We recently called in a order & they gave us the wrong bag. It really depends on how busy they are as to how your service will be

Food and service are fantastic! Nice setting in a re-emerging downtown area. Can't go wrong with the top shelf margaritas!

Great atmosphere upon entering the building . Food was always warm appetizing and correctly prepared . A favorite when I want some Mexican ! read more

Always consistent, great food and friendly service. I have tried a few differ things but always go back to Arroz con Pollo... soo good! I usually go 2x a month. And a huge plus they are close to me! read more

Minimal seating, mediocre food, & rude management that is more interested in shuffling you out the door than the quality of your experience. Go anywhere else. read more

This was the first time my husband and I tried this place and we will definitely be back!!! I ordered the fajitas with shrimp, chicken, & steak...the meat was so tender and the shrimp was cooked beautifully!! I also ordered a Top Shelf margaritas on the rocks with salt on my rim!! That was hands down the best margarita I have ever had!! My hubs ordered the Mexican pizza and it was so full of meats and veggies, even he couldn't finish it. I wasn't crazy about their chips, they were on the heavy side, not light & crispy like I like them. But the salsa served with the chips was a homerun!! read more

Great place to eat! Great food great everything mmmmmmmmmmmmm good I'm might come here everyday!

My favorite Mexican restaurant in Anderson. The owners and employees are very caring and take good care of you. The drinks are amazing and well worth the money! Visit today! read more

The staff is always so great! They always ask when someone in our family is not present. The food well it's the best Mexican food around!

Best salsa and margaritas in Anderson!!! Very friendly staff. I might eat here too often lol

I don't live in Anderson. Came here for lunch while working in town. Had the tostado lunch special. It was really good and so were the chips and salsa. Quick service. Would recommend. read more

Burro Loco - Mexican Near Me - Anderson, Indiana

The food and help are awesome! The only thing I would like is a bar that only adults can sit in. read more

Food is honestly subpar and the waiters were not friendly so yeah half a star is lucky at best and also the chips were stale and cheese had formed a skin read more

Best Mexican in the area. We split the combination fajitas and take plenty home. They add chorizo that makes them extra flavorful. Excellent management and service. read more

This is the best authentic Mexican in the city! You can go to the handful of other Mexican restaurants, and you will not receive the same quality of service, freshness of food, and awesome hospitality that you will at this locally owned gem! They make very generous margaritas as well, which is hard to beat! read more

Staff terrific, food exceptional. Close to my office is a bonus. A staple for a quick, satisfying, lunch

"If the kitchen is full of white guys, we're walking," I told him as we went in. We've seen several restaurants come and go in this building since we moved to Anderson a few years ago, but this one stands out for being anything other than Generic Midwest "Home Cookin'." I realized that the new exterior blue-and-orange colour scheme was significant when I crested the 8th Street Bridge one morning to see the new sign shining through the pre-dawn dimness. The kitchen was not in fact full of white guys. The building has been sold outright, and the new owners have obviously put a lot of work and money into the renovation. The space has been opened up to provide a lot more seating room. We were provided the requisite nachos and salsa upon being seated. The chips were warm, and the salsa was light, fresh, and full of cilantro. We split a supreme plate; a taco, a chile relleno, a burrito, a tamale, and one more thing I can't remember the name of. The burrito, tamale, and chile all shared a plate, and were too heavily doused in a salty tomato-based sauce. All of the items were beef; I'd like to come back and try something with chicken or shrimp before drawing a final conclusion. Despite the plate being a lot of food for the two of us, we tried the fried ice cream as well. It was novel, but the ice cream's texture was more icy than creamy, suggesting a lower fat content due to poor quality. They serve alcohol, which will improve their chances of lasting more than six months in a town that has a very high turnover for independent restaurants. read more

I rarely give five stars to a Mexican restaurant. However, I couldn't come up with a reason to give Burro Loco four stars. You start with fresh chips and salsa. I like hot fresh chips and that is what was brought out to me. The star was the Salsa. It had flavor and was spiced correctly. It was a bit on the chunky side but that is how I personally like it. The entrée was a shrimp dish cooked in a green tomatillo sauce. The sides were the typical beans and rice. The shrimp was cooked perfectly. The green tomatillo sauce was outstanding. The sauce has a kick and was spicy, but I really enjoy hot and spicy and this met my expectations. I though the beans and rice were prepared correctly and they tasted better than the standard beans and rice at most Mexican places. I was greeted quickly and was seated immediately. Chips and salsa was there within a minute. Overall the service was excellent. The place is clean and you can tell the owners and workers take pride in providing you an outstanding experience. I stop here before going to Mounds state park. If I am ever back in Anderson, I will definitely be back. If you are bored of chain restaurants and think for yourself and are not manipulated by millions of dollars in TV commercials to make yourself believe you have to eat average to below average overpriced food at some chain restaurant, I am one of you. Let's all keep supporting the true food scene in Indiana. read more

Burro Loco - Mexican Near Me - Anderson, Indiana

This was my first time trying this restaurant and it was amazing!! I had the taco salad fajita with chicken and loved every bite! It was even enough food to last for two meals! We were also advised to ask for the "special hot sauce" because we love spicy food! It was very good! The spiciness creeps up on you and then just kind of stays in your mouth for a while! If you like spicy food, give it a try! About a month later: My family and I decided to come back for some delicious Mexican food for Father's Day! This time I tried the Mexican Cheesesteak, which is also magnificent! I ate ALL of it! And I never do that! read more

See all

Food was tasteful but lukewarm. Service was non-existent. This was our second time here; same experience as last time.

