Food and service were excellent. Generous portions of delicious food. Nice cheese and ice cream shop next door. read more

If you're a horror or Halloween lover like me, you absolutely HAVE to check this place out. The decor and ambiance are SO fun -- it's such a vibe from the second you walk in. They have the cutest (and funniest) menu with items named after monsters and horror characters, and the prices are actually very reasonable. I ordered the **Nosferatu** -- a turkey club with sweet potatoes -- and it was DELICIOUS! Great portion, too. It's a smaller place, so definitely expect it to be busy, but we got lucky and grabbed seats at the bar. The staff was super friendly, and even the little touches were adorable -- like the bills being placed inside empty Halloween VHS tapes! I seriously loved EVERYTHING about this place. The food, the atmosphere, the decor, the spooky vibes... all of it. Can't wait to go back! read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Missy has a wide variety of meals and they are pretty comforting. I enjoyed the tots and pancakes. The portions are really filling. The server was attentive and accommodating. This place is unique and has goth decor. read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Most amazing breakfast and lunch creations ever! We've been to Missy's more times that we can count! Wonderful staff and food. A spooky, home run every time! read more

See all

Tiny place. Excellent food and service. Super fun horror movie decor. My wife and I go every few weeks... it is that good.

Do you like to take walks on the WILDSIDE? How about ghoulish encounters of the third kind. Missy's is a New Jersey themed horror show cafe and a local favorite. The walls are covered with photos of horror movies past. It's a cafe that would make Bela Lugosi and Elvira feel at home. When I stopped by on a cold Sunday morning the place was packed. The friendly host said it would be a 45 minute wait and she was right. I ordered the waffle with raspberry syrup and a cup of coffee and the bill came close to $20. The food and service was good. Next time I'm thinking about the "New Jersey Devil Bites" and "Th e Black Garlic Mash". Yes, the food is theme named. They offer breakfast & lunch specials. read more

See all

Good food. Tastes healthy and light. Interior is pretty cool and friendly service. Place is little small so prepare to wait a bit.

Missy's Main Street Café was a pleasant experience. I enjoyed all of the quirky spooky movie decor and the unique names that they gave their menu items. Their hard working staff does an outstanding job at seating customers and satisfying the continuous flow of hungry patrons. If you prefer bar seating, it is available. Each entree portion was large, cooked to perfection, and thoroughly enjoyed. We had the following: The Toxic Avenger (Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, pepper jack, lettuce, and ranch dressing), French Toast with a side of turkey sausage, and the Yummy Mummy Omelette (Tomatoes, scallions, American cheese, Noopy (1,000 Island) sauce, potatoes, and rye toast. My rye toast was one of the best I've ever tasted and buttered to perfection. I highly recommend Missy's and will definitely return to enjoy another memorable meal. read more

See all

It's a small family diner with a cool Harry Potter atmosphere inside. Our server was wonderful and the food was really good. read more

See all

Outstanding! 11:30 AM on a random Tuesday morning--many restaurants would be watching the last of the breakfast customers leaving, and hoping someone would be showing up for lunch--but Missy's is full, every seat taken and others waiting to be seated. Why is that? Because the food, the quality and the service are THAT GOOD! The breakfast and lunch SPECIALS are amazing creations! And even the portions are outstanding! After two people ate as much as they wanted, there was still a big container to go home! We just love everything about Missy's Main Street Cafe!!! read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Generous portions = great food to go home - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Was just ok for us. We were expecting a lot more after the glowing reviews. Food was just basic.

Now I understand why people are waiting to get inside ! This is a foodie delight with a creative horror decor which is fun . I got the grilled cheese with caramelized onions delicious ! It was to die for no pun Intended ! What a gem ! Look forward to coming back ! read more

Visited this cute place years ago and came back for lunch. They offered breakfast and lunch menus and we all seemed to enjoy what we ordered and said it was very good. They had inside and outside tables, street parking, and friendly staff. They do not take reservations....but we would come by again when possible. read more

See all

Love this place! The food is so yummy and the staff is really nice! You just have to keep in mind it's a small space and they get full really quick. I've seen the waitresses do their best to accommodate people but they only have so many tables to work with. And obviously the horror decor is fabulous! read more

Food is always 10/10, never misses! Call to get on waitlist. Fast quick easy service. My favorite thing ever is the Michael Myer's Melt. read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Michael Myers Melt - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

