We stopped by to this bar because it was open after 10pm on a Friday night. It is cash only so be…read moreprepared. They have an outdoor and an indoor section. The outdoor is very nice, live band, lots of chairs and a nice view of the water with a nice pier. We ordered michelobs $4 each. Not too bad. Inside there's a pool table and more tables to sit around and relax. The vibe was very nice. The service is great, we got attended right away at the outside bar. I've never noticed this place before, but now I won't ever forget it. Such a nice experience.

Yay!!! Here at a dive bar after dinner to listen to the band play on stage. Chilled out with…read morefriends in the sand next to the bay with drinks. The bartender was joking with us and looked like a local in the keys. Not a kids place. So glad we stopped here and will come again.

Amazing food, had the chicken Cajun pasta and it was so delicious!…read more Our server was busting her ass and never skipped a beat. She needs a raise, she was incredible! Great little spot to visit. The outdoor dining was great

The food here was very good. See below why I took off one star…read more I'd read about this place. It's off the main highway. It looks a bit ramshackle from the outside. But it is worth the detour. We sat at the bar, inside, with a view of the kitchen and cook, but I'd recommend sitting outside if it's not too hot and weather permits. That's a much better view. We started with their fried asparagus appetizer. The stalks were quite thin, and the portion small, but what we had was delicious. Especially tasty when dipped in the horseradish sauce. I'd get this again! After that we shared their fish dish. Two scoops on a plate with chopped tomatoes, chopped onions, and chopped green pepper. The cutest heart shaped crackers came with the dip. We had leftover dip so we took it home with us (in our cooler). We enjoyed it on toast later on. So the very good? The food. The not so good? The kitchen looked grungy and the ladies room was a mess. Would we come here again? Yes, but we'd sit outside.

This local dive bar offers a great vibe with a laid-back atmosphere. If you have a boat the…read moredock-and-dine feature is a perfect touch, allowing you to pull up by boat and enjoy the views while you eat. No boat, no problem. You can still enjoy the water views from the screened in patio. The food was delicious, fresh, flavorful, and perfect for a casual and satisfying meal. The staff was friendly, and the service was quick, making it an all-around great spot to hang out. If you're looking for a no-frills place with great food and drinks, Blackwater Siren is definitely worth checking out!

A+!!! We came here looking for a restaurant to watch the sunset! When we pulled up, we were a…read morelittle skeptical, but don't sleep on Blackwater Siren! The service was great. They let us go stand out back while watching the sunset and offered to get us drinks. And the food was exceptional. 2 of us ordered the coconut shrimp and one ordered the Harvey (server's recommendation). Those were up there with some of the best coconut shrimp I've ever had. The shrimp were JUMBO and the portion was generous. The steak fries needed salt, but all in all - delicious! My friend who ordered the Harvey said it was awesome too. Would definitely return!

Started with the lobster bisque, which was good with crackers and just as good without. Got the…read morelarger size and it was genuinely a big bowl, loaded with nice thin chunks of lobster. The Matecumbe was the standout of the night. Yellow tail with rice and black beans. Best flavor of everything we ordered. Also had the shrimp and scallop key lime, which was a large portion and very good. The mushrooms were a nice touch, and it comes with rice, corn, and coleslaw. One of the owners, Chris mentioned a 45 minute wait but got us set up at the bar within five minutes. We were grateful for that. I had asked him, should we wait or just move on? He replied, "We are worth the wait." And I'll tell you, that's the truth! The place was packed and had great energy and great food! Definitely worth the wait.

We went to visit the Fish House the other night and had a wonderful meal and a good time!I hadn't…read morebeen to FH in decades, 30'years later and the food and service is still fantastic. The food had my lady cooing with delight. These folks do fish and cocktails right. They also have desserts they tell me are the best on the rock...order the key-lime pie and report Back! You will love the place!

Great Sunsets. My "go to" place for sunsets. Very relaxed. Live music. Food is as good as many of…read morethe other places around.

Went via boat, great dock parking. Wonderful outside area, live music, beach and beautiful flower…read moregarden. Beautiful sunset views, good appetizers especially bacons wrapped scallops! The best i've had. Didn't eat dinner but will returnl!

Food was excellent and the bartenders were awesome. Had excellent suggestions for the area. Highly…read morerecommend!!!

Amazing mahi, the Nashville hot chicken sandwich was really good, very spicy but delicious. For…read moredessert key lime pie was amazing and the whole family loved everything. Service was excellent, our server was very friendly! We will be back

good buffalo chicken salad and the servers gave plenty of ketchup and ranch sauces on the sideread more

Wife and I enjoyed both our dishes. We had chicken wings and char-grilled hamburger. Both were…read moremarvelous. Service was exceptional. The wait staff works tables by committee. We had one main and two other waitresses that checked on us and cleared items. Fantastic. One more thing. This place will not destroy you wallet like most other places in the keys. We will be back everytime we come in town.

We love this little local bar and grill. . Waitstaff are friendly, beer is cold and food is good!read more

Friendly vibes, good food and service Great place to watch…read moreStanley cup with 8 huge TVs We have staid here for our birthdays for over 15 years Flip night on Wednesday toss a coin it may be free