I drive a 10 year old car that I'm particularly fond of. If you're going to keep a car,…read moremaintenance is inevitable. I feel very lucky to have found a garage to depend on for repairs. I've had oil changes, a belt replaced, clutch work, and new brake rotors done here. My muffler started making noise & they fixed it without gouging me for a whole new system. Amazing! They get the work done in one day so I can drive my car home. Their prices are extremely reasonable. They're a Spanish speaking establishment, but are fairly fluent in English - so by all means don't let that stop you! I highly recommend them; it's wonderful not to dread getting work done on my car anymore.

I was shopping an AC replacement for a 12 year old car and kept getting quotes worth half the…read moreresidual value of the car, in mid May I wanted a working AC system, but didn't want to improve an old car 50% for intermittent summer use. Carmel AG came back with a price I could live with, got it done in one day, and Will is one of the nicest guys on the planet. Going forward, I won't use anyone else.

From the owner: At Carmel Auto Repair, we specialize in fast, honest, and reliable vehicle repairs with a focus on…read moretrust, transparency, and long-term customer relationships. Whether you need a quick oil change or full engine diagnostics, we treat every car with care and every customer with respect. Here’s what makes us different: ASE-Certified Technicians – Our experienced team has serviced over 10,000 vehicles with accuracy and dedication. Same-Day Service – We prioritize speed without sacrificing quality. Most repairs are completed the same day. Free Diagnostics – Get upfront, transparent estimates with no pressure and no hidden fees. Complete Auto Repair – We handle brakes, suspension, A/C, electrical systems, hybrid vehicles, transmissions, and more. Hybrid and Electric Expertise – Specialized in diagnostics and repair for hybrid and EV vehicles. Clear Communication – We explain everything in plain language, so you understand exactly what your car needs. Comfortable Waiting Area – Relax with Wi-Fi and refreshments while we work on your vehicle. Locally Owned and Operated – Proudly serving Carmel, IN with a commitment to community and quality. 2-Year Warranty on Parts and Labor – Because we stand behind the work we do. If you're looking for a repair shop that delivers real value, real service, and real results, Carmel Auto Repair is the team you can count on. Book online or call today to experience the difference.

Very trustworthy service at a reasonable price, with experienced technicians who know what they're…read moredoing

They are very knowledgeable and reasonably priced. My car is older and needs a reliable repair…read moreshop. Thank you!

totally amazed John and Company did an awesome job recommend to anyone they do a thorough check of…read morethe automobile and let you know what you need beforehand and their Fair priced outstanding place

If I could give this guy 18 stars I would! I took my car in after an accident. He had to replace my…read moreentire front bumper and he did a fantastic job! I then took it back to him a week later because I was having a separate issue with my power steering and he fixed it for free! John is simply the best!

I had a new engine put in somewhere else, but started using Eagle. I noticed an oil leak and was…read moretold there were valve leaks from when Tom Wood put in the engine. Tom Wood said my vehicle was out of warranty (12k miles or one year and I work from home, so I didn't drive it often). I had Eagle do the valve work, with was over $800. A few months later, I noticed there was still oil leaking. I took it back and they said it wasn't the valves, but is now the top oil pan. I asked didn't they have to touch or remove the oil pan to do the valve work? They said no and said it would be another $800+ to repair. I talked to another mechanic and was told they absolutely had to remove the oil pan to do the valve work. So, my truck is leaking oil and loosing engine pressure because Eagle reduced to honor their warranty and wanted to milk me for money. Update after owners response: I took my vehicle back a few months later and that was the answer given. I did not drive for the majority of 2025 because of a hand injury. I'm writing this response now because of what I was told by a mechanic recently. If they look in their system, they will see they repaired my car and a few months later, I brought it back for a diagnostic because it was still leaking oil. I work from home and put very few miles on my car between 2020 and January 2026.

