Okay the buyers are soooo sweet! A lot nicer than Plato's closet! And the process of selling your clothes is a lot better than Plato's closet ! Definitely recommend selling here! Great vibes read more

I am from Dallas so I usually go to the Buffalo exchange there. The environment here is just OK it's kind of dark gloomy... Compared to the one in Dallas that is bright merchandise really fun and isn't so thrifty looking... I really enjoyed shopping here though... Even though I wasn't able to drop off any of my clothes because of Covid and I have to have a appointment I found some really good pieces that I am excited to wear... I look forward to coming back read more

Do not waste your time they are very courteous here but they give no money for expensive clothing it is a total waste

Horrible place to sell your clothes. I called before hand to ask if they were taking coats and they said yes. I drove an hour, and when I got to the buyer they said they were no taking coats. They waste peoples time. Take your business to Leopard Lounge or Plato's Closet. read more

Wait time was great! I was in and out in 30 minutes. Staff were nice. They didn't take much. But it's to be expected. You're probably getting rid of your worst stuff in your closet and they want trendy pieces they think will sell. All in all it's subjective. I'm sure it depends on who is working that day. I was surprised at some of the things they took and what they didn't take. read more

Buffalo Exchange is a great consignment shop (NOT THRIFT SHOP) where you can sell your vintage/trendy/in season clothing in return for cash or store credit. A lot of people come here to sell their closet, so if this is something you plan to do, get there EARLY or else you'll be waiting for a while. The selection of clothing, jewelry, and shoes is pretty decent. All items are in really good condition and look like new. The prices however, are a bit steep. An average t-shirt/women's crop top can run between $9 and $12 dollars and women's jeans/shorts begin around $13. If you're coming in to buy a cute outfit for a weekend out, be ready to spent at least $25. If the prices don't scare you, dive into the racks and you'll stumble on some pretty great finds. read more

This is really one of those very trendy thrift stores that have nice clothes for higher prices but no real gems. If you wanna find some steals try some less trendy thrift stores. I gave it two stars because it's just downright snobbish. The employees are just rude. I felt like I stepped into a vintage boutique in Manhattan but the clothes are so not that. read more

It was my first time coming in trying to sell to this place. I brought in a huge bin of clothes, a lot good brands including Lululemon, Zara, Princess Polly, Abercrombie, Patagonia, Steve Madden and more. A lot of items were still new with tags, worn once, or still in good condition. I left the store without them buying not ONE thing, with the excuse being the condition which was confusing because a lot of it was new. Also seeing some of the clothes/shoes they were selling's condition, I was definitely shocked they didn't pick any of my items. Won't be coming back here to shop or sell. read more

The prices are fucking ridiculous and I can get cooler and better quality clothes at a Goodwill or any other shitty resale dump...get over yourselves read more

Sold my clothes here, just made appt super easy! Awesome experience and the employees are super nice

I had so much fun working with Chey. She is definitely has a lot experience in buying clothes. She's very friendly and professional. Don't be disappointed if they do not purchased all your clothing but it's the same with all BST. They purchased some of my clothes and jewelry. Keep in mind what is trending and the quality of items you bring. It's quality not quantity l. I'm very happy with the offer. I will definitely will be back to shop, sell & trade here again. Chey is definitely an asset to this company. Thank you for saving the earth, BUFFALO EXCHANGE read more

Ever since this place relocated its gone downhill. The prices are ridiculous. A basic t-shirt for $15-$20, I would pay less at a Ross or Target. There selection is terrible and too "trendy." I remember the old location was super rad. They had a nice variety of brands and super neat accessories. I'm only giving it two stars because they did give me a decent amount of $ when I sold them some clothes. They gave me about $40-$50 for a couple of shirts and two jackets. Ps. I saw an American Eagle shirt with its original tags that said it was on clearance for $12. Buffalo Exchange was selling it for $17 read more

I don't know what happened to the store, I feel like there was a shift in the air.. super low staff. Recently came back and the wait for the dressing room and the register were super long. The staff was trying their best to give customer service, felt bad. I tried to be friendly and asked the manager for her name so I can start a conversation, but she came off rude and short. I use to love this place, would like to see it go back to normal but idk.... read more

