Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Brooklyn Pickle

    3.5 (46 reviews)
    Open 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Order Brooklyn Pickle Takeout or Delivery

    Brooklyn Pickle Photos

    Business Info

    BROOKLYN PICKLE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Brooklyn Pickle

    Recommended Reviews - Brooklyn Pickle

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    chili
    Jessica G.

    Was really easy to place an order online and go over to pick it up. Everything was ready and exactly as ordered. The food was good no complaints on that. Decent sized portions and pricing.

    Cheesecake
    C M.

    Another great Yelp find. I was in the area, searched for sandwiches, and this was the closest place. And let me tell you...what a find. Fresh, huge, delicious sandwiches. They have sweets, pasta, and salads too. The bread was soft. But above all...bring an appetite as the sandwiches are loaded and big; about the size of two sandwiches. I can say this place probably gets busy in the spring/summer during lunchtime, but they seem to have a good system to move it along. Bottom line: if you are hungry and want a sandwich or sub...this is the place!!!!

    Logo
    Tink R.

    Good sandwiches! Great service! Everything was clean and looking good. Good energy with the staff. Thank you!

    Outside of building
    Wendy K.

    I hope someone from customer service reads this review. Yelpers if you don't read any other reviews read this one. First time here and a big disappointment. Where do I begin? Placed an order a veggie sub sandwich. I wanted it on a sub roll. They don't bake their bread fresh, yes it's frozen and the bread hasn't defrosted as of 11:30 am. Next the veggie sandwich is to have zucchini and they are out. Out of zucchini as a main element of the vegetable sandwich? How does that happen? So I asked the question to the guy ringing up the orders. His reply: their fresh produce arrives Monday and when they run out they are out for the week. I repeated back to him what he said and he said yes that's how it works. So if you come in on Saturday and they are out of items to make the sandwiches then they are out. Just horrid. My first and last trip to this deli. I can't recommend it to anyone. It's really sad because based upon the reviews I was excited And went out of my way to get subs from them.

    Yeah baby!!  Classic Reuben.
    Marc G.

    If you like sandwiches this place is for you. My favorite is the Brooklyn Pickle on dark rye. Pastrami, corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. Plenty of options for everyone. Got it to go for work and all were perfect. My favorite location is on West Genesee St. This one is new to North Syracuse and still impressed me. Enjoy.

    customers at the check - in counter

    See all

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Can't go wrong with a sandwich from this place. The Cajun turkey sandwich on wheat is my go to.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Brooklyn Pickle

    Review Highlights - Brooklyn Pickle

    Hands down the best sandwiches in the Liverpool, North Syracuse, Cicero area.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Sandwiches 424 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sammy'S NYC - Orange Surprise

    Sammy'S NYC

    4.2(39 reviews)
    1.1 mi

    Friendly staff, hood service, food tasty. My first visit. Ordered a Philly cheesesteak sandwich…read more Good prices.

    We recently decided to give Sammy's NYC Deli a try, and unfortunately, it was a decision we quickly…read moreregretted. When my partner and I walked in, we were greeted by a man at the counter and mentioned it was our first time visiting. His response was about as uninterested as it gets. Instead of offering a menu or any guidance, he simply pointed off to the side and told us to order when we were ready. Not exactly a welcoming first impression. The space itself was small, with a few tables, drink coolers, baked goods, and smoothie options. After placing our order, we waited...and waited. After exactly 40 minutes, I finally asked about the status, especially after watching another couple come in after us, order, and leave with their food before we received ours. I understand that takeout and delivery orders are part of the business, but in-house customers should not be completely overlooked. There was no communication, no sense of urgency, and no effort to acknowledge the delay. It genuinely felt like we didn't matter as customers. And for what? Two sandwiches--a roast beef and a turkey. Having worked in restaurants myself, I can confidently say that should not take 40 minutes under normal circumstances. I don't enjoy writing negative reviews, but this experience was frustrating enough to warrant one. We will not be returning. Save yourself the time and look elsewhere.

    Photos
    Sammy'S NYC
    Sammy'S NYC
    Sammy'S NYC

    See all

    Double Cheese - Burger and fries

    Double Cheese

    4.5(26 reviews)
    2.7 mi

    Pretty decent, gotta be real honest. Hot like your mom burger was pretty good, wasn't a huge fan of…read morethe aioli, but it was still alright. The fries were excellent. The onion rings were pretty good, too. I gotta say for a place that kinda screams "overpriced", it really isn't. Came to almost exactly 50 dollars for two burgers with fries, order of onion rings, and a soft drink. Honestly? In this economy? Pretty fair for the size and quality. 6 dollars for a shake kinda surprised me too, albeit I didn't order one. Server was nice. Place was probably overstaffed, but pretty great experience overall. Very pleasantly surprised. Check it out.

