We consider Caribbean Sushi the best spot for sushi/nigiri in Broken Arrow. Service is fast and friendly. We have a couple rolls that we rotate through because they are favorites (Hamachi, Mahka, Caribbean), but we have never tried a bad roll here. read more

I just love this place. Their sushi is super unique and different. Their appetizer of tempera shrimp is amazing and of course the garlic edamame is a must have and I just can't stop going to this restaurant. It had been a little while, but my friend and I went and had great service. It was fast fresh clean, and amazing portion sizes for what you pay. I love how unique the roles are and will keep going back. read more

See all

Excellent food but portions are less than what we expected given the cost. Good ambiance.

Don't let the shopping center scare you away. Sushi was great!!! Love the omakase with three small rolls. Don't be scared as they don't have octopus or anything strange. Location was a little worn and bathroom were indicative of a "hole in the wall" type place. No liquor license here so don't expect plum wine or sake, which disappointed me some. I'm not sure if I will return as I live out of town but it's was very affordable, staff was friendly, it appeared family ran and it was good food. Hope I helped. read more

Great sushi, poke bowl, bulogi beef bowl. Attentive staff. Located in a strip center.

Sushi is excellent quality and the service is very nice and friendly. Lovely restaurant and the service was fast. A great place for a date or before a movie at Geaux Theater in that plaza. read more

Caribbean Sushi - Mighty Bowl - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Caribbean Sushi had me rethinking and expanding my notions of what sushi is and what it can be. This is such a good restaurant. Everything was fresh tasting and mostly balanced. Lots of interesting options that taste amazing. The fish rolls are good, but the vegetarian ones are perspective shifting. Service was excellent. Great spot for a casual date night. read more

Caribbean Sushi - Dragon fireballs - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

This kept popping up as a recommendation on Yelp. The Garlic Edamame is delicious. The Arepitas were good but even better with the dipping sauce. We also tried the Caribbean sushi roll and poke bowl. My daughters got kids cali rolls. Everything was good. Service was fast! Ambience is fun. They have fake plants, fun lighting above the sushi bar, & music videos playing on the tv. read more

See all

This place is amazing.. the sushi rolls are made fresh and delicious.. I don't care for teriyaki, the chef will charge the sauce, I've gone back and he remembered adding a different sauce for me without having to ask.. very friendly family owned business.. read more

ABSOLUTELY BEST IN TULSA AREA. My son and I have been coming here for over a year consistently and we have never been disappointed. Amazing staff and best sushi around. read more

See all

I was visiting my girlfriend in Tulsa for a few days last week. She was excited to share with me that Tulsa was hosting a Vegan Chef Challenge with over 60 restaurants competing in the challenge. She showed me the website and mentioned a few places in town she hadn't tried yet, but was excited about items on their menu. CS did not disappoint, when we walked in we were greeted at the hostess stand immediately. We shared we were there for the vegan challenge. A very friendly young man was excited to hear that, he asked if we were interested in a table or bar seating. We decided on the bar, so we could watch them create the yummy rolls. He spent quite a lot of time going over the vegan item challenge items with us, as well as other items that were vegan, or could be easily made vegan on their menu. We decided on the dragon fire balls appetizer and the trio. Don't forget to check in on Yelp- you will get a free miso soup. I showed him our checkin, and asked if it was vegan. He said it wasn't, but quickly offered an alternative of a house salad for each of us. We enjoyed all of the rolls we tried- and would be hard pressed to pick a favorite. We did try, and each time we took a bite would would decide that was our favorite. But then the next time we tried another one and then that was our favorite. The young man later came to ask how our journey with the vegan challenge was going. We told him this was our first time in, but that we would definitely be back. He shared this was a family owned/run business. That his sister is vegetarian, so that was why they had so many vegetarian/vegan options. We really like the decor, very pleasant and inviting dining experience. We both used the restroom before we left. Even during the busy lunch rush, they kept them well stocked and tidy. read more

See all

This place is a small little Tucked away treasure ! The food was really good and it was very flavorful. I will be back for more . read more

Normally, I love Caribbean sushi and I go here quite often. However, today was a tragedy. I was not met with satisfaction. In fact, I was met with quite the opposite; dissatisfaction. We placed an order, drove to the restaurant, and paid for it. Upon arriving home, we discovered that our order was incorrect and we were missing one of our delicious poke bowls. We called back and replaced the order for the poke bowl and also requested a side of jalapeños. Once we arrived back home, we realized they failed a second time, and forgot the jalapeños. It's not worth the drive just for jalapeños, so I'll be forced to use hot honey instead. read more

Caribbean Sushi - Jalapeño alternative - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

11-11-2023 Went with my Son and D-I-L to his favorite restaurant. I had the Spicy Red Norimaki and a Salmon Poke bowl with added strawberries, masago, and Serrano pepper. Poke Bowl was beautifully presented, tasted great and was filling. Pickled ginger on both dishes was great. Exceptional customer service by friendly owner/chef and waitstaff. If you go, check hours account split shifts Tuesday-Friday and closed Sundays. read more

