This place is filthy. I went in to grab a slice to go. After I ordered I sat down and started looking around while I waited. They literally have a large metal shelving unit, floor to ceiling, like one you would put in a garage for storage, packed with tons of grimy junk. I'm talking old printers and phones, boxes with all kinds of crap, loaded on shelves to the ceiling. This is right by the front door! Right by the dining area! Then I looked up...there is a loft storage area around the ceiling area that is packed with old junk, like Christmas decorations and old lights. Dusty loads of junk. It looked like an old man's attic. The tables all looked dirty too, like they never wipe them down. I don't know how the health department hasn't shut this place down. Even the employees looked filthy. I should have walked out without my slice, because it went in the garbage anyway. I was really mad at myself for not speaking up and walking out. The slice looked disgusting as well. I got pepperoni and it was floating in oil and the pepperoni was just put on top cold. Disgusting. Not to mention it wasn't cheap! You've been warned. If they are this filthy in plain sight, imagine what goes on in the kitchen. read more

Calabria Pizza - Raw pepperoni dripping in oil - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

First time ordering $200 worth of catering, as I was fortunate enough to have a gift card! Went with pretty much the usuals, Chicken Francese, Eggplant Parmesan, and penne in vodka sauce. I added an item that I not seen before, garlic knot sliders. The dishes were pretty much standard pizza parlor fare, with nothing bad and nothing particularly outstanding. The two best dishes were the garlic knot sliders and the penne vodka. Don't know if the vodka sauce was house made, but it was quite tasty and the sliders were unique. While I'm not running back, this is certainly not a place to avoid, and I would order food from them again without hesitation. There was plenty of staff behind the counter and they were pleasant enough. The restaurant itself is a hole in the wall. I didn't take pictures cuz there are quite a few people inside. While it didn't appear dirty, it certainly looked tired and run down. If you've got a hankering for some Italian takeout, check out Calabria Pizza in Oradell! read more

Calabria Pizza - Garlic knot sliders. Awesome! - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

I ordered a plain cheese pizza for takeout. No frill pizzeria, quick in and out. The pizza is good but on the oily side. No complaints, I would come back when I'm in the mood for pizza again. read more

Calabria Pizza - Plain cheese - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

We order from here fairly frequently. Our son loves the Vodka pizza. The apple walnut salad is delicious and the sliders are great too. Delivery service is usually pretty quick. read more

Ordered off postmates two pies, one mushroom and one pepperoni. When I first ordered the pizza, I thought this was the Calabria's in Livingston, but the order was already in and on the way. All good, the two pizzas were delivered within the hour and still hot which is good! Both the mushroom and pepperoni pies were really good. I appreciate that they used real mushrooms as toppings! Makes a huge difference vs canned. Since it was delivered, I decided to re-heat some of the slices on a pan and then add some water near the end to steam the cheese. Always comes out perfectly with a nice crispy bottom and the pizza was delicious! Very affordable prices here and will order again some day read more

Pizza crust was too thin and over cooked. Was like eating pizza on crackers. Maybe they pre-cook and reheat. Whatever it is, not good.

Pizza taste like if you put cheese on cardboard. Got the mozzarella sticks aswell. the cheese taste like glue and the breading was soggy. I could not even finish this food and had to get new food from a different place. I gave this food to my dog and he didn't even finish it. Disgraceful place. The service was bad too from the owner. read more

Trifecta pizza is delicious! My family regularly orders from here and we are never disappointed.

I was left home alone for a couple days and of course with zero supervision from my wife it was time to put on stretchy pants and pig out! Looking for pizza I found a VW Bug sized calzone from Calabria Pizza. I expected it to be doughy judging by the size...'twas not! This was massive meaty cheesey flavorful feast. I tried soooo hard to eat the whole thing but just could not get there. Also, the crispy fried ravioli are really really delicious. The calzone and ravioli are def a two person gig. Had it delivered too so I didn't even have to put shoes on! This was very impressive and I will be back. read more

See all

Never disappoints. Perfect crust, right amount cheese and toppings and delicious. Clam and white pies are my favorites.

