Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Caffrey House

    3.3 (4 reviews)

    Caffrey House Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Caffrey House

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Robin B.
    68
    34
    18

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of B S.
    2
    5
    3

    13 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hotels 1,012 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Hampton Ocean Resort - Living room into eat in kitchen

    Hampton Ocean Resort

    (15 reviews)

    Updating bc I'm looking into rebooking for this summer and while we had the WiFi issues when we…read morelook back it's not even a bit of a reason to not go again so. We LOVED it here. It is a hidden gem for people who are looking for a simple beach getaway. *** There is nothing fancy about this place except that it's ON the beach. So if you looking for a top of the line award wining resort, this isn't it. *** That said... The cabins are nicely sized and clean but are slightly dated and worn(wood floors have been loved etc). WiFi wasn't great, we definitely used some cellular and personal hotspot etc BUT you won't find a place on Long Island where you can get two bedrooms, a full bath, full eat in kitchen, living room and covered deck off the side of the cabin for the price you will pay here. There's common areas for BBQing and then you bring your food back to your room/cabin, or you can cook in the kitchen but who wants to do that at the beach LOL. There is also free snacks and beverages in the lobby for guests pretty much 24 hrs. Free simple bf foods like muffins, etc in the mornings too. They have day beds and hammocks on the backyard lawn but the entire point of staying here is that when you go up and over the stairs you're on the beach. They have beach chairs or you can bring your own. We brought a wagon and my husband was able to walk around the side to bring everything over instead of lugging your stuff up and over. Kid friendly, dog friendly quiet area of the beach. We got one rainy day and drove into river head for the aquarium and stopped in Mattituck on the way back to the resort for Magic Fountain HomemadeIce Cream. The kids (7&4 yo boys) didn't want to leave and have asked to come back every yr.

    Great little oceanfront hotel in the Hamptons! Nothing fancy- however to get a hotel with an ocean…read moreview on an extremely private beach (Dune Road has no other hotels) for the price, we just wanted a comfortable place to sleep at night and eat breakfast. Nice deck for ocean view breakfasts and an unbeatable beach right out front. Not fancy but clean and comfortable :).

    Colonial Shores Cottages & Marina

    Colonial Shores Cottages & Marina

    (15 reviews)

    $$

    My stay from July 2-3 fell short of that standard. We arrived between 6:00 and 8:00 p.m., and with…read morecheck-in listed until 9:00 p.m., staff availability should have been ensured. Prior to arrival, we made multiple attempts to contact the office to report our delay due to traffic, but received no response. Upon arrival, the office was locked, calls went unanswered, and I was forced to seek assistance from another guest to locate staff. The initial interaction with THE OWNER! --whose name I did not obtain- she dismissive and unprofessional. Although she gave an apology during check out, it did not mitigate the inconvenience and stress caused by the lack of communication and preparedness. I had arranged for a friend to stay with me, but due to the uncomfortable experience, she chose to stay elsewhere that night. This experience reflects a significant lapse in service standards. Professionalism, clear communication, and respect are fundamental expectations for any guest, and these were not met. As a result, I would not consider returning.

    We stayed at the Colonial Shores Cottage for the weekend and wasn't super impressed. When we came…read moreto check in, our keys were just siting there in the office and no one was there. So, we grabbed them and went to our room. Strange check in. For the price you pay for this place, you'd think it would be more comfortable. The living room couch is old and uncomfortable, the WiFi isn't great, the ice bucket had bugs in it, but the kitchen was clean enough. The bedroom only has 1 side table, the bed was super bouncy and high off the floor, pillows were horrible, the bathroom has no sink space and no electrical outlet or fan. I had to sit on the floor in the bedroom to blow dry my hair. At least they had a hairdryer. The ironing board was so old we could hardly use it without damaging our clothes. The AC works ok - it's pretty cool in the living room but the vent in the bedroom is small and doesn't cool well. Needless to say, we won't be back.

    West Hampton Bath and Tennis Hotel and Marina

    West Hampton Bath and Tennis Hotel and Marina

    (23 reviews)

    $$$$

    Absolutely gorgeous. My sister got married here, and she had a lovely Wedding. I can't comment on…read morethe rooms - I haven't seen them. We stayed at another hotel. But I know they are ridiculously expensive. I can comment on the hair salon (I think they call it the Spa). My hair came out lovely. However, they quoted me $45 on the phone and charged $140 when it was all said and done. I wore my hair down. The girl did a beautiful job and spent almost 2 hours with me. So I didn't argue. The beach is beautiful.

