I have heard heat things about this place. So I was excited to order it for the first time. I don't think it's the best in the area but probably a top 3. But I was talking to a guy at the corner store and he said to order extra sauce. So I will try that next time. read more

Pizza is delicious. Every side we've ordered has been exceptional. The staff is friendly and go out of their way to deliver. Highly recommended. read more

Been here since I can remember. Amazing food. Always fresh and hot. We now live close by and are trying different things each time we get to order. read more

great pizza, wish they had delivery... will get their pizza more often... my sons favorite...

This is the first time we've ate cattleman 's pizza I've heard so many good things about this place. We ordered a small pepper and cheese pizza with an Italian sub. The sub was pretty good. The pizza was the worst pizza I've had in my life. I guess that goes to prove Josie's pizza in the bottoms Westside Columbus was the best pizza ever. We wanted to try Cattlemens because they delivered. Josie's as far away from us now might have to go back to them but for now are go to Pizza, subs, salads and wings is MO'S IN Commercial point. read more

I highly enjoyed this pizza. I seen some people talk about them through Facebook and I thought to go give then a try. I'll give the same heads up that people gave me, order extra sauce. Our pizza along with the photo was extra sauce and extra pepperoni. We were happy and can't wait to be back to try the subs and the pizza with more topings. read more

Cattleman's Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

Food... I have been eating their pizza for nearly 24 years. The Team at Cattleman's is Best of the Best...and makes my Friday nights perfect. The crust is light and crispy with just enough sustenance you get to hold the toppings without everything falling off...I swear its a bit "beef hoppy" even though she swears there's no beer in the dough, pepperoni is nice cheese is blended well... trust me come out to Darbydale bring a fishing pole to either Osprey Lake or Pleasant Valley Battelle Darby...but stop by Cattlemans and have a pizza! Mr Boyd says Soooo! read more

Really good pizza and the Italian sub is great as well! Service was good, we ordered on the 4th of July and still got our food pretty fast. For sure one of my favorite pizza places read more

My family liked Cattelmans. The crust is not the best, too crunchy in my opinion, but I really like the sauce. They have great deals on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. The service was really good and we didn't wait too long. The place is not the best, for take out only. I'll try it again soon. read more

Pretty solid pizza Ordered on a Sunday the wait was a little long because of short staffing but the pizza come hot and was really good read more

I should have tried them years ago. Great Pizza. They did a wonderful job. I will definitely be returning in the future.

Pep mushroom and sausage, fire tonight, great job. Cattleman's definitely worth a try if you haven't

The old style salad bar is great and the service was very good. The steaks are a bit thin, however the staff is outstanding

My family absolutely loves Cattlemans pizza and it has been a staple in my household since 2005. The crust is on the thicker side, sauce it not too tart or too sweet. The service has always been fantastic. Mondays thru Wednesdays there are deals that make eating out affordable. They have an outdoor eating area however typically not used. Inside is bar like seating at a counter primarily for waiting for food. They are consistent in their quality and service. read more

Delicious pizza! Friendly staff. My family has eaten here for years. Highly recommend.

One of the best pizzas in the area. A dive hole in the wall but there is a reason they've been in business for so long. Worth the drive.

Great place!!! Love all the workers and the food is AMAZING!!! Love our lasagna dinner! So good and such a deal. Keep it up!

I love the pasta and sandwiches here, but the pizza not so much. Toppings are decent, sauce is OK, but the crust is horrible, in my opinion. Will continue to go back for the lasagne, spaghetti, and subs, but that's about it. read more

Cattlemens surprised me. Rolled up. Its in a shed/trailer. Take out essentially only. Ordered/waited in parking lot to take home. It is really really good. Reason been operating successfully out of a trailer for 20 years. Its good. read more

We decided to give them a try and I'm so glad we did. I kept trying to go to other pizza places but it's been hard getting a good pizza lately. So when I bit into Cattleman's I was knocked off my feet. It was super flavorful and delicious. The crust and pepperoni are perfectly crispy. It's so good that we've been back since without hesitation. It's a little pricey but well worth it. read more

Cattleman's Pizza - Half pep half meat pizza. Cooked perfectly. - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

I have had both the pizza and the meatball sub and it's def one of my favorites. It was SO delicious!

Cattleman's Pizza was discovered by my parents before I was born. Getting lost on the way to a party, they happened upon Cattleman's Pizza and were lured by the enticing aroma. My parents tasted the simple pepperoni pizza, and the rest is history. My parents, brother, girlfriend, and myself are addicted to what we consider the best pizza in Columbus. We drive 30 minutes both ways for this special place, and it is worth it every time. Service: 5/5 Driving down London Groveport Road, Cattleman's Pizza jumps out unexpectedly around the bend. A large rocky lot and simple sign welcomes you to the humble little shop. Entering the white screen door, large ovens sit behind the tall, worn counter. The familiar faces I've known since I was a kid joyfully greet me. They are always so nice and the happiness I feel each time I pick up pizza is persistent. Atmosphere: 3/5 The shop is a tight squeeze, with only enough room to grab drinks and pizza. A small wood table hugs the corner under the television for a lucky pair that choose to eat Cattleman's straight from the oven. While the shop is not stylish or sophisticated by any means, Cattleman's is quaint and inspiring, knowing what delicious fare is produced behind the counter. Food: 5/5 The pizza at Cattleman's has an incredibly unique flavor that is impossible to match. The handmade dough bakes well, absorbing the oils and juices from the delicious toppings, creating a crisp bottom and a chewy interior. The pizza's well balanced texture is another quality unique to Cattleman's and other places can't compete. The food is absolutely delicious and consistently produced. Sausage Pizza - Finely minced sausage, with intense flavors of fennel seed and fresh herbs is evenly and heavily dispersed upon the tangy, fruity, and nutty cheese that tops each pizza. The simple but robust tomato sauce blankets the dough in perfect quantity. This pizza is more than a sum of its parts, creating a flavor almost impossible to describe. Pepperoni Pizza - Old world pepperoni overlaying the delicious cheese produces sensationally flavorful oil once baked, soaking into the wonderful dough. The dough has flavors of beer and malt, lead strongly with a clean wheat profile. This simple creation is the perfect pepperoni pizza. Drinks: N/A Water and soda live in a cooler off to the left after entering the front door. Once you cash out, you grab the soda on your way out. The drinks are properly refrigerated. Cattleman's Pizza holds a special place in my heart, and the flavor of their pizza is intimately tied to some of my happiest childhood memories. A deep nostalgia is motivated each time I have the pleasure of eating their pizza. All other pizza in Columbus is a disappointment in comparison. I hope Cattleman's never disappears or I will be crushed. I will continue to support Cattleman's forever. read more