I am from Lafayette, LA and I have been to this Buffalo Exchange once this past December. The service was awesome - from the greeting we received, to the help we got as we went to try things on, to the checkout experience. Everyone was so helpful! I'm writing this review in order to thank Tessa, an associate who helped me over the phone today! She helped me with an inquiry I had about a blouse that I am having regrets not buying while on my trip there. She was wonderful and pleasant and helped me in any way she could to try to track it down. Thank you Tessa and team at Buffalo Exchange!! read more

This is a very cool "thrift" shop. I quote thrift because the prices are a bit steep. However, the clothes are very stylish and trendy so it is worth the price in my opinion. I recently found out customers can sell their gently wore clothes here so I will definitely be taking advantage of that in the future. Along with having nice clothes, the staff is also nice as well. Everyone seemed to be in good sprits inside the establishment. I look forward to coming back to find a good steal! read more

I love love love coming here to get rid of my clothes!!!!! And sometimes I find some hidden treasures here! read more

I love Buffalo. I love everything from the way they answer the phone to The way they genuinely care about how their customers look in their clothes and even when they compliment what I'm wearing it always feels genuine. I also get style tips or ideas from their staff and even if it's things I won't wear I love how they all have personal style. They don't always take what I'm selling but that's a good thing because that means the styles and store selections are on point with the seasons. I've found so many gems at B.E. It's my fav thrift store hands down and their customer service is excellent. read more

My first visit to the new location was to sell a few things. So this review is based on my selling experience. I have come here in the past with my daughter because she loves the vintage look. The prices to me aren't very competitive for a resell shop. But their inventory is much cleaner and hipper than some of the other spots around. It just seems most of the sizes are geared toward size 2. I haven't been a size two since Carter was President. Don't think they will buy your stuff if you bring it in. The guy in front of me had about a dozen boxes of well loved, expensive tennis shoes. They offered to buy maybe 3 pair and give him 30% of what they think they will sell them for. Some stuff, like classic sneakers may be better sold on eBay. I had a lot of the clothes I wore when my life was in the corporate world. Good labels like Jones of NY and Nordstrom. Classic tailored button down shirts and linen slacks. Good quality clothing that most any young professional would love to add to their closet at a fraction of what I spent. They bought none of that. The manager explained that it just wasn't what they were looking for at the time. She did buy some of my quirkier silk shirts and a couple blazers. I walked out with about $55. So I wasn't disappointed in my cash. I wasn't expecting retail value. It's fine to pass on inventory you don't think you might sell. But to not buy such classic and well made product lets me know what they are selling and none of it would work for a middle aged gal looking to find some decent business clothes. The new location has even worse parking than the old. read more

Hello, my name is non of your business. See that's how the employees were to me. They were very rude and talked shiz about my clothes while examining them with me right in front of them. The manager was also very rude, and she stepped on my toe and didn't apologize, and just laughed. They act like a little gossip club at school. One of the employees denied my pants and then i asked another one and he accepted them. it seems they can just pick what clothes they want and what clothes they dont based off of their personal interest. HOW ARE THESE PEOPLE BEING TRAINED!!! CORPORATE GET THEM OUT NOW. read more

They definitely have a reputation for being strict on what they will buy from you but I've always enjoyed coming here to both sell and shop. I always leave with a special piece! I do feel they've gotten a lot pricier over the years. There's almost always a bit of a wait when coming to sell though but thankfully the employees here are nice and let you shop around while you wait / hold your spot in line and will come find you when they're finished going through the items you've brought to sell! read more

Being a poor college kid who wanted new clothes, a friend of mine suggested we try this place out. Well, I wasn't thoroughly impressed. I brought in two bags of stuff and they only took maybe an 1/8th of it because it wasn't "in season." Well, I didn't complain too much since money is money. They gave me a cash option of store voucher and I chose the cash, which wasn't much. I couldn't even buy something from the store if I had wanted! Note: they are extremely picky. The staff really wasn't very friendly or enthusiastic, which automatically puts me in a bad state of mind. The lady who was looking through my stuff at one point suddenly stopped, looked at me and then asked "have you already been somewhere else trying to sell this before coming here?" I replied no, but she I could tell she didn't believe me. I left there wondering why I even gave them any of my stuff to begin with. In comparison to Plato's Closet, the layout of Buffalo isn't the greatest. At least at Plato's Closet they have it organized by color, size, item, etc. Makes it SOOO much easier. I would say Buffalo Exchange is an over-priced Goodwill. read more

