Great service, huge tasty servings Friendly staff and food is freshly prepared and service was fast. Reasonably priced huge menu. read more

First time here. I guess they've been open for about four months now. Drinks are very expensive, so we ordered water! I started off with a guacamole, not the table side, so make sure when you're ordering guacamole that they don't give you the tableside because it's double the cost. The guacamole was OK, not enough pico mixed with it, no onion, no cilantro, and very puréed. The salsa was a bit too runny for me, not my favorite. I ordered a chicken dinner that had onions, mushrooms, and cheese on top with a side of refried beans, scoop of guacamole, and some pico de gallo. It was good, but very salty. My friend ordered a taco salad and as you can see in the picture, there was hardly any lettuce. I tasted it personally I thought it tasted like how I would imagine dog food tastes. She doesn't like to complain so she didn't say anything. I would have. If asked if I would come back, the answer would be no. There are too many other really good Mexican or Tex-Mex restaurants out there to go back to this one. read more

See all

New Mexican restaurant in the Vue hotel on US19 in Palm Harbor. Hearing mixed reviews I went to see for myself. I give them a solid 3 1/2 stars The exciting decor and vibe invites you in and makes you want to stay. Bright, colorful, fun, Day of the Dead Service was attentive. I will say walking in and watching servers walk around there could definitely be a more inviting behavior than there is but as far as having my order taken and delivered, no complaints. Food: Food was decent to good. Nothing that blew me away and I've definitely had better but still pretty legit and worth coming back. The classic margarita which I got for free with a Facebook coupon and was undrinkable. Really really bad. I've had not so great margaritas I would still drink this is the first margarita I've had where I just couldn't force myself it was that bad. Price: I got the chimichangas that These were good but very small especially for $20 There are other places in north Pinellas with much larger portions for less. If I come back I will probably get something different or only come for the specials that are more reasonably priced. While I was there somebody ordered the margarita flight that comes in the airplane and it included an entire show that was fun to watch. But they want $30 for it!!! Typically a flight of any kind is $12-15 I get the margarita flight at Bahama breeze all the time for half that price Overall it's a great addition to Palm Harbor and worth a visit My understanding is they also own Taco Quila in Clearwater read more

See all

This place is fantastic! Very well decorated. Valery went above and beyond to make our experience amazing. She even gave us a free tequila shot to welcome us in. The food portions were huge so glad and the quality was superb. Their happy hour is from 4-6 months through Friday too! Will def be back. read more

The restaurant is a beautiful venue, it is fantastically decorated with a very large dining area and also a very large bar. After you are seated you are given an extensive drink menu and separate large food menu along with salsa and chips. The servers are very nice and helpful, the server makes the tableside guacamole if requested and made to taste. The food is nicely presented and quite tasty. The refried beans are very different from most other Mexican restaurants, red tinged with a very nice flavor. Their salsa is not my favorite and tonight the chips weren't the freshest but having been here 3 times this is the first time with not great chips. Definitely recommend this establishment. read more

See all

Amazing new spot for excellent Mexican food in Palm Harbor. We were greeted warmly at the door, and led through a bright vibrant dining room to our comfy table. We had chips and salsa (if you as for the hot salsa...it IS HOT!) to our table within seconds, and were quickly greeted by Diego. He did an incredible job all night long, and was just full of energy and great vibes. We'd prob ask for him again he was so good!! We were there for happy hour, so go the 2 for 1 margaritas....and they were tasty!!! We also had their fajitas, which were ample enough for us to share (unless you're really hungry). Would like to have some shredded cheese with the condiments plate, but everything else was perfect. The interior was super bright and festive with tons of beautiful murals and colors throughout the area. The lights could be a LITTLE dimmer, but we loved the feel of the inside. Can't wait to get back again!! read more

