Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Carol’s On The Water

    3.7 (18 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Carol’s On The Water Photos

    CAROL’S ON THE WATER ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Carol’s On The Water

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos - Carol’s On The Water

    Stuffed portobello. Looks really good. Our friends ordered it. They said it was good.
    Scott Y.

    Went there for dinner tonight. This place has great potential and they are definitely going in the right direction. Great location, view. The 4 star review is more aspirational at this point. But I think they can get there and beyond with a little time.They have only been open about a month. First the good news. As mentioned, great location and setting. Menu was smallish but still a good selection for anyone to find something they like. I much prefer a smaller menu that a place can execute vs a place with a huge menu that you just know the place won't be able to execute. Prices were VERY reasonable. We ordered the fried calamari appetizer. Very good. Crispy. Real squid and not the cheap cuddle fish other places pass off as "calamari". Then I had the chicken shwarma pita. Very good. Nice Teziki. A unique dish for this area. Really appreciated that. My wife got the zucchini pasta with shrimp . Looked very bright with fresh ingredients. She said it was very good. The only issue was that the menu called them Jumbo shrimp and they were not Jumbo. They were nice shrimp. Not small, but not Jumbo. This is a big no-no for shrimp efficianatoes. Just take the word "Jumbo" off the description. The dish and shrimp were still very good. Again, unusual menu options for this area but well executed and much appreciated offerings. Prices were super reasonable. Good portions. Byob is of course always a plus. Now for the areas that could probably use some work. The staff was young and inexperienced. It seemed one of the ladies had more experience than the younger folks and was covering for them. This will come along with time and a little extra training. The decor on the inside can definitely use a little more zip (some warmth with color and accents). I'm sure they are aware and have plans. These things take time. They will get there. Bottom line is that this is a great place/option to have in the area.Good food. Great location. Good portions. Super reasonable prices. It's definitely worth checking out. I'd advise making a reservation for peak times if you wanna be on the deck.

    Thai Wings

    I had an unforgettable dining experience at Carol's on the Water. The waitstaff was not only amazing but also attentive and welcoming, adding to the overall enjoyment of the evening. The food was simply incredible, with the Thai wings being a standout dish that I couldn't get enough of. My daughter's favorite, and my close second, was the special appetizer, arancini. And of course the view of the lake, which somehow surprised me with how breathtaking it was. Being on the deck makes you feel like you're in the middle of the lake. I highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for a great meal with a fantastic ambiance.

    Pizzetta

    See all

    9 months ago

    Helpful 11
    Thanks 1
    Love this 10
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 17
    Thanks 3
    Love this 17
    Oh no 1

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 2
    Photo of Scott Y.
    74
    70
    546

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Showed up for a birthday lunch during scheduled hours but they were closed. No one answered the phone. Oh well...

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Tasty food, the nicest servers, and a beautiful setting. 11/10 would recommend. Thank you for a great evening

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Carols On T.

    Carols On T.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of T O.
    0
    15
    1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Carol’s On The Water

    You might also consider

    Pren

    Pren

    4.5
    (191 reviews)
    6.9 mi
    $$

    We had lunch in this homey, charming little restaurant in Chester. The staff couldn't have been…read morenicer- they happily answered our questions about some of the items on the menu. I had the Smashed Sweet Potato Burger which was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had!!! A delicious brioche roll was filled with two patties made from sweet potatoes and spices, covered in pistachios and crispy shallots, then drizzled with honey. Even a non-Vegan will love this. The standard looking French fries were anything but- they were crispy and delicious with just the right amount of sea salt. The chicken tenders were cooked perfectly and seemed freshly made not frozen. Everyone had to have a taste. The dessert was the showstopper- citrus olive oil cake topped with whipped cream and orange zest. The texture was amazing and it was incredibly delicious. My young grandson had a dish of vanilla ice cream, which also looked standard until you tasted it- super creamy with a strong vanilla flavor that was really outstanding. Everyone enjoyed their meal, which was reasonably priced. I honestly can't wait to go there again. Located off the Main Street , it is easy to miss but be sure to seek it out- you won't be disappointed.