Let me start this review out by telling y'all that I made $534.02 here yesterday! That's right. $534.02. Let me also tell y'all that I weigh 280 lbs. all my shirts were 1x-3x and pants size men's 38 - 44!!! So for 1) this place most definitely is NOT fatphobic. I read that in a past review of this place somewhere on the internet. 2) the staff here was SUPER friendly and nice and accommodating. I especially loved the buyer that took care of us, I think his name was Kevin - super cool dude and the manager, forgot her name, who was really sweet. 3) did I mention I left this place with a $534.02 check!?! People, let me remind y'all of something. This is a resale shop. Which means they are already selling stuff for lower than what it should cost. These people need to not only make a profit but pay their employees, buy supplies, pay rent and electricity among many other things. So how do you expect them to do all that? 25% of what they price an item for is what they pay the seller. And to me that's very very fair and realistic. So if you are trying to to make close to what you think something is worth, this is not the place for you to go. Perhaps you should post your item on eBay or Poshmark or Grailed or Depop and wait a year or two to sale it. Now for those of you that are looking to clear out your closet and/or just get rid of some old clothes and pass them down to someone else who would appreciate them for a few extra bucks in your pocket, then this is the place to go. Also, if you are trying to sale some stuff you'd find at goodwill or a garage sale or a flea market or if you're trying to sale some boring, preppy trendy crap, perhaps you should try setting up a garage sale or going to Crossroads. I've been going here since the 90s when they first opened up and I was going through my goth/raver phases and this resale shop in my opinion has always been a thrift store that specializes in more edgy pieces with an alternative twist. I'm talking stuff that's funky, loud, extreme, vintage, modern, goth, punk, streetwear, luxury, weird, exotic, one of a kind, hip, fun, strange, sexy and unusual. So don't take it personal if they don't buy your stuff or offer you much. They are obviously after a certain style of swag for a fraction of the cost and what they sale it for in order to make a profit. That's their whole business! Duh. So in my opinion, as a shopper and seller and almost an employee at one time even, I highly recommend this place. Been coming here in the 90s, 2000s, 2010s, AND 2020s! Coolest thrift store in Houston. Period. read more

i definitely don't mind buffalo exchange! there has been times where i found some great pieces for a steal. the part that gets to me is the constant stares. i understand retail. i've worked retail and am working retail at the moment so i know all about keeping an eye out but the fact that every time i looked up, an employee was staring me down, made me very uncomfortable. these certain employees made it so obvious and made it a point to keep coming up to where me and my friend were to "put clothing up".. do you HAVE to put it EXACTLY where i'm standing? especially throughout the store? just very weird energy lol but they can be cool i guess (stretching it) read more

I've taken my teens here a couple times and it is always hit or miss. Parking is never good. Had to go around the block 3 times to get a spot on the side of the building in the street. The staff is always super friendly and nice. They treat this suburban mom as well as the hip teens and I appreciate that. My son found several shirts. The selection doesn't seem huge but we always find something for him. My college age daughter doesn't have as much luck as a lot of the ladies clothes are smaller sizes and she's, not. It is always a fun trip to Buffaloes Exchange. We had a BBQ lunch next door at Demeris which is also good. read more

I've been to my fair share of Buffalo Exchanges in California and find them to be mostly pretentious and overpriced. This one was less so. I found some cute dresses that were from Urban Outfitters and Anthropologie. Sadly they didn't work out and I was disappointed to see that one actually had a stain on it. FYI-Buffalo Exchange DOES buy stuff with rips or stains-I've seen plenty of things on their racks in various locations that shouldn't have been bought in the first place. Well laid out, clean, spacious dressing rooms. It's one of the better Buffalo Exchanges I've been to. Also, nice workers-not too cool to acknowledge you like the ones in San Diego-what IS IT with California anyway? read more

