Cassano's has one of the best meatball subs I've had in a LONG time. It's really good. They use garlic exceptionally here. So many times when I have something garlicky I'm disappointed, it smells more garlicky than it ever actually tastes. The food here has great garlic usage and does not disappoint. The piega is SO good. It's better than the pizza and I really like the pizza. It's greasy, but ugh it's worth it. Best local pizza joint in Fairfield for me... read more

I ordered ahead of time online and it was ready by the time I got there! We ordered a heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day and we enjoyed the crust and bbq wings (not pictured). I would highly recommend to call since the prices through online ordering (via Door Dash) are much higher than what their menu in store shows. Online, their projected wait times were 30-45 min. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Heart shaped pizza with sausage and green peppers - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

I ordered take out. The pizza was well made. Loved the toppings I ordered bacon, mushroom and banana peppers. The breadsticks were good too. The place was clean and inviting! We will be back. I was greeted as soon as I walked up to the counter. Great service read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - We had already taken some out of the box. - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

See all

Just wanted to update with a photo. Food was amazing. Service was good and the place was clean read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Sausage and jalapeño pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

I would also like to point out that the only reason "Cassanos Pizza Fairfield" won "Best Of Butler County" is because she made her managers make the workers pull out their phones and fill out the survey DAILY, no matter a rush or not. I will admit, they do have AMAZING food, just absolutely horrible ownership. She does not deserve to own and manage a restaurant, where she doesn't even know how to make the food she's selling. Kinda crazy if you ask me read more

Don't sleep on this place. Was craving some pizza so I made the 30 min drive & so glad I did. Pretty close to tavern style pizza Chicago is known for. Anytime I'm in the area (or not) I WILL make a stop to get a pie. I'd hit it...again. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - 9" deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

I was pleasantly surprised. Crust was fantastic, very crispy. Had enough salt/flavor in the sauce to be satisfying. I'm usually not a fan of pizzas covered in mozzarella and that still detracts a bit from this one. The cheese/toppings weren't super flavorful and was just stringy. Otherwise everything was good. Pizza was ready quick and was hot when I arrived. Pretty standard small local pizza joint. You can tell it's a favorite for families after their kids sports games. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

Used to be a favorite - but new owner did away with carry out specials and raised prices. This location was always higher than non-franchise locations and never observed company specials, but prices are no longer competitive. There are too many high quality options at better prices! PS - be sure to look at their website for current prices - the one listed here is from 2 years ago (a large meats is now $34.62 - not the $23.70 listed just 2 years ago) read more

They were busy when I walked in to pick up a carry out. I paid for the pizza I ordered then was given somebody's pizza after waiting 10 minutes past the time given. Mine should have been loaded including olives- and what I got was a lightly pepperoni topped cheese pizza. Sauce was ok but not worth the return. Leftovers on this 16" won't be taking up any room in my fridge, but I will need to make a dumpster trip in the morning. Welcome to the Cincinnati market. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Wrong pizza from what I ordered - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

Food is great but the level of service is subpar. Called in for carry out and was told it would be 40 mins. When I arrived and checked in, I waited another 30 mins. Apparently my order was ready but they failed to let me know. If I hadn't asked for a status, no telling how much longer I would have waited. By the time I got back to the office, sub was cold. Usually they do a great job, but this was a big fail. read more

Best pizza in Butler County hands down. Whenever I'm in the area it's a must to stop in. The new owners have really fixed the restaurant up. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Deluxe pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

Known for their great pizza, but they also have the best wings!!!!! Friendly service! Highly recommend read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Traditional BBQ Wings - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

Now that Chesters Pizza (the best) has been sold and gone way downhill, my second choice is Cassanos. Ordered through Doordash this afternoon and was very disappointed. Skimpy toppings and the worse part is that the crust/dough is very rubbery. Never had anything like it and will probably never order from here again. Tired of spending good money on a lousy product. read more

