Brothers Pizza

4.3 (15 reviews)

InexpensivePizza

Add Review

Call

Directions

Order Brothers Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Order Takeout or Delivery

Brothers Pizza Photos

Brothers Pizza - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Brothers Pizza - Half cheese, half pepperoni medium pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Brothers Pizza - Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Brothers Pizza - a car parked in front of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Business Info

Health Information

View Health Score

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Brothers Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Dan S.

2 months ago

Pretty good pizza and subs, wish they put a bit more meat on the subs though but still good. Very close to drummer boy rv so we usually go here when camping. Better than average pizza the fries are really good. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom D.

Elite 26

194

2 years ago

We have passed by this restaurant dozens of times, and finally made it a point to stop here. It's a cute little restaurant that could probably use a face-lift but it was clean inside at least. The mozzarella sticks were delicious but the marinara dipping sauce was heavenly. We were even dipping our pizza crust in that sauce! We were warmly greeted (both coming and going) by one of the employees. The only gripe I might have is that their fountain drinks had a slightly strange taste to them, which is typical for using the local water sources. There are plenty of other things I want to try on the menu, so I know we will be back soon. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brian P.

Elite 26

101

218

964

2 years ago

Authentic delicious made pizza in a former bank. I guarantee soccer is playing when you arrive. Perfect for the extended family wanting a few slices of pizza, drinks and watching the game. Very quick turnaround on the order. The pictures of the pizza say it all. read more

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jodie T.

Elite 26

153

559

3 years ago

I can not say enough how absolutely delicious the cheesesteak and Italian subs were that we bought today! The staff was friendly, the service was quick and the restaurant was clean and not run down. I didn't think to take pics because I anticipated it to be the same as every other sub shop. Stop in and give them a try! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kimberly W.

Elite 20

132

212

7 years ago

The pizza here is great! Not too thick, not too thin. And you absolutely must have the squeaky cheese! They are little fried cheese curds of heaven. My husband loves the cheese steak here as well. And if your looking for something on the light side, the grilled chicken caesar wrap is super tasty! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jordan N.

6 years ago

Wonderful food, friendly service. Our family of 8 came to eat outside and got two large pizzas , a small white pizza , a bunch of mozzarella sticks & a ceaser wrap. All delicious , hot , fresh . Everyone was happy! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eric W.

12 years ago

This pizzeria opened a few months ago in Bonneauville and it could not have done so a minute to soon. The town has very limited options as it was (no actual restaurants), but that's not to say Brothers is good because its the only game in town. With my wife's love of all things pizza I have no doubt that she would make us drive over an hour to get a slice. However we are both very happy with this location. The owner is very nice to chat with and they make great food. The pizzas are top notch and the make all their own bread for subs. I forsee us going to this Brothers Pizza for a long time to come. read more

Brothers Pizza - Busy evening! - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarah H.

10 years ago

Pretty good pizza, not the best, not the worst. Very good prices! They are really quick and convenient if you are in the area. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Johanna F.

Elite 21

9 years ago

Ok, so I've come to learn the PA really isn't the state for pizza. Locally, my favorite is Jerry & Sal's. I haven't liked any other local pizza, even though I've tried many, hence our ever continuing search. This location is good but not great. The crust for your typical tossed style pie is a PINCH thick, and there's a lot of cheese. Now, if you want to feed a group though, this may be the better option since you get fuller more quickly. It's good for a slice maybe two but not want to eat as much as you can good. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ron M.

10 years ago

Great cheesesteak special! Love their own made rolls and the sauce on the special. Pizza is ok, family likes it and it's very convenient to our location. Always friendly and good service. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tiffani P.

9 years ago

Brother's offers a casual atmosphere and great prices. I've only ever tried their pizza and it is greasy and delicious!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ben M.

7 years ago

They have the BEST Pizza. I have been to over 100 different Pizza Places and This is the Best there is and the Best I have ever had. They all so have one beautiful woman working there. She is So HOT and One of the Prettiest Girls I have EVER Seen :) The guy dating her has to be the Luckiest guy on the planet. OK, NOW Back to the review of the Food. I have had their cheeseburger subs,Chicken and Pizza and it is ALL Great and Top of the Line. My Favorite place to eat. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Susan B.

7 years ago

Love pizza and love this pizza place! They are so generous with their toppings on the pizza. The food is tasty and hot. Don't eat out much but like to get take-out here. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ryan B.