    Double Cheese is the latest restaurant from Feast Coast Hospitality & Design, the minds behind XO…read moreTaco, the recently shuttered Original Grain, the Hot Stuff line of bottled hot sauces and Fly Bird, their brand of chicken tenders that coexists on the menus at both XO Taco and Double Cheese. The calm ambiance and muted, cinnamon-brown walls of the space's predecessor, Cafe at 407, which closed at the end of 2023, have been replaced with TVs in the dining area and bar, a wall-length mural and a little nook with a neon sign that reads "Say Cheese!" and Polaroids of satisfied customers pinned to the wall. The menu taps into childhood fast food nostalgia, with burgers, fries, onion rings and milkshakes -- plus beer, wine, cocktails and boozy sodas. With five burgers, two chicken sandwiches, two salads, a few shareable starters, Fly Bird chicken tenders, a Chicago-style glizzy and a fried fish sandwich served only on Fridays, the menu isn't long, but offers enough variation to appeal to most diners. The wife and I stopped in on a Saturday right at opening time. We were sat and given menus immediately. We decided to share a burger and fries and an order of tenders. We ordered the blue suede shoes - a burger topped with cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, carmelized onions, pickles and house remoulade and an order of hot stuff buffalo tenders. Our food was brought relatively quickly and we enjoyed everything. Fries were fresh, crispy and seasoned, burger was cooker perfectly, the tenders were fresh, crispy, saucy and had just the slightest kick of heat to them. Our server was very friendly and helpful, prices were comparable to similar restaurants, and we has plenty of food to bring home. We'd definitely go again.

    Photos
    Double Cheese
    Double Cheese - Burger and onion rings

    Burger and onion rings

    Double Cheese - Photo wall

    See all

    Photo wall

    Utica Pizza Company - Eggplant Parmigiana - $16.99

    Utica Pizza Company

    3.8(109 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$

    We thought this place was a huge deal when we first tried it. We happened to be on the north side…read moreof town on pizza day, so we stopped here and picked up a pepperoni and 20 wings on a 39.99 special. The wings were good, plenty of sauce and good, crispy skin, soft meat texture. What blew us away was the pizza. It was just a pepperoni pizza, but somehow it had it all. Soft, plenty of sauce, the perfect amount of greasy and stretchy on the cheese, and then the whole thing had a subtle crunch to it. Never had that in a pizza before. I hate talking favorites for things as big as pizza, but this just might be my favorite Pepperoni Pizza in Syracuse. We've been back twice since then, pretty much on a whim when we happened to be passing by. First time was on a Friday, so we got some fried fish and a steak sub. We went with both the regular fried and beer battered. We ordered the philly/steak sub because it was featured on their website. We kind of know what we're going to get when we order a philly from a pizzeria, but figured it was worth trying if they're going to make it the first high def photo on their website. Despite the hype, it turned out to be the same meat, bread and cheese you get from any other pizzeria, or any other place that doesn't really go for it. The fish was actually disappointing - one of the worse fish fries we've tried in Syracuse. The regular fried haddock had a hard bread crumb coating that pulled apart from the meat. You could snap it apart to break a piece off the filet. The beer battered shrimp was better, but the breading was soft and kind of peeled right off. Fried fish and philly steaks are never a bad meal, but this is about as low as it gets without crossing into malicious. We saw multiple people raving about the eggplant parmigiana, and I wanted to try their riggies. I figured Utica, Riggies, can't go wrong. Once again, we were in town, and it was on a Thursday, where they have a few dollars off. The riggies hit the requirements with the creamy sauce, the cherry peppers, the wicked tender chicken, and the peppers and onions were a good addition. My only complaint is that they weren't better coming from a place named Utica Pizza Company. They were exactly average - sauce could have been creamier, hotter, more flavorful. The eggplant parmigiana turned out to be nothing special, I'm not sure why people raved about it. Just an inch or two of thin sliced eggplant, breaded, cheesed and red sauced. With that last sentence as your recipe, you could make the same thing at home. We also threw in a medium buffalo chicken pizza, which was really good, but didn't have the same amazing texture the first pizza did. I had high expectations for this place, so if it seems like I'm complaining, it's definitely better than your average pizzeria. I'm sticking with five stars because the pepperoni pizza we got was absolutely perfect. We've been working our way through pizza places in Syracuse for years and this one stands out hard. Take or leave the other stuff, but absolutely get a large pepperoni and some wings.

    Riggies are non authentic. Service was good. Not sure how a Utica place misses on a riggie but they…read moredid.

    Photos
    Utica Pizza Company - Original crew- picture open 11 years ago

    Original crew- picture open 11 years ago

    Utica Pizza Company - Hot Wings

    Hot Wings

    Utica Pizza Company - Street view in the days gone by

    See all

    Street view in the days gone by

    Brooklyn Pickle - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...