The Buckhorn used to be a great supper club for food and service. Now the service is sub par. Tables were not cleaned off in the bar after they emptied, the old fashioned was no longer muddled, and we had a reservation and waited for 1/2 hour after it and still were not seated. The prices are sky high and the menu has lost its variety. I have no clue how the food is because we left. read more

See all

Had not been here since 2022! Was great to be back! Wonderful experience and such a beautiful view. Service and food were both excellent. Prime rib was cooked perfectly! Didn't get pictures, but other people in my group had the duck and ribeye. They enjoyed both. Will definitely be back! read more

See all

We first had a cocktail at the bar, sugar cookie martini was absolutely delicious. I ordered the bbq salmon & my husband the New York strip, both dinners were delicious! Service was friendly, overall great night out. read more

Buckhorn Supper Club - Sugar cookie martini - Steakhouses Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

See all

Started at the bar - great ambiance and old school mafia supper club. Bartender lady is never in a good mood and difficult to deal with !! Constant negative comments under her breath and facial expressions. Hostess was excellent and seated us in the bar area. Waitress was awesome and food as always was awesome ! Salad, French Onion Soup, Filet, Baked potato and desert was great ! read more

Buckhorn Supper Club - Supper Club table inside the bar has Great Lake views and bar vibe ! - Steakhouses Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

The first time we had a bartender that didn't know how to make a muddled whisky old fashioned it was the worst. Then we got seated and the fish was ok. We went back another time thinking the first time was an off night. We waited for an hour to get served so I guess they had two off nights. read more

Food and service were great. Will go back! Had reservations took awhile to still be seated. We always eat later hoping to avoid rush.

We were craving a great supper club steak and the Buckhorn did not disappoint. Our steaks were cooked perfectly and the sides were excellent. Our service was wonderful and our drinks were made perfectly. Of course the real star of the night was the lake view. Grab a seat around sunset and the whole experience will be great. Add the Buckhorn to your Wisconsin supper club tour! read more

See all

Buckhorn's did not disappoint!! One of our favorite places! I love the vintage supper club atmosphere and moody lighting. The night we visited there was live music which really added to everything. The view of the lake is always beautiful as well! Bartenders are always on point and know how to make a fabulous cocktail. Everyone is so friendly and accommodating also. I'm a HUGE fan of their French onion soup - it's loaded with cheese and is always seasoned perfectly. I always use Buckhorn as the standard to all other French onion soups :) Love that they serve a great bread basket and spread cheese and crackers. I'm hooked on their filet mignon - always perfectly cooked and delicious They have excellent cuts of meat. My picky husband was very pleased about his lobster dinner as well, it was giant! We will definitely be eating here again - hopefully soon! :) read more

See all

Food was...fine. It wasn't bad, but I've had better, and certainly not good enough to justify the prices, which were on par with - or slightly higher than - the higher-end supper clubs around the state. My prime rib was nicely tender but surprisingly underseasoned, my wife's ribs were dry and undersauced, the garlic mashed potatoes apparently merely just had the word "garlic" yelled at them from a different room, and the fried shrimp were overcooked and tough. The French onion soup was rather good, albeit a bit heavy-handed with the melted cheese (but this being Wisconsin who's gonna complain about extra cheese?) The dinner salads were fresh, although I couldn't determine if the dressings were homemade or bottled. The hostess was very friendly, but overall service was hands-off. Our server appeared to take our order, deliver our food, and bring our check. It took us flagging down three separate people before we could get the sauce we requested with our order (and by the time it finally arrived, the meal was over). The place was loud and the overall ambiance was rather more "bar and grill" than "supper club." Not a dealbreaker by any means, since I've been to some great places with low-rent atmosphere. Nice enough view of the lake, but if I'm shelling out over two bills just for food, I expect a little better than "rec-room chic." (Also, extremely specific complaint - the menu design is awkward from a readability standpoint. The design is cluttered and inconsistent) I had high hopes, but was throughly disappointed. read more

Our party of nine was accommodated and everything was on time. Steaks were great wait staff was attentive and helpful. The happy 10 year anniversary and happy engagement went great. read more

Fun super club! The food was amazing, the drinks were ok. I had the prime rib and it was delicious my girlfriend had the filet, we both had French onion soup. I am excited to go back and try something different. The only non enjoyable part was the older female bartender was not friendly and very inconsistent with drinks with an "I don't want to be here" attitude. read more

Not what it used to be. Service was incredibly slow. Doesn't matter if you have a reservation or not, you will never be seated on time

They should not refer to this as a supper club. Soup or Salad? No salad bar. Prices are to high for a Wisconsin supper club.

