My fiance and I went and sat on the patio-truly an unmatched spot in Keyport-the view of the waterfront, the location's access to the waterfront/pier and the street access for parking/shopping! I have some food allergies and they were more then accomadating to make it work for the dish I wanted. We went on a slower day so we had no wait for seating or the food. Our waitress was training but both girls were great!! read more

See all

Service was terrible Slow Over priced The tables they put up are on top of each other. Waitress we had was forgetful Drinks were late Save your money go elsewhere I read more

First time visiting and last time !! Doesn't even rate 1, but that's as low as I can go. HORRIBLE !!! An hour and a half to get our entree ?! Inexcusable, when we did receive our food it was cold. The fried seafood platter was so dry. It's a shame when the best thing on my plate was the thimble of Coleslaw. And don't tell me our food is going to come out shortly 2X when it takes another 30 minutes to be served. If something happened, tell me (misplaced ticket,etc.) don't BS me. Bay view ? HA !! A take-out McDonald's Filet-O-Fish on the bench of the waterfront park would've been a more enjoyable dining experience than eating in this train wreck. read more

You're going to think this is funny. We had our favorite drink (Burlew's Peach Tea). Ordered sandwiches for dinner (chicken salad and chicken parm) which were delicious! Here is the funny part, I asked for pepper and actually got a pepper grinder and not fast food salt and pepper packets! I was so excited! read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Our favorite drink Burlew's Peach Tea and actual salt and pepper grinders! I am so happy! - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Extremely disappointed with our experience at Burlew's. A group of 12 of us came for dinner and spent well over $1,000 on food and drinks. After dinner, we went to the bar for a drink and were shocked by how we were treated. Tim the bartender told us to "turn it down a notch" even though we were not being loud or causing any issues. Then after only a few half-glasses of wine, we were cut off for no reason. I'm 60 years old, not some kid out causing trouble, and I found the whole situation appalling and embarrassing. After spending that kind of money, we expected basic respect and professionalism. We left angry and disappointed and will never return. Tim should not be behind the bar treating customers this way. read more

Came here because I was craving fish tacos. I had the blackened fish tacos which were so incredibly salty and tough. The fries were also tough and chewy. Really not a good dinner at all. I was so disappointed. Service was friendly but waitress never came back to refill drinks or check on us. It's a very busy place but I would not recommend the fish tacos. read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Blacked fish tacos - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Enjoying some cold Coronas at Burlews again. This is a spot I stop at every now and then since I live the waterfront location. The service is friendly and courteous and they serve some good raw bar items like little neck clams and oysters which I enjoyed. I also had some fried clams which were quite delightful. Very well made and served with some good tarter and cocktail sauce. The mood is great with people enjoying the music and the food coming from the DJ playing some good music on the waterfront. read more

See all

We love it here. We came Sunday food is great, service is good too. I do have a complaint, my husband's pork cop came out uncooked, ok it happens, they corrected it, but I ate alone than my husband ate. I am a manager for a restaurant so I know clearly this happens unfortunately. But not even a drink off the bill. Sorry but if you want customers back you should really do the right thing. As a manager if that happens at my restaurant I definitely do the right thing for a customer. Will back, just hope we get to eat our meals together lol read more

We are new to the area and this is our second time trying out Burlews. Both times we came middle of the day, post lunch crowd and pre-dinner crowd and had to wait 40 mins to be seated. Which is sort of crazy! Given that tables were visibly available. Plus they don't take reservations and had plenty of servers. Just doesn't make sense! View was awesome, but food unfortunately just isn't worth it and needs a lot of love. Tried the famous nachos, wings, wedge salad one visit. And then tried the calamari, fish tacos and soup of the day on another. 2/10 on all counts. Fish was fresh but dishes just lacked flavor. The other appetizers were just not very impressive (feta on a wedge salad is bizarre). Additionally, some items we ordered came out incorrectly (wings - ordered 2 types/6 buffalo and 6 garlic Parmesan and got 12 buffalo). Service was okay, friendly. Lots of local kids. Unfortunately this will not be on our rotation as a local. Wouldn't recommend to visitors or a friend. read more

Popped in for lunch after not being here in years. It was super nice out, but hot, so we opted to sit inside by the window, but they have a gorgeous patio. My friend and I split the mozzarella sticks appetizer, which was great! For meals, she got the Old Glory sandwich and I opted for the Blackened Fish Tacos, which were well seasoned, but a tad too salty (and I normally love salt). She had a white wine and I started with a frozen margarita that was very weak, tasted like fruit juice and followed up with an Old Fashioned that was MUCH better. Overall, the experience was good, but would have been better if the server had been a tad more attentive. read more

See all

No frills place. Service is solid and fast. Stick with the staples when ordering and you won't be disappointed.

