Mind you i hate coffee. I requested them to make my latte milky and not strong because i wanted to give coffee another chance. They delivered!! I'm surprised i liked their latte. Didnt skimp on bagel spreads. Just wish online delivery had toast options. Overall crazy good read more

I actually had pizza from this place and it wasnt bad at all. My mom bought for my son and honestly what a disappointment!!! When you have places like bagel boy of bakery city bagels this place can not compete. It taste like a bagel you can buy in a supermarket if not worse read more

Lots of seating inside. We got a Pastrami Supreme sandwich, which was great! Pastrami can be dry, but I was pleasantly surprised. However, for us the showstoppers were the giant chocolate chip cookie and the black and white cookie. They were soft and fresh and just amazing! . read more

Brothers Bagels - Chocolate Chip Cookie & Black and White Cookie - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Grabbed a slice of cheese pizza & a Margherita. The service was fast. Pizza wasn't the best I've had, but not terrible.

I placed my order of sandwiches and they made an error and they never fixed it for me after I paid for the sandwiches. I called and complained with the manager and he was rude and very unprofessional. read more

The location of this place is so convenient, and it used to be my favorite place for a good bagel. I never had issues with service as this place is for me:come-order-go, and I do not expect any chit-chat or pleasantness. The bagel shop is simple in the interior and has several tables inside and outside. I believe the owner change the dough recipe, cause they become tasteless and every one of them tastes the same. Hope they will get back on track, cause they had the best egg-everything bagel read more

Brothers Bagels - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

These place is amazing I use to go before they had pizza then also went after all the food is fresh great quality and made there the service is pretty good it could be a bit better but for a take out place what complaints can I really have and they have a couple tables and tvs there some people like to sit at read more

Great addition to the Brighton Beach area! The bagels are good and they have a lot of cream cheese options including tofu. I had an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, lox, and tomato. I asked for extra cc but I don't think they fully understand my definition of "extra," because what they gave me seemed like a normal amount. Whatever, it was overall very good. read more

See all

I just want to say I'm happy to have something in the area. Having said that, inconsistent pricing and inconsistent food. One time something is $4 and another time it's $6. Really, a bagel and drink shouldn't be $4 anyway. Sandwiches end up being $12. Two types of meat shouldn't be extra when you give half the meat for each. Food wise, people know when things aren't fresh. You're not saving the business money with day old bagels if customers don't want to come back. Worst of all, I hate giving the order to the guy at the counter for him to repeat 4 times, usually get wrong and then have to tell the lady at the counter the order again, typically paying for the wrong item. How about people order and pay and you give a slip with the order info to the person making the order. Lastly, could be nicer to customers. Sometimes it feels like we're inconveniencing them making an order. read more

Fairly good bagel! That much is true. It is filled with plenty, so you will not feel blue. The customer service is friendly and polite. The bagel is not too small, not too big, just right. The food tastes fresh and the prices are fair. It is near the Neptune Ave subway station on the F train, in fact, it is literally right there! The brothers are about as New York as it gets. It took a while to get my bagel, but I guess it is for the best. They sell other treats; which taste just as good. Like their Hamantashen, which tastes as it should! Is it the best bagel ever? No, no really. But you should take this bagel somewhat seriously. If you like bagels, I hope you will agree. That this bagel is a good one, most definitely. Stop by if you can, if not I understand. However, this bagel shop? I recommend. read more

Food and services is great. Everyone is so nice and the bagels are the best and delicious

Gave this spot 3 tries before writing a review. Decent bagels, will never compare to bagel boy. Last straw was my fresh squeezed Juice with pineapple, mango, and oranges. You're going to make me a smoothie, at least charge me for a frozen fruit smoothie. PS: it's so thick, I can't even drink it. Back to bagel boy we go. Also, please put a sign that dogs are not allowed and when you have a customer come in with a dog due to lack of a sign, please refrain from yelling at them about dogs not being allowed. Being nice will go a long way :) Here's a picture of my $7 dollar fresh squeezed "juice" read more

Brothers Bagels - Fresh squeezed "juice" which is so thick from all the frozen fruit that it's impossible to drink through a straw - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have read countless reviews regarding this bagel shop. In my opinion this shop is a great addition to this neighborhood. Yes it may not be the next bagel boy but the bagels here are delicious. They also recently started to offer pizza, which also taste great. Although the prices are high but that goes with everything going on these days I enjoy how yummy their bagels are. I hope this place is here to stay and will only get better :) read more

Variety of food not bagels only . Fresh juices,wraps, panini.. you name it. We had cinnamon bagel with jelly : good amount of jelly , love it. Western omelette ($8.95) comes with home fries and a toast : freshly made , but fries was too spicy. And whole-wheat bagel with lox and tomatoes was also vEry tasty. The total was $23.84. read more