    Horrible beyond horrible…read more This place has no comprehension of hospitality, or what a guest is. The young ladies at the desk neglected to inform me of the room Internet. They gave me a piece of paper about THE Internet, never saying that is the general resort Internet. So time wasting trying to make that work. Time wasting calling them to find out why not. Time wasting as they tell me to use the one on the back of the door. Time wasting as the one on the back of the door is incorrect. Time wasting to wait for the maintenance person. Time wasting as he discovered the modem in this room ISN'T the one the door indicates. Time wasting that the modem isn't even plugged in. Time wasting that for 2.5 hours, they couldn't get it to work. Time wasting informing the ladies at the desk who react less than a zombie robot would. Time wasting getting "tacos" at the Tiki Bar, as they were meat mush with salsa from a jar from the grocery story. It left me wondering, who are the rich people here who find an ounce of value belonging to this club? I accept the standards of an older resort but I do not accept the non-existent standards of an untrained staff, not having a checklist that the room function, including my outlet at the table so I could plug my computer in and work while sitting, and the vile slop they put out calling it carne asada "tacos". Counting the minutes until I leave in the morning.

    Bayview Resort - Free Kayak in the afternoon to relax the body

    Bayview Resort

    (33 reviews)

    Ceil and I have been going to the Bayview Resort for five years! This is our sanctuary! The white…read morerocking chairs on the deck overlooking the bay!! We begin every morning there, and we end every evening watching the stars and the moon. Brian and Patrick do an awesome job managing the resort. They are very helpful and always give us the best experience.!!! Warm, friendly and kind!! We are so grateful thank you BrIan and Patrick!! Elizabeth and Ceil

    This was our 2nd year returning and wow has the place has gone downhill. Our room was dirty upon…read morearrival, sticky floors that quickly turned the bottoms of my feet black and my childrens socks. I always bring cleaning supplies/Clorox wipes along and I wiped down all areas the best that I could, but its not like I travel with a mop. I couldn't exactly clean the floors. The bathroom cleanup I did turned my wipes brown, when was the last time this room was actually cleaned? TV in the room was breaking, which management was aware of. FYI its not hard to replace a cheap tv with a new tv, not sure if management has ever heard of a site called Amazon, they sell tvs and cleaning supplies , just saying. On top of it there was a large group who took over the communal spaces , with lots of small children who they were too busy drinking to parent. The tiny bathtub sized "resort" pool was overtaken by the unsupervised children with giant floats. By a miracle these kids survived their pool takeover, it takes a moment for a child to drown. On top of it these people were slobs leaving garbage, toys, fishing poles, crab traps all over. We mentioned it to the woman working who did nothing about any of it. We left the resort and spent most of the time at the beach to avoid drama and stress , we made the best of it because we couldn't find another hotel with availability to pack up and leave to go to. Overall the place is dirty, obviously mismanaged or management is in over their heads who can know, and there are many other much cleaner places in the area to stay for the prices they are charging. Overall a shame and disappointing.

    Bowen's by the Bays, Inc. - guest room

    Bowen's by the Bays, Inc.

    (7 reviews)

    $$$

    We enjoyed our stay at Bowen's during a weekend Hampton's trip. Upon check in, we were greeted…read morewarmly by Eileen, the owner. She directed us to our room and the best places to eat nearby, sending us along with a welcome goody bag of snacks and water bottles. The room was basic but clean, cozy and comfortable. Towels and soap was provided. Though we didn't use the pool, it looked clean and the grounds in the courtyard were well maintained. Easy breezy check in and check out. When we left, one of us unknowingly left a highly valuable item and we were instantly called to come and retrieve the item. Very honest people! Would definitely recommend staying at Bowen's.

    Let me start by saying the staff was very accommodating. We…read moreshowed up later than expected, and they worked with us to make sure we could easily access our room. Since we arrived later than expected, I didn't mention the following to the office since sadly it turned out we had to unexpectedly leave the following day. The room, while decorated exactly as described, had a very musty, moldy, almost baby wipe smell to it. The quilt on the bed (while it was very pretty) was actually moist (I'm guessing from humidity) even though the AC was on when we arrived. Fortunately, we brought our own pillows bc their pillowcases were also damp. We were able to open the door to the grounds and air out the room, which I was thankful for. With all the covid info going around, I've started carrying Lysol spray if I'm staying out of town. It was a blessing that I had this, as it helped mask the smell, which was a bit overwhelming. From the way it looked when I was able to quickly walk the grounds, if you're able to score a cabin that is the way to go.

    Caffrey House - hotels - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...