I had a good laugh! I bought some items in to sell as I was cleaning out my closet. These were all purchased in Europe, mostly MaxMara and other nice brands. The shop attendant rejected them because she did not recognize the brands, and they were looking for "high rise jean shorts and tank tops". Also, looking around the second-hand selection, I do not believe a 15-20 dollars resale price is valid for a fast-fashion blouse from Zara or HnM, as most probably that was the original purchase price in the first place! I have no problems with reselling fast-fashion for environmenal reasons, but if you are doing that, something's gotta give! read more

Everyone here is so inviting and friendly! I always leave so happy with everything I bought just from the energy of the store itself

Very busy, popular thrift store. Located in Montrose. Selection here is great. Plenty of clothes, purses, jackets, lots of shoes, scarves, etc. So many different name brands! I love it The clothes here are more geared towards a younger audience. The staff is helpful. DOWNSIDES: Beware that the prices are a bit more expensive than most thrift stores. Very pricey. Wish they had more plus size clothes. They have dressing rooms but no bathroom. read more

See all

I brought brand-name clothing to this location that was accepted at other resale shops close by. I would not even waste your time trying to sell to these people because they rarely buy any of your clothes. They have a decent selection of shoes for men but I really haven't seen anything else that I am too impressed with. Based on my last visit The manager has an attitude and isn't very friendly. The staff seems to be in there own world and talk more to eachother than the customers read more

I love coming here! Staff is always super helpful,friendly and knowledgeable. They have great finds for super low prices. Love this place!!!

There's a lot of negative reviews of this place so I wanted to give my two cents. I went here to sell some clothing and had a great experience. As soon as I arrived, a buyer, Janelle, greeted me and began going through my clothing. She was very polite and kind, as were the several other employees I encountered while browsing the store. I had two baskets full of clothing, and they were sorted through in about 15 minutes. About seven items were chosen. The buyer priced them individually in front of me and told me how much I would earn for each item. I was offered $45 store credit or $30 cash. I got a pair of earrings using the store credit and cashed out the rest. True to their word, the items taken were a combination of modern name-brand items more vintage/quirky no-name items. The items Janelle did not buy were folded and placed neatly back in my baskets. While browsing I did notice that the prices were higher than Buffalo Exchange's prices have been in the past. However, everything was very on-trend and high quality. Buffalo Exchange is becoming a more curated secondhand experience. If you are a long time shopper there you may be a little surprised by the changes, but it's not a bad thing. If you're looking into getting into secondhand sustainable shopping but dislike the idea of traditional thrifting, this is the store for you. A lot of people in the reviews are upset because their clothes were not bought... this store takes trendy clothing and if they don't buy yours, it is not an insult to your fashion taste. Try taking it to Plato's Closet, where they buy name-brand items. If you don't have luck there, donate it and call it a day. read more

Very much overpriced. Mostly SheIn and other fast fashion, for the retail price or MORE. Ridiculous

They expanded! They knocked down the wall to the vacant store next door and it's beautiful. There's wayyyyy more space to move around and actually look at what they have to offer. I've sold a few times recently and I was pleasantly surprised that I found some 1 of 1 pieces! As usual the staff was friendly and helpful read more

Don't even waste your time! I came in with the intention of selling my clothes and a couple of accessories. Now, let me preface my review by saying I'm no fashionista, but I take pride in the clothes I wear and take great care of them. I understand that they buy clothes that are in style and for the season, so I brought two large bags of winter clothes to sell since it's November. The Asian girl with the clear vanity glasses was so rude. She took a long time to look through everything. I had Calvin Klein, Louis Vuitton, Ralph Lauren, and many other great brands. I had two Louis Vuitton wallets, in great condition with the original receipts, dust bags, boxes, etc. Even the Asian girl helping me said they were in great condition. She said that she couldn't take them because they will not sell. Really girl? Really? As I'm literally staring at a wall of designer items. I just don't understand their reasoning in purchasing items when I'm looking at worn Target clothes on the racks. I just personally felt they the employees are lazy or they have a maximum amount they can pay out per day, so once they hit that limit, they don't accept anything even if they waste your time combing through your things. I ended up bringing all of my things to Plato's Closet down the street. THEY BOUGHT EVERYTHING. It was a much better experience. Even if you can't sell your things, I would rather donate to Goodwill to help people in need than to deal with the fake ass employees at Buffalo Exchange. read more