We made reservations for a Sunday, because you never know! Their parking situation is not ideal, but they are at the end of a road due to being on the water, so it is what it is. When you get in, there is a host stand, right there. They have a very large and welcoming bar, it reminds me of Springers in stoughton. We were seated right away, and our server was just stellar. So very attentive, answered every question without annoyance. I actually got an appetizer for my meal because it sounded so amazing. It was braised tenderloin over portobello mushrooms. They were fall apart, melt in your mouth GOOD. They would even Ben great over a pasta! I had so much tenderloin left, I joked that I needed another mushroom. My husband got scallops, and he's very picky. They weren't in his top three, but he said they were decent. The others in our party got a giant lobster tail, and the king cut prime rib. From the pricing on their menu, it is a no brained to get the king, because there is only a $1 difference between the king and the queen cut. Unless that was a typo, since it looks like they update it daily. That is also nice, because they put the day's specials on it too. Soup over salad, because the salad was meh, but the soup was STELLAR. It was slower when we went, so that made a huge difference in our experience, but we will definitely be back when the ice thaws, so we can really enjoy their view of the lake! read more

See all

Food was amazing! Drinks, delish! Views, priceless! A favorite to visit when in the area! Highly recommend!

Garett was wonderful, he hosted the dinner without ever interrupting us and never made us feel rushed at all despite our larger party being later in the evening. He made good suggestions and made sure all of our drinks were consistently kept full. All of our dinners were delicious and came out in a timely manner, as did our appetizers of the beef tenderloin bites- which were great with the sauce. We wanted to sit outside, and even with it drizzling a bit were were all comfortable under the large tent provided. The bar inside was really well done, the red LED's add a nice flair. Garett was personable & a delight overall, we appreciate the experience. read more

Buckhorn Supper Club - salmon w/ garlic dill sauce and loaded baked potato, peppercorn ranch starter salad- both very good - Steakhouses Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

See all

Fantastic classic supper club, great vibes, good service, drinks, and the walleye was excellent. Great lake views in a cozy setting. read more

See all

Family was visiting and wanted to experience a Supper Club so I had reservations for Sunday. Waited at our table for almost an hour for our drinks. French onion soups were delivered cold. 20 minutes after our order was placed we were told one of the entrees was wasn't available anymore and what did the person want instead? Then was told they were out of a side that some ordered and what would we want instead. Then was told the garlic mashed weren't available and then they found some. One person never got their side. Requested condiments for prime rib was never delivered after 2 requests. We had to flag down someone for more water for the table and they never asked if we wanted any additional drinks after the initial one. Very disappointed. They did remove the mandatory 8 person tip and gave us 2 free desserts for the poor service. Will probably consider other supper clubs in the future! read more

I would recommend this restaurant for the view in the warm weather months. The staff is very welcoming and efficient. The only downside was the prices. The prime rib was one of the best I have had, and the broiled scallops were quite nice, but the side choices were underwhelming. The roasted green beans were barely recognizable as beans, my wive's baked potato was overdone and dry. The accompanying soups were ok, did not come across as homemade, had more of a food service supply company taste to them.The $140 for two dinners and two drinks and tip was a bit much. I waver between 3 & 3 1/2 stars for this review. We may come back in the summer for broasted chicken and the view of Lake Koshonong. read more

Had a very enjoyable experience here. Started off with a lemon martini, which was perfect. Not too sweet or sour. For appetizers we had the scallops. Bacon wrapped. It was a $20 appetizer and there was only 4 but let me tell you, worth it. The prime rib was delicious and cooked just perfect. The onion soup deliciously sweet and tangy. The perch was good but my dinner partner said he could tell it was a little old but still good. It has that old time supper club atmosphere. The wait staff was extremely friendly and service quick. Be prepared to pay a little money here but great for a laid back date night. read more

See all

Went for a fish fry. Soup was good, and fish fries were decent. Ambiance was a little off. Waitress was attentive.