    Stopped in today and had such a lovely lunch! A few items were sold out, but there were still…read moreplenty of great options to choose from. We ordered the cornbread special, the porchetta sandwich special, and the biscuits and gravy. Everything was fresh, filling, and delicious. The porchetta sandwich was flavorful, though I personally found a few pieces a bit fatty with some skin, which wasn't my preference. The biscuits and cornbread on the other hand were fantastic! I also loved the cozy setup inside and the fun idea of having games to play while you dine. The staff was friendly and helpful, which made the experience even better! 4.5! Can't wait to come back and try more

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Blueberry pie
    Blueberry pie
    Note: freshly made items may take longer to prepare

    See all

    Note: freshly made items may take longer to prepare
    The Sizzle BBQ

    The Sizzle BBQ

    3.9
    (143 reviews)
    4.9 mi
    $$

    This place said, "Why choose a country?" and I respect that. Argentinian + Uruguayan…read morebakery/restaurant... with a Mexican corner on the menu just to keep things spicy. So yes, by my highly scientific logic, this is also a Mexican spot. The decor definitely leans Mexico, heavy, which its amazing, kept reminding me of my favorite Mexican restaurant. But anyway, we're not here for interior design, we're here to eat. There's a LOT going on here, menu wise and vibe pwise, but in a good way. I ordered the Sandwiches de Miga 'Olímpico' and if you haven't tried them yet, that's a personal failure you can still fix. They're a must. Soft, classic, comforting... except for the edges. The edges were... questionable. Hard/frozen-ish. Not blaming anyone directly, maybe the fridge settings were on "Antarctica," maybe they weren't fully thawed. We'll never know. But that first bite hurt emotionally. It was like ordering a burger without pickles, taking a confident bite, and BOOM! pickle. Suddenly your whole day shifts slightly off center. Service wise: the guy at the counter stared at me, I started my order with zero greeting, felt like human self checkout, and I'm fine with that. Sometimes you don't want conversation, you just want carbs. Despite the frozen edge plot twist, I'm 100% coming back. The food has real potential, the place has character, and I need to try their asado.

    We ordered Argentinian food for a party, empanadas and miga sandwiches. The empanadas were not as…read moreordered. We special ordered them but lacked almost everything we ordered. Pathetic.

    Photos
    Private Events
    Private Events
    The arrival of The Sizzle Bakery, our new Argentinian-Uruguayan bakery inside The Sizzle BBQ! Facturas in Hackettstown, Warren County, NJ.
    The arrival of The Sizzle Bakery, our new Argentinian-Uruguayan bakery inside The Sizzle BBQ! Facturas in Hackettstown, Warren County, NJ.
    Private events

    See all

    Private events
    Black Forest Inn

    Black Forest Inn

    3.9
    (452 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    All the food was excellent. Beautiful presentation the pride the chef has for the food he sends out…read moreshows the love and passion shows Its always an honor to sit down and eat such wonderful dishes put together the menu was perfect we picked a tasting menu which was perfect so i can taste a more variety of German dishes in small portions. I highly recommend black forest restaurant The soup really packed with flavor we had to order two pints to go. Soup and lobster bisque The ambience of this establishment is cozy quaint lovely, beautiful, very beautiful atmosphere. Nobody's loud obnoxious place right now is becoming full. All the workers are very professional the young men and women probably from the Neighbourhood. This is such a great place that even gives young people the opportunity to work these young men and women in this place really work hard and you can see that they're proud to work here and they take extra to provide excellent service impressed with Black Forest restaurant. My compliments to the chef for excellent cuisine and my heart to all the employers who showed nothing but professionalism and establishment I also would like to thank the young man Zion for his professional and courteous service. Well presented with clean uniform prompt service Thank you Zion for your table service in your mannerism and thank you so much for making it pleasant for my wife and I You're truly a great representative of the establishment that you work in. I hope your bosses notices that you are very valuable employee as I can see for myself as a retired professional chef for 37years thank you Yours truly chef Ramos.

