My family loves the garlic parmesan wings and a tuna hoagie. Don't sleep on this restaurant.

I've been going to Buffalo Biils for YEARS. The food is good and they have the best garlic parm wings in South Jersey! Customer Service has always been top notch and the owner is very appreciative and accommodating when possible read more

one star because the flavor is good, another star because the service at the desk is not bad. Took off 3 stars for how shameful the chicken wing sizes are. As pictured these tiny baby chicken wings seem like they are straight from the chick or a pigeon as apposed to a full size chicken. Chicken size has gone down considerably but the price has gone up. $50 for 30 wings of this size is ridiculous. I love the flavor but can no longer justify purchasing from this spot. The proper thing to do is find a new supplier or decrease prices for wings this small. I feel like they know the wing size is unacceptable but wont change because people keep paying for it. Also their debit/credit machine is always "down" but i think it has more to do with mistrust with their customers. read more

Buffalo Bills Barbecue - Baby wings - Barbeque Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

See all

The food here is amazing and the service is great. The place is small but nice. They would help you with your selection if you needed help.

Amazing Philly Cheesesteaks!!! Will definitely return everytime I'm in Jersey! No need to go to Philly!

Spent $23.00 for 1/2 rack of baby back rims with barbeque beans and coleslaw Ribs were terrible coleslaw was dry and terrible I never posted a negative review but this time I had to I should of known when I went in poster said cash only and not one customer there read more

Don't sleep on Buffalo Bills BBQ! Everything on the menu is good! Cheesesteaks, buffalo chicken cheesesteaks, garlic Parm wings, Mac n cheese, baked beans, and I love their cornbread muffins! Oh and the BBQ grilled chicken platters are my go to! The service is great, they are very friendly and the prices are very reasonable. Gotta check them out! read more

The other day, before the holiday weekend, I was craving bbq (Ribs!!) bc of all the commercials on tv showing the upcoming Labor Day Weekend Feast 2018. I turned to Yelp to find a local bbq takeout joint. Buffalo Bill's and their extensive menu tempted our family's tastebuds! My first hint there would be issues was from the girl who answered to take my order. She kept putting the phone down to ask someone else about my order specifications and questions. (If you read my reviews, you'll see I always ask to customize my order, including the cook on my food, As everyone should get what they want when they are paying for it). My hubby is not picky and just orders directly off the menu as described. He chose the 1/4 Pork Ribd and Chicken Combo with the sides of Mac n cheese & collard greens. He doesn't like to complain but his food was over cooked and dry. I chose just The "St Louis Style Pork Ribs" and specified a medium rare cook with the same sides as my hubby. I didn't even eat it. I tried to bite, then even cut some meat off of the ribs. OMG. So over cooked and desperately dry! Unfit for my dog kind of cook on those ribs!!! The Mac n cheese...again dry like saw dust. The collards...just gross. And I'm a Collard Greens fan! Into the garbage went my entire container!!! My son wanted pulled pork and a side of mashed. But their menu only says its on a sandwich. So, the girl again questioning ppl if they can serve without the roll. My son said the mashed were good. The end of that meal. I asked about their wings and the difference between the ones they offered. The girl couldn't give me a straight answer. My son likes The buffalo wings from "Antonio's Pizza" in Williamstown. He orders them dry but they have spice. I asked if they could do that. She told me I should order the Flour wings, that they were the best. Wrong. Hubby & son tried 1 each and into the garbage they went. I cannot express what a waste of money this was. So much for our bbq meal we were craving! Check my pix for proof, sooo bad! read more

This place is EXTREMELY RUDE!!!!! The girls answering the phones and working behind the counter are very very ignorant. I have complained numerous times n management does nothing!!! read more

Ordered a plain cheesesteak and chickensteak hoagie with hot peppers potato salad and rice pudding with raisins all items were very good . I strongly support local businesses and will order in the future!! Dan W read more

I happened on the place because it is close to where I work and I had an appointment very close. Today I stopped in and I must say that it didn't look to promising. (See picture of inside) However I had bbq pork with spicy bbq sauce and fries. Very tasty. As far as I can tell the bbq seems legit. The roll was so so, but the meat was good. Proper portion. The fries were hot and crisp, overall I'd say give it a shot. read more

Buffalo Bills Barbecue - Inside the restaurant. - Barbeque Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

So this my FIRST time n I must say it was just "ok". It was extremely busy n the seating was very limited. The young ladies were ok.Not overly customer service friendly but they were not rude. Ribs were good but the sides were not that good. The baked beans tasted like they came out of the can n doctored up, the mash potatoes were alright...n their gravy was REALLY good. Not sure exactly what the gravy goes on but whatever the gravy goes on an other meals I'm sure it's pretty good. They have a lot of selection and once again like I said the store was very busy that night so obviously it's good too many. I just can't say that I was overly happy with my experience. read more