Make sure you verify your order. I ordered 3 pies got charged and only received 2. When I called back to ask they actually asked you missing the cauliflower pie I said yes. Oh yeah we didn't charge you?? WtF how is that my problem? Never again read more

I was in the area visiting friends and we decided it was a pizza kind of day. I've been here numerous times and obviously the pizza is decent. I've had the original cheese pie and pie with grilled chicken and broccoli. They make the pizza good here, not too salty. Sometimes they give a lot of toppings and sometimes they don't give as much, guess depends on who makes the pizza. There is limited seating inside. It is part of a strip mall with parking in the back. If you pay with credit card, they will pass on the credit card fee to you, so paying cash helps everyone. Staff here is nice and friendly. Definitely will be back here again if in pizza mode. read more

Ordered Calabria delivery and it was a tale of two stories. Sliders? Yes. Baked ziti? Absolutely not. Ordered chicken and meatball parm sliders. Great flavor and were very good. The ziti was cold, just a bunch of cheese on top of cold pasta. Just didn't taste great, as if it was made from a box. Another problem, I ordered the ice cream sandwiches, and they called and told us they were out. That just can't happen with ice cream sandwiches. I'd probably return for the sliders, and possibly other menu items. read more

Calabria Pizza - Baked Ziti Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

See all

good pizza, but it's a little oily. had the regular and the grandma. they were super busy but very kind. will definitely come back!

Update to my last review. My wife and i made a second visit to Calabria Pizza since we were impressed with the pizza on our first visit, which was a 5 out of 5 stars. Our second pizza order was a Margherita pizza and the only word to describe it is: spectacular. The pie was visually perfect and the taste matched its looks. So happy we discovered this place. We will definitely be back to try some other things on their menu. read more

Delivery took over an hour, but the food for the most part was pretty good. I ordered a Buffalo wings, Chicken Marsala, Chicken fingers, and Grilled shrimp with sauteed broccoli rabe. The chicken fingers were so-so, but the other three were really good. I would order from here again, but probably I'll go pick it up next time instead of having it delivered. read more

See all

Great pizza for lunch and amazing dishes for dinner. Or any time really. The service is always fast and on point. This place never disappoints. The staff is always friendly and ready to assist! This place is a great little town place. read more

Consistently good pizza and large pies with plenty of toppings for average $20-21 -- pretty good value compared to the market. Have tried drunken chicken, meat lovers, and veggie lovers -- all were solid read more

This pizzeria is right down the block from where I work. Their salads are very filling! I love the Calabrias salad, but today I had a grilled chicken Caesar salad. Chicken had a lot of flavor, possibly marinated in balsamic? Regardless, it was delicious. Only had 30 min before my appointment. I ate inside- my food was served within 5-10 min. Everyone was friendly. My area was clean. I took my left overs home. Would come again! read more

Calabria Pizza - Chicken Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

Best pizza in town and, for that matter, any town nearby, not to mention, the eggplant rolatini is excellent. This is the best Italian takeout in the Oradell area. read more

No No Innovative , well made pizza and Italian specialty dishes . Recently picked up a "chicken franchese that was outstanding! Owners always friendly and informative! One of Bergen counties best! read more

Best pizza and pasta in the area! Delivery is also moderatly quick. There meatball spaghetti is the best! read more

Very good food and the delivery was so fast. I got the pizza and breaded chicken plus chicken roll it was all so good! Def recommend read more

Two stars for the lasagna. I've eaten here more than a handful of times and the last couple of times their lasagna was made with ready made pasta. I thought it was a one time things, but no. I ordered it again and it was ready made pasta. So here's the thing, I have even used it at home thinking it would save me time, but it kills the taste. For a restaurant to use it kinda sucks. It tastes horrible. Just boil the pasta. I'm paying enough for it. Please, if anyone from this restaurant reads this review, please stop using ready made pasta. Please. read more

Calabria Pizza - Lasagna, made with ready made pasta. Yuck. - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

This pizza is ridic. We had by-the-slice Grandma's (kinda Margherita) and a deluxe sort of thing I can't remember the name of. Holy cannoli, it's so freaking good! The dough of Grandma's is like soft breadsticks with a lightly buttery crispiness. I can't think of any other way to describe it. If I lived here, I'd eat here as much as possible! The woman at the counter is so nice and answered my questions pleasantly. This is a pizza-lover's place! read more

