Really cute spot! They did a good job with the space. It doesn't feel like you're on Main Street (unless you face the windows lol). Walked right into our reservation and got delicious warm bread with truffle butter - they should sell that butter. Service was good, drinks were good, food was really yummy. Want to come back to try other things and also want to try other restaurants from the same group. read more

Casa Stellina - Polpette al Sugo - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

It's my first time waking in here and it been great the hospitality is definitely 10 I asked for something f simple as a whisky sour and it was on point Fresh bread o the walk in and was greeted at the door read more

Casa Stellina - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

The restaurant is classic and modern at the same time. The atmosphere was warm and inviting with modern fixtures. The food was exceptional! The variety was classic meals with a modern flare. The service was top notch and very helpful when you don't know what to order. The portions were well plated. His chicken parm was HUGE! I would highly recommend for a romantic date, special occasion or even a dinner to splurge. They also had a prefix menu on Sundays!, which my husband ordered from. read more

See all

A great variety of unique dishes in a stylish but warm setting. Attentive service. Great handcrafted cocktails. Gluten free options available. read more

See all

Me and my wife were blown away how good the food was here. Very authentic Italian food with a very intimate atmosphere great for date night. Ambiance and decor here is very intimate and great for special occasions or a date night. Staff were great dnd very attentive and the food was amazing! I'm a bone in veal chop Parmesan guy so once I see they add ricotta with mozzarella I was sold. For appetizers me and my wife got arancini rice balls that were great and the calamari was a home run. The calamari is fried in tempura and just flaky and perfection. My wife got a bolognese and she was in love. My bone in veal chop was 10/10 and I will def be back. The food here is a little pricy, but worth every penny! Very solid authentic Italian and steak house. Came here for my birthday and will definitely be back. Right off Main Street parking can be a headache but it's hit or miss! You might find parking in the front but if not there are Municipal parking lot you pay at around the corner from the restaurant. Great food and you won't be disappointed! This place is way better than vespe, which is another Italian restaurant on the corner. Vespe is good, but this place is more authentic Italian and dishes are executed way better. Highly recommend if you're in the area looking for good food! read more

See all

We have eaten here twice since they opened and both times were great. Food was good both times and the wait staff was very attentive. The price is a bit on the higher side, but it's a little more upscale inside compared to some of the other Italian restaurants on Main Street. read more

Casa Stellina - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Wanted to try Casa Stellina for happy hour. They have a few cocktails to select from, wine specials as well as some small plates, salads and pasta. A really great variety but the delivery wasn't really there for me. We started with espresso martinis. They were just standard so then I tried the blueberry Collins and really enjoyed that. For food we got the zucchini flowers. They were crispy and the sauce was very flavorful but they were definitely heavy. We also got the tricolor pizza. This was kind of disappointing. The dough was like too thick and not in like a crispy Sicilian way just wasn't it for me. Service was good and the place is really cute. They have other areas for large parties, but I wasn't really impressed. read more

See all

This is a great new addition to Farmingdale. My friend and I decided to have dinner here because the decor was so classy and chic. What we didn't expect was how wonderful the service would be too! Our waiter did an excellent job of checking on us frequently and giving great recommendations. As other reviews have mentioned, the food and wine were great and the portions were large. Seriously, the bread, the pasta, and the dessert were to die for. I will definitely be returning for a fancy date night! read more

See all

I went to this place after seeing it featured on the devour power YouTube channel. On the video they made it appear to be a casual kind of a really nice pizzeria place . The truth is it's not really casual. It's definitely more of a halfway formal upscale trendy kind of restaurant. Although they were very nice to me in my gym pants and hoodie...... my date was dressed a little nicer. Food is great, my guess is the lasagna has tons of reviews . On my way out, I noticed half the tables in the restaurant had one or more lasagnas on their table. That's what I got and I will tell you it is very good. My issue with the place was the service. Again, everybody was extremely nice. But when I went there, it seemed like we didn't have anyone whos primary job was to provide my table service. There were two girls one seemed to be primarily working the bar, the other primarily working the front seating people and stuff. Then there was a young gentleman, dressed in a suit who appeared to be the manager, perhaps an owner. Then there was a guy from the kitchen who was doing a lot of food running. And while everyone was willing to help me when I needed it, it didn't seem like anyone was keeping an eye on my table the way a server with my table would have. I had to actually put my arm up to signal for help more than one time because the 4 people were all going by my table so quickly and not even glancing in my direction to see my cup was empty, or that I was looking around for help. That being said, I would highly recommend trying this place because the food was outstanding and the people were very nice. I just hope the not so great service thing was kind of a fluke that doesn't happen on a regular basis. read more

