1 Star - This Ain't It Flyer's Pizza really flew off course with this one. The sauce was way too sweet, the pizza was burnt, barely had any cheese (if any), and just tasted off. And don't get me started on the sub -- it was paper-thin with no real veggies in sight. Just bread, sadness, and regret. I'm not picky, but this was straight-up nasty. Never again Only good thing was the cookie read more

See all

Flyers Pizza is my favorite pizza place. Delicious sauce, cheesy and fast delivery. Thank you for the excellent taste and service.

One of our go-to pizza spots! Very friendly workers. Pizza is always delicious. A bit pricey, but we usually use a coupon or reward. Very clean inside. read more

One of my favorite pizza places in Grove City! The sauce is what does it for me. I have lived in Grove City off and on for most of my adult life and Flyers is definitely a staple here. read more

I placed a large delivery order over the weekend to a hotel we were staying at for a soccer tournament. The online order process is very easy and the pizza arrived hot well before the quoted time. Also, they brought napkins and plates per my request, which is always a great bonus! The pizza itself was quite good. I heard many of our players and families commenting on how good the pepperoni pizza was and I agree. Would gladly order again. read more

I've never had Flyer's pizza until this year and have been going back a few times. You can order on the phone or online and they tell you how long of an estimated wait it is. The restaurant itself is pretty small, but you can pick up your order through the drive through. The pizza is really good. I love their sauce and always get extra sauce. I've only gotten the pizza cut into small pieces, but I'm assuming you can get it cut into triangles. They don't typically have coupons on just pizza, but a large pepperoni is $15.25. Additional toppings are maybe $1 more? I'd recommend! read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

We get the same thing The Nightmare Sub and it's always delicious. We live in Commercial Pt Oh There is a Flyers on 665 but their Nightmare sub doesn't taste as good. Can't figure this one out. read more

Great pizza, timely service and good Stromboli! Chef salad is really good! Convenient location right on Hoover just south of Stringtown Rd read more

Great food. Salad super fresh. Meatball sun yummy. Delivered hot and in good timing.

Love this place. Being from Chicago it's hard to find good pizza. Not anymore this place has it all. Great philly steak, great natural potato chips. 10/10 read more

This is really more of a side dish complaint. I will say their pizza is one of my favorites, a nice sweet sauce and thin crust. So for the past 4 orders we order the plain bread sticks and they always come out dark brown and hard ends. Such a problem I called and complained. So today when I order I specifically ask them to not over cook the breadsticks. The person taking the order says "so a light cook" I said sure just don't want them dark brown. So I go pick up my order to find the breadsticks in this picture. 2 of the four bread sticks had these almost burnt marks and the other 2 are perfect. So the question is was this on purpose or just another mistake? I would expect someone to catch that and not serveEither way I have to go somewhere else for Friday night pizza next. Since this happened I was contacted by the manager and he was very receptive. We had Flyers tonight and it was perfect!! Pizza-perfect, breadsticks-perfect, cheese sticks were great! read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

It's been awhile since I've eaten any pizza from Flyers. All the others pizza stores had long wait times for pickup and Flyers didn't so I decided to see if the pizza is back to normal. I don't remember the crust being as thin but it was well made, extra sauce tasted good and overall great. But I wonder how it will be late night when ordered. Hopefully they are back to normal. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Old World Peppperoni with extra pizza sauce and garlic sauce I ordered. - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

We LOVE the service at this location! Drew was super friendly and patient with us. Super fast service and great food. The food is the same as other locations but you should try the BLT pizza! We also like the Meatza pizza, the Buffalo chicken without the blue cheese, and the old world pepperoni with salami. I also love that this location supports local youth sports!!! Thank you Flyers! read more

Pizza was soggy. Sponge like texture and cold. I'll take my chances with other places.

In my opinion, it's excellent pizza and subs. The pizza sauce is sweeter and the pepperonis are perfect. The subs are great. They have a lot of meat, cheese, and the bread is good. I always enjoy flyers. read more

Ordered Flyer's pizza for the first time today and I didn't know what to expect. After trying some of the other pizza locations in my general area I was not too pleased. But I am glad Flyer's changed that. I ordered a large sausage and black olive, a mini BLT, and an order of chocolate chip cookies. On both pizzas I asked for the original crust. Everything was cooked perfectly, not undercooked, not over-cooked. The lettuce and tomatoes on the BLT was fresh and crisp. The mayo was on the dough in place of a sauce and was not overbearing. The original crust is a medium thickness that was crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and golden on the bottom (no cornmeal). The cookies were warm, and thick with big chunks of chocolate. I do not think they were homemade though. Next time I will try their thin crust and wings. The BLT was good enough I will order it again. read more

See all

I got a gift certificate for $10.00 off anything I wanted from here and who can pass that up. We went inside to order take out there was a girl on the phone and another who was organizing the orders in the window. We were not greeted nor did either girl acknowledge us which I think they should get them to work on. We stood there for a couple and once the girl got off the phone she greeted us and we placed our order and she did suggest a side of mushrooms which I declined, but she did a good job. We ordered a large pepperoni with sausage which would have been $17, but was only $7 for us so great deal. We got through pizza quick and it was piping hot. I really enjoyed the crust and sweet sauce and plenty of cheese too, but there sausage was too spicy (not hot spicy) for my tummy. He liked the crust and pepperoni, but wanted more sauce and bigger chunks of sausage. All in all I don't trust the sides, but the pizza is much better and I will order again. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

