You know what Crawfordsville didn't need? Another pizza joint. You know what Crawfordsville did need? A high quality pizza joint like Mama Fazio's. Sadly, even with all the pizza places in town, my favorite was still, as much as I hate to admit, Pizza Hut...until last night after trying Mama Fazio's. We ordered breadsticks and an XL (18 inch) supreme pizza (no anchovies)to be delivered to the new brewery in town. I loved that the breadsticks orders each included two dipping sauces--no fighting over dipping choices there! The breadsticks were soft and well seasoned. The supreme pizza was amazing, even warmed up for lunch today. Toppings stuffed high and covered in fresh mozzarella cheese. I think this is the only pizza place in Crawfordsville with ground sausage other than Arni's. My only complaint is that they used canned mushrooms instead of fresh. That actually tends to be a deal-breaker for me, but the rest of the pizza was so good that I can overlook it! I see a lot of orders from Mama Fazio's in our future. read more

Mama Fazio's Pizza - XL supreme pizza (no onion or anchovies) - Pizza Near Me - Crawfordsville, Indiana

Barstool fan review Frankie we are here in Crawfordsville. Home of the worst restaurants in Indiana. One bite everyone knows the rules. Mama Fazio's is a hole in the wall pizzeria just off the corner of the blustering downtown Crawfordsville. One bite, everyone knows the rules. Just on pizza alone. It's one of the best in town, which isn't saying much. If you want to try the blandest pizza in all the land Crawfordsville is the place. Arnis with their tomato paste sauce. Marco's with their cardboard crust. And then the collection of national conglomerates. That is about it. But one bite, everyone knows the rules---- 6.3. One bite. Everyone knows the rules. The flop was real. Real bad. Cheese thicker than crust. No flakiness. Too much oil not enough flour. Sauce is real good. Pepperoni spicy. Too much cheese. Basic. But might be the best pizza in Crawfordsville. Which isn't saying much. Three stars is on the salad, breadsticks, and wings. The sauce came on the side which looked like the nacho cheese I ordered for the breadsticks. Salad was good. Not Arni's good, but it's hard to screw up a salad. I could tell their dough and breadsticks were frozen. Three stars on the location. Most restaurants in C-Ville are two stars. So it is above average. Rookie rating scale by Yelp! Should be a 2.7. read more

Love this place. It's the sauce. I'm not sure what kinda magic they do with it but I personally love it. Very thick, meaty, saucy, delicious. Just give it a try, its worth it. read more

Cardboard crust and Salad dressing from a packet, do not make an Italian restaurant GOOD! The server said "OH, you're in for real treat, our pizza is SO GOOD" Not with 27.00 for a small pizza and two salads! If your going to open a pizza joint, you should make your own crust! read more

Visited the pizza restaurant on Nov 21, 2017. The pizza was cooked to order and was quite tasty. The service was also great. This is a family owned business that we highly recommend. They offer appetizers, salads, sandwiches, create your own pizzas, speciality pizzas, and desserts. They deliver to customers in Lake Holiday, New Market and other surrounding areas. There is a $10.00 minimum order for delivery. Of course they offer carry out too. read more

This might be decent pizza for Crawfordsville Indiana, but it's poor pizza in general. They don't make their own dough. They don't make their own crusts. The pre-made crusts they do use are far more cardboardy than not. Even ordering extra cheese, leaves you wanting more cheese. The place is clean and the workers pleassnt enough, but if you can't be bothered to make dough, you shouldn't make pizza. I can't comment on the rest of the menu, I'm just about the pizza. read more

Ordered Hawaiian pizza and breadsticks. Both taste awesome! Pizza has a thin crust that's fantastic with just enough crunch. Fresh ingredients, only issue is maybe have smaller chunks of ham so it doesn't slide off. The pizza is soooooo good! Definitely need to comeback and try the meatball bake! read more

Mama Fazio's Pizza - Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crawfordsville, Indiana

