Only my second time here, first time in broad daylight, lol. The selection was pretty good for 5pm, I love a buffalo chicken pizza and this definitely tasted like one! Only one person working, but I got my slices quickly and efficiently! A family of 5 were the only other people in there and they got their pizza super quick as well. This place is great if you want a quick, ok slice! read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Dang that place is a vibe and a half!! Great slices, and the guys working were absolutely hilarious!! Took phenomenal care of us! If we ever make it back to Syracuse, we'll see you again Nick's!! read more

We happened to stumble upon Nick's Tomato Pie after visiting the MOST to check out the new Nature Photography exhibit and what a fantastic surprise it turned out to be! We came by on a Thursday around 5 PM and had the place nearly to ourselves. Michael and David were absolutely terrific & incredibly welcoming and kind. They even had a few jokes for our kids, which made the whole experience feel personal and warm. Honestly, it felt like we were visiting family. There's a lot more seating than you'd expect & especially in the attached room (former bowling alley) Plenty of space to relax and enjoy your food. Now, the pizza: perfectly crunchy slices that hit the spot. One of our kids even declared it "the best pizza they ever had!" And all the kids loved it, which is saying something! We'll absolutely be back. Highly recommend stopping in, especially if you're in the area visiting the museum. Bonus for college kids- They stay open until the line ends on the weekends (2-3am) read more

See all

Amazing pizza & great service with a smile!! Placed an order online thru their website & ordered for pickup. This place speaks pizza vibes! I ordered a large cheese & pep pizza, medium wings extra crispy, and mozzarella sticks and let me tell you this is real Authentic Italian pizza with huge slices of cheesy goodness. The wings were crispy and held great flavor with the right amount of sauce i asked for extra crispy and they honored my request. Highly recommend Nick's Tomato Pie to anyone in the area looking for good Italian pizza and I will definitely be coming back for more! Thank you for such great service and delicious food! read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - Medium buffalo 10 Wings - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

Pizza and wings were amazing! Michael Watson was amazing. Great customer service. The whole order was cooked to perfection! read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - Great Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

Conveniently located in the heart of downtown, this pizza place is only populated after 10pm and for good reason: the pizza is mediocre and staff bullies guests. Probably will not be coming back as I witnessed one of the staff members slap a slice of pizza out of a guest's hands and the security guard berate and throw out a separate group of non-disruptive customers. An eventful night, but it seems that this is a regular occurrence for this business. read more

This place is so fire, I would 100% recommend, very nice staff and quick results, nice aesthetic.

It's a slice shop where you can get a pie and it's open late. Usually for places open late the quality isn't that great, especially when surrounded by bars, but with that all in mind, I don't think it was bad. The dough was a little one dimensional, reminding me of bread, but It's worth stopping by for a slice. Far from the best in Syracuse, but it'll get the job done. I was not disappointed and I'd be back if I was craving pizza past 9PM. read more

Happened to stumble upon this place. The employees were absolutely terrific and welcoming. They have a lot of seating in the attached room. Pizza slices were nice and crunchy. Enjoyed the tomato pie. I forgot to take pictures. Can't say enough about the staff!!! read more

Better staff!! I'm a recent widow that was taking to a customer when I witnessed the staff became upset and picked a customer up by him neck as through him out of the store. Unbelievably inappropriate and totally unprofessional. I will never come back or tell anybody to come to this establishment. Disgusting behavior by this staff!! read more

Stopped in twice during a recent visit to Syracuse. This place is open at all hours and seems to do a good business during all meal times. They have a wide variety of slices that are priced just right. My only complaint - the warmups in the oven could be a little longer. The staff is very friendly. Who I presumed to be the owner was running the register both times and was very personable -- even to the too drunk frat boy ahead of me in line. Kudos! read more

Family is from Texas and they wanted to try a ny pizza and this was my first choice and I can say it was the best family loved it so much 100% recommend read more

Excellent pizza, service, ingredients and the CRUST! Wow - there is no comparing Nick's Tomato Pie to anything in California (or Florida) where we cone from. Ask for the spicy honey! Yes, no kidding - delicious on your tomato pie. We will be back - $30 for an extra large with toppings. Hip old tin ceilings and lively sidewalk conversation right outside. read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - Outside entry - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

I came here the other night as it's right downtown and open later. Got a slice of pepperoni. First of all $3.75 for a slice of pizza is high way robbery. Secondly, the pizza was terrible. He threw it in the oven for me but it was barely lukewarm. I didn't notice until I got to my next destination (5 min away) because they had boxed it up. I didn't feel like turning around and I didn't have access to an oven. It was kind of soggy and just not good. I ended up throwing it out. read more