This place has been around a long time and one of the few that still cooks with a gas oven. The decor is old and it's like most places that can be called a hole in the wall. Those are usually the ones that have good food. For those who gave it a bad review probably likes frozen pizzas. It's a regional pizza that you either like it or you don't. Most places have different versions of pizza and people have different taste so people should not compare it to dog food unless they have eaten dog food. A can of tuna looks like cat food but it's still good. This place has history and a following of people that has been coming to this place since the 80's. A lot of these have closed down because they went into areas that people like other pizza's and didn't get the followings. The pizza is different and I like it, is it the best pizza that I've eaten, no but there are others that I don't care for and that is my opinion. When we go to Jungle Jim's we always stop here. So if you like thin crust with finely chopped items and a sauce that is not doctored up then you will like this pizza. Eat it with Grippo's and a cold beer from a walk in cooler. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Mom's big cheese - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

The service was very slow it took 50 minutes to get my order and it was supposed to be ready 45 minutes but no it took almost an hour

Fantastic service and food Ver friendly and professional Prices were fine Family atmospheres read more

Saturday December 13th 2025 I ordered a big mom's with sausage mushroom onion extra sausage. We ordered it 2 weeks ago and it was around $27 give or take and when we ordered our pizza December 13th it was $10 more. The guy that took our order on the phone said corporate raised their prices. That's fine and dandy but $10 more that is ridiculous. We won't be buying pizza from there anymore. The pizza was neglected very chancy it had very little toppings. We were very disappointed. read more

I'm sorry to say this. This the first time saying anything or writing a review. This was the worst pizza I got from a Cassano's. First time going to this one. The pizza was so thin and soggy. Didn't even taste like a Cassanos. Middletown on Verity, Jackson Lane , Carlisle and Springboro. Is the only ones I be going to from here on out. You all should get retrained. Yeah I'm little heated just wasted $20 just go in the trash read more

Not sure what has happened here the last couple years, but we've been lifelong Cassano's lovers in our family. But the last few times we've gone we either sit in the restaurant waiting over an hour for food or we order pick up just to arrive and there's a line out the door of people that have been waiting, almost an hour to pick up their food. Last time I finally got up to the register and the woman in front of me had gotten in line for the second time to see whether her order was ready and was that her order was going to be "at least another 30 minutes." She asked if she could just have a refund because she'd already been waiting 40 minutes and the girl told her they couldn't do any refunds. So she had no choice but to sit there and wait because she had already paid. What? How is that possible? You can't offer a refund for a product you didn't provide? Kudos to the lady that was able to walk away without losing her shit! We haven't been there in months because of the poor service and you better check your order because it's always wrong! Not sure if there's new management or what has happened, but it needs fixed desperately or they'll be shutting more doors! read more

This is an odd place in a strip mall. My son and I came here after working on my plane. I really wanted a meatball sub and they had one. So my first time here just because. The have pizza and subs, I seen that they do a thin crust pizza that looked good. I ordered a meatball sub that was fairly good, my son got an original sub. I enjoyed my sub very much and my son said his was very good. I will be back to try one of the Cassini or Calzone. The staff was very friendly and I would say it was a worth while lunch. Prices were not bad either and since it isn't far from the airport I am sure I will be back. I am always looking for a good place to eat nearby. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Counter and cooler - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

See all

Great Pizza-bad service! Waited an hour and a half for two large pizzas. Dining room was near empty. Door dash/carryout orders are priority over dine-in so keep that in mind when going here. No refunds will be given if you have time constraints waiting on your order. read more

First time trying this place and will be my last!! First, had to wait for an hour for a cheese pizza and potato wedges. Second, the pizza is a NO for me. My husband and I will stick to Chester's!! read more

they don't need to be no buisness idk if they are short staffed or what but they had multiple people waiting for hours .. even doordashers this shit is ridiculous read more

DON'T THROW AWAY YOUR MONEY HERE. Cassano's Pizza is good and I have been a fan for life. The Fairfield ,Ohio location is poorly run with poorly made food. Spent $ 24.95 for a three topping pizza. The pizza was dry and had so little toppings. It look like a manager was trying to stretch the toppings he had in store. After driving from Hamilton I called the store. They told me I could return the Pizza and they would make me a new one while i waited. This store doesn't have this policy because customers use it against them. They do it because the product is so poor and way overpriced. They will never rip me or anyone I know off again. You have been warned. read more

I keep forgetting to add this review, this place is great, the anti pasta salad is delicious, pizza good and the manager , the blonde lady , is always so nice & pleasant. The other people working are so nice. I always like this place. read more

This is the only pizza I ever crave. There are other good pizzas in the city and I enjoy those as well, but this one has a permanent place in my brain that calls to me often. read more

Nice, clean remodeled interior. Great pizza and friendly service. So much improved. TV's and keno.