Owner and his crew are down to earth , trying their best great crew!! Food n drinks always #1 Great place honest business Yess Go!! Dave Fort atkinson glass co. read more

Went with a LARGE group of about 22 on a Friday night.... Had the King's cut of Prime Rib that DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!! My cut was rare to medium rare, EXACTLY how I like it! Then, someone in the group ordered a Brandy Alexander - I had never had one before - and I finished it off!!!! Delicious!!!! The staff was great and the place was hoppin' with an older decor - kinda circa 1960's / 1970's.... 10/10 would eat here again!!!! read more

We've been a few times a year customers for 30+ years. Last night had it's down's and up's, starting that staff isn't masking (but I wasn't really surprised). We've been eating out a bit lately and most servers and staff are, so having always thought of the place as upscale, I thought maybe... Next was the bar debacle (mrs grumpy pants), where we order our favorite, margaritas one of each, for the usual higher cost of $16. My wife noticed something black floating in hers, fished it out and inspected. Relieved that it wasn't a bug we attempted to continue on when she noticed many black specs in my strawberry drink. The lady was grumpy on so many levels that I was just going to take mine to the table and bring it up there. My wife doesn't back down from many people and soon called grumpy over, where she looked at the black specs and shrugged it off as normal...wtf, then dumped them in sink without even checking what it could be, and maybe find the source. Grumpy asked if we'd like something different. We got a couple sodas and she never even considered adjusting the cost. The dining experience was better with a very nice server and the Bluegill was the best as always. We did however realize the place hasn't been remodeled in our lifetime and is seriously run down. read more

Ate outdoors on a Saturday night in early October. Like many other restaurants trying to recover from the pandemic, they are running a smaller menu. I missed the giant pile of onion rings they used to serve. The food we did have was quite tasty, and our server (wish I could remember her name) was very nice and on top of things. Our crew had the prime rib, tenderloin, halibut (why? Just for the, err, Hal-I-but) and the ribeye. French onion soup was delicious. Their ice cream drinks are ridiculously large and creamy. Save room for one to share! read more

Buckhorn Supper Club - Grasshopper - Steakhouses Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

See all

My husband and I drove from Indiana to meet my cousin, who drove from St. Paul to experience the lobster boil at The Buckhorn Supper Club. It was a great experience and worth the drive. Our evening began with drinks in the bar. We all enjoyed a glass of Old Fashioned, a white wine from Drumlin Ridge Winery in Waunakee. A nice selection of local wines and beer is available. I also had a brandy old fashioned sweet. My cousin had a bourbon old fashioned. Before the boil began we moved to the patio which has a lovely view of the lake. We were able to see the lobster boil from the patio, but most walked down the hill to watch. After the boil we moved to the dining room to have our meal. Dinner began with a Caesar Salad and a piece of jalapeño cornbread. The lobster arrives at the table plates with a potato, corn on the cob and the whole lobster. Staff circulates the room helping guests to shell the lobster. For dessert we were treated to a fudge brownie with grasshopper ice cream. White and red wine are also included. Except for the lobster, you can enjoy additional helpings of the sides. The meal was great. The staff works hard to make sure everyone is enjoying their evening. Matt and Chico moved around the dining room to check on their guests and made sure everyone is enjoying their meal. I would recommend the lobster boil. We are looking forward to returning in the future to try the regular menu. read more

Seriously?!! Had a reservation and still had to wait 40 minutes (isn't a reservation supposed to reserve a table?). Food was another 40 minutes after ordering.... Salty overpriced and mediocre. Way too expensive. Coasting on their reputation. read more

My husband had the best prime rib ever! I had the breaded shrimp which was good as well.

Over priced and not very good quality meat. Last time 4 of us were there, we had over $150 bill with 1 drink a pice and dinner and the steak was to tough to chew read more

Ambiance was great. Food is over priced and mediocre. There are better super clubs with better food for less.

Terrible - we planned this evening a few weeks ago to celebrate a birthday - scheduled a reservation at 7:30. Arrived at 7 and I'm still waiting at 8:15. Terrible so far... The rest of the night only got worse - finally seated at 8:30, pleasant server got us drinks and bread - and took our order reasonably fast - she stopped to say she was sorry for the long wait a couple of times - finally got our $250 meal for four at 9:20. All three ribeyes were ordered medium rare and all came out medium (pink) with one closer to medium well pinkish grey and the prime rib ordered medium rare, was well done. My wife sent it back, also needed to have the mashed potatoes reheated. Buckhorns gave us two free desserts and didn't charge for the unbeatable prime rib. Lobster was good. Tipped the waitress 15% because she was trying ... and left. The experience was absolutely terrible but the steak, although overcooked, had good flavor. read more

Great Wisconsin supper club Fish Fry so good, the baked is my favorite Best dirty martini served A nice bar. The view is amazing. Nice out door in summer. read more