I came to this place after a volleyball tournament and the guy serving me was so friendly and very sweet, im not from Syracuse and generally didn't have a lot of generic fast food chains close by and this place was closest to my hotel, I honestly was having a bad day and the guy struck and held conversation with me and also gave me extra food, 1000000/10 read more

Heard lots of good things about this place. I can see the appeal of this as a spot for after a long night out, but we came for a quick late bite. The pizzas were sitting on the counter and looked a bit sad. We tried two slices (there was a huge discrepancy between the slices). The good thing is that the pizza was reheated so everything tasted better. Everyone was really nice, pizza was okay, but won't be my first choice in general. read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Absolutely delicious! New York style pizza by the slice as well! Service was great, the restaurant itself is small, There's an area in the back if you wanna sit down and have a meal instead of being in with everybody coming in for slices. It can get packed. Even when the line is at its longest, still Worth it though! read more

awesome store awesome food everything is great one guy did try to sell me a bicycle with no seat and 4 wheels however that just made my night better. nicks tomato pie forever read more

Go to spot for a tasty pie. I'm picky about my tomato pie and I absolutely love it here. I also like their regular pizzas. The pickle pizza is a favorite for sure. read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - Pickle, bacon, and ranch pizza with no bacon. - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Pleasantly surprised. Calling at 8:45 PM Friday night and told 20 minutes I got there it was ready amazing. Good quality pizza, excellent service better then we expected. read more

Food tasty! Service and staff awesome and friendly! Ambiance - eh basic pizzeria good drunk munchies!

Came to try the "Tomato pie" with honey...crust was good but otherwise ..ehhh, nothing to write home about.

Excellent Choices of Pizza, service is prompt & accommodating , I highly recommend this establishment even though the prices are not the least expensive read more

If you hate this pizza, then you'll want to Nix Nick's. Luckily, you probably won't, because it's actually really good. Now bear in mind that I give a 5 star to anything that really does it for me. A 4 star is more "average" because I don't rate family businesses less than 3. So a 3-star family business is more like a "1 star" to you. And my 4 is more like your 3, maybe. With that in mind, the 4 star here means that Nick's is not my favourite. If you want to eat this pizza like an animal, and feel it from the inside, and if it gets you closer to god, then it's NIN's Tomato Pie. However it's not bad, and I definitely don't want to Nix Nick's. It's a little like Pavone's Pizza nearby. Rochester and Buffalo have so many great pizza places (and don't get me started on NYC) that it's hard for me to really get into Syracuse Pizza. The only 5-star one I've had in town so far is the unfortunately-named Paladino's (because Carl Paladino sucks). If you bring your dog here, and he or she keeps biting you while you eat, then it's Nip's Tomato Pie. The server was kind of iffy about recommending something to me, but he did so based on how fresh the pie was, and so pointed me to the cheese & pep. It was nice. It cost only 2.75 and was really big, and I appreciated that part of it a lot. And plus this place is open til 3am for when the clubs let out, so it's a great asset for Syracuse to have. "Nice" is about right for this pizza. In fact I'd consider changing it to "Nice Tomato Pie." In any case, if you're in the Syracuse area and want to try the good slices, this one is pretty good. read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

The NEW Nick's. Place had been closed a while due to construction on the building next door. They are back. This review is geared towards the one type of pizza I eat. THAT is Tomato pie. It has far less fat calories from cheese, but still satiates like pizza. The Tomato pie. Glorious thick, soft crusted focaccia pooled with generous helpings of sweet, zesty tomato sauce. The nine slice 8th Wonder of the World is only 14 bucks, but you will gladly leave a twenty and say " Keep the change, Maestro." The employees are WAY cool. But no one can compare with the out of this world manager who personally checks the quality of each tomato pie made. She is a real ball of fun and professionalism. It takes 45 minutes to get one of these gems made as the dough has to rise slowly. Utica, NY pizza chefs come by trying to figure how they do it. Spying for tips and sevrets on the ingredients and methods. These are amazing. Go for it now. read more

Pros: cheap eats, cheap beers, good selection of types of pizza. Cons: The pizza here tasted like it was last night's pizza reheated in a toaster oven. The vegetables were standard canned stuff, the sauce tasted like it might have come from a can and had added sugar. The other reviews raving about the food mostly mention it is great as a late night snack after boozing. I can appreciate that On a weekend afternoon, however, there are better options. To quote Yelp's rating guide, two stars, "Meh. I've experienced better." read more