After fasting all day, this Clam Pie from Calabria's in Oradell is hitting the spot. Once I saw this special posted this morning I knew I had to order it. Added a little crushed red pepper to satisfy my own Calabrese Blood. Calabria Pizza read more

Calabria Pizza - Clam Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

This place has really good food. This my family's go to place to get pizza. Their delivery is quick and the food arrives at a great temperature. Their chicken wings are also great. read more

I love this place, now they have a wonderful patio outside, very relaxing great atmosphere, fantastic staff a delicious food , can't wait to go back and enjoy my glass a wine because it's a byob , and the great food . I strongly recommend this place. Good Italian food . Thank you so much guys for this fantastic place . read more

See all

Great pizza and salad choices when area options are plenty. We now order from here regularly and for special occasions- everyone has raved about the quality of pizza at our kids various parties. The white pizza with mushrooms is delicious, but the salads are just as good and filling. The grilled chicken salad with the fixings tastes so rich I forget it's healthy! A local favorite that doesn't disappoint. read more

See all

Ordered for pickup food was ready when I arrived Food portions were large and food tasted great read more

Best pizza I've had in the longest time!!! I'm picky about pizza and this surpassed what I had read. It was so fresh with quality ingredients Excellent Caesar salad too. Thank you! read more

The vodka pizza and grandmas were good. I think the dough is really pillowy and the crust is perfect for dipping. Four stars because the bacon chicken ranch wasn't so great. It didn't taste very fresh. Overall, a pretty good pizzeria! read more

I ordered from here for the first time this afternoon and was pleasantly surprised. I have many good pizza places near to where I live but was wanting to try something new and different. I was not disappointed! I ordered 3 small pizzas, plain, pepperoni & bacon and mushroom and sausage. All three were delicious with a flavorful sauce and a nice crispy crust. I also ordered a caesar salad, good but not spectacular. The stracciatella soup was obviously homemade and very good. I like to order vegetarian options when offered and saw they had eggplant "meatballs" served in sauce and topped with ricotta cheese. These were outstanding and I would be very happy having them instead of traditional meatballs as a meat substitute. Nice crusty bread was included with my order. I will definitely order from here again and give it high recommendations to anyone looking for good quality Italian food. read more

Consistently good food! I'm new in town and have been ordering pizza and chicken fingers from here for housewarming events and the food is always delicious. It's nice to have this pizza place close by. The delivery is always fast and easy as well. read more

My friends & I usually order delicious pizza from Calabria which is fantastic and always served with a smile. I recently had a family party and decided to order food for my group. The selections are great, the prices are reasonable and the service is terrific. The food arrived exactly on time, piping hot and everyone raved about it; calamari, chicken francese, veal piccata, sausage and peppers, and broccoli. All terrific! The portions are generous and the leftovers were delicious too. What a great neighborhood restaurant with a terrific staff! Thanks Calabria for making our day a success! :-) Kathleen D. read more

Awesome mushroom thin crust pizza and a side of two sliced in half longitudinally sausages for delivery.

Great food when I'm working I always order from here and it's always good .. it's delicious and arrives hot read more

Calabria Pizza - Pasta E Fagioli - Pizza Near Me - Oradell, New Jersey

If you want an easy order/pick up experience, friendly faces, and quality pizza, Calabria is the place for you. Ordered online through GrubHub, for which I got a first-timer $5 discount. Went with a classic Margherita in the small size (12 inches). It was ready for pickup in 16 minutes. To make things even easier, there is a parking lot right behind the place. The three young women behind the register were more friendly and professional than any employees I've ever encountered at neighborhood pizza places. The Margherita itself was divine. The blandness of fresh mozzarella was balanced by flavorful plum tomatoes and generously sliced strips of basil. What about the crust, you ask? Crisp, crackly on the outside, gloriously chewy on the inside. Already looking forward to ordering pizza from Calabria'a again. read more

This is my go to place. They always deliver really fast and their foods are great! I love their calabria sub! read more

Pizza and salads are always great! Delivery is always accurate and drivers are great! Highly recommend.