See all

The meat lasagna is essentially meatless and the pasta is mushy, the pizza were just okay Not worth the price my local pizza place is just as good and the whole pie is larger and cheaper.... It may be better dine in but not on my list as I was very disappointed read more

Casa Stellina - Lasagne - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

At Casa Stellina in Farmingdale NY. Stopped in for a meal. They note it as traditional meatballs and tomato sauce/gravy. The meat is a combination of veal, beef and lamb. (See pix) The real Italian style very tasty foods. A bottle of sparkling water ($9.00) Capachino, and rainbow cookie donuts , gelato Ala mode. Their front windows open bringing a light breeze. The decor is simply effective. The waiter pleasant and attentive. I plan to go back another time and try some other things on the menu. read more

See all

BLUF: Grilled octopus, bucatini all'Amatriciana, chicken parmigiana, porterhouse, and pistachio gelato. All standout dishes. And if we stuck with those dishes alone, five stars aren't enough. The red sauce needed some depth of flavor which the guanciale and drippings rounded out perfectly. The fired rosemary on the steak Florentine was a nice touch. They put that garlic butter sauce on everything. You won't be disappointed here. Great find in Farmingdale. We opted for a round table, but it was in a booth, which wasn't very easy to sit in. Restaurant is beautiful inside. Service great. read more

See all

Every dish we have had here has been delicious. The apps, veal and. Chicken parm, pizzas, pasta are all amazing. We always want to try new dishes and are never disappointed. And the drinks are always are great pour and spot on. The staff is also so friendly and welcoming. Mikey, the manager, makes sure everyone is having a great time I can't say enough how much we like coming here read more

Service was great no waiting Food on the expensive side it was ok noting to rant and rave about went there with a group of six Unfortunate I got sick after my dinner next day very sick not sure of what maybe the cream in the pasta a la vodka was bad The deco of place was beautiful and my style would I go back no def not to pricey read more

We had the margarita pie as an appetizer. It arrived on a wooden board and we devoured it! So delicious and must have. Next we had the fried artichokes which came out hot and crispy We enjoyed the sea bass which was good. The Cacio Pepe which was really cheesy, the strozzapetri al Fume pasta which had a spicy kick but not overwhelming in spice and the angliotta veal stuffed purses which were truffle strong. We were stuffed to extreme and left stuffed. We are looking forward to returning soon! read more

Casa Stellina - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

The food was delicious. The service was excellent with attentive, courteous and friendly staff. The facilities were clean. The ambiance was lovely. Our family had a wonderful time. Keep up the good work. read more

I've been wanting to try this place for a while. Having just got back from Italy, I picked it as our Book Club dinner out. I am so glad I did. It was perfect. It's beautifully decorated, the staff is friendly, and the food is delicious. We all got their homemade pastas and were not disappointed. I'm looking forward to going back. read more

See all

Food was really good and fresh! Place clean and comfy. Trio pizza was on point, hot and tasty

Staff was kind and attentive ; lasagna was tasty but definitely not the best I ever had ( too much mozzarella , not enough noodle. However this does tend to be my general gripe when I order lasagne so it's probably just my quirkiness to want more pasta than cheese). Calimari was thick , juicy , plentiful, pleasing the whole table . A delicious green dipping sauce came with it . The desserts were so good and there were so many to choose from ! The ambiance was classy- makes you want to wear a pretty dress and fancy coat . I look forward to returning . read more

I've been here on several occasions atmosphere and staff are wonderful and the food is delicious. I've tried a variety of menu items everything is made with high quality ingredients. Nothing is over/ under flavored or salty which is appreciated. read more

