Let me preface by saying that everything else in St. Paul's (the church itself, the crypt, the gift shop, etc.) was excellent, and one disappointing restaurant should not turn anyone away from visiting this historic church.
The cafeteria-style setting was certainly creative (and probably convenient for staff) and though there were an abundance of people and the noise level wasn't particularly kind, I did quite enjoy the ambiance.
We (me and 2 others) came in looking for a quick, cheap bite as we were hungry after a morning of sightseeing. I looked around for a menu of some sort, and was slightly confused when the only sign indicating prices or selection was a small piece of paper listing a few varieties of coffee they served. We realized that the price was listed next to each dish along the serving area, so we went to take a peek at the food. This caused a bit of a traffic backup, as the one way flow of the small line didn't allow us much time to decide on what to eat.
We ordered one spiced pork roll, one chicken, one tomato basil soup, and one almond cake. The pork roll was served with potatoes and veggies, and was pretty good (one of the reasons I'm giving this place 2 stars instead of 1). The veggies were slightly undercooked, but nothing to get worked up about. The chicken was just disappointing. Dry, bland, and overall difficult to swallow. The soup was solid, but tasted canned and generic. The almond cake, was quite tasty and well made, and I feel as though I would've had a better experience if we had just picked from the desert and pastry selection. In my opinion, everything was a bit more expensive than it had to be.
Overall, a bit of a letdown at the end of a fun experience at St. Paul's. Wouldn't recommend it; 2 stars. read more