9 years ago

I love the look of the building itself ( it used to be a bank) and they are inexpensive. For two large pizzas it is only $17 plus tax. While at others it can 20 to $22. Best of all the pizza is good. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Merg N.

11 years ago

Best pizza I have ever had! Ever since the M&T Bank closed there, I have been going and enjoying it! Delicious pizza! The environment is very nice, prices are meaningful, and workers are respectful! If you are new to the area make sure you stop in and get a good taste of Brothers Pizza! Great Eats! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Brothers Pizza

14 Hanover St
Gettysburg, PA 17325
Directions
(717) 398-2676
Call Now

Full menu

Hours

What time does Brothers Pizza open?

What time does Brothers Pizza close?

Payment methods

Does Brothers Pizza take credit cards?

Yes, Brothers Pizza takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Brothers Pizza have catering options?

No, Brothers Pizza does not have catering options.

Does Brothers Pizza serve alcohol?

No, Brothers Pizza does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Brothers Pizza have TVs?

Yes, Brothers Pizza has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Brothers Pizza have bike parking?

No, Brothers Pizza does not have bike parking.

Does Brothers Pizza have outdoor seating?

Yes, Brothers Pizza has outdoor seating options.

Does Brothers Pizza have parking?

Yes, Brothers Pizza has parking options.

Other Amenities

Does Brothers Pizza have free WiFi?

No, Brothers Pizza does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

Ask the Community - Brothers Pizza

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Review Highlights - Brothers Pizza

“I didn't think to take pics because I anticipated it to be the same as every other sub shop.”

Mentioned in 3 reviews

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 1,185 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

The Upper Crust

Stopped by The Upper Crust in Gettysburg recently for lunch and had a great experience overall. The…read moreopen-air seating was a really nice touch--perfect for a relaxed afternoon. We both ordered pizzas, and while the center of the crust was a little on the softer side, the overall flavor was excellent. You can tell they put a lot of care into the ingredients and combinations. All in all, a solid spot with great atmosphere and very good pizza. Definitely worth a visit if you're in Gettysburg.

Stopped in here a couple weeks ago when we were in Gettysburg for the weekend…read more This was the second time we ate here and I have to give this a mixed review. The first time we came here, last fall, we ordered pizzas for the table (there were four of us) and we all loved the food. Pizzas were bar pies and were pretty good (coming from a pizza snob). The drinks were a little pricey, but the service was great and we love the atmosphere. This most recent trip was not as good. We both wanted to try the bbq this time and were seated on the 'other' side. We were very confused as there was no BBQ on the menu, only to realize when the waitress came over that we didn't get the BBQ menus. We placed an order for drinks and looked over the menu, eventually we both chose a one meat combo - wifey ordered the brisket, Mac and cheese and cornbread and I had the ribs with baked beans and cole slaw. We also ordered an appetizer of hushpuppies. The sides were all fantastic...the Mac n cheese needed a touch of salt, but otherwise they were great. The hushpuppies were missing something-not sure if they put the sweet and spicy chipotle drizzle on them. Neither of us loved the meats. The brisket was tasty, but very fatty (yes, I know brisket has a fat layer, but this was very fatty). My ribs were a bit tough...again, they tasted fine, but they needed a little more time on the smoker (I'm not a fall off the bone guy, but the bite on these were a bit too much). Additionally, it too WAY too long for us to get our drinks...arrived about three minutes before our food was served. I'm sure this was a one-off, bad day, because I've heard great things about the bbq here. We're gonna stop in again next time, hopefully to bump up the rating.

Photos

The Margeherita, with tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil.

The Arugula, Includes ricotta cheese, fresh mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese, caramelized onion, and tender Italian guanciale.

See all

The Pepperoni with Upper Crust tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, fresh mozzarella cheese, parmesan cheese, and mild, smooth pepperoni

Deliso Pizza

Slightly off the beaten path since a mile from center of downtown Gettysburg, this is clearly a…read morelocal favorite. Very busy with folks popping in their pjs to pick up dinner. Generous portions of great food and reasonable prices. The gluten free hoagie roll was the best I have ever had, can't even tell it's gluten free!

delicious food and nice workers. affordable food as well. they repainted the place so it looks…read moreextra nice.

