Chiafullo&#x27;s

Came into Christine's in Atlantic Highlands on a Sunday for dinner. First off, the service was…read moregreat. Very welcoming and hospitable from the hostess to the servers, and even the chefs made a point to say hello. You can definitely tell it's a local spot with a loyal crowd and friendly atmosphere. The appetizers were honestly the highlight of the night. We had the fried burrata, baked clams, and the egg rolls, and all were flavorful and enjoyable. The bread was also delicious. For entrees, we ordered the Chicken Margherita and the Rigatoni Alla Sharon. The chicken was decent, simple and comforting, but nothing particularly memorable. I felt like the chicken itself could have used a little more seasoning and flavor. The biggest disappointment of the night was unfortunately the pasta dish. The Rigatoni Alla Sharon was extremely overcooked to the point where the pasta was very soft and mushy. It lacked salt and overall just didn't have the texture or flavor you hope for in a good pasta dish. We were excited to share it and it just fell flat. Overall, I'd say the appetizers alone are worth trying, but the entrees were a bit hit or miss based on our experience. The atmosphere is cute, welcoming, and clearly loved by locals, and the staff truly were wonderful throughout the night.

we came here as a group of 6 and although the space was cozy, it didn't feel tight at all! The…read moreservers were great - super attentive, gave great recommendations and very friendly. Every dish we ordered exceeded expectations. They're very big portions but the quality is what stuck out the most. Ingredients felt fresh and dishes masterfully put together. Definitely a restaurant we'd come back to!

Cozy Restaurants, front room.

Sword fish

See all

Great patio!

Strada Pizza Bar

3.8(51 reviews)

I am borderline between a 2 out of 5 stars, but the food and location itself was very good bumping…read moreit to a 3. Strada has a great atmosphere in Atlantic Highlands and works well for a casual dinner or a night out with family and friends. If you can sit outside I would as the inside is very busy and somewhat cramped. The food was great and made with quality ingredients, but I found the staff somewhat underwhelming overall. While everything was prepared great, nothing really stood out or felt particularly memorable. We have been here twice and found both times the cramped space plus the hectic atmosphere/busy-ness made it difficult to have a good sit down conversation. The first time we went we waited an hour and a half after ordering to get our food-my fiance insisted on staying but I would have left at the 45 minute mark. The experience wasn't bad, but it also didn't leave me eager to return. There are some positives here, but considering the service, and overall value, I felt it was just average and didn't quite meet my expectations.

1. Napkin was dirty 2. Utensils were dirty…read more 3. Super loud for no reason couldn't even have a decent conversation 4. Couldn't even fill a small glass a water to the top. Only stopped by once to refill 5. Food took over 30 mins (pizza & pasta, as basic as it can get). The whole pie was 3/4 burnt crust & a floppy center, no flavor sauce and sodium packed toppings 6. Speaking of food, super mediocre & super salty. Not worth $80 Unfortunately I had a gift card to this place and the disappointment of knowing im going to have to go again pains me. Shouldn't be paying $20-$30 for a pie & around the same price for pasta. You're better off hitting up your local mom & pop shop & supporting them.

Pistachio gelato

See all

Drinks/menu

Pomodoro Rosso Italian Grill & Pizzeria

3.3(74 reviews)

0.8 mi

Chicken parmigiana dinner here is absolutely delicious! The generous serving size made the price…read morereasonable, with bread and a small salad (excellent vinaigrette) it made for a great lunch, too.

