The Pizza was phenomenal. The meat lovers had quality meats including chunks of ham. The margherita pizza delicious. Pizza tasted just as good the next day. The Stromboli was perfect. The sauce that came with it was the best. Price very reasonable. I highly recommend Casa Calamari. Also The wings and sauce were the best I have had in awhile. Our new favorite restaurant. 2nd time...just as good as if not better than the first read more

We loved it! Great waitress, chicken parm and the grouper special were very good. We will tell friends and definitely come back!

These guys were super! We were buying dinner for our family after a long day on the road and wanted some seafood! They were the "bomb". While it's Italian and seafood menu had me questioning where the it would be may good . . . It was off the chart good! Green Fried tomatoes with Balsamic vinegar! Fried shrimp, pasta - all yummy! read more

Shrimp scampi is delicious with a good volume as well. I appreciate that we got a 20% discount because we check in with the Yelp program. That is very sweet read more

We were looking for Italian and headed here. The food was delicious, our server Coretta was excellent and the prices fair. We will be back. Thanks! read more

First time here. We will be back! It's deceivingly roomy inside with an open airy feel. It can be loud but not intolerable. Still has China Virus spacing so lots of room between the tables. We had Caprese to start. Could have used more seasoning (vinegar and olive oil) but was overall good. The salads were fresh and the Caesar's was quite tasty. We had the baked ziti (excellent and a huge portion) and Cavatelli with sausage and broccoli. The sausage was well seasoned but the cavatelli was just a little bland. As this was the first time for the dish as well I will give it a passing grade. Prices were not outlandish, the service was prompt and friendly. Bill for two was $60. ( no alcohol) Bottom line is it's worth a try and we will be back. read more

So So GOOD... just visitor here .. but for all you residence... great place !!! We went at 4:30 1/2 price meals and happy hour what else can you ask for ... great food and service read more

See all

Absolutely amazing food and service!! I have loved this place since they opened. The best Italian food you will find anywhere y'all!!

Closed for no particular reason. No explanation nor any apologies. Messed up my plans. Business posted it closes at 10pm but my family and I were there at 7:50pm. Not acceptable. Never going back there. read more

Great atmosphere Extensive menu Very reasonable prices Great NY style bread with optional oil /garlic/cheese Fresh delicious salad with wonderful homemade Greek and or Italian dressing Wonderful Red & White Sangria Delectable Chicken Marsala and Chicken Sorrentino with side of creamy risotto (dishes and sides we chose) Free desert for birthday chose Limoncello Cake which was to die for VERY AMAZING SERVICE I feel the need to put the word out on this hidden gem. I only found it because I was looking for a nice Italian Restaurant and found many great reviews online. I have passed this place many times and never noticed it. We were treated like royalty and all requests (we can be picky) were honored with absolute enthusiasm. The best Italian food I have had since moving here from NYC in 2012. read more

Casa Calamari was absolutely delicious. A great little gem off of hwy 17, Myrtle Beach. Our waitress, Karla was wondering! Will definitely be an every year visit for us! read more

Very good! Truthfully a surprise. Had Calamari (of course) fresh cold salad ( salad must be cold for me). My wife had pasta carbonara and I had the steak & shrimp with garlic sauce. All worth ordering again. The wait staff seemed busy multitasking which is unfortunately common these days read more

Casa Calamari was not a good experience. We had a lovely day at the beach and the day came to our demise when we dinned here. The man showing us to our table didn't say a word to us and gave us quite a wobbly table. It took almost 30 minutes for our drink orders and another 20 minutes to receive the drinks. It then took an hour from the time we got there to get our food. Now listen, the food was bussin, the service, not so much. There was also a screaming child you kept interrupting our meal. ps- don't get the chicken daniela, it's gross. read more