See all

Casa Stellina in Farmingdale is a restaurant to try. The service and the food weas amazing. We had the Pappardelle Ragu and the Agnolotti, both were delicious. One of the Owners of the Sicilian Group, Mike made sure that everything was perfect. The restaurant has a nice beautiful decor with table seating. There is a nice bar in the rear. Parking in the village is a bit difficult but there is paid parking all around. Great place for friends and family to go to. read more

See all

Food fresh and delicious Service was on target I just did not like she added tip without telling us read more

Stopped by this new Pizza Shop. Some unique slices in the showcase- including various Neapolitan, square and NY styles. The staff was friendly, though the restaurant temperature was a bit warm. The chairs at the table were a bit dirty and we had to wipe them off. We ordered an upside down Sicilian slice. The slice was large and very inexpensive. The crust was light yet still had a nice crunch and the sauce had a refreshing nice tomato covering . The dough was light and airy. The workers were trying very very hard to please their customers. They offer free water. Definitely a place to stop by and try. read more

See all

The food was amazing and the service was excellent. Can't wait to go back and try other dishes as well. read more

Casa Stellina - Chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

Where do I start, I came to this location a year ago and the pizza was fantastic. I came back and they had completely changed to try and be some high end Italian place, completely abandoning what made the place good, the pizza. Replacing It with some half ass attempt at a flat bread. Sick to my stomach over this read more

Food (New Year's Eve) was excellent. Service was extremely good. Table (for 4) was a bit small. As with past visits, a great dinner.

Let me start by saying the gentleman on the phone who took our order was the nicest person I have ever spoken to ordering food at a restaurant. We ordered The Trio Roman style (1/2 size)and the Chicken parm w/garlic butter. Both were extremely salty. My tongue was tingling hours after eating. The chicken parm is well under the standard of an italian place...it truly tasted like a tyson frozen chicken patty drenched in salty sauce. The pizza was idek what to call it...so bad. Everything on Instagram looks so amazing and while it's very disappointing to spend any amount of money on bad food, spending $62 (not with tip) on a 1/2 size pizza and one chicken parm that was SO very bad is quite mind blowing. By husband said the actual restaurant was beautiful on the inside. But boy what a disappointment. I would think with such a limited menu they would have their food on point-but the food is not even decent and at that price point just plain unacceptable. It's also worth noting the google reviews are much higher and they have two google profiles with two different scores. I would not recommend going and I'm not a hater I just hate really bad food that looks amazing on social media. read more

How this place gets 4/5 stars is beyond me. We have eaten at the Oyster Bay location before and it was good so we expected the same from this place. First off the acoustics are horrible and then 4 dudes came in and sat at the bar basically screaming at each other so we could barely talk sitting across from each other. I said something to the bartender (we were eating at the bar) and she agreed they were loud but did nothing. (Where's the manager??) Sooooo let's move on to the food. I had the Lobster Fra-diavolo with pasta. The lobster was way over cooked, still in the shell, none of the guts of the lobster were removed etc..and it was sitting in a pool of grease and oil. The Fra-diavolo sauce was so hot it was almost inedible and was not made by an Italian chef for sure...How do I know this...? It had jalapeño peppers in the sauce...yes you heard that right..I don't know what kind of Italian chef would use jalapeños in an Italian sauce but none that I would ever let cook for me again. You don't even want to know what they charged for this mess. My buddy had a chicken parm that was mediocre at best...for $39......$69 for the veal parm..There is no way the place should be charging these kind of prices. The service was good other than the fact that they would rather let 4 drunks scream at each other than worry about their other customers. It seems to me the ''Stellina Empire'' has gotten too big with all their new locations and has outgrown their quality control. Sad used to be a good place, will not be back..We skipped dessert and went down the street to a rowdy bar where it was quieter. read more

My fiancé and I absolutely LOVED Casa Stellina! The food and drinks were delicious and all the staff were polite and attentive. We will definitely be back!! read more

See all

The restaurant is just gorgeous. The food is delicious and the wait staff were just great. Took my husband here for a Father's Day dinner and he really enjoyed his meal which was the lasagna. I had the chicken parm which was so yummy! My kids had a gourmet meal of tenders & Fries and they approved as well haha. read more