Decided to check out this store for the first time. I've gone to Plato's closet many times. I liked the store layout. It was neat, everything was hung, there was staff around to assist you, and around the fitting rooms. None of that having to ask someone to open a fitting room. They organized sections based on what they were such as tees, pants, jeans, shoes, sweaters, blouses, and dresses. I liked that more than having to dig through cluttered racks of clothing at platos. I do have to say I think the selection of clothes in general was less than platos, but you don't have to sift through so many basics and etc. Oh, that's another thing. They don't really stock basics. The store was roomy so you weren't constantly bumping into other people. I went around 4 pm today and there were about 20 other customers as well. Prices were okay...more towards the higher end, but I liked their selection. It wasn't just american eagle, a bunch of forever 21, target or Aeropostale stuff. I saw free people, boutique brands, banana republic, urban outfitters, etc. As for shoes, I saw quite a few doc martens as well. They were priced around $70 give or take. Another thing I liked was how they weren't using plastic bags and instead gave tokens for customers to pick one of the charities for the store to donate the cost of the bag towards. I first saw this implemented in uptown cheapskate in San Antonio, and was happy this store was doing it too. Parking was awful... It was limited, there's construction on the main streets nearby, and you literally have to park on gravel if the few spots are taken. There was a sign that said if you parked past a certain point, your car be towed. That made me a bit nervous, and it'd be great if the store could do something about that. I'll definitely come back in the future. read more

I typically come here to sell some items that I no longer wear and am always greeted with such caring, sweet customer service. The new sign up process to come sell is to basically launder your clothing and leave it untouched for 24 hours and you can call/schedule the appt to come sell on the website. It's a really seamless process tbh. I have gotten between $10-$60 for a sale. I will def be coming back! read more

I brought in 4 bags of clothing all good name brands like banana republic, loft, Columbia, the north face, and plenty more and they only accepted one skirt for $2 ?? I browsed around to see what kind of clothing they had and it was all mainly just washed up clothes. Please. Do a better job at selecting clothing . read more

Not sure what the deal is with the employees here. All of them seem to have a personal problem with me and my friends. I brought a small bin of clothes in nearly like new condition (I've lost 30 pounds so they don't fit) and were treated poorly. None of my items were bought which were almost ALL high end designer brands [Calvin Klein, Vince Camuto, Tom Ford, Ralph Lauren (which was new with tags still on it!), etc.] but then they have Target's Mossimo on their racks... really? Smdh. Suggestion to the owner/manager: hire people who don't appear to hate their lives/exhibit bitter behavior and maybe you'll see a higher influx of better items and happier clients! read more

I'd always kept my distance from Buffalo Exchange because I'm rather rough and tumble when it comes to my thrift shopping experiences. Buffalo Exchange might be a little too ~classy~ for me. Juuust kidding, well, a little bit. So as expected, it really depends on WHEN you visit - you'll either find some really great items and deals, or you just won't. This location seems to be fairly discriminatory about what to accept for the most part, but still sometimes you're thinking, "Um, why sweet baby Jesus why, are they selling this? And for this much? Mmm, I don't think so!" There are some designer pieces here and there - decently discounted (not crazy WHOAH MOMMA cheap), some older "vintage" items, and more hip stuff for you stylish hipsters and non-hipsters. A good amount of never worn before dresses - leftovers from boutiques I suppose? The staff is fairly friendly, sometimes they're more attentive than others. They do represent the store well as they all seem to wear the inventory, so thumbs up for that? I've never tried to unload my old clothing here, but my friends have and they're pretty selective (as aforementioned) - so be forewarned of that. I have some pretty cute stuff from this place, but nothing super duper exciting. Overall, a pretty okay place. If I'm in the area, I do stop by every now and then. But it's not the best ever. read more

Buffalo Exchange is one of those stores that I have to be "in the mood' to go. Even then, it depends on the selection they have that day and the amount of people there whether my buffalo shopping experience will be successful or not. That being said, I either come out with a ton of awesome finds or with absolutely nothing. The staff has been pretty nice to me, always asking if they can hold my stuff while I shop. In any case, I check it out every once in a while in case I find something I really really like. read more

Buffalo Exchange - Men's Clothing Near Me - Houston, Texas