We had a large party of about 18 people and a reservation. We did have to wait quite a while for our tables - which I know is classic supper club, so no worries there. Huge place and large bar where we were served quickly. I will say the cheese curds were good but pretty $$$ in my opinion because we didn't get very many on each plate. My little table all got fish and were satisfied with what we were served. We did get a bread basket - good, and a coleslaw type salad that I was not a fan of. read more

Extremely overpriced. Had to wait 70 minutes for a table even though there were open tables. It was over priced by about 30%, when compared to food of comparable quality and quantity at some supper clubs in a 1 hour radius. Maybe catering to a Chicago audience who is used to overpaying for going out to eat. read more

My son and I have been visiting this Supper Club for 5 years now, and we were never disappointed. Tonight was no different. We were seated promptly and courteously. Our drink orders fulfilled immediately and were very good. We had asked for some time to just talk and enjoy the view of Lake Koshkanong. They were more than happy to accommodate. We ordered, probably THE BEST Baked Fench Onion soup we have ever tasted. My son ordered the Queen Cut Prime Rib, which he states is by far the best he has ever had, and he has been to a lot of places that serve prime rib. It's his favorite. I had the 7oz Fillet medium rare. It was presented on a stainless steel hotplate and cooked perfectly. With that, the steamed broccoli was lightly coated in a delicious blanket of butter. I also added on some broiled scallops, which once again were cooked to perfection with a side of drawn butter. For dessert, I indulged in a Brandy Alexander. It was very large and indulgent, and my son went with his go to; Key Lime Pie. He absolutely loved it, saying that it wasn't too sweet but not too sour. A perfect balance. Thank you to Garrett, our server, for being extremely attentive and accommodating. I would recommend this Authentic Wisconsin Supper Club to anyone who wants the real deal!!!! read more

One of the best prime rib dinners I have ever had! Showed up at 6pm on Saturday so had to wait an hour to be seated outdoors without a reservation which was fine. Sat at the bar and enjoyed a couple of great old fashioned and watched the bartender make beautiful ice cream drinks. Service was outstanding even as busy as they were read more

Buckhorn Supper Club - Excellent prime rib! - Steakhouses Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

We went here last night for the first time. Greeted warmly by the staff an the owner. The service was wonderful, attentive and quick. NOW, the food. WOW. We had the spinach and artichoke dip with garlic toast for appetizer, queen cut prime rib with baked potato for entrée and pecan pie for dessert. ALL was amazing. The prime rib was to die for, perfectly seasoned and cooked! We will be back! read more

So to start off my party of 14 and I came for Friday night fish fry. We are from Georgia and come to Wisconsin once a year looking forward to this tradition. However, our experience at Buckhorn was definitely one for the worse. To begin with, knowing that it is a supper club, I expected prices to be high. However, with high prices I expect delicious food. Despite this, the exact opposite was true. The fried cod, steak, and shrimp were mediocre. The menu has nothing cheaper than $11.99 (which is Mac and cheese), yet the food is worth no more than $15 at best. Along with the poor quality for a high price, one of the members of my party asked our server if they could have an item off the kids menu because they wanted a smaller portion. The waitress responded that she would revive the same amount of food but for an up charge!! Why on earth would they charge more for the same amount of food?? Then, another member of my party asked for a salad with chicken on it but they refused to put the chicken on a small salad saying they only put chicken on large salads. It sounds like to me they care more about the money than the satisfaction of their guests. Lastly, in addition to these negatives, our service was quite poor. With a large party, I expect the server to be annoyed but put on a good face considering their tip. However, the server clearly displayed her anger and annoyance of our party. She was extremely short after every request for a drink refill or menu question, and she proceeded to stare at us from afar after the bill was payed and we stayed seated at the table. In all, definitely would not recommend. Cool atmosphere but poor food, high prices, and substandard service. read more

What a great meal glad we didn't take the latest reviews to heart. Spending our 20th wedding anniversary there was a hit and our server Beth was one of the best I've encountered. The only reason I didn't award 5 stars is was more barish and lacked a tablecloth and way to many tables. The food and drinks a bit on the high end and the mushrooms with the steak came from a can. The quality of meat and the homemade desert are second to none. I would go back! Oh the fried bluegill was almost as if I cooked it myself. read more

Buckhorn Supper Club - Steakhouses Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

See all

I love the vibe here and always will. Service is outstanding I just wish it was a touch more reasonably priced. I paid I think like $14 for mac and cheese off the kids menu for my daughter and I'm about 90% certain it was Kraft. Love the stuffed shrimp, drinks are great! read more