We eat breakfast there and everything, the food and the service is great. Very interesting ambiance

Another Review from a poor man. I will do the pros and cons about this place Pros. The food, service, and atmosphere of this place is great. The wait staff are nice and as colorful and eclectic as the decor. I had gotten the Ch ch ch ah ah ahhmelette with a substitution of caramelized onions instead of home fries on the side. The omelette was very tasty. The caramelized onions were, quite possibly, the best I have ever had! The unsweetened iced tea was good and was definitely made in house. The cons. The space is very small and can get crowded very quickly. So you might need to wait for seating. The only other issue I had was when I got my bill and they made a 14 dollar omelette and charged me 24 bucks because I asked for side of caramelized onions instead of the standard home fries. I protested because there is zero reason to make it that much and if it was going to be that much of an up charge, I should be informed before it. With some protesting I got the bill down to 17 dollars (even though that math still doesn't make sense to me). Although the bill left a horrible taste in my mouth, the omelette did not. So overall, a good experience and definitely one I would suggest checking out for breakfast or brunch. (Just pay attention to your bill). read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - The Ch ch ch ah ah ahhmelette (with a substitution of caramelized onions instead of home fries. 7 grain toast. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Small casual place, about ten tables and five counter seats. We had to wait about ten mins which isn't bad from what I've heard it could be. However, their system of making sure people are sat in order should be used. When we first walked in the one girl just told us to wait as they had people leaving in the next couple of minutes. But there were people who came before us and then after us and then when another girl walked over she was trying to figure out who came first and had to back track through the four parties standing there at the time. Food was decent. I would go back to try other things. The PB&J French toast could have used more peanut butter, but I loved that you had different options of jelly to choose from. My husband's waffle came with raspberry syrup which he did not use so I see for my French toast which was amazing. Jersey Devil bites were our favorite part of the meal! read more

See all

My wife and I headed to the area to check out a nearby thrift shop. Obviously that's an excuse for me to send her three or four Yelp recommendations for nearby lunch. Having not spent a lot of time in the surrounding area, it was a good opportunity to see how beautiful it is. Kind of area that makes you start wondering about real estate prices, even when that's an unrealistic dream. We both knew pretty quickly that Missy's was our choice, everything about it screams fun and food focused. By the time we arrived on a Saturday at about 1:30, the place was full and we lucked into bar seating. They're a luncheonette style place, closing at 3 each day and serving breakfast and lunch throughout the day. Each and every staff member treated us like a regular, from the moment we walked in. They were quick with recommendations, although it's the kind of menu where you'll be tempted by every item. My wife selected a Big Mac inspired wrap with a side of tater tot's and absolutely loved it! I went with a dish that I had seen on Yelp, the Black Garlic Smash. It features sunny side up eggs, Taylor ham, onions, and a black garlic hot sauce over perfectly crispy tater tot's. It also includes a couple of slices of buttered toast. I'm a sucker for a savory dish on a breakfast menu, this one cannot be beat! Absolutely delivers just enough heat from the hot sauce and the ingredients come together so well! The ambiance is perfect, I was wondering if it would be a bit over the top with the horror theme but it wasn't. Just enough to add character to the place. Obviously I've been gushing and adding to the nearly 700 perfect reviews that they have at this point but I would close with, the people that work there take the place over the top. We found ourselves discussing music and hockey with a waitress we had just met. Absolutely a great experience! read more

See all

deceptive deliciousness tucked away in a quirky lil jersey horror movie themed restaurant. as soon as you walk in you're sweetly greeted &offered coffee as you wait. once seated (tight yet cozy) i ordered the JB black garlic smash aka the real reason i saved this place to my must try list! & yes... you MUST try it, absolutely smackinggggggg & well worth the visit. i enjoyed the many hints of horror splashed throughout the decor (love a place with a theme) & the little details like the check mailboxes which you can use to signal you were ready. if you're in the area, check them out! read more

See all

Here's the deal. Still amazing after multiple visits! Service was great! Love that their outside tables are dog friendly. Be prepared to wait for a table. read more

See all

While traveling I was perusing Yelp really looking for an espresso. Though Missy's doesn't serve espresso, the reviews and pics for Missy's made me want to stop. Our food was very, very good and didn't take too long to come out. I'm not going to jump on board with all the rave reviews for ambiance, service, and food though. The service was "ok", it's small and has only 2 tables outside, and the ambiance cute enough... not anything to write home about. As stated, the food was good, there were some vegetarian options- I wish there were a few more. read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