I was in the mood for seafood risotto. I called Burlew and Lindsay stayed Chef will make it fresh. Of course I went. Can't say no to fresh. First time here, definitely a pleasant surprise. As I found it to be different in a good way. I saw a sign for plenty of parking in the back. But I didn't know how to get to the back, I asked a nice guy outside the place. He stated I had to drive around the block. So I did and the packing wasn't behind the restaurant but adjacent to the walkway. I went back to the street parking on the Main Street. Walked in the glass door and seen a few businesses as I walk down the stairs towards my destination. I was Amazed. Reached Burlew and their staff all greeted me. Loved it!! I was just in Awe! Very nice decor and the view was stunning!! I announced I was the seafood risotto person. Risotto was good had the right amount of seafood. I prefer a creamier risotto. Pretty good for a requested dishes. Kudos to the Chef Lindsay was a great host. She kept me company. I had a great time. Relaxed enough to get that traffic back north. I would definitely come back. read more

See all

Wonderful location with great food and very knowledgeable staff. I always ask for suggestions, and they are consistently excellent.

Normally I'd give them a 5. Been going to Burlews for over five years never had a problem. 12 of us went for dinner spent over $1000.00. Four of us decided to go for a after dinner drink. Mind you we were all over 60. Sat at the bar. Bartender name is Tim. After five minutes he came over and told us to TURN IT DOWN A NOTCH. I was dumbfounded. As we were just laughing. The people next to us even said wtf is he talking about? Then my girlfriend asks for another glass of wine. Which would have been her 4 one. But if you want to get technical it really would have been two since they only fill a wine glass half way. He told her she was cut off. WTF? She wasn't drunk, wasn't driving, wasn't loud. We all got up and left. Everyone at the bar was like Wtf is he doing. Tim the bartender is around 21ish. No personal city to be behind a bar. I bartender for 15 years and NEVER experienced anything like this. I know if Candice was working none of this would have happened. Im calling the manager today. Needless to say ill only go back when Candice is on. And the other 12 will never go back. read more

Both the hostess and waitress were exceptionally polite and engaging. The iced tea wasn't great. The rum bucket was good. Chips accompanying the chili were warm & delicious. The chili was appetizing, made with both beef & beans. Warning:FYI Wedge salad came with olives. I enjoyed the salad enough to order it again. The Caesar salad was perfect; shaved cheese and homemade Caesar dressing. The potato salad was tasty. The lasagna would have been good if the meat had been seasoned. The seafood in the Mermaid's Delight was outstanding: flounder, shrimp, scallops & lobster. Same with the Fried Seafood Combo. The chocolate cake was incredible and the ice cream complemented it perfectly. I've dined in and outdoors. On a clear enough day you can see the New York skyline across Raritan Bay. Music was as playing but at a level which allows you to have a conversation. Apparently in the summer months, if the small private lot is full, you can be shuttled to & from a nearby larger lot. read more

See all

Happy Sunday Adventurers! I dropped in here for a late dinner and drinks Friday night with a guy friend of mine. I remember always seeing this place with live bands during the warmer months but this was the first time I ever got to stop by and check out. We sat at the bar upstairs, which I imagined with the front deck overlooking the waterfront would be beautiful. Catching a sunset and breeze, enjoying a cocktail or app. Parking wasn't too bad, we had to park in the back in a small lot since there wasn't any street parking. We ordered the firecracker calamari and shrimp, with sauce on the side. I prefer having crunchy fried items than covered in a sauce. It's a huge portion for one person so definitely plan accordingly. The sauce had a kick but it was really tasty so I had no issue. My friend ordered the shrimp on crostini in this sweet & spicy sauce. You can choose between shrimp or scallops over the garlic crostini whichever you prefer. we also got the lobster bisque--pretty decent but once you try Maine lobster bisque, jersey is no comparison. I'd like to come back here during the summer to see how it is with live music and back patiol. read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Shrimp on crostini | #intenselypassionatephotography - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

Great ambiance. Car show and live music outside. Wait for about 30 minutes. Got seated promptly though. Waitress very attentive and nice. Shea I believe. Drinks and food were good. We'll return again! read more

See all

This was my first time dinning at Burlew's. What i loved was the views, the restaurants is along the coastline so the ocean view is amazing. I chose the broiled seafood platter as my meal with a side of sweet potatoes fries and mixed vegetables with (grilled zucchini, broccoli, carrots) the food was and fresh i enjoyed it. Im giving this place a 3 star only because the customer service could of been a bit better. But i enjoyed my meal. read more

This is our go to place for appetizers drinks, chicken sandwiches, etc. Staff is always friendly. There is never much of a wait. Stunning views of the Raritan.. Nice crowd. Definitely get swordfish bites there amazing my partner loves their chicken sandwich.. Especially fun in the summer months when you could sit outside and enjoy life music from downstairs. Staff is always extremely friendly and helpful. read more

Great spot great food and service. Pump up your side salads and your blue cheese dressing please! But otherwise it's really a spot to hit up. Excellent seafood cooked perfectly. read more

My cousin and I went for lunch. Hostess was friendly and made sure we were comfortable with our seating. We both ordered the lobster roll. It was very tasty, not too much mayonnaise and quite plentiful. Pieces of lobster were big and you needed a knife to cut some of the pieces. Fries and homemade chips were fresh and well seasoned with homemade coleslaw. Service was excellent! Love the location overlooking the water. Since Covid prices have gone up dramatically. But all was good read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

