of a restaurant!! I had hands down the best chicken franchise that I have ever had! Side…read moreof pasta that came with it was yummy and covered in delicious sauce! The staff was so nice, meets you at the door, walks you to your table and makes sure you want for nothing! It's comfy and cozy and the booths are the perfect size to have a real conversation! My only regret as just as I was tucking into another amazing bite of chicken I saw a pizza go by me! It looked amazing! Guess who is going back for seconds!! This guy 10/10

Food was alright. I think Mario's is better and certainly has more food for the money. I wouldn't…read moresay no to this place but it's not my first choice. Service was good. Price fine.

Pizza and garlic knots were soooo good! Everything was fresh and made quick. My husband and I were…read morejust about to get Wendy's when I saw the big apple pizza sign and we are so glad we stopped. Definitely would recommend. 10/10 The two guys running the Restaurant were very kind and the place has a comfy family vibe and Thank you also very reasonable priced.

This pizza is awesome! Having had pizza all over I love to try different places…read more Big Apple is simple, but delicious! We got a pepperoni pizza and meatballs, savory and delicious! Can't wait to try more pizza from here! Check them out if you are in the area!

We're locals, and a few years ago this was our absolute favorite pizza. Then something changed and…read moreit just wasn't the same, so we stopped coming. I am *sooooo* thankful we decided to come back tonight and give it another try! We ordered our favorite--the Grandma pizza--along with an order of garlic knots, and everything was amazing. It's officially back to being our favorite pizza on the Treasure Coast! And trust me, we're pizza snobs, so that says a lot From the crust, to the cheese, to the sauce (the sauce is *the best*), it was all 5-star perfection! Thank you Carmelas! Xoxo P.s I should've taken photos when the food first came out, but we were so hungry we had to eat first.

Lunch today took a friend from church close by st Mary's . Service by Laura was excellent you can…read moretell she is a happy people person and loves her job! Food always consistent fresh and hot . Wish I had room for desert!

Thank you yelpers. We love to travel for good food. This is place is about 35 minutes from home but…read moreso worth it. I would recommend reservations. We walked in and were greeted and seated right away. I read the reviews about the margarita pizza but after looking at the restaurant we wanted to try the pasta as well. We had the Scoglio linguine which is seafood pasta. The fish is so fresh and with of pasta which was cooked perfect. My husband had the pappardelle braised beef short rib ragu. Everything was absolutely delicious. We highly recommended this place. The owner is present and very friendly. They also have a nice selection of wine and desserts.

Listen this is a place to go; considering the options we have in this town. Forget about grilled-…read morebroiled or blackened with slaw or fries. This is a real restaurant. We felt like Miami for the first time since we made the mistake of relocating to Jensen Beach. Mistake that we are on doing very soon. Awesome Branzino with frsh vegetables and outstanding wine list. Definitely accommodating staff and incredible desserts options. Best of all not overpriced like your 2 other options in that little mall. HIghly recommended!

Excellent Chicago style pizza and other food items. Friendly staff we have been going there for…read moreyears several different owners but always excellent food

Chicago "tavern" style pizza …read more SERVICE: Nice people great service. Fast.. ATMOSPHERE: Cute little hole in wall atmosphere like you'd see in Italy. Dining inside and outside. Across from the Memorial Park Amphitheater. FOOD: I've never heard of Chicago "Tavern style" pizza. I'm used to the typical Chicago deep dish square pies. This pie was sold as whole pies and by the slice. Slices are cut like a traditional round pizza. I'm not a fan of the new designer, thin crust, pizzas, and that's what this pizza appears to be. Pizza sauce was tasty. Pepperoni could've been a bit spicier for my liking and the crust was a bit chewy. BOTTOM LINE: As always with all my reviews, the bottom line comes down to the "customer so what". Would I come back? Probably not. Not because the pizza wasn't OK but because this type of pizza is not my favorite style of pizza. If you think you'd like to try and learn what Chicago "Tavern style" pizza is like, check it out. Otherwise, there were other great pizza places in the Stuart area.