I have enjoyed this pizza for decades. I love the thin crust with the way they cut it into little squares.

What's better on a fall Friday than a food cheat day for hot pizza? It's a rhetorical question of course. Cassano's in Fairfield, OH is well worth the drive for a consistently tasty pizza. Whether you choose carryout, like me, or to eat in the dining room, like the faithful locals, you will NOT be disappointed. A very busy Friday evening at Cassano's and I had my large sausage and pepperoni pizza in hand in 20 minutes. They handed the pizza box to me with a big smile, exclaiming "enjoy" because obviously they can see the future and knew we would! I was very impressed with the staff as a large group of several families walked in at once, with many little kids, and the wait staff welcomed them as if they were family. They treated the elementary age kids with as much respect as the adults "what would you like" and "great choice!" Keep up the great work Cassano's! read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Cassano's menu - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

Service is okay. Pizza bottom is ALWAYS charred. Unsure if it is cleaning of oven but makes the whole pizza taste awful. read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Pizza char - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

I have been eating Pizza King/Sir Pizza pizzas in KY, OH and IN for over 50 years, so it's something I grew up on. This one is about 20 minutes from home. I usually get the deluxe or Royal Feast which has about 5 items on it. Have never had a problem here. This location has resumed dine-in, which I did tonite. read more

Decided to try it out and it was pretty good pizza Pepperoni and sausage pizza had some great flavor to it read more

Heard a lot of good things about this pizza and they all held true. Best mid western pizza I've had. We got their classic pepperoni and pepperoni with mushroom. The garlic on the pizza was a welcomed surprised. It's all cut in small squares which is fine but it just makes you wish you could hold more at once. Place gets crowded after 5:30. All in all a very solid pie with a nice fired bottom on the crust read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

There has been a makeover inside the old Cassano's and the service and food was amazing. The new owner said the first improvement was to the bathroom which is wonderful and that old sour smell is long gone. read more

I have been coming here for years and I love their pizza! It has a thin crust, lots of cheese, and is extremely well priced.

Great pizza for what it is! It's good cheap pizza in a fairly divey restaurant. The crust is ultra thin, and cut into bitesize pieces. I've never had pizza cut so small and I'm such a fan! When else do you get to eat like 30 slices of pizza? We ordered a sausage and banana pepper pizza and the sausage was very crumbley and covered most of the pizza. They definitely don't skimp on the toppings! The place was packed when we were there so the pizza was pretty slow, but that was apparently unusual. They were very nice and even though it was slow I'd consider it good service! read more

Cassano's Pizza Fairfield - Large Sausage and Banana Pepper Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fairfield, Ohio

Great service and cooked fresh yummy Love that thin crust best sausage with crispy crust

Amazing every time, definitely a great place for my family and I to hang out! A great hole in the wall mom and pop shop!

This location can't be bothered to advise customers that they do not have sufficient wait staff and ONLY provides carry-out service. This would have been nice to know before we drove over from Lebanon to have lunch at Cassano's. Talk about not communicating with your customer base! Likely, we will not return. read more

I had ordered an Italian sub. I wasn't impressed with this sub. It was my first time having this sandwich. It was more bread than meat and toppings. Better Italian subs at Donato's and Penn Stations. The service was terrible. I've ordered in the restaurant and waited. After about 30 minutes I asked if my order was ready. It was and was sitting under the heat lamps. The woman, Natalie, knew I was waiting but never called my name out when ready. I've complained and she was rude. read more