Years ago I used to go in Burlew's when it was on route 35 in Aberdeen but I haven't been in this Keyport location. I was told it's been here 17 years. Before YELP. The view is gorgeous overlooking Keyport Harbor and Matawan Creek. The decor inside is nautical(obviously). Lobster and a Yellowfin tuna platter were excellent, very tasty with extra cilantro. Emily did a decent job serving. read more

See all

Ambiance was festive. Service was excellent. Drinks and dinner salad were good. Food was awful considering how expensive it is. Shrimp cocktail tough and rubbery for $15.99 plus tax plus tip. Fried flounder was absolutely horrible. Flounder is a tender fish. Theirs was so tough it needed to be cut with a knife. Tasted like cardboard. That was not fresh flounder. We will never return. The owners should be ashamed. read more

Well, another visit because of their amazing food brilliant view; wanna just come and relax and enjoy the food this is the place to get away from the city. Services Just what we need read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Seafood OMG - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Oh, the food is delicious. The lobster bisque, filet of flounder, the salads are wonderful also. Please don't let me forget the mojitos with Bacardi, baby!! Actually, I think I am on my way there now. read more

Food and service was amazing as usual. My mom and I were seated at a middle level, where the water view can be seen. This place has multiple levels so the layout is different. Tried Burlew's for the first time for a friend's party and would keep coming back. read more

See all

Burger and fries were outstanding as was the service and the view. Definitely will be back.

I agree with all the other people service is awful and the prices on the menu are not what you pay check your bill they up charge even if you use cash they just up the menu price. Very deceitful. I question the waitress and told her about it and they just add it to each item on your bill as if your stupid. read more

The food and view were wonderful! Such a professional and attentive staff. We will be back soon!

The worst place ever! Just for being latino they throw me out and they make me feel like I was not good enough! I was seating at the table for 20 minutes waiting for the waitress and finally when someone came was just to tell me that I had to leave the table because they had a waiting list ! I asked to speak with the manager and she was just as rude as everybody else . Please don't come to this restaurant! read more

We had a great time last night, food and service were great and Virginia was terrific. Loved the hostess upstairs too. First time there and will be back. read more

See all

Food is excellent however service not so much. Staff is not friendly at all and seems as if you are bothering them when you are in need of things. This could definitely be a top place if they just hired some better trained staff. There's no parking lot only public parking which was kinda hard to find especially on weekend nights. Atmosphere inside is nice and waterfront view is very nice. read more

A very delicious seafood restaurant. I am allergic to seafood so I had no seafood items, but the rest of my party had seafood. They said the mermaids delight was delicious. The lobster looked heavenly. To drink I had the Bounty Rum Bucket, which I enjoyed. I had a wedge salad which was very tasty. Be forewarned there are olives in the salad, which is not on the menu. I also tried the lasagna. Overall it was good. The meat wasn't seasoned enough but I would give the dish a 6/10. For dessert I tried the chocolate cake which came with both chocolate and vanilla ice cream. It was divine. The vanilla ice cream cream was AMAZING. The music was all country Christmas as it's December but overall it was tolerable. Service was great, our waitress was wonderful. I will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Place is great! Great and delicious food! Great service and overlooking the water. We thoroughly enjoyed this spot and will def come back. We got the seafood platter and tuna bites!!! read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

A very low level of service. Arrogant staff. Mr. "This is my restaurant" is a rude, ignorant person. I wouldn't eat there if it was free. Forget this place, you get what you pay for. Go upscale and avoid the trash. read more

Over priced for so so food... Broiled lobster and a broiled seafood combo platter two beers two Prosecco's $220 with a tip. You got to be kidding me. I'm boycotting this place. read more

First real meal of the night and found this place located right next to the shore. Sat on the second floor while I side. You do have other options such as sitting outside but it was a little bit on the hotter side that day. We wanted to sit and relax. Enjoyed our dinner here, our server was pretty friendly and the food came out pretty quick. The inside reminds me of an old house and we are sitting inside. The tables are pretty close together so you might actually be touching the next group of people. Ordered just a steak and it came with a baked potato and corn. Overall the dinner was pretty small but it was still alright. I kind of wish they had other options besides corn. read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Menu - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

Just okay. Victoria, our server was great. 2nd deck has a nice view but the food, meh. My food arrived long after my fellow diners. How long? They were finished eating. Nothing comped. We won't be back. read more

Don't write reviews often. But...The hostess there are liars. We did them the service of calling ahead because we had a party of 12. They said to come right in it would be 20 minutes or less. Within five minutes... we were there. Unfortunately they had "given our table away and we would now have to wait an hour." I will never know how the food is there because I will never give them a dime by of my money. read more

All these open seats and people coming to try and have a drink , we get told sorry no drinks are allowed down in the open seats and there is no room at main bar. The phone ringing off the hook several others came in to eat and we're told sorry no! They called and were told no reservations needed.This is sad to see this place will not survive and Chains will be in soon. What the heck!! read more

Burlew's Seafood and Steak - Empty bar and won't even serve a beverage on a holiday weekend ! Smh that's why local places can't survive! - Seafood Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey