I accidentally came to this location thinking it was the one for my Yelp experience. The lady working here was so friendly that I decided to purchase something since I was here. She told me about the cookies and drinks they have. The drinks sounded interesting so I thought I'd try one out. I asked the worker for her recommendation and she told me her favorite drink was the Full Blitz. The base was sprite mixed with some fruity flavors. It sounded good, so I purchased that. It didn't take her long to make it, and the color of the drink was pretty. I was happy with the selection because it was delicious, I thanked the worker for her recommendation. They offer different sizes, I went with the smallest which was a 16oz and it cost a little under $4. I noticed the inside isn't too big, and it looked more like you grab and go here. I didn't see any inside seating for dining in, although outside had a table so could be an option for when the weather is nice. Parking for this location is street parking, they have spots right out front, and it is free. They change cookie flavors every Friday morning. read more

See all

I ordered from the app and read the descriptions and followed through. The app is very easy to use and you can set the time that you want to pick it up for. The service when I got to the shop was awesome. My order was ready to go. However, this is where things changed. I ordered the lemon poppyseed. Now, if I was just ordering a poppyseed cookie, this would've been nine out of 10 there was crispness to the edges, soft middle, but not too soft and also not too sweet's a really solid cookie. However, since I went into it thinking this was gonna be lemon including lemon icing drizzle on the top I did not smell lemon when I first smelled the cookie and I did not taste any lemon in the cookie itself so I have to say that my review went from 9 to 5 out of 10 because I love lemon flavor and almost never does anyone have enough lemon flavor. in this case there wasn't any. Highly disappointed crave. Onto the next cookie, I ordered the mango sticky rice because the ingredients looked awesome and the concept sounded good There are big chunks of mango in every bite. I believe these are dried mango pieces. I think fresh mango would've tasted better, but probably would've led to a much more wet cookie. This cookie was pretty dense. It was not as soft as the first cookie however, it was also not very sweet which was good. I would probably order this again. read more

See all

Pleasantly surprised by this cookie place! Their chocolate chip cookies are so soft and chewy in the middle, but crispy on the outside - perfect! I can't wait to try their other flavors as I understand they rotate. They also have dirty sodas with a lot of options. Much better than Crumbl and the best cookies I have had in Fishers so far! read more

Crave - Chocolate chip - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Sweeeet This Cookie purveyor begs for return visits. You might say Crave creates a crave for Crave Cookies. Warm, flaky and delicious are these decadent confections. WARNING: These can be habit forming. Staff are very knowledgeable about their creations as well as being pleasant and efficient. read more

These cookies. These cookies. These cookies. Addictive! Since discovering Crave I have tried more cookies than care to admit. They release new cookies every Friday (usually when I go!) These are big cookies... huge! And probably the best I've had Enjoy the pictures--and go get some cookies. Oh- there's a Groupon now. And they're open til 10 (and midnight on the weekend)! read more

See all

Crave is my new go-to for cookies! The service was amazing--friendly and super fast. Each cookie was unique, baked to perfection, and clearly made with love. I also loved the location--right in the heart of Fishers, which makes it super convenient. Can't wait to go back for more! read more

Crave - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I had stopped at this cookie store because I had never tried it before and it was on the TooGoodToGo app. This store they change their cookie line up each week which is really nice. The cookies were fresh and very delicious. The store was nice and clean. There is not any seating area inside the store. Prices are very reasonable. If you are looking for some good cookies I say give this place try. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

I was over Crumble cause the texture of the cookies were too cake like. The cookies here are sooouch better in comparison. The outside is crisp while the inside is soft. Cookies are large and they've got weekly rotating flavors plus some yummy standards. These cookies are good even after a few days! read more

See all

Crave has an interesting menu, with rotating cookie flavors changing each week. We tried 4 different cookies, and they were okay. They are warm, and have reheating instructions. The cookies were okay, and a bit dry and on the crunchier side. They also sell dirty sodas, which I loved! They have premade menus for this, and also let you customize the drinks. read more

Crave - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Saw this place when I went to Handles and went back a few weeks later to try it. They have a cookie of the day and then their standard cookies so be sure to check out what the cookie of the day is. They will also allow you to sample which is very helpful. The cookies are big and about $5 each. We made the mistake of getting two, if you just want a little something I suggest getting one and splitting it as they are very rich in flavor and sweetness. They also are thicker cookies. If you are like me, I like smaller thinner cookies but if you are unlike me and want more depth then this is your place. The staff that works there are very friendly and happy to walk though which cookie to try. It's very clean and there is parking along the street we did not have trouble finding a spot, even with Handles near by. read more

See all

Tried this place on a whim and so glad that we did. Think Mom and Pop Crumbl. Tasted more homemade (big plus) rather than big store manufactured. Both cookies were amazing. Chocolate chip was moist, soft and buttery. Husband loved it. Banana cream pie was heaven!!! I've had crumbls and this was even better. Just wish there were more locations. The lady who took our order was so friendly and talkative. It really felt more organic in here. I hope they do well bc we need more locations!! read more