Caribbean Sushi - Spicy Red Norimaki [Tempura Shrimp] - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

One of a kind and unique sushi fusion experience. Great service and fun environment. Owner has a true passion. Order the chef's selection and you will not be disappointed. read more

My daughter wanted sushi for her birthday dinner and we decided to try somewhere new. Firstly, I loved the atmosphere, such a fun tropical vibe! Our server was excellent and gave good recommendations. We had a boba tea, arepitas for an appetizer, two tempura rolls and a poke bowl. Everything was absolutely fresh and delicious. The arepitas were so good, I've craved them since! read more

Caribbean Sushi - Caribbean & California Tempura Rolls - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I will be honest. I had very low expectation when I ordered because the name of the restaurant threw me off. I am glad I tried the poke bowl though. I had half/half (sushi rice with mixed greens) with ahi tuna, and I added spicy yellowtail and spicy tuna. I think I will just order extra ahi tuna next time because it was the nicest out of the three sashimi. I might try their tempura some day too read more

Caribbean Sushi - Custom poke bowl - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

I love all their tempura rolls and miso soup! Owners and staff are very attentive and nice! read more

Caribbean Sushi - Shrimp tempura roll and miso soup! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Quiet little spot off the beaten path. But such a treasure. When they say fusion they mean it. The spice level was hot but paired so well with everything! We will be back. Our server was also so helpful and attentive. read more

Small sushi places hidden in a large strip malls are always a toss up but this place is a gem! Really good sushi, garlic edamame, & fast service! read more

It was good but pricey. The rolls were well put together and tasted great and the selection was abundant.

Excellent food! Service is great! Ambiance is warm and cozy! It was recommended by some friends at QT and we were not disappointed.

Food was very good a little different offerings than traditional Japanese shushi and sadly no alcohol.

The food is great, service is awesome! Ambiance is cute and makes you feel at home. The sushi portions are huge (that's all I've gotten there) read more

Absolutely wonderful...best sushi in Tulsa This is now our sushi place. We decided to try it out after reading the reviews..found it hard to believe as most were 5 stars....and here I am giving 5 stars as well. No complaints, and it did not take long to get our food either. read more

Wonderful Sushi fusion! Get the Omakases! Chef's choice and reasonably priced! Also, best edamame!

Great sushi! Like no other place! The service is perfect! Huge portions of food! My favorite is the off the menu, Scott roll!!

After hearing about Caribbean Sushi from multiple friends and family members, the hubs and I decided to give it a try. And are we GLAD we did!!! Their menu has something for everyone. Today I enjoyed the GF Vegan Poke Bowl (YES, those are fried plantains in the picture ), the vegan sushi roll, and the fruit & chili roll. I'm not kidding when I say this was the best sushi either of us have ever tried. . As if the food wasn't good enough, we were fortunate to have the opportunity to meet the chef (who is also the owner) and he was a joy to speak with. It is evident that he has a passion for making meals from fresh whole foods which speaks to my heart (and my belly). . We will definitely be back as I'm certain this will be our new regular place for lunch/dinner dates. . Love supporting my local business entrepreneurs! read more

Caribbean Sushi - Vegan Poke Bowl - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Who would have thought that a hole in the wall sushi joint in Broken Arrow, OK would offer the best sushi in the Tulsa Metro area? Better than In The Raw. I said it. Cheaper, too. read more

Very good sushi, service was quick and friendly. Atmosphere was nice and they had a variety of options that I haven't seen at other sushi restaurants. read more

A friend and I shared the 3 rolls Omakase platter and it was divine! I don't know what everything was but I do know we had eel, tuna and yellowfin tuna on our rolls. We sat up at the sushi bar and talked to the chef while he made it. He explained everything to us and added strawberries to one of the rolls for a hint of sweetness. Super fresh sushi with to die for flavors this is absolutely my new favorite sushi place in the Tulsa area. read more

Caribbean Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Small sushi restaurant, and we went during a week night so there was only one server but she was really nice and attentive. I've always been curious about this place because I don't hear about it much. The quality in the fish was excellent and the rolls were so good. They don't offer a lot of kitchen entree so I would only highly recommend if you truly want sushi. I can't wait to go back! We got the saba, mahka roll, and the carribean. All excellent choices read more

Caribbean Sushi - Mahka, carribean, Saba? - Sushi Bars Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Really cool fusion restaurant, big menu, cozy atmosphere. Don't knock plantains and sushi until you try it!

This is our favorite place to get sushi, hands-down! we love everything we have gotten there and the staff is so nice.

The very best sushi in the entire area have eaten there over 20 times it never vagaries its excellent

Small place in strip mall in Broken Arrow. Very attentive staff. Good sushi rolls and appetizers.

Best sushi place we've been to in about 20 years. The chef will create sushi for you tailored to your tastes and it never disappoints!

I think this is the best place for eat sushi!! Is amazing big rolls, good prices and great service and friendly.

Delicious food, wonderful staff! We have been going for years, entire menu is amazing!

Some of the best sushi in the Tulsa area. Try the unique rolls but the Salmon Poke bowl is incredible.