After having a bad day, I decided I needed a quality treat! graeter's was the treat my soul needed. The ice cream is so delicious! Staff is kind and friendly. Can't wait to go back! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Any of the berry flavors are the best! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Portions are to small for the amount they charge. Too many employees standing around doing nothing but staring at you when you try to look at the menu for more than 10 seconds. Also they need to have a walk up window to service the massive apartment buildings behind them. Most people have dogs and want to get ice cream without abandoning their pet. Missed opportunity for them read more

Best ice cream in town!! Specially their Peach Flavor!!!!! All the flavors are amazing read more

Delicious ice cream store with indoor and outdoor seating. Staff is friendly and helpful. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We went here last night after dinner and got some ice cream. It was really good but my favorite ice cream is chocolate chip and what they had was more like chocolate ice cream with some fudge in it or something. It was delicious but I like the actual chocolate chips in mine. Staff were nice and friendly. We sat outside and ate our ice cream and were on our way. They sit right beside City BBQ. read more

Some of the most delicious ice cream and best service. The space is always clean and well managed and the employees are friendly and helpful. read more

See all

It's all about the ice cream. If you're a Cincinnati native, you don't need to read any further. If you're not, it's some of the best ice cream you will ever eat. Mainly because it's made in small batches using the best ingredients using the French Pot technique. If it's your first time I highly recommend the Blueberry chocolate chip. The chips are bonkers since they are broken hardened chocolate in the process of ice cream making. My visit yesterday I had Elena's blueberry pie ice cream. Yes it has blueberry pie crust IN the ice cream along with blueberries. Service was friendly behind the counter and you can sample flavors also if you are getting acquainted with this shop. Quiet simple ambience with indoor and outdoor seating and pints are available to take home. If you want to ship it out of state that is possible also. read more

Butter pecan in a waffle cone... yum! Huge pecans pieces in the ice cream were so good! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Butter pecan - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Great service, friendly, offer samples, clean space. Fun place to eat inside or outside.

Food was delicious! Tables were clean. The service was kind and focused on doing their job correctly and swiftly. Watched a family come inside and when the door shut, the locking mechanism fell right out of the door lol. That's since been fixed but everyone found it funny and it was a wholesome moment to experience laughter with strangers. I highly recommend Graeter's to anyone looking for ice cream. read more

Always delicious! I've brought my BBBSCI little here a few times over the last few years and we always really enjoy the ice cream :) I forgot to take a photo before I started eating my icecream though..whoops read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Blackberry chip in a waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

If we are comparing apples to apples or Graeter's to Handles, then we will have to say value is lower here, but quality is higher. The cones are better in our opinion and the portion sizes are more correctly aligned to size ordered. All in all - much better than your typical DQ as you'd expect, but a tiny notch better than Handles. That said, they didn't claim their Yelp presence. Shame shame read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Double Classic Sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

YUMMM! The waffle cone has a classic waffle cone taste but the texture is much lighter than competing waffle cones in my opinion. I'm a diehard fan of the mint chocolate chip!! The service at this place is quick despite being very crowded most of the time. The way they run things is very efficient. read more

I stopped in for a quick scoop of ice cream and was met with prompt service. Black Raspberry struck my fancy that evening as I was needing some cheering up after a really sad few days. Thank you for a clean shop and friendly service!. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Black Raspberry Chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Ben made me the most perfect banana split!!! He suggested flavors and toppings for it, which was so helpful, I was struggling. 10/10 love this place. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Banana split - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I'm not a huge fan of chips in ice cream, but its what they are famous for, and if you like chips, they are plentiful and huge. This evening, hubs got the chocolate chocolate chip. I had the dark chocolate sorbet. There are always some unique flavor options, and the tastes are always flavorfilled. Service has always been very friendly as well. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Dark chocolate sorbet! #yum #ReviewsByRL - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

For the chocolate lovers: Their mocha chocolate chip ice-cream and dark chocolate fudge ice cream taste amazing together. Graeter's ice cream has better selection is flavors compared to a lot of ice cream places I have been to. The staff is wearing masks and the customers are requested to wear one too. This location has a dedicated parking place and you won't have trouble finding a parking spot. It is not usually busy and the wait time is pretty low. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Great ice cream. A classic. I've moved since they opened, so I don't go much anymore, but I went back tonight for the first time in a year or so. It's still such a clean shop with nice lighting and very outgoing employees. Ice cream is a little pricey, but nothing outlandish for craft ice cream. Mint chocolate is my favourite because there's no artificial colours and the "chips" are chunks of chocolate. Highly recommend if you're craving good ice cream read more

See all

Stopped by recently for ice cream. We have tried the one in Carmel, but this was our first time in fishers. It is a very nice and big, and the ice cream definitely lived up to the Graeter's high standards. The black raspberry chip is my wife's favorite around. This time I got a pint, but didn't realize it was the dairy free, more expensive alternative. I wouldn't have knowingly grabbed that, but it was right at start of line and I didn't see other coolers with different options so could have helped having it made a little more clear but it was my fault for not reading closer. She did say she could notice a difference but that it was still really good, so that is a cool alternative for someone who may have dairy free needs. There was a big group of younger people in front that all ordered shakes when I walked in, so I could tell they were a little flustered trying to get them all done, but I didn't think it impacted my experience at all because they were still quick and welcoming. Overall, we will definitely keep coming back here. read more

Great old fashioned ice cream store!!! First visit. Had their banana split and it was delicious. Highly recommended.