See all

We were greeted with smiles and friendly faces. Quick to seat us and very helpful to tell us about the specials. Monday was a bogo night with fajitas and margaritas! Deigo was our server and he's was the best! The manager offered us the "HOT" sauce over the mild sauce that is offered with the chips. WOW! Hot a delicious flavor with a hint of smokiness. DELICIOUS!! Our fajitas were fresh and very hot with full flavor and char on the peppers and onions. The decor was extremely colorful and well done, nice tables, bright, red seating, etc. the murals on the wall are gorgeous!! They're having a grand opening on Sunday 1/4/2026. Stop in and help this new business succeed! Happy New Year See you Soon! read more

See all

Pricilla's customer service spot on Food great Ambiance very pleasant We are regular diners here read more

Excellent! Everything! I have been to quite a few Mexican restaurants but this one is one of the best I've been to . Highly recommended. read more

See all

I'm not a fan of Mexican food but the staff was lovely and helpful... LOUD but wonderful Mariachi band read more

Diet coke :-). Food was good service was great. Kind of a water view. Much better than the previous things here I hope they are successful. Levi was our waiter. Did well. read more

Casa Mateo - Christines protein bowl. It was good. - Mexican Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

We had a coupon and tried their tacos. The restaurant is beautiful with vibrant and bold paintings on the wall. There are different sections inside and outside. We had a table outside and were entertained by the alligators and turtles swimming in Lake Tarpon. Food was seasoned well. We will be back to try items off the menu. Raul was very friendly and attentive. read more

Casa Mateo - Mexican Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Edible but not what I'd call good Mexican food. Gawdy murals and lots of neon. No ty

We've heard a few positive reviews about the new restaurant. We were impressed from the minute we walked in. The photos I've seen on Facebook don't do this place justice. Beautiful, bright and clean. Very friendly staff. Delicious drinks and the food was better than expected! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Food was bland. Ambiance is great the restaurant is colorful and nicely decorated. Being on the water and watching the alligators is a plus. The service was very attentive. But the food was bland. read more

Awesome food and service! Atmosphere is excellent as well. This will be our new go to for Mexican in the area.

Went there with my daughter tonight to support our new latino local restaurant and were not disappointed. The ambience was better than expected with a water view which was a surprise to us. Larger than it appeared online..the margaritas were amazing, the food was delightful and priced reasonably. Now as far as the staff was concerned, Mateo , Jose and our waiter the young man who was so pleasant ..these wonderful people made us feel like we were at home. Thank you for the wonderful experience, we will be back and we will spread the word! Gracias por todo Mateo y Jose y que Dios los siga bendiciendo! read more

See all

Food is great. Service is excellent. The view of the water was unexpected. Unexpected and amazing

When I'm hungry for lunch or dinner I don't typically think of going to a hotel but this place is on a canal leading to/from Lake Tarpon in Palm Harbor. Boat docking was adequate and accessible with the water levels up and the weeds minimal but that can always change. The interior decor is very vibrant, bright and authentic Mexican with plenty of seating. We ate lunch with family that were visiting and everything we ordered was hot and fresh. The menu is extensive and I have never seen a drink menu with so many choices! Our waiter was very attentive and the food came out quickly. I would recommend anybody in the area to give this place a try! The only criticism I have is the entry when coming by boat could be improved, we had to step over a rat trap to enter the building. read more

I had enchiladas and rice and beans and it was delicious. The chips that they serve with salsa was also delicious. This is our second time eating at Casa Mateo and definitely recommend it. It's a little pricey, but it's worth it. The ambience is very fitting. If you sit by the water, you can see turtles popping up. Ivonne was also a great server! read more

Celebrated two birthdays yesterday with a party of 8. A new restaurant - fantastic. Loved the atmosphere. The entire staff is fun and friendly. The drink and menu has a large number of selections. Our food was simply delicious all the way around AND OMG, the portions are very large. We had about 7 go home boxes!!! Will be returning and spreading the word on this new (4 months open) restaurant. read more

We made a reservation back in March for my mom's 85th birthday. When we arrived, they told us that they messed up the reservation and the room was given to someone else. They offered another room with no a/c. We have to sat in the middle of the restaurant. Service was sooo slow. We had to ask for silverware, napkins. They told us because of another party, they needed to serve them first. I don't think that was right specially when we had 5 kids that were hungry. We asked for the manager 3 times and were ignored. I order beef flautas and was given chicken/shredded meat. I told them and only got apologies and not even an offer to get the right plate. On top of that, they charge me anyways for something I did not like/eat. Again, I will not recommend for big groups. Very disappointed. Don't know if I will go back. read more