See all

The place is okay but definitely overpriced . The food is of a decent quality but the people that work there don't really follow directions . Not much of an ambience b/c it's a bagel store . There are a few tables there , you can sit outside in the summer . Ordering online is a nightmare , you can't customize your order . I've had the same issues repeatedly so I know it's not a one off incident . Try it and let me know what you think ! read more

I have rated this place 2 stars today, but I have to change my review now. After an expensive salad and a unhappy mindset, I wanted to test their meat and breakfast item department. So I ordered, the Peter Luger hero, a 2 egg bacon and a bagel to go, on door dash. The order was ready within 15 minutes. I came this morning talking to my sisters, baby father and I was unhappy. But, when I picked up the order, my bag was huge. I wondered , what? I opened it outside and I had my order, but instead of 1 bagel, I got 12 bagels. I am unsure, if this is to "compensate" for the "expensive" salad or because I look the workers in the eye each time I pass by them, looking at the scenery. I wanted to go back and give the bagels back, but, I believe it was done for a reason. So, I will be coming the next 7 days, buying a large coffee, to subsidize the cost of giving me 11 "free" "1.75" bagels. Just the base cost and labor and coffee is pretty much a 25-.75 cent item to make. So, I guess this random act, known or unknown has changed my mind about this place. I can tell you, the brothers, if that's them, the bald, sicilian looking men, are smart people. Afterall, they have large heads for a reason. Oh yes. The Peter Beef Hero was a 6.25/10. My father said it was a strong 6. The bagel with bacon and eggs, a 5/10. Bland all around and for $7-8, I would cry. The bagel, on the other hand for $1.75 on doordash, is worth it. Not only is it fresh and is seasoned well, but it actually tastes like a 6/10 and is fairly priced to be honest. I guess that's why they have bagel in their name. Their child product, and the brothers; being the father. - Artur Siedlecki 9-15-2024 2:40 PM read more

Good food, horrible customer service. Placed two orders for pick up on the same day. Both times the gentleman at the window made it clear he did not wanna assist, the first time I gave them the benefit of the doubt, the second time I stood in front of him to see how long it would take him to acknowledge me. I've been able to write this entire review and although he sees me, he continues to act like he does not, as I see my order is ready behind him. Props to the chefs here! Wish I could give a better rating but their service takes away from it all. read more

Delivery was earlier than expected! The food is fresh, delicious and great quality. I ordered the Vegetable Tuna Sandwich with jalapeños, a Caramel Latte, and a Chocolate Twist. Great, thick layer of tuna for my sandwich. Their latte is fantastic! The chocolate twist was also very fresh. Decent pricing and I love that they're near by. Will definitely be ordering for them again. Very happy with the quality and their service. read more

Gave this place plenty of chances, but how many times am I gonna get a sandwich with stale bread? Not going to get a lot of customers, trying to sell, yesterdays, bread and bagels. loss this one for sure read more

Best bagels in LONG TIME AND THEY HAVE BLUEBerry bagels which are huge! parking is hard but worth it. Go before the they sell out early in the morning. Place is clean and not self service! read more

Great customer service the people are nice and it's a great place to go and eat .they have great quality food and their bagels and pizza is awesome read more

In my humble opinion this place is an amazing addition to our neighborhood. I was there once in person and also ordered a delivery through Seamless a few times. Every time I had a good experience. Staff is very polite and courteous. Great selection of bagels and multitude of cream cheese spreads along with many other yummy things. Bagels that I had tasted were really good-fresh, crunchy and scrumptious. On a delivery they followed my instructions exactly and nova lox sandwich was huge and tasted delicious. I rarely have coffee but today I needed it, so got myself a cup and was surprised on how fresh &flavorful it was. So "Brothers Bagels" Welcome to the neighborhood and Please keep up the good work, so we-your regulars, won't get disappointed. read more

The bagels are OK. The owners, and some of the people who work there, are not OK. One of the owners seem to be annoyed when you come in, as though you are bothering him. Neither of them ever seem happy, and never say thank you when you pay. It's like they don't at all care if you buy from them or not. I've only been there a few times, and mostly just bought bagels, as a lot of their food is overpriced. I did buy a BLT 2 times, as that was reasonably priced. The first one I bought was pretty good. The second one was really bad, fatty bacon. I now only go there maybe once every 3- 4 months or so. This is mostly because they are just unpleasant to deal with. read more