    I was fully prepared to come in here and unapologetically grade on a curve - I always feel a little…read morebad for this area of NJ when it comes to the gastro scene, and I want to support a legitimately unique enterprise like this. This was, sadly, not a good meal and based on expectations easily one of the most disappointing experiences I've had in recent memory. I came here yesterday with my top-tier chum from the Kingdom of Sussex, along with my #1 Honorary Young Pup Chum, fresh off a 20-mile walk down the Sussex Branch Rail Trail - so a bit tired and very hungry. Black Forest got me (and my appetite) in the best situation for them, in theory. Unfortunately it stayed just a theory. The atmosphere in here by far is the biggest selling point. I love a good taxidermy situation, and this place had it in droves. We were seated near a bear, and had eyes on numerous other wildlife, preserved for eternity. The stained glass throughout the restaurant is also pretty wild - it feels like you decided to go to church in a European hunting lodge. It's also deceptively large in there, which I discovered later as I tried to locate the bathroom (there is no signage for that) and wandered into two or three different dining rooms. Just wild and really does set this place apart from virtually any other restaurant in the area (maybe the far superior Walpack Inn can lay a claim?). I was intrigued by the Potato Pancakes w/ Applesauce on the appetizer menu, which ended up being the best item I ate. As you can see in the attached photo, they're basically big hash browns. They were good, and the applesauce made for an interesting palate combo. In what ended up being a bizarre theme throughout the meal, the accompanying applesauce came in a small plastic container that you had to open. This to me is one of the more egregious self-inflicted wounds I've seen from a restaurant, but also pretty fixable. This wasn't a crab shack at the beach or a taqueria in Newton - this is a restaurant with white tablecloths. Why aren't you serving the accompanying sides in a nicer dish, like a ramekin? What makes it more mystifying is that they HAD ramekins or something similar - they served the wrapped butter for the stale dinner rolls in it. I genuinely don't have a clue what the thought process was, but it honestly cheapened the optics and is something they should stop doing immediately. For my entree, I went classic German with the veal wienerschnitzel and a side of spatzle. The wienerschnitzel itself was fine - I've honestly had better from a food truck in Jersey City called Mordi's (I just checked and sadly they've closed), but it had no sauce or anything so it was super dry and overall not that tasty as a result. It would have even been an upgrade to get one of their infamous plastic containers of basically any condiment. The spatzle was honestly terrible; I had an excellent version of this at an Austrian restaurant in FiDI called Schilling (which has now converted to a French restaurant, apparently; I can't with these closures. Lord.), and this was just utterly tasteless. My chum likened it to "brain noodles," meaning the noodles you'd use in a blindfold game around Halloween. Fair, but even some of those probably had some flavor to them. Huge miss. I'm not sure why I kept going at this point but I decided to end this situation with the Black Forest Cake. It was a little stale (maybe it's kept in the same area as the dinner rolls?), but it was okay. Could have been worse, so I'm taking that as a victory of sorts. The chocolate mousse within it got positive remarks from my other dining companions in the context of their items, so that's probably the play if you're hitting up the dessert menu. The service was mediocre. Our waitress was very nice when she came to our table, which was infrequent. It seemed like she was waiting for food to come out (which took a while) as the context for a visit, rather than taking initiative to check on us. The Young Pup Chum waited close to 15 minutes for a second soda, which shouldn't have happened, especially given that we were there at a VERY slow time (just before 4pm). And the price point was honestly close to insulting. Neither of us are opposed to plunking down some Jacksons for a nice meal, but getting a bill for $200 (plus tip!) for not great food was not a fun feeling to close out our afternoon. I hate to end this on a dark note, but given that my two recommendations for German food in the area have both closed, you might not have much of a choice but to come here if you're hankering for schnitzel.

    Photos
    Black Forest Inn
    Our newly renovated casual pub
    Our newly renovated casual pub
    Our Seafood Medley

    See all

    Our Seafood Medley

    Carol’s On The Water - tradamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...