If you find yourself passing through Eagleville, Firehouse 54 is a total hidden gem. It's exactly…read morewhat you want from a small-town spot--great food, friendly service, and a local vibe that makes you feel right at home. The Food They are known for their hand-stretched pizza, and the crust is definitely the highlight. It has that perfect chew and char. The Pizza Bowls: A great option if you're trying to stay low-carb but still want all the pizza flavors. Taco Tuesday: If you're lucky enough to be there on the 2nd or 4th Tuesday of the month, the tacos are a must-try. Just a heads up--they usually only do tacos on those nights, so no pizza then! The Vibe It's a cozy, "hole-in-the-wall" kind of place in the best way possible. It's where the locals hang out, and the staff is incredibly welcoming to travelers. Because they are only open for a few hours in the evening (5 PM - 8 PM), it can get busy quickly, so showing up early is a good move. Things to Know Hours: They have a short window, so plan your drive accordingly! Parking: Plenty of easy street parking right in front. Takeout: They do a brisk carry-out business if you're just passing through on the I-35 and want a better meal than typical fast food.

Great spot! Pizza and cheese sticks were so good! Service was great! Love the history of this…read moreplace, it was fun reading the articles posted around the dining room. Oh! And they have a keto bowl option that I have never even heard of before at any pizza restaurant! W

I'm not sure who was working the evening shift on Mar 14, 2025, but my order was absolutely…read morehorrible. I just ordered a super supreme and a small personal, so not a complicated order, but it was really really bad.... I have gone there for years and it has been pretty decent most of the time. Definitely NOT 5 star, but usually 3 or 4. Tonight I'm only giving it a 1 star because I can't go any lower.... The pizza was cold and for some reason tasted stale.... Even the personal pizza I got for my kid was terrible. So, bland crust, zero salt... It only had half of the amount of toppings and cheese it should have. And over all tasted horrible. Unfortunately because there are not a lot of options in a small town, places like that tent to not care about quality or service.

I liked their buffet today, (Sunday in August 2023). I'm a veggie, no meat, thin crust pizza…read moreperson. I thought the waitress said that they had a thin crust on the buffet but I only saw one that had I think Canadian bacon there was an all veggie pizza but it was the thick crust so I chose it anyway. I thought the price was reasonable just under $11 included the salad bar but the iced tea $2.50.

Found hair in my daughters salad and on my plate with fried shrimp. $100.00 bill and they didn't…read moreeven offer to replace the food. Won't be going back

BAD Crust... frozen grocery store pizza crust is better. I make pizza at home and we eat pizza out…read morea lot. Cr@p crust and thin sauce was like watery tomatoes juice. Crust had zero flavor. And texture like stale bread. Generous amount of good toppings ,which is sad that it was ruined with bad crust. No other items we home-made (according to the server) on the menu. The fish looked like frozen type. This place was 90% filled with rhe 70 and older crowd. And they didn't have any draft beer...or orange slices for blue moon. If you care about your taste buds, don't go here.

Just what you want from a small town, family owned pizza place. We were there during the week and…read moreenjoyed their nightly buffet. They kept the drinks full and our stomachs even more full!

We were in town visiting family. We went to Pagliai's for dinner with two of the grands. We all got…read morethe buffet and it was great. The salad bar was fresh, nice and cold, and had lots of options. The pizzas were a great variety and we all enjoyed them. Their cookies for dessert were so good, chocolatey and chewy. Many of the reviews say folks had to wait for a table, but we didn't. Our drink orders were taken and filled quickly. We would definitely go back.

Whatever you do, do not ask the girl working the pizza oven how long till the next pizza is…read morefinished. I asked this very simple question and she responded extremely rudely stating it will be a while when all she had to do is say it will be six minutes. She had no reason to be rude to me. This was a total turn off. Next time I will go to Kum and Go.

This is a typical small town Casey's: a few fuel pumps on a small lot and a convenience store with…read morethe snack and drink basics. However, this location has a Subway style sandwich counter for made to order sandwiches, pizzas, and wraps. Clean restrooms and friendly staff.

Alaiha was such a pleasure to work with! I was being annoying and called 3 times with a bunch of…read morequestions and she was so polite and professional and didn't make me feel like a burden at all. She was so fantastic and helpful. When we picked up the food, the lobby was so clean! She gave me a Togo container for the salad bar, and all the veggies were so fresh and the whole salad bar was so clean. We are from out of town but we would come back just for the great hospitality if not the great food.