See all

It was just okay for me. I ordered ribs that were not tender. The Mac and cheese was bland, potato salad was missing some type of seasoning. Now the burger my son said was banging. He truly enjoyed it. My sister said the cheesesteak hoagie was good. The cake was good too. read more

Once I had their Garlic Parm Wings, their Garlic Parm Wings are the only wings I'll eat. No other places' Garlic Parm Wings can't even come close. Absolutely The Best & Delicious By Far!!!! read more

This place is horrible. Me and my family ordered a whole BBQ chicken and thought it smelled very weird we even called to ask why it had a weird smell and she assured us it was nothing and probably just too much vinegar... we trusted her and gave it a try and long and behold a few hours later the ones who ate it got sick... I reported it to the owner and he called back and didn't seem sorry or sympathetic at all. All he kept saying is he looked at the chicken and it looked "fine" ... obviously something was not right because the ones who ate it got very sick with food poisoning like symptoms ...you would think the least that he would do is refund me my money or something to show that he was sorry but no he didn't. So no i would not recommend this place due this experience! We use to order out on a monthly basis but never again BEWARE OF THIS PLACE! read more

Owner provided fantastic service. The food was authentic BBQ and delicious. It had a good crowd so it is evident that it is a favorite with the locals. My husband lived in Texas for several years and said the food reminded him of the BBQ places in Texas. We will be back!!! read more

Small BBQ place in a strip center mainly used for take out. The menu was huge between BBQ, burgers/wraps, soup with quite a few sides. Our BBQ platters of ribs and chicken came with two sides for a pretty cheap price of $12 and $13 each. The sweet sauce was pretty good but it smothered the chicken and ribs (not my preference) and the meats themselves were quite good. This is one of the very few places I've found in Jersey/Philly that actually had dirty rice and it was easily my favorite food item today. The Collard greens were ok but needed some seasoning besides the salt and pepper given to us. The sweet tea was on point. The young lady that took and orders was nice and it took maybe 20 minutes to get the food but they were pretty busy with the take out orders being placed. The inside had a few tables and a very loud TV so just plan on a take out order being the best bet. The three stars were mainly for the atmosphere, smothered BBQ and unseasoned collard greens. We will be back when we are in the area but its not something we will go out of our way to visit. read more

See all

When in town visiting, my boyfriend and I decided to use groupon to find a place for dinner. We saw a great deal for BBB ($13 for $20 to spend) and immediately came to yelp to do some research. It seemed like pretty much the only negative people had to say was that the prices were bad and to us, seeing the menu online, that was laughable. We live in New York so of course we are used to steeper prices, however I still don't think that for BBQ this place is even remotely costly. We ordered a full rack of beef ribs which come with 2 sides and corn bread for $20. The two of us split it and still couldn't finish. We each ate two of the massive ribs and about half our sides. We brought 3 ribs and the equivalent of a side home for leftovers. Now even if we hadn't had the groupon, three meals worth of food for $20 is not bad whatsoever, especially for BBQ. We've gotten a similar meal in Dutchess county NY for $30+ (however in our opinion Bills did it better). How could you expect to get ribs anywhere cheaper? Enough about price... The food was amazing. We really enjoyed how tender the ribs were. The sauce was great, the sides were great, everything was awesome. The staff working were also so friendly and made eating in (although a casual atmosphere) a fun experience. My boyfriend who is the most frugal person I know even said after dinner that had the groupon not worked and we paid full price, he would still have felt like we got a great deal for the amount of great food. I felt like none of the reviews on here did this place justice so I wanted to Share our experience ( I apologize for the length). We have already decided that next time we are in the area, this is a spot we will not be missing! read more

This place has very good pork ribs. I also tried their wings, hot and bbq. Both were good. But the ribs really shine here. Their sides are also pretty good. This is definately a take out place, but delivery is also available read more

Buffalo Bills Barbecue - Wings. Hot and bbq, baked beans and mac and cheese. - Barbeque Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