We were walking up to the grocery from where we anchored in the harbor and decided to grab a slice…read more This is the best pizza my husband and I have had in ages...no flop! They have a great selection of slices, I ordered the white pizza with all the yummy ricotta and broccoli and my husband had their sausage and pepperoni. The pizza is thin crusted and flavorful. The server that helped us was helpful and chatty, telling us what other restaurants are around, who has the best happy hour, really fun. We enjoyed our slices so much that we stopped by again, the same day, and I got the white pizza and spinach. Hey, when you find a good slice, you enjoy it! David got the sausage pizza. We also picked up some garlic knots. What a treat! The restaurant is typical, simple New Jersey strip mall. Nothing to write home about, however they serve up great thin crust pizza. They do serve up other Italian fare, someone was picking up a huge order of lasagne, eggplant parm and meatballs, sounded delicious. Based on the person in the back folding boxes, they seem to be very popular. We tried the other pizza in town, but prefer Pomodoro's thinner no flop pizza!

A wide variety of slices!

See all

Julio's Pizza Co.

4.2(65 reviews)

Good pizza, good dinners. I will say where Julio's make the biggest impact is in the community,…read morefrequently hosting fundraisers and showing up when needed. During a recent power outage, they expanded the delivery radius of their Keansburg store well beyond their means to accommodate people without power. One thing to watch out for...I have had individual slices in store that aren't great, go for the fresh, whole pie when possible.

when i was like 11 i got this necklace here when i got pizza…read more i don't remember if the pizza was good but i think they had a game machine or something

Inside

Mozzarella sticks, Buffalo wings, BBQ wings, and meatballs

See all

Just OK crust. A bit chewy. Not bad but nothing special.

Porcini

4.6(121 reviews)

2.1 mi

We had a very impressive meal at Porcini Restaurant. A delicious crab cake appetizer, very well…read moreprepared Osso Bucco, Chicken pounded flat deliciously coated and served with a fresh salad, hand shaved parmesan cheese topped with a balsamic glaze. This place is operated by a young husband wife team who care what they serve. And serve at a very personable level. Chris is the executive chef and Alexandria is the General Manager. Worth the trip, especially if you have been at Sandy Hook for the day. If you live in the area, check them out, their personality is as good as the food.

Very Good! We haven't been in years but the food is still excellent. I ordered the spaghetti…read morecarbonara which was a surprise because the bacon was quite smoky. I thought it was a little overpriced for what it was, but Porcini is a BYOB so I get it Someone else in my party ordered the scallops which came out without at least six. For the price, I thought that was pretty good and my friend said they were very good. I will probably get them on my next visit. Another person in my party ordered a halibut special. She didn't like mashed potatoes so she subbed them for a sweet potato hash, and said the meal was delicious. My wife had the goat cheese ravioli which she didn't love, but full disclosure, on our way in to the restaurant we met a couple we knew who had just finished dinner and they recommended the goat cheese ravioli! So obviously it's good but just not everyone's cup of tea. It's a small cozy room, so a little loud in there, but definitely worth going. Perhaps going during the week would be a quieter experience?

Checked in

TOP FALL DISH BUTTERNUT SQUASH RAVIOLI FANTASTIC!

See all

Fusilli In a spicy vodka sauce delicious!

The Wine Bar and Restaurant

4.0(68 reviews)

I guess things didn't work out as planned. For quite some time now they are private events only…read more Gotta say one thing, it's tough to get in, lots of stairs.

The wine bar is elegant and appealing. The staff were outstanding and certainly well trained. The…read moreplace had a real fine dining vibe. They have a happy hour deal with $6 selected drinks and half price selected appetizers. The choices are diverse from tuna tartar to a truffle oil tater tot. There are many small plate offerings. The entrée choice and salads see very appealing and from I'm told the portions are generous. I've heard chatter that the prices are a bit overzealous but don't let that deter you from a visit. This is the place you bring someone when you are trying to make an impression. Just don't show up in jeans and a tee shirt, think upscale casual. We did a small plate dinner and an early movie at the theater only a short walk away. Do not miss a chance to visit the Wine Bar.

Gin and tonic in a pint glass? Ok, then..lol..

