So good! My friend and I stopped by after a workout during the heat wave, and it was exactly what we needed. We enjoyed a banana split and a two-scoop banana pudding waffle cone, and every bite was delicious! The tucked-away patio creates such a cozy spot to enjoy your treat, and the walk-up ordering window makes it easy to grab your ice cream and relax. The service was quick, the staff was friendly, and everything hit the spot. We'll definitely be adding Bruster's to our list for future ice cream runs! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

My daughters and I all went there to nights ago for ice cream. I asked which flavor she recommended between 2 and she told me her favorite and then said here try both and gave me samples. She was super sweet and gave us time to decide what we wanted. The ice cream was AMAZING! The outside seating was perfect too! We will be back! read more

We just love coming here the service is friendly to they give back days. The ice cream they offer non dairy options that are hard to find. Lots of outside seating also for groups. read more

See all

Heard about this place from a friend that said it compared to Handel just fewer options so I tried it. Had a nice selection of ice cream. I went to walk up window and ordered the superhero Italian ice. It was super hot so I needed something to cool me down. Super hero has blue, cherry and lemon flavors so it's red white and blue. There seems to be plenty of parking, with easy in/out from olio. I will return. read more

Stopped here to try out this new Icecream spot. I arrived around 7:30 and there seemed to be a decent amount of people as though they all had the same idea, to get Icecream after dinner. It's located right off Olio in a strip mall. There are other businesses there so the parking lot was pretty full although parking didn't seem like too much of an issue. This is one of those places where they don't have inside seating so when you order and get your treat, you have to find a seat outside which they have 3 or 4 tables out there or take it to go. I'd say the best thing about this place is the fact that they have non-dairy oak milk Icecream as an option and it's actually really good. Great addition to this area of Fishers. read more

See all

Good scoop size. The fruit flavored ice cream was a bit more artificial tasting than other local ice cream shops in the area. Those in our group who had the chocolate flavors said they were very good. Service was quick and employees were friendly. Seating is outdoors on the side of their building. read more

I've been hearing a lot of talk about Bruster's. I had some errands to run so I grabbed the kids to give the new ice cream shop a try while out! Bruster's is currently walk up only (the door was locked when we went). We ordered our ice creams and enjoyed them at the outside tables. The kids got kid sundaes: a scoop with crushed oreos and a worm which the kids loved! I got a small which comes with two scoops! The ice cream is so creamy!!!! And there are tons of vegan flavors so I'll be bringing my family that enjoy dairy free treats! read more

See all

While the customer service was great, and we were allowed to sample different flavors, the ice cream is definitely overpriced, in my opinion. We went back in December, and the ice cream was good, but not memorable. And It's not great enough for me to return and pay those prices again. Great service and location! read more

The Brownie sundae was good, the waffle bowl was good. The spoon was too soft though! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Sundaes- min - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Great ice cream with great service! As of recent Bruster's has been my go to for quality ice cream and I love that they offer both traditional and non-dairy (oat milk). My go to flavors have been the Key Lime (Traditional) and the Cookies & Cream (Non-Dairy). Both are great in their own way, especially during the hot summer months. Service is provided through a window but they do have a few tables/seats outside. If you are ever in the Fishers area and are looking for a quality treat, check out Bruster's! read more

Pretty good ice cream! I really like the caramel coconut cookie as I haven't found anything else like it around here. Prices are comparable to other ice cream shops around. Service is always friendly and when it is nice out, they have tables to sit outside as it is a walk up order window. read more

VEGAN All Vegan Ice Cream Pie- Mint Chocolate ice cream center with vanilla ice cream, layer chocolate fudge and chocolate graham crust. DELICIOUS I SAY!!!! read more

See all

I never shy away from coffee ice cream and Bruster's was a pleasant surprise. The sweet aroma of the waffle cone in a handy holder was just as satisfying as the taste of this homemade cold brew ice cream with chocolate flakes and (I had to look it up)...pie crust pieces. Espresso Yourself will be my go-to at Bruster's! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Espresso Yourself - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We love Bruster's! My family and I decided to try it now that it's just right down the road from us. It was delicious. We tried several flavors. I got the peanut butter cup sundae and it was VERY good! However I could have done without allllllll the whipped cream. I will probably do without it next time. Also - you can't sit inside but you can walk up and order like Handel's on 116th. We will be back! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Peanut Butter Cup Sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Mmmmm. Brusters is very good! I would say it's a little much expensive than some of the other shops around but it's good! My favorite flavor so far has been a seasonal one that was a almond wedding cake flavor with black raspberry jam in it. Please bring it back and I will come daily!! read more