Overall, the food was super tasty, the service was courteous, and I would definitely go back. Thanks to the Groupon we were able to get a LOT of different foods, broken down: Shrimp Basket: Standard fries, tasty and crispy shrimp and they give you a lot for $6 BUT still had the tails attached--not appetizing to have to pick those out of your mouth. Crab Soup: Amazing, very rich and very thick. Wish it was more soupy, less paste-like but incredibly tasty. In the words of Guy Fieri, I would eat it on top of a flip-flop it's that good. Texas Style Beef Ribs: Delicious sauce, super tender, but there was almost no meat on the bones, the meat that was on it was mostly burnt. I will definitely try their chicken and pork next time. Baked Beans: Very sweet, great pairing with everything else. Dirty Rice: Good flavor, nice contrast to the sweetness of ribs and beans. Chocolate Mint Pie: Very good, interesting flavor. Like frozen thin-mint chocolate pie. Sweet Potato Cheese Cake: The BEST part of our meal. Recommended by the woman who handled my order. Really creamy, great spices that remind you of fall. I would stop by just to get this after work. Would also eat off of basically anything. This was about $50 worth of food (piex2). Definitely worth it, some leftovers for tomorrow's lunch. I'm excited to go back and have some better luck with the rest of their BBQs. read more

The best BBQ in the area! The prices are a bit high but you get SO MUCH food for your money. I love their grilled BBQ chicken- perfect mixture of BBQ, tangy, and hot. Their mac and cheese is DELICIOUS! Mashed potatoes are ok- one of the items I was disappointed in. Chili is always amazing! read more

Short take is that if you love BBQ done right, this is a great place to order up and take it with you. Mild BBQ sauce is sweet and tangy and the Spicy is just that - not really hot, more spicy and very good. The sides are much better than I expected and stand-up as a compliment to the ribs. Definitely worth a trip as S.Jersey is kind of lacking in excellent BBQ. This place is more of a take-out than site down, but the staff is very friendly and there a re few tables to eat at. Long view - My son and I continue our quest for the penultimate BBQ in S. Jersey. We had the Pork ribs and the Beef Ribs, with sides of Black-eyed Peas and Dirty Rice. First, let me again say the side were very good. Hearty and spicy dirty rice in a very traditional flavor is unusual to find this far north. Black-Eyed Peas had a slight Dill flavor that complemented the peas. The Beef ribs succulent with meat that just melted in your mouth. The Pork ribs were very meaty, but a little more chewy. No melt in your mouth on this one, you had to work at it. My guess is that is was a busy Friday night and we got there later. Perhaps the order we got, didn't have the same amount of time to slow cook? Still very tasty and worth a second chance. Reasonably priced with 2 half racks, 2 sides, sodas and fries coming in around $35. More than enough for for 2 hungry people. read more

I got the Mac and cheese, candy yams and Mild BBQ chicken. The food was exceptional. I'm not going to lie I still want to play around with the menu I don't think I've tasted the best that this place offers. I'm going to indulge in them ribs my next visit!! read more

Buffalo Bills Barbecue - This is it!!! - Barbeque Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

This was my first time eating here. The inside is not well-suited for dining in, but we had no choice this particular day. The service was pretty good. The food was satisfactory. The Mac and cheese was homemade, but it tasted like it was heated up in the micro wave or perhaps just sitting for some time. I had the bbq chicken with mild sauce. The sauce was sweet and spicy and I really enjoyed this. The sweet potatoes were candied and fresh prepared. The basic theme is home kitchen style. A nice place to order take out food in Sicklerville! read more

(4) ~ very good overall food & service. Yes they take Credit Cards($10 minimum) and there are only (2) tables inside, so it's best for Take-out. BBQ MEATS: ** St. Louis Ribs(w. Hot BBQ Sauce) = (4.25) Very Good & Meaty...this was our Favorite both for Ribs & BBQ Sauce:) * Beef Ribs(w. Mild BBQ Sauce) = (3.5) good SIDES: ** Dirty Rice = (4) very good w. bits of beef...our favorite side:) * Potato Salad = (3.75) Good flavor * Mac-n-Cheese = (3.5) good * Corn Bread = (3.25) pretty good * Candied Yams = (3) ok DESSERT: ** Banana Pudding = (4) very good BEVERAGE: ** Arizona Sweet Tea(bottle) = (4) very good read more

Have been dinning with Brain, Dave and the Crew for years over 15+ One of the best BBQ spots around

I stopped pass an old go-to spot to grab some lunch. Chicken & beef rib platter. I must say its been at least 4yrs since I've been here and the food hasn't changed a bit. Still awesome, incredible BBQ sauce and tender beef ribs I love it.... Hope it's not 4 more years before I can come back but at least I do have 1 place for sure to eat whenever I come thru South Jersey... read more

Buffalo Bills Barbecue - Barbeque Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

See all

I really was excited to return here after so many years. The front of the house is a clutter mess. The ladies at the counter were pleasant enough but you had a feel something was missing. The boneless wings were so disappointing. I had 3 in the household to have fair tasting opportunity. It's a total thumbs down. Go to the Piccadilly it's a drive but so enjoyable. Going to Buffalo Bills is settling not even the worth the money spent. read more