See all

La Bella Italia

Good service, good food. Food came out quickly, fresh homemade bread and our server, Sarah was very…read morepersonable

Pros: Great menu choices, nice portions, fresh food, great service…read more Cons: none. Our favorite restaurants in G'burg. Always clean, always your favorite itailian dishes and service is always great. Tonight or server was Caleb and our compliments to Caleb who was top end, very friendly and attentive. TonightbI had Veal Parmigana with Spaghetti. Being from Phill originally I love thier Veal Parm which has a lite crunch on the outside but tender and quick inside topped with the right amount of sauce and cheese. Was perfect. I also had a Canolli for dessert which has such i light and fluffy filling drilled with chocolate sauce, one of the best. Cya next time.

Photos

What's left Good experience

Tortellini

See all

Tommy's Pizza

Whenever I visit a new town, I am finding myself trying new pizzerias I was in Chris' hometown for…read morethe wedding and it just so happened to be Father's Day. Myself and Chris, along with his two brothers and niece decided to hit Tommy's. Apparently its a childhood spot for them and a favorite. It was a very every busy Sunday with orders to-go as well as guest inside and outside enjoying the experience. We ordered pepperoni pizzas and a dozen buffalo wings. I had a hard cider and two delicious slices. The race car matches were on the tele, and everyone seemed to be enjoying the nice sunny day. I love smelling food from the outside of an establisment whenever I arrive or leave,, haha. That speaks volumes!

Best pizza in town. Great sauce, toppings and crust in the right proportions. Nothing more…read moresatisfyning than taking a bite of Tommys pizza.

See all

Antica Napoli Pizza

We are from out of town and went with the Yelp recommendation. Not far from the town center ,…read moretucked away at the side of the building. Meat lovers was great, crispy crusty... quick service, clean and the staff was very nice!

Their pizza is great and the lady at the counter is very nice. Really great pizza stop in…read moreGettysburg.

Photos

Restrooms positive!

See all

Chicken Parm Hot Sub

Pizza House

First night in Gettysburg and ordered pizza from here. Very good pizza, a bit greasy but not bad at…read moreall! Good flavor and did amazing with extra cheese. We did delivery and it was quick and easy! Definitely recommend. Will say Lg pizza was a little smaller than expected.

Below average pizza. Missed toppings. Veggie pizza didn't have many veggies. One poor guy working…read moreall parts. Old dilapidated facility. Tommies is much much better (they were closed today)

Photos

Chicken finger

See all

101

4.5

(10 reviews)

5.3 mi

What a fun place! It was 100 degrees outside but 101 was a great place to cool off. The gazpacho…read morewas tremendous. So fresh and tasty. Along with the tuna burger, it was a complete meal. The service was great and everyone was so nice... 101 is a place to go!

Just to clarify, Food 101 is OPEN. It was temporarily closed for a few weeks in fall 2024 but it is…read moreback open permanent now - was just there for dinner on 11/25/24 and it was delicious! If you are looking for a delicious, yet affordable place to get sandwiches, artisan pizza, salads, or something a little special, check out Food 101 in downtown Gettysburg, close to Gettysburg College. They have a small space for indoor dining, and also offer carryout. I've eaten there several times and Everything is always delicious and made quickly. Highly recommend for lunch or a casual dinner!

Photos

Caesar salad (side salad size)

Club 101 with couscous

See all

Apple Cheddar Chicken Sandwich with a side of pearl couscous

Blessing Pizza

4.3

(6 reviews)

3.8 mi

We have ordered here 2 x so far and will continue to order. Each time, each item has been great!read more

Just happened to check this place out while wandering around the food court and I'm so glad I did…read more I saw the Italian slice pizza and was immediately intrigued. The service was fast and friendly. But most importantly the food was delicious and fresh. Never seen an Italian sandwich in the form of a pizza but it's so delicious. The crust was a garlicky focaccia style dough that was light and slightly crispy. But the shining star is the smoked provolone coming through with high quality tasting ham and salami. The right amount of lettuce and tomato to give a fresh and bright note to it to finish it off. I highly recommend it!

Photos

Located inside food court at the outlets at Gettysburg

See all

Clementina’s Pizzeria & Ristorante

4.1

(17 reviews)

7.3 mi

We received the wrong delivery from a food delivery app. Clemintina's made a new order and…read moredelivered it themselves. Great food and great service. LOVE them.

6/17/2026 We stopped on a whim here on our way to our Air B & B because husband wanted a 6 pack. I…read morefound the people working there to be quite friendly and personable. We grabbed a menu because we considered ordering for dinner. Well, we ended up ordering 2 pizzas, one cheese, one pepperoni, a cheesesteak and an antipasta. I really enjoyed everything. The sauce was very savory and I really enjoyed it. The food was ready when I arrived and it was hot and fresh. If I'm in the area I would definitely go back for sure! The place is small inside with a few tables and cozy. It is in a strip mall next to a tattoo shop.

