Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    ModeratePizza
    Open 4:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of R A.
    0
    22
    4

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 415 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Mother Bear's Pizza Campus

    Mother Bear's Pizza Campus

    4.2(925 reviews)
    49.7 mi
    $$

    My daughter and I had a great night out after watching one of favorite dancers on The Crimsonette…read moreTeam. We had NO wait, received fast, and friendly service. The Breadsticks with delicious marinara, and our cheese pizza were truly the best we've ever had. There are SO many options for vegetarians, as well as a kids menu, and SO much more than only breadsticks, and pizza. We can't wait to dine there on our next visit to IIU.

    When I first moved to Bloomington years ago I was surprised that the town did not have a Little…read moreCaesar's Pizza. Locals told me that it was because the local pizza places, especially Mother Bear's, are so popular, that college students would go there instead of getting cheap, mid pizza. I have now been to Mother Bear's three or four times and really wish that there was a Little Caesar's Pizza in town. This most recent trip was during lunchtime and I ordered a cheese slice, a small house salad, and a drink. I fortunately got there early enough to get a clean table, though I saw probably fifteen to twenty people come in after me who were not so lucky. Following the sign at the door, instructing them to "Please Seat Yourselves," I heard several people ask out loud how they were supposed to do that if there were no clean tables. Some employees frantically cleaned a few tables and had them sit down. A few minutes after I ordered, the waitress brought the house salad. It looked fresh at first but the more I ate the more I realized that several of the romaine pieces were either clearly out of date or simply bad. In a moment when cyclospora is running rampant through the US, the lack of care in selecting the lettuce was worrying. Several moments later I began wondering if the cheese slice was going to be brought to my table soon. Instead, it was probably twenty minutes between getting the salad and the cheese slice and it was pretty obvious (see the photo) that the slice had been sitting under a heat lamp for around that same amount of time. The crust was dry, the cheese had become stale and too salty, and it was not a very enjoyable experience. Eating around the bad lettuce was, unfortunately, more enjoyable, and it was also better than the pizzas I've had here in the past, where the dough, toppings, and cheese aren't integrated in a way that blends their flavors together very well. The one thing I can say about this time is that the Dr. Pepper was fine, which is not something I can always say about restaurant sodas. I think for me this will probably be my last time going to Mother Bear's. It seems like one of those places that probably was good at some point in the past but now they rely on the fact that undergrads and locals will go to the restaurant no matter what. I'll probably just keep dreaming of eating Little Caesar's instead or, more likely, I'll just go get better pizza at Osteria Rago.

    Photos
    Mother Bear's Pizza Campus
    Mother Bear's Pizza Campus - "Paulie Pine Nuts" pesto pie

    "Paulie Pine Nuts" pesto pie

    Mother Bear's Pizza Campus - Guinness

    See all

    Guinness

    Anthony's Pizzeria - Pepperoni 14"

    Anthony's Pizzeria

    4.4(34 reviews)
    7.6 mi
    $

    If you've tried their mozzarella sticks... Oh my God it's absolute heaven. I got the mozzarella…read moresticks here thinking they're going to be average mozzarella sticks with some average marinara but when I took that first bite, OMG those were the best mozzarella sticks I've ever had in my life!! So I really recommend you to get the mozzarella sticks they're insanely crunchy but not the hard crunch where your teeth hurt, the cheese stays gooey and nice for a while but it's also not too hot. The marinara sauce pairs perfectly with the cheese and the breading, I absolutely recommend the best mozzarella sticks place which is Anthony's Pizza

    It's just like the pizza in the mall...but better! Anthony's is tucked back by Heritage Lake and…read moreserves pizza by the slice or to order. They also have some spectacular looking calzones, subs, salads, etc. We ordered the pepperoni sticks and a 14" pepperoni pizza. The pizzas are large, great for feeding a family - 14" is actually the smallest size. Our pizza was slightly raw in the middle, it definitely needed more time in the oven. It was delicious, regardless. We loved the breadsticks with pepperoni in the middle as well. For a total of $27 we also got two fountain drinks. It took about 10 mins to get our order and we enjoyed playing darts while waiting. This looks like it would be a great place to grab a beer and watch the game. The staff is super friendly and I was surprised to see the young man in the back actually throwing the pizza dough. We are definitely going back!

    Photos
    Anthony's Pizzeria - Stuff slice

    Stuff slice

    Anthony's Pizzeria - Can you believe this used to be Pizza den

    Can you believe this used to be Pizza den

    Anthony's Pizzeria

    See all

    Mama Fazio's Pizza - XL supreme pizza (no onion or anchovies)

    Mama Fazio's Pizza

    3.6(19 reviews)
    14.4 mi
    $$

    You know what Crawfordsville didn't need? Another pizza joint. You know what Crawfordsville did…read moreneed? A high quality pizza joint like Mama Fazio's. Sadly, even with all the pizza places in town, my favorite was still, as much as I hate to admit, Pizza Hut...until last night after trying Mama Fazio's. We ordered breadsticks and an XL (18 inch) supreme pizza (no anchovies)to be delivered to the new brewery in town. I loved that the breadsticks orders each included two dipping sauces--no fighting over dipping choices there! The breadsticks were soft and well seasoned. The supreme pizza was amazing, even warmed up for lunch today. Toppings stuffed high and covered in fresh mozzarella cheese. I think this is the only pizza place in Crawfordsville with ground sausage other than Arni's. My only complaint is that they used canned mushrooms instead of fresh. That actually tends to be a deal-breaker for me, but the rest of the pizza was so good that I can overlook it! I see a lot of orders from Mama Fazio's in our future.

    Barstool fan review…read more Frankie we are here in Crawfordsville. Home of the worst restaurants in Indiana. One bite everyone knows the rules. Mama Fazio's is a hole in the wall pizzeria just off the corner of the blustering downtown Crawfordsville. One bite, everyone knows the rules. Just on pizza alone. It's one of the best in town, which isn't saying much. If you want to try the blandest pizza in all the land Crawfordsville is the place. Arnis with their tomato paste sauce. Marco's with their cardboard crust. And then the collection of national conglomerates. That is about it. But one bite, everyone knows the rules---- 6.3. One bite. Everyone knows the rules. The flop was real. Real bad. Cheese thicker than crust. No flakiness. Too much oil not enough flour. Sauce is real good. Pepperoni spicy. Too much cheese. Basic. But might be the best pizza in Crawfordsville. Which isn't saying much. Three stars is on the salad, breadsticks, and wings. The sauce came on the side which looked like the nacho cheese I ordered for the breadsticks. Salad was good. Not Arni's good, but it's hard to screw up a salad. I could tell their dough and breadsticks were frozen. Three stars on the location. Most restaurants in C-Ville are two stars. So it is above average. Rookie rating scale by Yelp! Should be a 2.7.

    Photos
    Mama Fazio's Pizza - Hawaiian pizza

    Hawaiian pizza

    Mama Fazio's Pizza - Breadsticks. The garlic sauce is just eh, reminds me of the papa johns sauce but not really any flavor.

    Breadsticks. The garlic sauce is just eh, reminds me of the papa johns sauce but not really any flavor.

    Mama Fazio's Pizza

    See all

    Casey's - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...