The pizza was good, but not over the top amazing. There wasn't as much sauce on the pizza as I was hoping. The crust was crunchy, but yet chewy so that seemed odd and the center was slightly over cooked which was also strange. I live 30 minutes away and have a pizza bag but the pizza wasn't as fresh as I hoped when I got home. The garlic bread was average. read more

Cattleman's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

The pizza is decent for being so far out of the city... the service is definitely sub-par. I have asked for simple instructions to be followed before such as the pizza to be cut a certain fashion, only to pick up the pizza and find out they did not care enough to even try. Just tonight I called to order pickup OR delivery, to which they replied that they were closed and did not offer either... almost 30 minutes before they even close. Sorry I was not off of work sooner? read more

We kept it simple: pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and an Italian sub. The sub: first off, the bun was amazing, I saw a box from Auddinos so I'm guessing they made it, fresh toppings , baked just right , literally no complaints. The pizza had a sweet sauce and it had that doughy taste where you can actually taste the dough and toppings together , like, you could smell the flour so you know the dough was fresh. They use real pepperoni , the kind that curl up in the oven, and super fresh cheese too. We had half a pizza left that we kept "for later" but ended up eating about 2 hours later because it was so good. read more

Grew up on this pizza. Still great all these years later! I moved from GC to West Jeff and was so happy that they still deliver!!! read more

Cattleman's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

See all

Got pizza for the first time in a long time. Pizza crust a little on the chewy side, needs to back off the shaker a little bit. Chef salad a little lacking on the meat side. More lettuce than anything else. Would I get again? I'll give another chance. Will ask for no parm shake on pizza. read more

Remember my sadness over the kids changing the grown folks' recipe? The Wonderful Pizza is back! The yummy, cheesy, delicious parm cheese sharpness is back on their cheese pizza. Greasy goodness worth driving from German Village out toward Trapper John's canoe livery. We were driving around looking at Christmas lights and saw Cattleman's and almost cried. My daughter decided to stop and try it one last time.. I was transported back to 10 years ago. I found my favorite Pizza shop in central ohio. Cattleman's! Pickup is best. Go in early and watch them work. read more

I used to have this place several times a week as a kid in the 80's and 90's. We moved away and I recently made the trek for another round. This is by far on of the best pizza places i have ever had. This include Chicago, NY and darn near all other columbus places. It continues to be the same as it used to be! Only problem is they don't deliver 45 minutes away. read more

The pizza here is the best! The closest comparison in the area is obviously Zamerellis's, but I would say Cattleman's is definitely better. Check out their daily deals, which change depending on the day of the week. Give Cattleman's a try, you won't regret it! read more

I like the people here. The place is small and dirty, but has a little charm. But the product is not my type of pizza. Undercooked dough, bland watery vegetables on top. Lacks flavor and quality. Ill try it again someday. We did a side by side taste test (bc we were confused on who was picking up dinner) with hound dogs pizza near osu campus and hound dogs blew this pizza away. It was actually displeasurable to take a bite of cattlemans after a bite of the other. Again, i like everything else about them, but not their pizza. read more

We live right around the corner from this place. Ordered spaghetti with meatballs a salad garlic cheese bread and wings. The spaghetti was ok, the wings I'm not sure where they get them they are tiny very tiny no meat on them. Can't get them extra wet. Just wasn't good. We pick up because if we order delivery it takes over an hour! read more

Great food and service. Love everything but the veggie sub. I highly recommend the pizza.

The pizza is ok, but other items are really good. Staff is always friendly, and service is quick!

Just moved to the area, great pizza, quick service. Just make sure you give them your full name, last time there were two people picking up with the same last name @ the same time! Was corrected quickly and we were on our way with our pizza read more

We just discovered Cattleman's Pizza and it's our new favorite. We've had the pizza, lasagna, and salads. Loved everything. Salads are fresh and loaded with meat, cheese, and veggies. read more

Please please please save yourself the time and money. Horrible experience pizza was a half hour late. The ENTIRE perimeter of one of my pizzas was BLACK. They completely entirely forgot my girlfriends sub and then as we trying to eat the one pizza we thought was edible we find a loooong hair baked into the cheese. Please guys don't give this company your money read more

Great pizza, very consistent with their cooking and taste. If you like a medium thickness crust pizza, this is the best place in the Columbus area hands down. A tad pricey and be sure to use cash as they charge for CC and the receipt they provide has your account balance listed on it for some strange reason. read more