PERFECT consistency. It's not hard like most ice cream shops. Very smooth and great flavors! Probably my favorite ice cream in the area. 10/10 would recommend! read more

Super friendly and family oriented! They have great knowledge of their ice creams and give great recommendations if they don't have the flavor you want. They also have flavors of the month which are amazing!! It's a must try and a must visit. read more

I've lived in Fishers for about 3 years & I've never tried this ice cream shop till tonight . & I'm so glad I did . Both girls working tonight were very helpful & friendly, wish I would of got their names . But I'm very pleased with what I ordered. Thank you ! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Salted Caramel malt & Sunrise sensation smoothie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I visited the Fishers location of Graeter's for the first time today. Temps in the 20's and flurries still qualifies as ice cream weather for me - :-) I was greeted by George, the assistant manager, who provided information about their seasonal flavors and helped me to navigate my app. In this era of hit-and-miss customer service, it was nice to see an employee who went above and beyond in establishing customer relations. I will be sure to visit this location in the future. P.S. The two scoops of ice cream were, as usual, delicious. read more

10/10 ice cream!! Never had a flavor I didn't love - anything with those gigantic chocolate chunks in it is amazing!! Black raspberry or black cherry are my favorites! read more

This ice cream is *delicious*! I used to be a baker in the early 90s at a Fuddruckers (to help pay for college) in another state. My guilty pleasure was sampling their cinnamon ice cream. I have been searching for comparable cinnamon ice cream for over 30 years! But Graeter's has the only cinnamon ice cream as good as my memory of that ice cream. Thrilled to find it in Fishers! read more

Got blackberry chocolate chip, my favorite. Need comfort foods in times like this. Almost got the bourbon pecan, it's also good. But went with the tried and true read more

A Cincinnati Favorite! We love Graeter's but are also a house divided. One offspring loves Graeter's and the other loves Handels. Us parents, we love them both. Tonight we went for the birthday of the child who loves Graeter's! I tried their new seasonal dark chocolate with brownies. It's very good but there aren't as many brownie pieces as they have chocolate chips in their ice cream. About those chocolate chips. It's kind of magical, they are delicious, rich chocolate in ice cream but they somehow do not freeze and get hardened like regular chocolate chips. And some of them are huge, as big as the spoon, it's like hitting the jackpot when you come across one of those. You pretty much can't go wrong with any flavor that ends in "chip"; mocha chip, black raspberry chip, chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, mint chip. All good! Because it's the birthday of one of my children and well the anniversary of my working very hard to have said child I treated myself too and ordered a chocolate dipped waffle cone. I highly recommend trying it. But watch them as they scoop your ice cream, I know this sounds crazy but I had to stop her... she was going to put three scoops on ice cream into the cone. I would never have been able to eat that much and it would have been a crying shame to waste it. So, word to the wise, the waffle cones have a lot of ice cream in them. read more

Delicious ice cream. Friendly service too. Will go back and try more flavors. I had cotton candy and it was top tier.

Hi yes, I'd like a sample of everything. Ok so I didn't get a sample of everything but I probably could have ordered anything and liked it. Walking in I was already impressed, the shop had a clean smell to it. Not like they just cleaned it smell and it smells overwhelmingly like cleaning solution but more along the lines of it always smells this way kinda clean. We entered from the back door, that's what all the cool people do, and soon noticed a drinking fountain with plastic cups. Don't you always want a glass or plastic cup of water after eating ice cream? You don't have to answer that but if you do, you wouldn't have had to purchase a bottle of water. Its details like that I can appreciate, thanks to whosoever idea that was. Before walking over to the counter I took a moment to check out the two different displays one that held prepackaged ice cream ready to go and another that displayed some candy and other assorted trinkets. I knew what I wanted, the maple cinnamon stroopwafel which features maple cinnamon crunch ice cream, hot fudge, butterscotch and a stroopwafel. If you look carefully the word butterscotch is spelled wrong on the menu board, it shows buttersotch under the description for the maple cinnamon stroopwafel. However the treat listed directly below, the turtle sundae which also features butterscotch has the word butterscotch spelled correctly. Regardless of spelling errors as long as my ice cream is correct, I'd be happy with anything really. Any combination of ice cream flavors, toppings and however it was served, whether it be in a cone, dish or cup would have been good, and was as between everyone in our group we had ordered a variety of ice cream that would bring us back again. We took our order outside and maybe it was a sign, maybe it wasn't but I had noticed several lady bugs on the ground. They are a sign of good luck, well, there supposed to be. Regardless of my luck I'll be coming back for more ice cream. read more

See all

Big fan of Graeter's Ice Cream, never missing it when i'm in Cincinnati Ohio. Very glad to see that they are here so no travel is required. Very nice selection of ice cream, the staff is friendly and you have a lot of options for it. Loved that they offered pints to go as well. Stop in for seasonal flavors, looking forward to the Egg Nog version just around the corner. read more

New to town and first time trying and omg sooo delicious!! The staff was incredibly helpful and friendly. Will definitely be back!