See all

Truly an amazing dining experience from top to bottom , beautiful dining room with enclosed outdoor patio, full service bar, Very impressive wine list, The staff and wait service were beyond accommodating and polite Marlon & Eric truly Exemplify first class service, Food was excellent , I especially enjoyed the grilled octopus, one of the best I've ever had, even though this is an Italian restaurant the porterhouse steak was even better than most steakhouses on Long Island, A nice dry rub with garlic butter, it was tender and juicy, Not only do they have an impressive wine list, but the cocktails were very creative , And also, they have more of the well-known cocktails, right next door, the family style pizzeria, they even own a café and bakery in oyster Bay and Syosset, all the desserts are obviously homemade from the bakery, also like to thank Mike, the manager very friendly, checked up on us regularly, as he did to all the customers In the dining room, The lasagna was very good just like any Italian grandmother would've made, they are bone in chicken Parmesan was crispy and delightful, I tried something different with an appetizer with a combination of shrimp and calamari, both grilled in a spicy Calabria sauce that was outstanding, They also had a fried artichoke ready to eat, peeled with a garlic, butter, dipping sauce, very good, and of course their signature meatballs are one of the best, pizza was nice and doughy top it all off with the Stelina martinis, and for dessert. The pistachio gelato in a semi hard shell was perfect for a warm spring afternoon, located right on Main Street. So, on every point, I recommend this place stop by you won't regret it And a thank you again to Mike for the chocolate cake & and the staff again for everything read more

See all

Overall a little pricey but typical of the modern dining experience... inconsistent but generally good size portions. No dish lacks in flavor.. Excellent service. Very clean but loud when it's busy. Have been there 3 times and rank it highly in Farmingdale.. read more

Awesome! .. In every way. Food was outstandingly delicious - Service was pleasant, thoughtful and very accommodating. Surroundings were relaxing and easy on the eyes. We will keep Casa Stellina at the top of our list when deciding where we'd like to go to enjoy a really special meal. read more

Had dinner with my son on a Wednesday night. The place was pretty busy - but it did not effect the service or quality of the food in the least. The service was impeccable. Out server, Nick, was attentive and thoughtful. The timing of the food was perfect. We didn't take pictures, but our specialty cocktails were great as well. This is a pretty new place in Farmingdale, though they have a location in Oyster Bay. we ordered: 38oz porterhouse Wood fired broccoli rabe Sauté of mushrooms Grilled slow cooked octopus Smoked buratta We also each got a Gentleman Fig cocktail - great! read more

See all

While the service was good the food was poor . It was too salty , skimpy in the portion for the price and overdone . We paid $420 without tip for a party of 4 and left hungry . The reviews that I read for this restaurant were obviously posted by the owners or employees . I would stay away from this restaurant. I give it 1 star and that's generous. read more

Food was outstanding. Ambiance really nice in private room. Service was friendly but Servers coukd've checked if Family style dishes were still desired. I think it's not a bad idea if there's significant food left to reduce the dish platter size & place it down shifting flowers/glasses carefully. My husband & I really dislike poor service where Servers forget to remove dirty plates before bringing the next course. Diners should not have to pick up anything. That makes sense. Guests are busy chatting so can't always just grab the new dish of shareable food. read more

They need to take care of the rodent problem. There was 1 that came out of the kitchen. When me and Amy wife got our table she noticed dropping near our seat as well. read more

This place is a gem and the food was absolutely incredible. We had heard good things but the food and service was just fabulous. Definitely a place we are going to be going to again for sure! read more

Fantastic. Very high quality food , service and atmosphere. Even my wife and kids loved it . its a little more expensive than some other Farmingdale restaurants but you get what you pay for . read more

I would give this place 3.5 stars. Pales in comparison to Stellina in Oyster Bay. My Old Fashion was underwhelming (too much ice and short pour). 4 of us shared everything. We had fried artichokes appetizer (good), Saute shrimp and calamari in Calabria sauce (good) and Bresiola pizza which was very good. For pastas we shared Bucatini A'Matriciana, The stuffed homeade pasta with veal, and Cacio y Tres Pepe. The first two were great but the Cacio Y Pepe lacked flavor (and quite frankly, pepper too). We also shared a bone in veal parm which tasted very good but was probably sitting out for 10 minutes before it was brought to our table. Not a bad meal overall, but am in no rush to go back with the surplus of good Italian restaurants in the area. read more