Great pizza! My new "GOTO" place for pizza. Old world pepperoni with extra cheese, extra sauce, and "well done" is the best! Not only is it good food, the employees are always friendly and courteous. Great customer service! read more

I bought this last week based off the best of Grove City Awards, and also because they are a sponsor/supporter of Autism Speaks. I had high hopes. Sigh..it was average. It was edible. Ok, it was disappointing. I ordered 2 build your own pizzas. One thick crust with sausage and onions, and one thin crust with pepperoni and pineapple. (I like on pizza, move on.) It was delivered lukewarm, so maybe it's better hot? The thick crust was not great. It actually tasted stale, the crust didn't crunch, and it was not chewy, it just kind of bent in your mouth and took awhile to chew. The sauce was unmemorable. The thin crust was better. It was crunchy, the topping were generous tasted good. I just think I'll stick to some other pizza places for now. read more

I travel for a living and this is one of the best pizza places in the country, a must try when in the area

This is the second time I've had the pizza, and it really is worth ordering; it's worth becoming a regular here, too. We had the pepperoni and barbecue chicken pizzas, and each were incredibly delicious. The pizza had very low amounts of grease, which is what I look for in a pizza. The bottoms were gracefully toasted to perfection. The portions were also very good. The only thing I would suggest is to figure out how to make the pizzas a little more puffed up. It was really thin, but hey, just leaves more of the pizza to be eaten! Overall, I'm going to be a regular in the future. read more

So on Memorial day we had family in from out of town. We told them how good flyers pizza is. They wanted to go elsewhere but we talked them into it. So we ordered $60 in pizza and were told it would be about 25 minutes. So we go to pick it up and they can't find our order after about 5 minutes we are told they didn't place the order, we were asked to wait in there lot and they would prepare the order. After about 30 minutes my wife went in to check progress only to find the order ready and they forgot we were waiting in the lot. So to make it right, they said they were going to give us a credit , a short haired spunky lady was the person that my wife spoke to. So today we ordered some pizza and asked them to put it against our credit. She couldn't find it, we gave the story to the current manager and they told us they wouldn't honor what was promised to us. We cancelled our order and will never go back read more

We recently ,with the help of a nice letter from the Mgr, and gift certificate, decided to have another pizza from this location. Although we said nothing of the past issues, I am sure we are in the computer now. We ordered a pizza that do not normally get. Lots of Veggies, and pepperoni. My only request was we needed it delivered and begged for their great crisp crust. We ordered a large which we have found the larger the pie the harder to get a complete crust. We asked please don't overdue the sauce instead of "light sauce". Pizza arrived in 25 minutes, could not have been faster if they prepared it in our own kitchen. The pizza hot, the great crunchy crispy crust had returned. The toppings were generous and fresh tasting . A better pizza I could not imagine, I hope this has not spoiled us for the next time. 45 minutes to a hour on busy times is expected for delivery, just either hot (warm) or a call that "We are busy, and tryin to keep up, you have a ETA of......" If the pizza is cooked the way that you have sold us on over the years, we have a oven and cast skillet. Thanks for the redemption , the effort and the great Pizza. The certificate? We used for the order but in cash value 1/2 we used for a tip, the other 1/2 will be the tip on our next order. Please don't make this great order be the "1 out of 4". Late but great is acceptable. Thanks Terry W read more

Buffalo chicken pizza without jalapenos. I love flyers buffalo pizza, thet use white meat breaded boneless wings which makes the difference. They have a user friendly website for ordering, and excellent service! read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Buffalo chicken pizza without jalapenos. - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

I am not happy with how much meat they put on there subs. I asked even for extra meat and cheese and it looked pitiful. I called and they brought it again. Still pretty much looked the same. I love there food but I will go to my regular place for subs that I don't have to ask for extra. read more

You have GOT to love Flyer's Pizza. It's a West Side Columbus/Grove City thing. You either love Flyer's on Hoover or PJ's Pizza at Hall/Norton. Me, I'm a flyer's man. A good, tasty pizza, not soggy with grease, not cracker-thin, and it's not one of those pizzas where you eat a slice and be grateful you got a few pepperoni with the whole loaf of Wonder Bread you just ate. The sauce is nice and sweet.... great hot, great cold, and always spectacular with beer. Delivery is always on-time or early... can't beat Flyer's. I am, however, dinging them one star for their other menu items. The subs are passable (Gimme a King Don at that point), and everything else is bar food fare. They should team up with Tammy's. Get rid of all their sides, Tammy's sell Flyer's pizza, and Flyer's sell Tammy's sides. THAT would rule. read more

Went through there tonight and got a small pizza and a salad . The pizza was greasy and the salad was mostly just shredded lettuce with no carrots,ham or anything else. read more