See all

Undici Taverna Rustica

3.8(306 reviews)

2.0 mi

Undici is a little piece of Italy in Rumson! The dishes are authentically true Italian, Freshest…read moreingredients, beautifully plated and consistently delicious! When you walk in you feel like you are in Tuscany, in their beautifully created indoor space, and their rustic Italian outdoor patio seating. The staff is always sweet and professional, we love our Sunday dinners there! Thank you Undici' for every detail both beautiful and delicious!

It's been a while , but Vicky and I were curious to see what had changed here at Indici since the…read morerecent rebirth The room was always very inviting , warm, and sensual in a way that keeps you captivated, nothing changed here. That we noticed. We sat at the bar with a truly pleasant barkeep named Devon. Great guy. Produced two stunning cocktails ( Awedome Negroni and blood orange Margaritas) He showed us the changes which were mostly operation things but also the new menu. ( I always liked the old menu but this one was also inviting ) He explained that they did away with pizza .. that's fine as I wouldn't think of going here for pizza .. that I'll do at Birravino .. we ordered the tuna appetizer which was delicious and fresh. Served in a chilled broth with Avacado nice dish. Vicky loved it ! I had the eggplant parm app which was also pretty authentic in its simplicity but with a fantastic sauce. I could have stopped there as it was so satisfying but no.. we needed. To try the veal malfadine which was perfectly al dente and the killer pork chop which was hands down one of the most delicious I've had in a while To finish we sampled the bambaloni, a zeppola type dessert which was nicely deep fried .. presented well and tasted great but I had a major guilt thing after eating such a heart attack invitation All told we love it here ..

See all

Franny’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.5(151 reviews)

1.9 mi

•$

Great pizza, amazing flavor and great price. Small place quaint and wish I lived closer. Friendly…read morepeople.

After watching sunset at the Sandy Hook Beach, me and my friends stumbled upon this pizzeria en…read moreroute home. We ordered Florida Deluxe pizza, chicken wings, garlic bread and sodas. The pizza and chicken wings tasted great. Despite serving delicious food, I am rating it low cause of two reasons: 1. The garlic bread never arrived. 2. Our server had a very questionable attitude towards us.She was constantly staring at our group. We were seated outside. When we asked for Chilli flakes and Oregano she asked my friend to get it himself which he did. We still tipped well.

Love this guy to death!

Buffalo pizza, margarita pizza, mamas and plain

See all

One Willow

3.6(220 reviews)

1.5 mi

Fresh seafood, waterfront views, and a relaxing afternoon along the Jersey Shore made for the…read moreperfect lunch at One Willow. We skipped brunch and went straight for the seafood favorites, starting with fresh little neck clams and the bright, refreshing citrus calamari with fennel, yuzu vinaigrette, and citrus segments that tasted like summer on a plate. The spaghetti with local littleneck clams was packed with flavor, perfectly balanced with white wine, colatura, breadcrumbs, and aged Parmesan. Paired with an Arnold Palmer and the tropical "Vacation Mode" cocktail, it was the kind of meal that makes you want to stay by the water all afternoon.

The food was delicious, fresh, tasty. The ambiance is absolutely beautiful!! The server was…read morefriendly & the service was great!

Good happy hour here!

See all

Outside bar

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tyler D.

6 months ago

Chiafullo's Pizza is an awesome local spot in Atlantic Highlands. The pizza is always fresh with a perfect crust, great sauce, and generous toppings. You can tell they really care about quality and consistency. What makes the place even better is the atmosphere. It's a family-owned restaurant with friendly staff that make you feel welcome every time you walk in. Whether you're dining in, grabbing takeout, or ordering delivery, the service is always quick and reliable. Their menu has a lot more than just pizza too -- plenty of great options if you're going with family or a group. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area and looking for a great local pizza place. Highly recommend! read more

Mike W.