Had a great dining experience here Friday night. It was out first time at this restaurant, and we wanted Italian food as our plans to go to Sole had fell through. The salad was so fresh! Sorry I find fresh salad a good thing, not pre made in a fridge. My wife has the lasagna and I had the Chicken Alfredo with broccoli. Both very good! Our server Grace was so nice and very attentive to our table. I recommend you to try this place, with hopes you will like it. read more

They seated us quickly. The food was great. No complaints at all. We were serve quickly. Got the appetizers first, then the side salads came out, They served bread with the meals. Very very good atmosphere. read more

Excelente food and friendly staff. I went with a big group of people and every single one of us loved the food. Their coffee is also amazing! read more

Got this Togo last week. Delicious and quick. We got a pizza and a Stromboli. Awesome is all I got to say. A must go or to go!

Very good food. The staff there are very nice and always make sure you and your guests are taken care of..always the best take out pizza and dinners :) read more

Good luck getting you food in a timely manner. We were the only people in the place and placed our order at 6:30 and got our soup 45 minutes later. Now at 7:30 still nothing. I would comment about the food but unfortunately it still has not arrived. Other people who came in after us just got their food. read more

Casa Calamari - a table with glasses and a plate of food - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

I took a group of 60 here. They don't usually open at lunch, but they will for large parties. This restaurant was fabulous during the planning and, the day of the lunch, they were so efficient, it was fabulous. Their food is excellent and the staff is fabulous. Great place to take a group of people. read more

Everything was good, but they played really sad music and it really got to me. The problem was that I recently lost my father and everything reminds me of him and half the song that were played were also the the songs that were played at his ceremony. #tragic read more

Ordered thru door dash at Casa Calamari- food was delivered promptly and it was hot- Quality of food is delicious-and i am Italian so i know what is good and what isn't - Bravo to the owner and chef - We will continue to support you during is very difficult time- I ordered the Veal Parmesan - it came with a fresh salad and penne pasta in sauce - large portion and very delicious My husband ordered the Spaghetti with bolognese sauce - also came with a salad -he also order an appetizer of escarole and beans - both were delicious thank you again doreen w read more

Food is always great !!! We always enjoy eating here, tex we are locals and bed. Coming since they opened.

The food was absolutely delicious however heather our waitress was rude, not talkative and looked like she wanted nothing to do with our table or our money, the bus people left our dirty dishes from the appetizer all over the table and never removed a thing we had to ask them to take our used plates which is terrible when your a waiter or waitress, they looked at us scolding my and didn't care at all. After we ate as we were leaving they didn't say thank you for coming or anything like that instead looked at us like we were scum. Great food terrible wait staff, and an experience is only as good as the front of house. Definitley don't reccommend if you wanna feel happy and delighted read more

Everything was delicious! Tortellini with garlic Alfredo was great! Michael Angelo! Bread and pasta faglioli was good and the bread all excellent read more

This is a hidden gem of a restaurant. We have dined there a few times. It has become one of our favorites. Spacious and clean dining area and a nice bar. The food is served hot and the service is excellent. Many classic and new Italian entrees to choose from. Everything we ordered was delish. read more

Always amazing Lasagna, salad, and bread. Tonight they were challenged with a really large Holiday group but they stepped up and provided great service and amazing food. As good as it gets, gotta come here! read more

Got very good pizza there a while back when we were renting nearby. Always meant to try it for dinner. Finally got around to it and glad we did. The staff was happy and attentive. The salad was crisp, fresh and cold. The chicken parm was so tender I never picked up my knife. Wife loved her manicotti. Will replace the chain place as our go-to Italian. read more

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!! This place is the place to go eat in Myrtle Beach, SC. The Maryland Crab Ravioli was so delicious but the real bomb was the Molto Meat Stromboli!!! Our waitress was so sweet, service was excellent. You will not want to miss this one. We are still thinking about this food and it is 3 days later. Be back real soon!!! Rudy and Barbara Diehl read more

Enjoyed a delicious Valentine's dinner with my husband and children. Food was delicious from the bruschetta to lobster ravioli! Very courteous staff and great job socially distancing customers to provide a safe and enjoyable dining experience! read more

I went there several weeks ago for lunch & they were not open til 4:00. Recently tried calling to see if they were open, no one answered & got a loud beep. Are they closed? read more

This place was great, moderately priced, good service. Food was fantastic, large portions. Good variety. I'll be back......