AMBIANCE: I'm not a fan of Halloween themes in general BUT in comparison to others I've been to it was good. missys leans more into movies and not into gruesome or devil themes. FOOD: I was expecting basic diner food but it tasted and looked really good . Great presentation and the server Austin was great, explained everything for us well and was super quick read more

The food at this local small business is always excellent I love their specials. I had the Evangeline's Stuffed Frenchy: Two Thick Fluffy Slices of French Toast Stuffed w/ Hazelnut Spread & Massacre Manor Strawberry Sauce Topped w/ Whipped Cream & Dusting of Powdered Sugar. It was superb. The service is always great. The coffee is great. The ambiance is Halloween themed. It's small inside with less than 10 tables inside and also counter service. This is my favorite place to eat at when visiting my dad in Wharton. I continue to return and highly recommend it. read more

See all

Warm atmosphere, great attentive service and surprisingly good food. Warm friendly greeting as soon as I entered, but I wasn't in a rush because I was busy mesmerized by the decor, creative, homey, Halloween themed right down to the Beetlejuice video box containing the final bill. I ordered the delicious garlic mash with perfect sunny side eggs, Taylor ham and tater tots. Very generous portions and homemade iced tea. The one downside was the coffee was a little weak for me, but that's a personal preference. I love a place that respects its customers by providing fresh authentic inventive real food at affordable prices. It's a gem. I'm returning with family and friends. read more

What a unique find. We wanted to support a local business and were not disappointed. The decor is all Halloween. The menu has both breakfast and lunch choices. I went with special and my hubby got the breakfast platter. The wait staff was very quick and the place was packed for Thursday. read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Breakfast platter - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Always delicious and always friendly! This place has a special place in my heart. I got engaged at Missy's over bacon and eggs!

Always excellent. Frequent new menu items, many different interesting meals. No reservations, always busy, so it's best to go early or at off hours. Very much worth the wait if it is full! read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Scrambled eggs, bacon, home fries & toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Walked in and you can tell it's very divey and chill. Staff was super friendly and they had some background music on. They mentioned it's sometimes gets huge lines but I walked right in and had a seat at the bar no problem (guess I got lucky) The food was so good, waffle was soft and raspberry was a nice touch. Will be back to try the PBJ French toast and report back but definitely worth trying if you're in the area. read more

See all

Missy's used to be a great place to go for brunch. Recently we went and the eggs were undercooked, runny. They don't have a set platter for eggs, toast, meat and potatoes so had to order side of meat which I felt was odd. When we got the bill it was quite high for breakfast, over $40 for 2 people. Got charged 6.99 for bacon and then 6.99 for sausage which is wild. The only thing we enjoyed was the pankcake. Things have gone down hill big time and they charged more. Such a shame! read more

Another work trip to NJ led me to this gem cafe in Rockaway. The place is small, very cozy with wonderful staff, making everyone welcome. I didn't mind the 25 minutes wait as we could enjoy coffee while waiting. My server Kellye was awesome with the brightest smile. I enjoyed my lumbar jack, which was served with the most delicious sourdough toast. The whole experience was pleasurable, and I will definitely come back next time I come to Jersey. read more

See all

When Yelpers post 682 reviews and they are five stars across-the-board, one needs to pay attention! I think Missy's has been here forever. Every dish looked better than the last. I ordered the Miss-Griddle; two fried eggs, two sausage patties, and cheddar cheese nestled inside two pancakes. There was so much food, we could've split it and walked away sated. There was a sign on the bathroom door stating there would be a slight fee if one paid by credit card. I appreciated seeing it and also seeing it printed on the Bill. The difference was less than $.50, which felt fair. The server who took our order was the best! She was friendly, enthusiastic, engaged, and answered our questions. The server who took over was anything but. I got my coffee to go but couldn't find her long enough to get a box for my copious amount of leftover food. Check out the photo and you'll see how much food was left over. We were about to give up when another server came over with a container asking if I wanted to take my food to go. This is what makes this place exceptional. Great food and a fantastic staff. Thank you! A couple sitting next to us has been coming here for decades. In fact, the woman, who had to be in her 70s, used to come here with her father when she was a little girl! 'Nuff said!! She said that it is often impossible to get in. She says it's usually packed so I think the time of day made us lucky. Hooray! Definitely eat at Missy's! read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Miss-Griddle breakfast. Delicious and enough for two! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