The food and drinks were very good. Have tried several different things off the menu & was not disappointed with anything. Loved the atmosphere! Great place for a celebration or just a good meal. Friendly service. read more

Don't order the taco salad Watery-bean on bottom no ground beef Black berry margaritas was the bomb read more

Food absolutely excellent and generous portions Atmosphere is so cute especially sitting by the windows seeing alligators read more

I have eaten here twice since the Tarpon site opened. This is a great location near tarpon springs, easy parking, but easy to miss as the Hotel connected is the most visible from 19. The food is good, but pretty much like every other Mexican restaurant in the area. Service is excellent but as it is new most servers use English as a second language and that has caused some "order errors" that are happily and quickly rectified. If I had to comment on anything that needed more attention.... The chips...last night some were stale and no salt or flavor... try harder as this is the first food offering after being seated. Most Mexican RR around here offer chips that are really just off the shelf products. Perhaps be original. Here The salsa is good, both mild and spicy but the chips...2 out of 10... Summary...try it, nothing to blow you away but good food, friendly, quick and reasonably priced. Hope it succeeds I will be back. read more

Great service, outstanding dishes, best atmosphere. Mariachi on Sunday night. We love the place.

Never seen refried beans so pureed & red, food with so much color red. My sopes never ever did it have those beans in it. Not going back, drink was juice not a margarita read more

absolute awful food but the waitress was very nice.we sat outside and the only atmosphere was the water view.had the Monday special fajitas which had no flavor and the meat was dry.wife ordered enchiladas alacarte which they charged 4 dollars for and had no seasoning at all.The meal was served in 3 minutes which makes me question how much work the microwave is doing.i will never go back I can make the food at home tastier and cheaper.by the way 5 bucks for an iced tea that's crazy. read more

Great drinks ('driver for me, martini for my date), generous portions of good food. Service was fast and attentive. I had a fajita burrito, date had a taco/burrito combo. Both were large and tasty, and the rice and beans were good as well. Atmosphere is colorful, cheery, and clean. Plenty of good seats including some right next to the water. Definitely going back. read more

The decor, the staff and the food are fantastic. It's only been open since the first of the year and this place has got their total act together. I'll go again. read more

Fantastic atmosphere, delicious food & outstanding service. Our server Luz was fantastic - attentive, prompt with drinks & food & personable - everyone working seems to have the same great attitude. The queso fundido is sinfully delicious & the enchiladas supreme - enough for three people was fantastic! read more

this place is so beautiful! yummy food, quick and friendly service. the views from being on the water are gorgeous, and there's so many places to sit. love it read more

See all

My husband and I visited Casa Mateo for the first time. Ambiance is nice and bright. Greeted and seated right away. We tried the Spinach Chicken Enchilada and it was surprisingly delicious. We plan to come back by boat with our neighbors. It's definitely worth trying out especially if you have a celebration event. read more

Great service, menu selection is excellent, could dim the lights a bit but otherwise great!

Exceeded expectations. Love the vibe, lake views and the food was delish. A much needed fun spot in town. We'll be back!

Great Food. Great Atmosphere. Service is excellent. So many drink varieties. Will definitely be back.

New and a work in progress as of Jan 1, 2026. Clean and excellent service. Fresh Guac. made at the table. Everything in the dining area is newly updated since the previous restaurant moved out. Outside dining available and private room will be available soon. Owner and staff are very pleasant and attentive. Large selection of drinks and meals. read more

We celebrated my mom's birthday, the staff was great, friendly and just great service. Diego was our waiter he made sure we had everything from drinks chips and salsa and our food. He made the experience even better with him being polite and also very humble, he was the better waiter. The staff sang happy birthday to my mom too. This was a great experience. Ask for Diego read more