Literally one of the worst experiences we have had eating out in the area. We arrived at 7 and we were seating in the lobby....like they made a table for us in the lobby (it's not that it was super crowded but there isn't a ton of seating.) We were the only table seated in the lobby. They did tell us they were short staffed but that did not prepare us for the dinner that we had. To start, no one came to take our drink order for 15 mins, and they only came that soon because we went and asked about ordering drinks. After we ordered, it was another 15-20 mins before we got our drinks. When we ordered drinks, we of course also ordered apps and our food all at once since the whole restaurant only had 1 waitress. Our apps came out after we had been there almost an hour and we didn't have plates, drink refills etc. We again had to get up and ask the people working at the take out area for these items. Then 5 of the 7 meals we ordered came out about 1.5 hours after us being there and it wasn't until 45 mins after that that the other 2 meals came out. Of the 7 meals we ordered. 4 were pizzas and 2 of those were the 2 meals that didn't come out until 45 mins after all the other meals. When it did finally come out, one of those pizzas was half the size of the others. All were supposed to be the same size. At this point we has been there almost 2.5 hours and 2 of us were eating alone since everyone else had gotten their food 45 mins prior. We were frustrated and irritated. To top all of this off....the food was only ok (not that it would have made it worth it). When our bill finally came, they had charged us $10 more for the margarita pizza (which ironically enough happened to be the smallest one). It did have chicken added to it but that was only supposed to be $2 more. After getting the manager (who was only just indifferent...not apologetic or empathic for the experience) and having to show her the pizza and the price on the menu, we did get it for free. Due to us getting 1 of the 7 meals for free I thought about giving it 2 stars....but it still didn't deserve it. When we walked out it was 9:57.....almost 3 freaking hours and we ate at 9:30. Since we were in the lobby we watched LOTS of people come in and order or wait to be seated or whatever and end up leaving. They have 2 entrances which is super confusing and off putting. They also have a take out area....based on the 3 hour wait, they should stick to dine in or take out, they can't handle both. One person said he waited 45 mins for his bill. Almost everyone coming out said it would be their last time and that it was a bad experience. I for one can 1000% confirm we will never be back. Expensive, extremely slow, bad management, only okay food, and horrible atmosphere (at least in the lobby). At least the 1 waitress they had was nice and was trying. read more

I gave this 4 stars before because it was great!Today I ordered a vegetarian dish. I called to make sure the order was correct. They assured me I'd have extra vegetables but did not. Not worth the money. read more

Heard good reviews about this restaurant so we decided to give it a try. For Italian food it was pricey and everyone at our table (4) was wondering what the big commotion was all about. We all had the same thoughts - ok but we provably won't yback. read more

Food is always fresh !!! Best chicken parm ever!! Service is always exceptional. Definitely our go to for Italian !!

Don't be discouraged by the counter-serve look when you enter - there's a gorgeous bar and dining area just around the host stand. Service was great and the lobster ravioli was to die for. I hope to see this place take off! read more

Went for the 1st time tonite. Food was amazing and service was top notch. Can't wait to go back!

All I can say is that this is the real thing. Fantastic service great authentic Italian food. Large menu, great wines and drinks. Don't be fooled by the takeout section in front. Large dining area in back with large bar. We had Salmon, grouper, sausage and broccoli rabe and eggplant parmesan. Large portions well prepared. Lots of happy hour specials Monday thru Friday. We will definitely be back soon. read more

Absolutely the best Italian food in Myrtle Beach! Service was exceptional too!! Our new favorite Italian Restaurant! So many dishes to try!!! read more