Photos

Sunday mid-afternoon in mid August

6/17/2026 Exterior

See all

A Sunday afternoon in mid September

Pizza Hut

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a brownie for pick up. Pizza was great. Brownie was supposed to…read morebe 9 servings. But brownie wasn't cut and unable to cut it myself. Had to use a spoon to scoop it out of the aluminum pan it was baked in. What was scooped out tasted good but must of it stuck to the pan. Wish they had put a little oil on the pan before baking the brownie. Won't purchase the brownie again.

This pizza hut was really good. The pizza was hot and fresh…read moreand tasted so good. Ordered the sausage and pepperoni pizza and it was so yummy. Since there are no more Pizza Huts in Philadelphia, it felt like a treat eating Pizza Hut since its been months since the ones near me closed down.

Photos

See all

Appalachian Brewing Company

I visited with family in Gettysburg and we stopped for lunch here. It was my first time but the…read morefood was delicious so I understand why they would bring other people to check them out. My uncle ordered a cup of chili to start. It was served hot which is always a bonus. Not too spicy even though it had a spice label next to it on the menu. The presentation was nice as it's served with 4 tortilla chips. My Aunt opted for the babyback ribs served with fries. My uncle's main dish was the soft shell crab tacos while I went with the brisket mac and cheese and side Caesar salad. These items, with exception of the salad, were on a separate menu, likely seasonal. The servings are large (even the side salad)! I barely put a dent in my Mac and cheese. I was a little disappointed that the brisket that was "folded" within my MAC and cheese was playing Hide-and-seek. I would prefer more protein in that dish based on the quantity of pasta. The salad was well-dressed. At most restaurants I have to add caesar dressing to the salads. I washed it down with a sweet tea while my Uncle tried the White Birch beer. My aunt thought the baby back ribs were dry, and had a bit too much sauce on it. It would have been nice to have less sauce on the ribs, with additional sauce on the side. My uncle did not think the soft shell crab tacos were all that (although novel), which is probably why he ordered. It had more batter on it, and one can barely taste the crab. He said he would not order it again. As residents they will not go back to this restaurant anytime soon, and can't really recommend it unless someone just wants to try give it a try. I'll have to try the root beer on my next visit. Our waiter was very attentive and the volume in the restaurant was reasonable enough to have table conversations. I definitely recommend stopping at one of these locations if you're visiting or passing through.

It was pouring rain while we were visiting town and we ask the locals what we could do while we…read morewait for the rain to go away so we could visit all the historical sights. Everyone was right and the place was packed when we got there, we were lucky enough to get spot at the bar and a local even moved over so both of us could have seats. They have an extensive selection of beer/cocktails/wine/rootbeer (you have to try) so you can pair it with their great menu. We had the pierogies and were great: crispy texture outside and tasty in the middle. If you are in town stop by for a refreshing beverage and a great local vibe.

Photos

Interior.

Nachos. They were not bad. I am not sure if they make these fresh but would taste better I think if chips were warm fresh. No to lettuce!

See all

Seared ahi tuna

La Bella Italia

Good service, good food. Food came out quickly, fresh homemade bread and our server, Sarah was very…read morepersonable

Photos

What's left Good experience

Tortellini

See all

The Gettysburger Company

This is the spot to get hamburgers in Gettysburg. Theirs are huge, made of prime meat, and…read morepresented hot & juicy. I always order my burger medium-rare, and that's what I get here. I can't tell you how many times that medium is what I usually get when requesting medium-rare at restaurants. There's a big difference between the two in terms of internal temperature, center color, and texture. This place knows how to properly cook a medium-rare burger, and for me, that's a sign of quality and sets it apart. The sidewinder fries are fab as are the homemade potato chips and either comes with burgers. The dressing on the coleslaw needs some seasoning, but the slaw itself is fresh and crunchy. The Maryland crab soup is pretty slammin', too. I favor the back dining room, not the bar (in front). These 2 areas have different vibes. The back room feels like the way a burger joint should be. The bar is, well, more bar-ish. One of the servers, Brody, provides exceptional service--a shout out to him. This establishment's name is playful and clearly informs the customer as to what their specialty is: hamburgers. I bought one of their T-shirts, perhaps that says it all.