Crave - Banana cream pie - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Omg a pregnant ladies craving is so happy! lol I've been craving gourmet cookies for the last few weeks and the other cookie stores selection hasn't been sounding good. Facebook must have read my mind because an ad for the holiday M&M cookie popped up and I had to come try out Crave. Holy moly! The local fav (Dubai chocolate) ended up being our families favorite! They were all delicious and SO sweet. Between myself, two littles and my fiancé there is still plenty left for more later! Cute little spot, (had a little trouble finding it at first) and staff is very kind! Will be back when the next sweet tooth strikes! read more

Crave - Holiday M&M, Nutella Cinnaroll, Dubai Chocolate (Local Favorite) - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

3.5 stars. Two words: Biscoff Explosion! Probably one of the best cookies I've even had to pleasure of enjoying! After trying SEVERAL different flavors and not being wow'd, I was underwhelmed and disappointed. But then, August happened! The Biscoff one... the chilled Oreo one... then the Biscoff Oreo one. One word: YUMMY! Clearly, cookie butter and Oreo are two of my favorite indulgences. So, I was happy to pay $5/cookie for those well-crafted flavors. But beware, not all of the flavors will make you smile. So, please ask for a sample! They have excellent customer service and are willing to accommodate you. And definitely watch for some pretty sweet coupons and specials in your email/text after signing up for the rewards program. When Biscoff returns, so will I!!! read more

Crave - Biscoff Explosion!!! - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

crave is a wonderful cookie place in Fishers. They have gourmet cookies. Chocolate chip seasonal favorites like Keylime . My favorite is the shortbread. They also have dirty cola's many favorite flavors or you can create your own. They're located in the heart of Fishers they have street parking and shopping close by a block off the trail read more

Crave - Cookie assortment in December - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I definitely prefer crave over other gourmet cookie places. They're dough can sometimes be undercooked (especially if you get the plain chocolate chip), but I got the mango sticky rice cookie, and it was really good!! I have a wicked sweet tooth so this hit the spot. The workers are mostly younger and are SO funny and make things quick and easy! read more

Crave - mango stick rice cookie - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The best cookies I've tasted. They are #1 in my book. The service is always amazing. The store is always clean and well organized. The workers all have great customer service! I will be back soon! read more

See all

I was impressed with the value--4 large cookies for around $16 is a great way to try different weekly flavors. The cookies are generously sized, soft, and fresh. The banana cream pie cookie stood out to me the most. It had a distinct, balanced flavor that wasn't just overly sweet like some places. I'll definitely be back when that one returns. This is a solid spot for anyone who enjoys trying creative cookie flavors. read more

Crave - Cannoli and Banana Cream Pie Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

To satisfy my sweet craving, I decided to give Crave a try. Store was bright and clean. A digital screen on the right displayed the menu. The week's offerings were also on display on the counter. I opted to try the Key Lime Pie, Campfire S'mores, Baked Butterbeer, and The Samoa. They were ready in less than a minute. The cookies are large and thick. I could only eat one a day. They were sweet, flavorful, and decadent. I really enjoyed all of them equally. read more

See all

I got a cookie I didn't order only reason I didn't give 5 stars. The place is nice and clean. You can see them working from the counter. Staff is nice and friendly enough. I like that they have samples available but I did have to ask for a sample and wasn't offered one. These cookies are absolutely delicious. They taste like whatever they are suppose to taste like and they taste homemade!! I'm a picky Cookie eater and prefer peanut butter but every flavor I tried was delicious. I ordered a 6 pack and here are the flavors: Samoa- this is the one I didn't ask for. I'm not a fan of coconut so I wouldn't have ordered this one. I feel like I was taking to long to decide (there was no line or no one else in there ) so the cashier picked one. Or maybe she selected it by mistake. Either way, I tried and it was good...I'm just not a fan. 2 Oreo cookie ones because two of my kids wanted that's they taste exactly like an Oreo and served chilled. Maple doodle ---I wasn't expecting to like this one but it's so good!!! Biscoff---this is heavenly. It's very rich. Would go good with a latte! Finally, my all time fav, peanut butter. It's a peanut butter cookie with a Reese's smack dab in the middle. It's delicious!!! These cookies are nice and size and shareable in my opinion! They are rich in flavor and so good!! read more

Ordered some cookies on a whim for an evening with friends. Got several varieties that sounded good. We got the chocolate chip, the chookie, and the brownie cookie. I have to say that I love these cookies. They aren't sugary sweet but I feel like you can taste the chocolate better. The order was promptly filled and we had our cookies in no time. Staff was kind even though the place was pretty busy for a weekday evening. Will definitely get again! read more

