Giving it 4 stars because of the pizza. I read all the reviews on here and had higher expectations…read moreof this place. Let me start out by first saying the pizza was great. I had 3 slices, a pepperoni, a chicken bacon ranch and a Buffalo chicken slice. The pepperoni was decent. The chicken bacon ranch was definitely pretty tasty but I was blown away by the Buffalo chicken slice, it definitely out did the others. Would rate the slices a 4.5/5. I've never been a huge buffalo chicken slice fan because I hate loads of grease dripping off my slice and the flavor has never been there for me, but whatever these guys are doing with this works, so this is something I would order again. I also ordered a large Turkey sub with American, LTO and Mayo... definitely sub par for sure (pun intended). All lettuce and not a lot of meat...was very surprised as it was roughly $15 and probably 2 slices of Turkey all the way through, so probably a total of 6-7 smaller sized slices for a large sub. Would rate the sub a 2.5/5. I will definitely be back for the pizza! Hoping they see this and throw a little more meat on their subs next time especially for the price. All in all Chittenango Pizza loads their slices up with toppings which I appreciate. Who wants a skimpy slice of pie? Service was great, ambiance was comfortable, I appreciate that it's the old Pizza Hut, kind of nostalgic and decorated with wizard of oz knick knacks etc which is typical for the town :-)

Haven't had good pizza like this in a long time, highly recommend! The crust was slightly crunchy…read morewhich was perfect.

Place is fantastic. Food is great, prices are fair, ambience is casual and relaxed. Very surprised…read moreat how great the food was! Wings are awesome, pizza and their homemade sauce is even better. Literally drive by this place 2x a day and never stopped. Glad I finally did!

We have stopped here several times and the food is always good. We come with 2 toddlers and a…read morenewborn and the staff is so nice to them. They offer them coloring books and take time to talk to them, too. Good beer selection and overall awesome service.

Everything about this restaurant is absolutely EXCELLENT!! 5 stars on all levels. Chicken Parm, oh…read moremy gosh, so so good! Hands down the BEST!!

Lauro's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria in Canastota, NY for lunch today and we are both glad we…read moregave it a try Service was friendly, very good and the food was also good. I ordered Sausage Parm - local Basilo's Sausage with onions, sauce & mozzarella Cheese $ 7.99. Sub Bread was home made and tasted great which added to the taste of my sandwich which was also very large. Friend ordered their Italian Trio - Salami, Capicola, & Loads of Fresh Ham $8.99, All Quality cold cuts and extremely large. My next order for lunch. Even though mine was good, I was Jealous We both brought home half our subs. Nice Draft Beer - Craft selection. Tried their meatballs personally everyone has different taste for their meatballs - 6.5 out of 10. So in summary for lunch this could be a 'HOT' Hidden Gem in Canastota. For dinner if you are looking for Pizza, Subs, but want Beer, wine etc. Try them. Entrees are limited.

I would be fibbing if I didn't say I have intentionally went to Yellowbrick casino just to get…read moreeverything wings from them! The service is A1 the food is even better. The pizza slices are a bit over priced but I have enjoyed every flavor and topping option they have to offer and they always come thru. I spend way too much money at the casino ofcourse so they owe me some free food and a win lol. I have sat and eaten here for my hubbys birthday after stopping up to enjoy the day and the dining area is always clean and spacious. A must try if you ask me!!!

Located in the casino, it has excellent customer service and is very clean in the eating area. I…read morehad the two simple slices of cheese. The pizza was cooked perfectly and had a good taste to it. Two slices of pizza in the water 10 bucks.

Small town pizza right along the main drag. It's quaint and has a nice atmosphere…read more Unfortunately, the pizza is pretty average. It's NY style, which I like. But, there just wasn't a ton of flavor. For my fellow midwesterners, I'd compare it to Casey's pizza. In fact, the pepperoni tasted exactly like Casey's. I also tried the Everything But Anchovies (supreme). It was better as the toppings were pretty good. But still, I think I'd prefer Pizza Hut's supreme. One gripe - no delivery. It was snowing like crazy. I would've paid a fee to have it delivered 1 mile up the road. I'd definitely eat here again. But, it's not the best pizza in America that's for sure.

Best pie this side of Pavone's in Manlius. And ice cream and a barroom too! Who could ask for more?read more

Great pizza made by great people. Always fast and consistent quality. There are a couple tables…read moreinside.

Casual environment and courteous customer service. They make…read moredelicious personalized calzones ! My family enjoys their pizza a lot! Great family run business!

After writing my review had to go back for the fish sandwich, my favorite fish sandwich in Syracuse!read more

I placed a "to go " order tonight for 30 wings, xtra xtra xtra crispy, chargrilled with garlic…read moreparm sauce. When she said 20 minutes, I absolutely knew they would be a fail! Twenty minutes later I got the wings which were a tad pricey. Drove three minutes home and opened the packages, there was not one hint of chargrilling on any of the wings. They were definitely not xtra xtra xtra crispy,(sorry but I've worked in some crazy busy pizza shops and to make wings that crispy takes at least 30 to 35 minutes to reach that amount of crispness.) Finally, the wings were definitely not coated with any garlic parm seasoning. They were at best plain, fried wings. To say we were extremely disappointed is an understatement. I did call back when I realized they were not chargrilled and they offered to recook a new batch. But I just did not feel like waiting 20 more minutes. We are seniors and we don't like to eat too late at night. The alternative was a $10.00 gift card which is there waiting for me. However, i honestly do not see myself going back for another try. Side note: we normally go to OIP for incredible chargrilled wings but for some strange reason they were closed on this Tuesday evening. On the hole, honestly I would give them one star, only because that's the lowest rating possible. Stingers, we tried them and we likely won't be going back.

I got a slice and the flavor was great, though super greasy on top and a bit overdone on the crust…read more I'd give it a 7.5/10 on the slice. Great selection of toppings, tho.

Great parking, well lit. Good seating with a lrg TV. Now about the food, oh yes the pizza sauce is…read morehomemade, the dough is delicious and great texture, the bake is spot on cooked and not burnt. I ordered the large one topping mushroom and it was SO GOOD!

Had a great experience having a dine-in pie at Pavone's on a weeknight. We ordered a large cheese…read morepizza and each had a few slices and had some to take home. They have the best cheese pizza in Syracuse! The staff were friendly and the dining area was clean.

I've been going to Pavone's for over half a century and after having lived in the City twice, I can…read moreaver that it's still the most authentic New York pie in CNY. But it's not just a pizzeria! All their subs are great (and yes, I've had them all!), but their meatball sub is perfection on a plate. One nice surprise is their salads, which are always fresh, crisp, and tasty. Add in the fast, friendly service and the no-nonsense décor and Pavone's is a phenomenal 5-stars.