So I love ordering from Buffalo Bills, however they are slipping in the customer satisfaction department. I ordered wings as I always do and the last time they gave me blue cheese instead of ranch. One would say that's a small detail that shouldn't be a big deal except I'm allergic to it!!!. I called they were quick to bring but another blue cheese to my door!.. I did say I asked for RANCH! Tonight I ordered again wings, I got NO CELERY, they did get the ranch right this time! Barbecue chicken meal, I was asked if I wanted hot or mild sauce. What's the point in asking if your not going to put it on the chicken?.. I call back and explained what I ordered but received something different. They said they would bring the correct order. When the driver came back the girl handed me Barbecue sauce!.. I'm appalled that the manager or whomever was in charge this night thought it was ok to just hand me sauce to finish his/ her cook's job!.. I did call back to speak directly to the manager, however no one answered the phone. I will probably not order from here anymore!.. Disappointed- Eatsleepplay. read more

Fast and friendly service the prices are really cheap ! I order beef rib plater with double Mac cheese the ribs are tender and flavorful They need a little more meat on them the Mac cheese is almost a home run it's just missing a little pinch of salt! Now the potato salad not sure what the hell it's missing! The fried chicken was very taste and the corn muffins were really good! I'm greedy so I order their take on Baltimore crab soup now if your going to name your soup with crab in it please have some crab in it! Now the seafood chow was really good nice size pieces of shrimp and scallops good job ! My date side her ribs were really good but the Mac cheese and the greens were both needing salt! This is my second tome come here and It will be a third time overall the food is not bad at all!! read more

See all

I've been here over twenty times, and what keeps me coming back is the spicy BBQ beef ribs. It's hard to find places that have them on the menu, let alone make SPECTACULAR beef ribs. The sauce is what sells my family and I. When the ribs are all gone, we harvest (YEAH I said HARVEST) as much of the succulent sauce as possible in another container. That sauce works tremendously on wings too. Their wings are great. Their fries and sides are amazing. The only thing that rubs me the wrong way is the constantly changing price of the wings. They are INCREDIBLY market priced when it comes to their wings, and the market is never low. That aside, still the best place for food in Sicklerville, and it still has me driving 50 minutes round trip to buy their food. IT'S THAT GOOD! read more

There aren't a lot of non-franchise, quality BBQ places in the area so it's great to have one in your own backyard. Prices are very reasonable. Wings are very good and generously (but not overly) covered with a variety of sauces, my favorite being their garlic-parmesan flavor. It will knock you into next week. read more

This is a great BBQ place hidden in Sicklerville. The ribs and BBQ chicken are really good but the best thing is the buffalo wings. I don't get them from anywhere else. The macaroni and cheese tastes fresh and they even make their own buffalo sauce. read more

The staff are really patient, helpful, and friendly. The food was tasty. Even the children's platters were tasty looking. There are a number of meal options. Eating in is a little different. On a hot day, you wouldn't choose it, plus there wasn't an accessible restroom. However, I'd definitely recommend this place and order from them again. read more

Great place to watch the game the wings are usually good you can catch them on an off day and their soggy everyone walks around with a smile and they have some good drinks their beers usually crisp and the kids can always play a game on TV with their tablets at the table all in all it's a four star fast food restaurant with 10 million TVs read more

If it was possible to give this restaurant zero stars I would; the service was great,that was all!!! First of all they were expensive and I don't mind paying for quality but this was far from it !! I heard that their wings were good so I ordered 30 Half Honey habanero and half Buffalo the celery was old and wilted the wings tasted old and possibly freezer burnt! Whoever made the wings just tossed the sauce on top and didn't take the time to try the season or dredge them in the sauce in anyway!! I also ordered mozzarella fries or I should say mozzarella soggy fries! I won't go to this place ever again and you shouldn't either! read more

So disappointed in my wings purchased this weekend. Always get my wings at Buffalo Bills the family and friends Love them. Now this weekend on Saturday I ordered 100 wings and they were at the smallest wings I ever saw. I think this is the last time I will ever buy wings from here game after years of buying them. read more

Food was great ... just wish it was a little less expensive so i could order it more often!.

Completely lousy. And trust me, I'm not "that guy" who complains about everything all the time. Premises-dirty. Staff-dirty. Food-lousy. Price-way too high! I got the sampler platter ($12 bucks!) just to give everything a fair shot. Everything including the sides were disappointing to lousy at best. Sorry. read more

Took my son here for lunch a few times as he is a huge wing fan. Overall, the wings are good. My son is 8 and selected the hottest wings on the menu- he made it through half of them before he couldn't take it anymore. They are extremely HOT! My favorite-Asian zing and the harbanera. read more