A friend from the area told me I had to try out Missy's Main Street Cafe, so I stopped in for brunch on a Saturday. The line was out the door, so they took our number and said they'd call us when a table was free (estimated 1 hour). We went to go get coffee, and they called shortly after (20 min). We were seated quickly. It's a hole in the wall with lots of interesting decor. The waitress came with menus, and took our drink orders. The service is fast and the food comes out quickly. We ordered a number of different items, including the Nookie, JB Black Garlic Smash, Chuck Norris wrap, and Fleeky's Huevos Rad-Cheros. They were all really saucy, greasy, hearty, and tasty. We didn't end up finishing most of them because they were so heavy (minus the wrap). I'd go back if i were in the area, but not worth the drive for me. read more

See all

Really good service and even better food! I would definitely recommend- the place is small but has lots of character! read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Hot sauce wall for spicy lovers - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Before leaving beautiful Morristown New Jersey, I wanted to have a kick azz breakfast. My buddy says Crackerbarrel? I think of the Batman & Robin meme when Batman slaps Robin? I'd like to dine in a local Jersey cafe thankyouverymuch. I pull up to the restaurant and we're quickly shown to a window seat. We place our coffee orders and are given menus. The restaurant is decorated with eclectic items throughout, i can see its a fun space. It's similar to a restaurant near Atlantic City called "Shut Up and Eat". I stopped going because the owner took the shut up part a little too far and I almost slapped him in moms kitchen. Our friendly waitress comes over as she answers our questions. I have a question, what is Taylor Ham? It's like the room went quite! She touches my shoulder and says where are you from? You can't tell from this outrageous accent, New York! She explains the ham as my buddy orders a side of it with his meal. I ordered J.B. Black Garlic Smash, it's mash up of tater tots with eggs and chopped up Taylor Ham. There is a lot going on with this dish!! It's not thick like Canadian Bacon, I think Im a Taylor Ham Fan. The garlic drizzle brings a sweet heat, the J.B. Is fun and filling breakfast. Overall, I loved my waitress and the explanation of Taylor Ham. Next, I'll tackle what a Pork Roll is... read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

I'm not a big breakfast person but I really wanted to try out Missy's Main Street Cafe on E. Main Street in Rockaway after reading some recent rave reviews, most recently one by North Jersey Eats reporter Kara VanDooijeweert. A small, independently owned, homey, comfortable, casual, local hot spot, the eatery certainly lived up to the hype. The menu included a wide array of creative and tantalizing dishes. Service was super friendly and welcoming. Our server, Kasey, was phenomenal, and made us feel at home. I opted, at Kasey's suggestion, for the Miss-Griddle; Two Sausage Patties, Two Fried Eggs & Cheddar Cheese Sandwiched Between Two Small Buttermilk Pancakes, all Topped w/ Butter & Powdered Sugar. A great choice. It was between that and the Nightmare un Last Main St.; Chopped Steak, Scrambled Egg Flat, crispy Bacon, Carmelized Onions & Homemade Roasted Garlic Aioli Sandwiched on Grilled Sourdough Bread. I'll have to save that one for another day. My friend went with the Lumber Jack; 2 Eggs, 2 Pancakes, Homefries, with a Choice of Meat & Toast. Fun spot, highly recommended. I will be back for lunch in the near future. Thanks for the hospitality. 07/09/2024 read more

See all

Never disappointed when visiting Missys! Loved their BBQ chicken wrap with sweet potato fries! read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - BBQ chicken wrap with sweet potato fries - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

While, the atmosphere is absolutely adorable, and the service is even better, I have to say the food really wasn't very good. It was pretty average. Enough to the point where I probably wouldn't come back to eat, but I would definitely come to hang out. This place clearly is a staple of the town so I mean no offense. I'm not from up here so maybe that's where the disconnect is between the food I'm used to eating and what's up here. Again can't emphasize enough how great all the staff was! Very cute establishment, the food just wasn't for me read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Have been here several times and it never disappoints. From the service to the food even at its busiest the wait time is always worth it. Wish they would make the ozzy special a part of their regular menu because it was so good! read more

Missy's Main Street Cafe - Ozzy special burger - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Food is delish.. and actually got to meet missy herself who was a good time and great to chat with. Service was great even when they are busy. And the vibe is so my family.. read more