Well. Besides being the priciest pizza delivery in grove city. You would think that sending out a way over cooked order would be thoughtless. Nope. Almost $40 worth of greasy and over cooked food. Could call and complain. But what's the point ? If product rolled out and deemed ok to serve. Why complain- pointless. Ticket # on the order should someone there in management want to do the right thing was # 231 on 9-1-17. Otherwise the last time I purchase your product ever. Fixed mushrooms the should be called died mushrooms. Pizza obviously over done by the extra crunchy and burnt edges. NAhh. That's good. Send it on out. Not unexpected to get delivery that is cold and needs heated up - I get it. Overcharging for a pie one may expect to maybe upgrade the delivery bags to keep it warm? NAhh why bother. Done. Doubtful that it matters but I'll say it here. Quality for the price is not here anymore. Grew too big for their britches I'd assume. Go with the BIG chains if you want consistency and quality. read more

Flyer's Pizza & Subs - Yeah. Overcooked and brakes teeth. Umm that is not as terrible as it tasted - Pizza Near Me - Grove City, Ohio

I had a great experience at this location. They were very patient with me as I tried to find my coupon unsuccessfully. However paying the regular price wasn't an issue with the employees friendliness. One girl (sorry I can't remember your name!) spoke with me the whole time I was there about different things and mostly horror films since tis the season and because she is a film major. I found it a very pleasant experience as most places will just take your order bring your food and go about their way. As I was by myself, I really appreciated the friendliness. And the food was, of course, delicious! read more

Been traveling all day, checked into my hotel and guest services recommended Flyers Pizza. Was an EXCELLENT recommendation!!! The girl who took my order was very courteous (rare these days) driver was super friendly! They even brought me paper plates and napkins which I forgot to ask for.. OUTSTANDING JOB Flyers!!! Next time I'm passing through I'll for sure order again!! Oh BTW the BBQ chicken pizza was AMAZING!! THANK YOU!! read more

I would have gave them a 3.5 overall. I would say 4 on customer service. Management always works with you. Friendly staff fast service. Mistakes do happen, I have ate here at least 50 times maybe more. Frequent Flyer miles always a perk and coupons are usually always available. Food quality 3. 3.5. read more

Fairly consistent, fresh and good. Dine in and get the free home made chips when they're fresh. (If they're not fresh don't bother) small dining area but not usually that busy. read more

Ordered two pizzas and two sides...add ranch to both sides. Both sides were wrong even though the to go ticket was correct. Pizzas tasted like they had been made for hours. Last time I'll be ordering from Flyers. "First class service" -I don't think read more

First time customer here. Normally go to Pizza Hut or Masseys when I want pizza, but they just built a new flyers in front of our apt. so we decided to check it out. Their Stromboli menu online sounded irresistible! I ordered the Philly and couldn't wait to get it home. When I got home, I found I had marinara in my box, and not the cheese sauce mentioned on the website menu. Now normally that wouldn't warrant a bad review, but when I called the store back to give them a chance to right the mix-up, I was informed I was in the wrong and every Stromboli came with marinara, not the sauce listed on the online menu. And for resolution, the girl I talked to told me she would let her manager know.... So in the future, I would choose little Caesars over this place. At least I know what to expect! read more

I placed my order online then immediately called to give a my credit card number since I realized I had used all my cash earlier. I was put on hold, waiting waiting waiting.... After 30 minutes I called from another phone to tell them I was on hold, lol. The girl said we have no lines lit up, no one is on hold. Knock knock... Guess who? " Hey can you hold on while I answer the door, I think my pizza is here." I really wanted to leave her on hold for 30 minutes but didn't. Quick delivery, food ok , price above average. read more

Extremely good thick crust and breadsticks! I look forward to trying more things off their menu.

I ordered two pizzas for carryout. When I got there to pick them up one was wrong. Mistakes happen and I waited 15 minutes while they made a new one. There was no apology for the mistake. Replacement pizza comes out and it is still wrong. Again no apology and the manager on duty overheard there was a problem and quickly went in the back to avoid dealing with it. They offered to make a third pizza but I told them to just forget it and credit my card back for the pizza they got wrong. They told me they couldn't issue a credit to my card but could give me store credit for a future order. I told them the credit needed to be issued to the card because I wasn't paying for a pizza I didn't get and after this horrible excuse for customer service I wouldn't be back. They finally said they thought they issued the credit but had no way to give me a receipt to verify it. The one pizza they did manage to get right was now cold after sitting that long. Pizza was just average at best and service was the worst I have experienced in a long time at any dining establishment. Will not be back. read more

This location is too stingy with the toppings. Flyers isn't cheap but it's good and the whole reason you pay $13 for a small pizza is because it's loaded with toppings. Not here. Take a lesson from the location in West Jeff,they do it right. read more

Never actually went inside the location or personally ordered from them, but on occasion we would order a few pizzas from here for lunch and the taste was phenomenal, even more so after the slices went cold (who doesn't love cold pizza)? read more

This place is fantastic! I work in an office where I cant leave for lunch...and it never fails!! Every time I order from here the food is fantastic and delivered quickly! The delivery guys are always super friendly as well!! They have gone above and beyond for me in the past when I didn't have change for big bills and have always been great!!!! read more