10/10 on their margaritas, the peach one is probably my favorite! Food is always fresh and delicious! Service is great, and they are always keeping up with cleanliness read more

First time here. 7/31/2021. Ordered the Paella. Has shrimp, scallops, beef and chicken with green peppers and onions. Was a VERY large portion enough for 2 plus meals for me. Service was good and food came really fast. The beef and chicken was dry and chewy, the rice was gummy and the green peppers needed to be cooked more but still was good. read more

Burro Loco - Paella - Mexican Near Me - Anderson, Indiana

My favorite place to eat the food is good the atmosphere is very relaxed. It's an all round great experience

Visited here many times since my Bachelorette party. The food here is probably my favorite of any Mexican food locations within Anderson. Service has always been friendly and efficient. If you want good food and not worry about quality of it...visit this place. I stopped going to a different spot after seeing some nasty things and listening to cursing in Spanish. Choose Burro Loco!!! read more

Best Mexican restaurant in Anderson. The fish tacos are awesome. My kids LOVE the Arroz Con Pollo. Margaritas are the bomb. Staff is friendly and efficient. read more

See all

Just regular Mexican don't get a taco salad it it like soup in a shell! Yuck but their fajitas are good!

Great chips and salsa. Often the chips are still warm when they arrive at your table. Good food at a reasonable price .

We love Mexican food, here they make every meal unique! Great atmosphere and service!

Love this place. What a great destination. A wonderful Mexican experience. You should try the veggie burrito.

Both times I've come here Ive wished I'd just gone to McDonald's. Underwhelming flavor... entrees just come as a pile on a plate. It's clean, service is fine. I just want more! More food, more freshness, bigger burritos, more heat, more intensity, more seasoning... feel me? read more

Best Mexican in town! Great service and super good food. Different then the other Mexican restaurants in town

Oh, Burro Loco, a restaurant I hold dear to my heart. Without question, the best Mexican cuisine in Anderson. If you want to really maximize your dining experience, order the queso, fajitas, or arroz con pollo. These are my main dishes and they have never done me wrong. read more

Amazing food have been many times never had a bad time recommend this place 10000 per. Would die to eat here once and would rather have my fingers chopped of then never eat here again read more

Ordered regular tacos and arroz con pollo. Service was great. Fast and friendly. Salsa and chips were good. However the food lacked flavor compared to other authentic places I've been. read more

Ordered take-out on a Thursday night. The place was nearly full for a weeknight and was loud with high energy. I ordered a cheese quesadilla and sides of pico de gallo and guac. I am a guac aficionado (aka, I only trust myself, Chipotle, and Qdoba to make quality guac), so I am always worried when ordering guac at restaurants. The guac taste pretty good, but I, personally, didn't care for the smooth consistency - prefer it chunkier. I wouldn't order the pico di gallo again, but I mixed it in with the salsa that was complimentary, and it made the salsa even better. The reason I am writing my review: The manager (I'm assuming) brought me my take-out order and told me that he gave me 2 quesadillas, because one of them was a little too crispy and he wanted to make sure it was perfect. Don't think it had anything to do with the cute running outfit I was wearing - kidding. That's good customer service. And the quesadillas were great! read more

Outstanding restaurant in downtown Anderson providing great food and wonderful service. The manager and his team go above and beyond to make sure their customers have an outstanding visit. Can't say enough good things about this place! read more

If you know Anderson, IN you know that this is one of 2000 Mexican restaurants in town. Fortunately for me (and you) I've been to all 2000. Only thing that distinguishes these places are their salsas. So, no more judging Mexican restaurants based on food; base it on the salsa. As a result... this place is great. It's quiet, never too busy and chances are you'll see some familiar faces. read more

We ate dinner here last night (Sept. 12 2019) The service was great and the food was awesome. I had the Matzalan fajita. I brought half of it home for lunch. Will return soon. read more

My first tine to this restaurant and the food was mediocre and the service was terrible. We asked for Sour Cream to go with the Quesadillas and another drink and the waiter never returned to our table. read more

The hottest day at 110° heat index and we greeted our move to our new home in Anderson. Seeking some authentic food like I make. Oh man, oh man! For my first meal I was not dissatisfied. The waiter obliged our table by bringing us a pitcher of water, too. The beans and rice are top notch, you ask for spicy, and that is exactly what you get! Thank you! read more