My car decided to stall on the way to work while driving it this morning. I was able to get it…read morestarted and headed to another car shop down the road. They said they wouldn't even be able to look at it until Monday, so I remembered Eagle Auto which was half a mile away. I got there 10 minutes before they opened and was the first one in. Jessica helped me at the counter. She was absolutely phenomenal and LOVELY. She got my keys and said they'd have someone run diagnostics on it. I made my self comfortable and waited for about 45 mins until she came back with the results. Thankfully nothing popped up on their tests and she gave me my keys and said no charge. Wow. Just wow. Great service and they were so prompt. I told her that I would be giving them an awesome review- especially her help. I will most definitely be coming back (hopefully not too soon) when I'm in need of service. They also gave a ride to a gentleman that came a little after me. Very nice. Well stocked coffee bar and snacks. Jessica asked if I needed to do any work bc they have an office for people that work while they wait. How great is that? Thanks Eagle Auto for your kindness, thoroughness and promptness.

I scheduled an oil change for 2/27/2026. The price they gave me was good. Later they informed me…read morethey could not do the service due not getting the plug out. They said, in order to do an oil change, they would have to replace the oil pan, which would cost over $500. They said that the plug were stripped. I left there and went to the place that did the last oil change. They replaced the plug, cleaned where the plug went out completely, changed my oil, and put in a brand new plug, and I only had to pay for the oil change, which was $60. Needless to say, I don't think i'm gonna be going to that firestone again. I also called corporate after I got home. And they were very passive and trying to understand what it was. They also never took my information from me. Regarding my complaint.

Wouldn't change our tires from all-season to winter tires even. Claimed that "we don't have…read moreinsurance to change over tires if they are used tires." I have never had a tire place not switch out tires if we offered to pay no matter what brand we had or the age of the tires. What tire place can't switch tires from one to another if we pay for a service. I guess I won't ever get my car serviced here. A morning wasted going to this place. Belle Tire, Big O, CaRx, Walmart, and Town Faire tire never had any issues. Don't waste your time and go there instead.

They did a great job with a front end suspension repair last week. Up front I was given a very…read morehonest and helpful estimate / information before they did a very complete and efficient repair in reasonable amount of time and at a very fair price. A++ experience from start to finish.

Service was quick, the owner Ty is honest and knowledgeable. 12/10 family owned business I got my…read moremirror and tire sensor light fixed. Great value for the service! Thank you

I can't recommend Jerry at Goodyear enough. I've been going to him for over 20 years! Finding a…read moretrustworthy mechanic is usually a headache, but working with Jerry is always a breeze. He is straight-shooting, honest about what actually needs fixing, and never inflates prices with unnecessary upsells. Every time I bring my vehicle in, he gets the job done quickly and correctly. Top-notch service all around!

I called the night before about getting a new battery installed for my 2019 Ford Escape. I spoke…read morewith Eric who was very nice, polite and professional. He told me the total for the battery, plus labor for installation (it's complicated for my car), and sales tax would be $342.09. He advised me to bring it in the next day (today) and just drop it off and they would have it done by that afternoon. I dropped my car off around 11:30 AM and went over the details with Jerry who confirmed what Eric told me. They confirmed my phone number and I left. Before I left, I noticed their small waiting area. It had a few seats and a coffee table, I don't remember if there was anything else because I didn't stay more than a minute or two. It did seem clean though. I called them around 4:30 PM to check on the status and was told it would be done in 30-45 minutes. When I arrived around 5:15 PM, my car was sitting outside waiting for me. Only waited a few minutes before Eric came out and checked me out and I was charged exactly what I was told. I'm happy with the professionalism and the fact that they didn't try to upsell me from what I was told I would have to pay.

Will is an excellent mechanic, honest, upfront, and transparent about everything with your vehicle…read more Great pricing, fast, and thorough work. I recommend this shop to everyone I know!

Very responsive, can get you in same day and fairly priced!! The owner is wonderful, this is the…read moreonly place I'll take my car from now on. Highly recommend for any repairs or maintenance on your vehicle

Changed all four of my tires. Very thorough and had great products. Also provided extra service!…read moreGreat team.

I came in to get my tires rotated and balanced. They let me in early! They had coffee ready and…read moreasked if I was warm enough. My service was completed in about 25 minutes and I am totally SATISFIED 100%. Will definitely be returning!