Cute old fashioned ice cream shop! Creative flavors, friendly service and a retro look to the place made for a nice experience. Really glad to have tried this ice cream, loved the coconut chocolate chip. The kids definitely liked whatever they had because it was all over their faces! read more

This place is not nearly as good as when it first opened. The portions get smaller and smaller. The single scoop I ordered didn't even go to the top of the lip of the waffle cone. When you pay almost $6 for an ice cream cone, there should be a decent amount. Won't be coming back here even though it's the closest ice cream shop to my house. Wish I had taken a picture of the ridiculous portion size! read more

Two words....chocolate chips. If you don't remember anything from this review then at least remember this one thing: get ice cream with the chips in it. Graeters has a ton of flavors with their signature chocolate chips in it. The chips are luscious and large and perfect for that chocolate craving. The wide variety of flavors with the chips in it gives each person the ability to find something just right for them. I ordered the toffee chip and it was a mind blowing combination of sticky toffee, clean vanilla, and those wonderful chips. Highly recommend for a quick ice cream experience! And trust me, it is an experience! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - The huge bourbon ball. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I am just going to be honest and put it out there, I LOVE ice cream. Probably too much. I have gone a day here and there without ice cream, but not too many. (Thanks to the discovery of Halo Top.) When I am not devouring my "healthier" ice cream at home, one of my favorite things to do is grab the hubby and go on an ice cream adventure. This brought me to Graeter's and I am so so glad it did! I have read a few reviews on here about it being overpriced and I am going to call bologna! If you are having ice cream that is not bought at the store and even then ice cream at the store can be even more expensive, then the ice cream is already going to be overpriced. You get what you pay for here, so take the price in and know that you will get what you put in. To start, anything here that is "chip" really means CHUNK. I love this, because, chunk means more chocolate, but be aware that they have large pieces of chocolate inside their ice cream and it is heavenly. Flavors I love include : Strawberry Chocolate Chip *limited time only unfortunately Strawberry - theirs tastes like natural strawberry and is not overly sweet, yet very creamy *** Bourbon Pecan Chocolate Chip - NO WORDS. Seriously some of the best ice cream, especially if you love bourbon. MUST try. The staff here are always friendly, efficient, and helpful with recommendations. Lastly, I recommend getting a car air freshener of your favorite flavor. The scent doesn't last long, but you do get a few days of crave-inducing car rides. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I really want to love Graeters but I can't get past how expensive their ice cream is compared to other ice creameries in the Fishers area. Here a $2.99 single scoop gets you a small single scoop. At Handles a little further up the road a $2.95 single scoop gets you a huge & mighty dish full of premium ice cream. Most recently I decided to pick up a quart of vanilla to-go. My jaw dropped in disbelief when they said it was going to be $14.00. I could only assume there were pieces of edible gold mixed into this quart but to my dismay I found nothing but vanilla ice cream. What a bummer. On the upside this location is indoors with lots of seating, they have a case full of items you can take to-go, they have gelato, sorbet, old fashioned soda, shakes, sundaes, smoothies, ice cream cakes and pies. I have tried several of their ice cream flavors and the two I would come back for are the Bourbon Ball (it has actual bourbon in it) & the Black Raspberry Chip. read more

Great small batch ice cream. They have a handful of flavored they keep all the time and then some rotating flavors. One scoop is definately filling but their specialty sundaes are fantastic as well. You can make a sundae with any flavor ice cream and any topping. The whip cream is also made fresh. YUM! Great place for a date night but expect to wait your turn. They also have a rewards card if you are a frequenter read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - 2 scoop banana ice cream with choc syrup and fresh whip cream sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

A Cincinnati favorite in Indiana. The chocolate chunks in any of their "chip" flavors are better than any other ice cream I've had. A classic to order would be the Black Raspberry Chip, but really you can't go wrong with anything. You can also purchase a koozie to fit an ice cream pint to keep your hands from freezing when you're diving into a pint of ice cream at home. To date, that is the best $10 purchase I have made in my life. read more

I'm originally from Cincinnati, so this was a taste of home. I ate my ice cream too quickly to get a picture, but I ordered the Strawberry flavor for the first time, and it was really nice on a hot day. Good service too! read more