See all

Sometimes you just don't want Pizza or, sometimes you want a dinner so you add on to the pizza order. Their salads are great. Not bagged but, freshly cut lettuce and veggies.You can tell them exactly what you'd like in the salad also! Clean, crisp, chilled and delicious! Sandwiches and sides are also great. If you're in the mood for a treat, the cannoli's are authentic and the cheese cake is fresh and delicious. Not friends with them, don't know them, just trying to help you with a good takeout choice. By the way...the previous reviewer to me stated that Mama Fazio's had deleted their Facebook page because of bad reviews. Not true. Facebook page is there for all to see. Don't know why people have to be so mean. You really could destroy a person's business by spreading false statements of any kind. One of the very first lessons I was taught as a child was..."if you haven't got anything nice to say, don't say anything at all" read more

The pizza was great. We have eaten here a few times now and we will def go back. The staff is also very friendly and it is one of our favorite places to grab pizza now. read more

We came into town for a weekend, chose this place because they had a gluten free crust (my fiancé had celiacs). It was so good we ordered it two nights in a row! The sauce is great! read more

Delivery was prompt, a rarity for delivery in this town. Toppings were not skimpy, which was nice. Crust was tough and no rise to it at all. I prefer a thin crust pizza, but this had more of a frozen Totino's Pizza taste to it. Garlic bread was alright, but still had that straight from the freezer feel to it. read more

Love at first bite! We were traveling through the area and wanted to eat local. Our great luck was to walk into Mama Fazio's. We have had pizza all over the country and this was exceptional! Crust was not too thin, but crunchy. Perfect amount of sauce and just the right seasoning. Then there is dessert, the cannoli was better than what I had at a high end Italian restaurant recently. To make everything even better, everyone there was so cordial. We chatted with employees and owner. They love what they do and are darn good at it! This is pizza worth the trip! read more

Bad just bad, save your money and time, they claim to be amazing but blah it's horrible.... shortly after I reviewed this I got a crappy message saying I shouldn't have put this on there. I don't know if it was an owner or employee but I feel that was very tasteless to do. I travel a lot and try places out. I always give another shot but not if I'm going to get crappy messages for saying how I feel read more

They don't make their own crust, the pizza is below chain standards, and the prices are too high. At that point, there's not a lot going for it. But when I called in an order and asked for it to be "pie cut" (I hate the Midwest trend toward cutting non-Sicilian pizza in squares), they were both confused and rude. "You mean, like triangles?" they asked. I tried to remain polite, and said, "Yes. I never thought of it that way." What I really wanted to say was "Well, just pretend you're making *real* pizza," or make a geometry joke. read more

Crust was pre-made. Kinda like what you'd buy at the the grocery store. Not at all what I want out of a local place. Was expecting a lot more read more

Absolutely loved this! We have had nothing but great service, quick, outstanding pizza, wings, sandwiches and breadsticks everytime. They even delivered to our house which is just the cherry to my new favorite pizza place. The only disappointment is they close early, I like pizza at midnight and everytime I really want pizza my choice isnt an option. read more

We were passing through Crawfordsville and happened upon this spot. This is a little hole in the wall, small town restaurant. The food was ok, we had a personal pizza and Stromboli, the crust was thin on the pizza and the stromboli were on a sub roll, a sandwich. I wasn't expecting a sandwich, but the filling was good. Cannoli's tasted home made. The service was good and the staff were friendly. The food came out fast. Seating is limited. Another plus, they have parking spaces for the restaurant so you didnt have to pay for parking. read more

Really enjoyed our great tasting pizza! Service was awesome and kept our drinks filled! Super breadsticks that our grandson asks for all the time! Clean and friendly atmosphere. We drive from Westfield, Indiana just to have their delicious pizza! read more

I've tried every pizza place in town but none of them can compare! Just went in and ate a couple of days ago with my boyfriend (first time we had been inside) and we had the most fun! The owner is a great guy who cares about making delicious food, running a good business, and making sure his guest are well taken care of! We first fell in love with their awesome wings (the sauce is perfect) but then we tried the pizza and breadsticks oh and dessert! everything is what you would want from a small quality pizza place! read more