11 years ago

i am housesitting for my mother, and figured i would order pizza and make it an easy sunday night. WORST IDEA EVER!!!!!! After an hour I called and someone got on the phone and said the oven were not working. Does that really happen?? you're a pizza place?? He said it was leaving in 5 minutes. After another 45 minutes I called and they said he left 10 minutes ago he should be there soon. SO after another 30 minutes the pizza show up cold and not worth 5 bucks much less the 38$ they charged. If you order from this place you are in for a very expensive and disappointing experience. Save yourself the trouble. Worst restaurant in New Jersey. read more

kristen h.

167

12 years ago

Great place. I was there over the weekend and had a great Strawberry Salad with Goat Cheese. It was soooo good. For dinner I had a Shrimp entrée in a Vodka Sauce and a really good Chocolate dessert. Everyone in our group was very happy with their experience. The food really was excellent! Nice menu selections too. Great Experience!!!! We will definitely be back. read more

Lee D.

9 years ago

Was not a fan of the pizza. So far all pizza joints we have tried in the area has been disappointing.

Jacob H.

13 years ago

Generous portions, friendly staff, great for groups. We stop here after ever beach trip.

Mike S.

13 years ago

Stick to the pizza and get it well done. The pasta dishes are not worth it.

Steve R.

12 years ago

Most overcharged pizzeria in New jersey

Chiafullo's - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Chiafullo's also viewed

Maurizios Pizzeria & Italian Grill

3.7

(166 reviews)

I've been here a few times and the food and value is exceptional! I'm from NY and like to think I…read morehave an appreciation of Italian food, plus I use to have a small pizza/Italian food restaurant. I had a fantastic sautéed spinach and mozzarella roll; the spinach was sautéed with garlic and baked in a light pizza dough, almost like a puff pastry. Tons of mozzarella and a tasty side marinara sauce. We also had a wonderful marinated eggplant hero with fresh mozzarella roasted peppers, arugula, and balsamic dressing. The bread was very light and the sandwich was enormous. I've had their entrees before and they are excellent as well. My girlfriend swears by their pizza!

Wow! I would have taken a pic of the entire pie but I was to slow and the family grabbed up a…read morecouple slices before I recognized it! This is the best tasting pie in NJ! We found this place by chance and have been twice this summer. The staff was polite and attentive. I've had a veggie pie, plain, and now the meat lovers. Absolutely delicious crust with plenty of cheese. And not that cheap low fat stuff many places try to pass off in an attempt to save money. This is real deal NJ Pizza

Zoni's Coal Fired Pizza

4.3

(305 reviews)

This is my favorite pizza place in the area. Love the Tony Sausage (spicy!) and the classic…read moreMargherita. The crust is thin and chewy and a little smoky and the toppings are always fresh. The coal fired wings with Gorgonzola sauce are also great. Would I give this place 5 stars if it was located in NYC? Probably not. For the Middletown area, though, it's the best.

First time here, I've driven passed it countless times without realizing that it was a small pizza…read morerestaurant tucked in the corner of a very small strip mall. Today my daughter wanted pizza. She's been away at school and said that good pizza is nonexistent in Florida, unless it's a chain like Dominos. So we searched and we found this small and clean place with good reviews and our very nice wait staff named Veronica. We had a quick lunch which consisted of a large margarita pie with vodka sauce. We also ordered triangle shaped fried mozzarella. The breading on the mozzarella as well as the sauce was very good. My daughter loved the pizza but I can't say I was a big fan of the vodka sauce. It was my first time having it. I prefer the margarita with tomato sauce and I think that's what I will order the next time that I visit again. I did love that the pie was thin crust, but it arrived a bit burnt. I'll have to request that my pie not arrive burnt. I will be returning to try other items.