Crave - One dozen HUGE cookies - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I can't say enough about these cookies! They're delicious and so convenient. Picked up a 6 pack to share with friends. Staff was super friendly and the location is bright and clean. Love love love in a cookie! read more

See all

The perfect place for cookie lovers! The quality of the cookies honestly took me by surprise. I am quite picky when it comes to cookies and usually prefer to make my own, but Crave has me wanting to return. Their flavors are more authentic and homemade tasting than local competitors. They have gone straight to the top of my top 10 cookie list. Additionally, the service was outstanding. The staff works hard to create a welcoming and friendly atmosphere. I really appreciated how personable the owner was as well. He made a point to chat with us and offered free flavored sodas- I reccomend the Full Blitz! Prime location with great cookies, good staff, and a clean store- what more could you want? read more

Crave - Cinnamon Roll, Chocolate Chip, Banana Cream Pie, Peanut Butter Cup. - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

One of my colleagues told me about this new cookie place in Fishers so first chance I got to drive down there I had to stop in. I didn't take any photos of my cookies I bought but we got the Key Lime and snickerdoodle. These blow away the competition. So many flavors to choose from. All that we tried were so good. I love that you could try the flavors before spending $4-5 on a cookie that you may not like. I also got a Vanilla Coke once I seen that they had flavored sodas. I'll be back during my next trip to Fishers. read more

Crave - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

10/10 best cookies we've ever had. We ordered through Grubhub and unfortunately, we didn't get one of the cookies we ordered and one of the other cookies was the wrong one. But even with that experience, we will definitely be back because the taste and quality was so great. read more

Crave - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We got a 4 pack of cookies the Nutella cinnamon roll the carrot cake and the grasshopper. We were extremely underwhelmed! The carrot cake was under cooked and gross! Will never be returning! The lady who served us was very pleasant tho!! And the packaging is beautiful read more

Crave - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Dare I say Crave may be better than Crumbl.... I have only had the chocolate chip cookie which they were handing out for free during their grand opening! But wow it hands down is the best chocolate chip cookie I've had. They were warm and crunchy on the outside but soft on the inside and huge! I cannot wait to try all of the different flavors on their menu as well. Very clean and super friendly staff. Love having this addition in the fishers neighborhood! read more

Crave - Chocolate chip cookie - Desserts Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Nice kids working there & great ice cream! Chocolate Shoppe brand! We moved here from Madison, WI where that is THE ice cream & we were really missing it!....UNTIL, we discovered that Crave now has that brand! Our 2 favs flavors are Zanzibar Chocolate & Fat Elvis! The only problem is that apparently those are favs of others as well, because too often they don't have those in stock, & we both have to select another flavor! Anyway, manager seemed like a nice guy when we spoke to him about that one day. We both appreciated him listening to us (& at least seeming like he cared!) & he said that he would work to try to order more of those 2 flavors. Lines can get a little long here, especially in the summer, but that's just proof of how great the place is, right?!...And it's worth the wait! - Enjoy! read more

Cookies were soooo good! We got 4 chocolate chip and 4 others! Every one was better than the next! Very large and lots of flavor! They came out warm! A little expensive but if you got the 4 or 6 it made it a better price! People were all very friendly and helpful. Menu was a little confusing but it was their first day! Seeing how they make the cookies was very cool also. The restaurant was clean and seating outside. read more

See all

Keegan and Elias were amazing and very helpful. Definitely made my day! I recommend coming to crave!

Service was great, but they were out of half of the cookies ordered. Be careful ordering ahead through the app. Disappointing experience.

Best cookies anywhere... the recent French Pie chocolate was the best ever... they can customize your selection if you ask when ordering on line or in person at the store... super friendly staff read more

This place is amazing. Really good ice cream and service. The workers are nice too, and you get to order fast.

I went to the fishers location at 9:48 (they close at 10pm) which means the workers should have been able to serve me but when me and my friends were seen by the workers they locked the doors and shut off the lights. It was two girls and it's unbelievable that we're still doing this in 2025. Crave really disappointed me tonight, I was in the mood for some cookies until my night was ruined... read more

I ordered every type of cookie they had. They were all fun to taste and the cookie makers were so friendly. The cookie shop smelled oh so good and I'm happy that I found this new cookie destination. read more

See all

Got a $6 order off of too good to go. Was my first time trying this place 10/10 cookies and the employees were nice. Will be coming again, also highly suggest checking out the too good to go app. read more

Best cookies I have ever had! Amazing!!! I'm sure we will be frequent return customers! Thanks! read more

We love the cookies, so fresh, warm, crunchy outside and chewy in the inside! Couple tables outside. read more

staff is always so nice and welcoming! the store is always so clean and they're always so quick with making orders!

I have come here 3 times within normal business hours and only been able to get something one of those times. Hours are very unreliable. Sad because I want to come more often but it's not worth the drive when they aren't always open during their normal hours. read more

The manger keira is so amazing! she really knows what she's doing and is super helpful. I definitely recommend coming to this location!