I would give no starts if I could. I was attempting to buy an item from someone and they said to…read moremeet at the this location. As I arrive I park in the parking lot. Within 5 minutes 2 state troopers drove by didn't even care I was there. Then I'm guessing the manager pulls up I'm thinking it's the person I'm supposed to meet. Tells me I'm "freaking out her employees" that I needed to leave I explained that I was waiting for someone and she still said to leave. I left peacefully but I will never eat here. Maybe get your facts before your employees start crying and freaking out over nothing.

Forever the best. This place has always had the best pizza. The crust is amazing and I'm so happy…read moreto taste that it's still the same! The Louisiana hot sauce tradition is alive and well and the place looks great. A little nostalgia & the best pizza in the world (I've checked.) I would drive hours just to get this pizza and really appreciate that it still lives up to the goodness of my high school and college years 20 years ago! Thank you all so much, my hometown needs the Pizza Shack and I'm so glad it's still there and still yummy!

A large 16" inch pizza with two toppings. Canadian Bacon and tomato. Is 28 dollars now. It's what I…read morejust was charged. One pizza two toppings $28 dollars.

Try the Black Raspberry ice cream, it's the best flavor! The staff are friendly. The store is a…read morenice, small, quiet place to take a break.

Definitely call ahead!! We were the only ones who showed up to place an order…read more Place was busy, but they seemed to be working hard to fill everyone's order as fast as they could. They have 6 - 8 booths inside and a picnic table outside for eating. Not sure of their history and how long they've been around, but this place looks and feels like it's an institution. We ordered 2 cheeseburgers and 2 small shakes for $21.00. The burgers and shakes were a good size and a good value for the price.

Great food! Homemade everything! It's been an age since buffets were a thing so we were surprised…read morewhen we walked in Ham, prime rib, fried fish all fantastic! Desserts that bring back memories of my childhood...there are so many choices it's kinda impossible to have it all lol but my goodness, it's so delicious you can't help but try! (You can also order from their menu, I saw an impressive looking cheeseburger on a nearby table ) The staff is efficient and super friendly! Evenings can get busy but they keep the food refreshed and there's no significant wait. We were traveling through the area a couple of years ago and kinda stumbled upon this little spot since we were staying nearby. We never miss it now when we come back!

Such a nice surprise! Never been there since we don't live near there! Saw a big sign off 35 so we…read moredecided to give it a try! What a cute place! BUFFET makes me wanna drive 78 miles from our town! I just admired it.. we ordered off the menu... TENDERLOIN sandwich and onion rings! So so good! I thought it was so cute! Then I walked back to the bathroom and it was MUCH BIGGER than I thought! I went back and grabbed my mama and walked her back there to see it and we talked to some nice customers, one used to work there when she was younger! Servers were so kind! Great memory with my mama!

I travel to St. Joseph for work at least three times a year and I come here every single time. Have…read morebeen doing it for years. After today I won't be coming back. My work colleagues and I got sat and were informed of a long wait as there was only one server - cool. No problem. It happens. We are sitting about 20 minutes when a table of 8 gets sat next to us. The cook immediately came from behind the counter to bring water for them. We were still sitting there with nothing. Our server came over - apologized and got our orders and brought out our drinks. Our salads came out and all was well. Then we waited and waited. We were informed that one of the potato pizzas we ordered couldn't be made because they were out of potatoes. No big deal. We changed the order. Then the group next us - who came in 20 minutes after us and ordered after us all got served their pizzas(including a few potato pizzas). While we waited and was not served. Finally realizing that our diverse group of 5 was being shafted for the very non-diverse group of 8 we asked for our pizzas to go and we left. So if the intention of Il Lazzarone was to make us feel sidelined and "othered" - congratulations. Job well done. Because we left there being reminded of just how how bigotry feels. The pizzas was still great in my hotel room. But you will never see a recommendation from me or dime of my money again.

My hubs and I had a great experience at Il Lazzarone! The Neapolitan pizza was new to us. It's…read moredifferent than anything we've had. The waitress did a great job explaining and her recommendations were spot on! We started off with the bruschetta. It was very fresh and layered with flavors! We then ordered the Salsiccia Italiana (Mozzarella, Sausage, basil, olive oil, sea salt) and the Crepa (Mozzarella, bacon, basil, garlic, balsamic glaze, olive oil, sea salt). We both agreed the the Crepa was our favorite but they were both very good! The Italian sausage was very flavorful. We ate half of each pizza and saved room for dessert. Our waitress recommended the S'mores with added cookie dough. It was so yummy and worth the calories! We love supporting these type of specialty restaurants in St Joe. We will definitely be back!