We love the Gettysburger! We stopped in on a busy Saturday afternoon and waited about 20 minutes. I…read morefeel like we waited longer for our food than we ever have before, but they had a few large parities, so I get that. I ordered the Muenster burger which was excellent! I've never had a bad burger here and always order the smash patties - I just enjoy them more. Two burgers and two beers were less than $50 with a tip - can't beat that in a tourist town. We'll be back soon!

Photos

01.17.25 one section of the dining area

The Gettysburger at The Gettysburger Company in Gettysburg, PA

See all

Waffle Fries with Powdered Sugar at Gettysburger

The Garryowen Irish Pub

Our waitress was top notch, very attentive and so kind. The selection of traditional Irish food at…read morethe lower portion of the menu was very nice, half of us chose from that and all agreed that was very good, including our Irish friend! Great atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Wow.... The best lunch we had all vacation. I had the fish and chips, the hubby the lamb burger…read more.. it was beyond amazing. We were recommended this by the gentlemen at the horse solider.... And they did not disappoint. Thank you for great Irish food! Service was amazing as well.... When we're back in town we will be back!

Photos

Interior tables

Bangers and mash

See all

FourScore Beer Co.

We visited fourscore back in September of 2025 and have not stopped thinking about their smoothie…read moresours since. I cannot recommend this brewery enough - 100%!! We just wish we lived closer - or if they considered shipping cans to NY!!!

Wifey and I were recently in Gettysburg and decided to try FourScore Beer Co. Unfortunately, we got…read morehere right after a big event in the area so the place was packed and it took us a couple trips around the neighborhood before we found a place to park. Because we were going out to dinner in a couple hours we just shared an appetizer and ordered flights. We ordered the large pretzel with pub cheese and it was really great. Pretzel seemed like it was made with fresh dough and it the buttery, saltiness just made it exactly what we wanted. I felt bad for the cooks and bartenders as the place was super busy, but it was a really fun vibe, and great service for how packed they were. The beers were great: I had the: -Incessant Luminescence (American Stout) -Portergeist -Sunglow - Hefeweizen -Jamba Blueberry Pumpkin Swirl sour Wifey had the: -Gettys Brau - Pilsner -Hop Hat - IPA -Dead Man Walking - Hazy IPA -My nickname in high school - Citrus IPA Ok, to be fair, the Jamba Blueberry Pumpkin Swirl sour was weird...it was more like a smoothie than a beer so the texture was odd, but the flavor was fun. I hate IPAs so I can't speak to them, but Wifey loved them. Overall- fun place, great vibe, very good beers and a great pretzel appetizer. I'd come back the next time we are out in Gettysburg.

Photos

Fourscore Beer Co., in Gettysburg, PA

Wings

See all

Bar

Gettysburg Eddie's

It's been quite a while since my wife stopped here to dine... probably 5+ years…read more I've noticed that in the 17 years I've been in Gettysburg y this restaurant is #1 still here, and #2 continues a level of food service that both the locals and tourists enjoy. My wife and I both had the shrimp baskets and two soft drinks for lunch. The shrimp baskets were $17 each and the soft drinks $3 each. With tax and tips the total bill came to $50. The shrimp were obviously pre-battered and frozen but they were pretty tasty. The french fries had some kind of a nice crispy coating and were excellent. The coleslaw was pretty tired. The service was cordial and quick. The decor is as I remembered very nice. There is free parking behind this restaurant, but not many people know it is there. The only reason I gave four stars instead of five is because I think that the cost of the luncheon was a little more than it should've been for what we received. Had the shrimp been coated with a batter and fried from scratch (instead of being taken out of a frozen bag) I might've been able to award five stars. But... All in all this restaurant continues to hold its "very good to excellent" reputation for food and service over many years. I would die there again and I would recommend it with no reservations.

Right in the middle of the very touristy part of Gettysburg, surrounded by tacky shops, and with…read morealmost no nearby parking. We were there on a busy Saturday; they were clearly slammed and probably understaffed, and it took a bit over 20 minutes after ordering to get our food. Other than the wait for the kitchen, the service at the table was very good. It felt a bit pricey at about $62 for two with tip. Cheesesteaks were good but on the small side for $17 and $19 (the latter on a gluten‑free bun), and a little light on the Cheese Whiz. That, plus a cider and a Coke, left the overall experience somewhat underwhelming.

Photos