Brothers Bagels makes delicious breakfast sandwiches. Tried the bec and sec on garlic bagels and they were worth their price of admission. Fluffy eggs with nicely melted cheese and properly cooked meats living inside of a soft flavorful bagel. The spot itself is very nice. Very clean and friendly with plenty of good workers there to assist you. Back in the day we used to have the sea garden restaurant to go to as the kick ass breakfast spot but now luckily Brothers Bagels has come to town to carry that torch. Looking forward to trying their other goods. read more

Brothers Bagels - Sec on a garlic bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered a few times from a different locations ..Delivery time is always over an hour no matter how small the order or how close the location ***!!! Not best with service. Kinda RUDE on the phone. As if annoyed with taking an order!!! **** Pro: Food is fresh ..con: but mess up ur order 4x out of 5. Don't tell you the amount right away but ask for ur card info and charge you. Also pricey. read more

Can't lie, that I was somewhat disappointed last Tuesday when I picked up a catering order placed the day before for pick up in the morning. The bagels were nicely split as I asked and halfed as well (although I didn't ask for that). I also ordered several spreads to go with. I let them know it was for 12-14 people in my office and I needed plates and utensils. The bagels were hard and dry. They must have been from the nite before. I also noticed that the toppings were somewhat scarce on the everything bagels and the sesame bagels. We received only 8 plates and knives so I had to run out to get additional plastic knives and plates. This is not usual. I've always gotten great bagels and spreads here. I would not recommend placing your order ahead. read more

Garbage place treating people like they owe them something food is taking them 20mins to make a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel horrible experience with the nasty guy at the front didn't even apologize he told me whats the issue... read more

I don't understand all of the negative reviews, especially as it concerns the food. I've been shopping here for bagels every week and I haven't had a bad one yet. read more

If you want to get a satisfied meal or snack this is the place to visit!!! My brother and I had delicious wraps ))) read more

shit was W the pizza was fire no bathroom but tv bagels and pizza buffalo was so good and the drinks

The best I've had in a long time. Great owners. I spoke to Simon and he was very courteous and kind, regular Brooklyn guy. I grabbed two dozen for my family in New Jersey who can't get real Brooklyn bagels. read more

This bagel store sells excellent and fresh bagels and almost all types of sandwiches. I love shopping and buying here because the food is and tastes good. The store is very clean, neat, tidy and beautiful. I usually buy here before I go to church because it is near my church. I even enjoy the trip to this location and look forward to buying here every weekend. read more

Place is great well needed in the neighborhood. Bagels are fresh and delicious Staff is very friendly read more

Ordered from brothers bagels, they advertise 35 min delivery time. Order took over an a hour and 30 mins. Food arrived ice cold and went into the garbage, they offered to remake it but who wants to wait another 1.5 hours. read more

Out of the last 3 times I went there, all 3 of my orders were wrong. I was just talking to a friend about it and the only reason this place exists is because of its' location and proximity to a densely populated residential building area. Their bagels taste like they're made with water from Flint, MI. I really really wish I lived closer to a better bagel store. I ordered a bagel with lox, scallion cream cheese, tomato and onion- this guy puts lox cc and scallion cc on the same bagel. WHAT IN THE ACTUAL F****. All I wanted was to enjoy my lunch on a stressful day but instead I get a bagel with 2 pounds of cream cheese on it. Now I'm legit never coming back here. read more

Solid spot, just came through the other day. Bagels are on point, no longer need to shlep to Bagel Boy! A much-needed cafe in this area. Espresso blend it pretty on point as well btw. read more

Ordered a hot hero and a pound of macaroni salad via Grub Hub. Delivery guy hung my food on my door knob and no one notified me it had been delivered, nor did he ring my door bell. One hour after ordering Grub Hub shows that my order is "in the works" and arriving soon. So I called Brothers Bagels an hour later and the guy on the phone lied and said I didn't get the phone call or hear the door bell. Brothers Bagels basically blamed the customer for them dropping the ball. My hot sandwich was cold and my macaroni salad was warm. All he had to do was apologize and admit fault. Nope, he doubled down and argued with me insinuating that it was my fault. Bad business practice. I attached a screen shot just now of the Grub Hub status just to prove Brothers Bagels was lying. Wise up or loose customers... read more

Brothers Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

great place. You get anything you like there (like Alice's restaurant :)), breakfast, lunch, dinner. Bagels always fresh. Service is great. Prices reasonable. About five tables there. read more

Solid bagel place--MUCH needed in the neighborhood. Everyone there is super friendly, and prices rival those at other bagel stores. Bagels always taste fresh, and their iced coffee is pretty good too! read more

My new breakfast and lunch spot!! So happy this place opened up in my neighborhood! Can't wait to try more things on the menu.