Bruster's ice cream is delicious and we are always interested in trying 2 different flavors every time we visit! So far, our favorites have been;! Chocolate Covered Pretzels in Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Butter Pecan and Jamaikin Me Crazy! Actually all of the flavors have been wonderful and enjoyed by our entire family! The service has been wonderful and timely, for pick-up! Any ice cream lover will definitely "Love" it here! Very nice surroundings and especially clean. read more

Bruster's Fishers is now open ! I shared a Brownie Sunday with my daughter over the weekend and we can both say we both approve ! Great ice cream and flavor . The price is just right , and the staff is very nice and welcoming. Highly recommend if you got ice cream on your mind . read more

See all

Brusters "real" ice cream ruined my day it was so bad. How can you make ice cream worse than Dairy Queen? I got the chocolate ice cream and it was soft serve (I threw up), and melted to hecc. They had no other chocolate flavors so I had to get that TRASH. I'm killing myself tonight because of you Bruster's. read more

The ice cream is super good however I do wish they had dairy free pistachio I love the dairy free option

The smoothest, yummiest ice cream. And they make cakes and pies, dairy free flavors, sorbet and sherbet. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Everything is delicious! Every flavor I've tried is sooo good. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I stopped by last night to see what all they had to off. Cute location but I can see parking getting crazy in the summer. It was so nice to see a place fully staffed! I was able to try three samples and ended up getting a half gallon of New York cheesecake (my absolute favorite- amazing in a cake!) and Wedding Cake! Wedding cake was absolutely amazing- I wish it had icing in it but the almond flavor was delicious! Chef's kiss! Service was great! Price was fair for homemade ice cream and they had so many options! Will be back! read more

The ice cream is Amazing and the cookie dough with the waffle cone bowl is the best but

It was ok. Didn't knock my socks off. Average. Good selection for those who can't have dairy.

Chocolate Chip Mint Vegan is the best!!!! Thank you for having several flavors of dairy free as options. I'm a big fan! The kids that work at the Fishers location are always so friendly and helpful read more

We fell in love with Bruster's while on vacation and were excited to find a nearby(ish) location. We live 40 minutes away from this store, but we stop by whenever we're in the area. I'm s suckered for good ice cream in a waffle cone! Come to the Westside for a second location! read more

It's a bit pricey but what isn't nowadays. Great flavors and good service with a smile and friendly service. Caden goes the extra mile to bring straight to you if you've had to wait. I appreciated that. Cherry Pecan is the BOMB!!!! read more

Have been to Brusters a couple times now and it has not disappointed yet. Their monthly specials are unique and delicious- I tried the southern banana pudding and it was one of the best ice cream flavors I've ever had! Staff are also very kind and quick. read more

What a great addition to the neighborhood!! The ice cream is amazing with a unique consistency that highlights flavor. They have opened with plenty of staff to match the quality of product. We have been 3 times in the last 10 days and can't wait to enjoy when the weather requires delicious cold treats. Highly reccomend read more

Such creamy ice cream! The Buckeye flavor melts in your mouth. Service is outstanding, so friendly and accommodating. So many options, gluten free and dairy free as well. Can't wait to go back! read more

I kept waiting for the little ol lady from the Wendy's ads to come out and scream where's the ice cream! Like a previous review, the flavor of the ice cream was good but portion size was ridiculous for the price. I personally will not go back after paying that much for so little, especially when there are better local ice cream shops like Sundaes. read more

This is the hands down the best ice cream I have ever had! Everything taste so fresh. The staff is very friendly and helpful. Seating outside is great, plenty of parking. Can't wait to go back and try more treats!!!! read more

I have waited a long time for Brusters fishers and it's here! The ice cream is great. Fresh, made daily, and seasonal flavors. We all approve! There is outdoor seating the staff is great. read more

Ice cream is just ok, very creamy but it's no Handels! Average at best. Won't be back.

Icecream was delicious but the portion size was shocking. My scoop of icecream was literally the size of a golfball. It was almost insulting. Will definitely go back back as I know they're new but just something to be aware of. read more