Dirty. Annoying political garbage on the TVs all the time. Pizza has zero taste and sits out for hours if not all day or week long...pandering to Clarence the drunk bum. But it's awesome if you're an underage drunk kid in Armory square on a Friday or Saturday night... read more

Their pie is good. I opted for the ricotta, tom, & broccoli slice. If ur hungry late night stop in. read more

Nick's Tomato Pie - Sausage Pep & GP plus Toms, Ricotta, & Broc #NY #Cuse #Pie - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Not only is the pizza always great, but Mark is more than hospitable. It's because of him I always feel welcome and we'll taken care of. Outstanding service and great food! read more

Great pizza, and not just when you're drunk at 3 am! I had it sober just to be sure it really was good. The pizzas always great and they always have a variety of slices ready to go and the staff is friendly, they have to be to deal with the drunks that come in after the bars close! Green pepper and bacon is the way to go! read more

Ah this place brings back some great memories from when I used to work downtown! It was the go to place when you needed delicious pizza with a creative flair. I still come here even when its out of the way for me. They have one of the best pizzas there that I cannot get anywhere else. Well maybe I can, but it would be out of the norm anywhere else. Its the BBQ CBR pizza. That's Barbeque Chicken Bacon Ranch to the initiated. It combines all of the amazing flavors of a BBQ pizza with A CBR pizza. If you call ahead they will typically let you know that either one is made or they can make one for you. You wont regret eating a slice of that divine pie. The prices are good, the location is great, and they have a wide variety of pizza that you can order. I highly recommend this pizza! read more

I have been to this place many times and the pizza is consistently excellent. Having lived in Long Island and Manhattan most of my life my standards for pizza are very high. Just like the pizza I am accustomed to, Nick's Tomato Pie has nice thin crispy crust, covered with tasty cheese and tomato sauce. They have plenty of vegetarian options and many different meat toppings as well. They have a lot of seating so it's good for groups. It is one of the few places in town open late night which is great. Unfortunately, their hours of operation are not reflected in the sign outside. I have walked by many times in the afternoon and evening hoping to grab a slice of pizza and they have been closed. read more

I am from Long Island, and so I have a particularly high pizza expectation that is generally not found in the area. This place is the best. Thin, crispy crust and flavorful sauce. Plenty of seating indoors. Great idea after a night of drinking, or not. read more

Pizza was tasteless and bland. What bothered me even more was the owner! It was a Friday night they had the news blasting and he was making racial jokes. Completely unacceptable behavior. I would choose anywhere else to eat than to allow a racist to make profits off my dollar. read more

The two guys that were working there, worked their asses off! The line was pretty long and they constantly engaged us all and didn't let that stop their customer service. They were fast, efficient, and kind! But what got me excited most, BEST WINGS EVER!!!!! I ask everywhere I get wings, I need them to be super crispy and no one gets that 100% right. Nicks Tomato Pie DOES!!!!! Perfection!!!! read more

solid pizza- guy who seemed like the owner gave me flack for asking for ranch and made me pay after doing my home girl a favor with it. everybody stingy with the sauce these days read more

I used to like stumbling into this joint drunk and pigging out. However, I left Syracuse about 7 years ago. I have no clue what it is like now. Back when I would go here, they had a wide array of pizzas laid out, ready for the drunken post bar crowed. It was called davincis before. Anyways, this was one of my favorite pizza places. I didn't care for the people running the place. They were your typical rude upstate new yorkers. To this day, still one of my favorite slices of pizza. Very truly yours, GuyLaDouche read more

Small interior, but they have plenty of slices and goodies ready for your Armory Square lunch. The guy working there during the day whenever I've gone in during the day is friendly and inviting, and is enjoyable to talk to. Pizza is good (and not super expensive). A nice sauce that I found to be the best part. I come here semi-regularly. read more

The pizza is good, the place looks very nice on the inside. Most employees are cool, some questionable. The pizza is a bit overpriced but they get away with it because 97% of their customers are already drunk. But other than that I feel like it's a great place for the after bar experience. read more

The perfect pie! There was one guy working by his self in the restaurant. We ordered a pizza to go and the guy was running a bit behind. He was obviously swamped but kept his cool and friendly demeanour. Making great pizzas, answering the phone and dealing with customers all at the same time! Well done!!! The pizza was great too!!! read more