Olivia's Trattoria & Artisan Pizza

4.3

(129 reviews)

Stopped by Olivia's on our way home from the shore and it did not disappoint. We ordered the fried…read moreappetizer sampler and it was pretty good. I loved the fresh fried mozzarella rectangles. instead of the buffalo wings, we ordered boneless wings and got chicken tenders, which is totally fine - they were pretty good. The fried ravioli were OK. For pizza, we ordered half barbecue chicken, half cheese and it was delicious! Even for next day leftovers which isn't always the case for every pizzeria. The service was great - friendly and welcoming. Ambience is chill, laidback - you can sit outdoors or indoors. Indoors had a couple booths and some tables with chairs set up comfortably with a/c for any hot summer day looking for some cool air. Will definitely stop by again if we're in the area.

pizza mid 5/10 zilch flavor. my good friend Gussy boy said it tasted like garbage and the workers…read morewere a little off when he went to pick it up. This place can succhiare il mio cazzo !

Rockafellers Pizza

4.2

(49 reviews)

Locally owned resto. Friendly and welcoming crew and owner. Pleasant experience, highly…read morerecommended. Ample space between tables. Highchair seen. Accepts debit/credit cards. Street parking. See images for reference.

Ordered to-go on 2.20.2026. Superb. Wish that I could hold this up as the North Star form Jersey…read moreShore pizza. Is it you IG/T'tock focaccia gourmet pie? Nope & doesn't wanna be. It's classic, Long Branch, Jersey Shore at its very best. So fresh. Legit ingredients. Sauce, primo. Pie & crust, what you remember from forever. I got sauseeg, peppers & onions. Beyond expectations. Want frills? Pay triple & drive 40 minutes south to AP. Want primo, passionate in every pot, local... come to Rockefellers.

Nonno's Pizzeria and Restaurant

4.1

(54 reviews)

We were in the neighborhood and decided to give this place a try…read more I ordered the Gourmet Roll, with Sausage, pepper and onion - I liked this. This combo reminds me of my dad because he used to eat this. Hubs got the Grandma Veggie Balsamic slice. This has spinach, mushrooms, breaded eggplant and zucchini, and roasted peppers on a layer of melted mozzarella, finished with a drizzle of sweet balsamic glaze. This was hubs' favorite of the two. He said that the combination reminded him of LA but with a better crust. He'd probably order this again. I thought this was ok and pretty healthy. Service was friendly and quick. Will return to try other items on the menu!

What a pleasant visit! Hospitality, smiles, then the…read moredelicious margarita slice...the crust, the sauce, the cheese, very satisfying. I learned they cater, so definitely I am having an office lunch catered with them. 5 stars for sure.

Bella's Pizza

3.6

(76 reviews)

Came here on a Saturday night. The food was not good at all. The pizza had a weird after taste. The…read morewings tasted like they had 0 seasoning.

We ordered XL pizza and garlic knots it was all enjoyable. We would go back again soon. Enjoyread more

Olivia's II Pizza and Pasta

4.4

(53 reviews)

Olivia's II Pizza & Pasta is a great local spot. When Ruffino's Pizza (which served Eatontown…read moresince the 1970s) closed their doors and Olivia's took over their retail footprint, I know many customers hoped any successor pizzeria would be as good. Thankfully there's no need to worry. The staff is very friendly and the food is better than most offering similar Italian fare. I especially like Olivia's "Brooklyn Pan Pizzas", like their Grandma, Trenton Tomato, and OG Classic varieties. Pasta dishes are also very good. The Rigatoni Filetto di Pomodoro and Tortellini della Nonna are two of my favorites. Definitely worth checking out!

Grabbed a plain slice after I saw this place next to Habit Burger. I was coming from the inspection…read morestation and needed a quick lunch. I had already ordered at Habit, don't like the computer screen ordering. 7.45 for a plain burger with extra patty, then I saw Olivia's! I'm making it my business to try every pizzeria I can find now that I'm back in NJ. So I asked for a cancel order and refund and she took 10 minutes to basically tell me it might not go through! You can't make this stuff up. Anyway the slice I got charged 3% for cc use. A whopping .09 cents. The cheese: excellent Crust and dough ratio: excellent Friendliness of young man who took my order: excellent Would definitely eat her again Bon Appetit!

Doughboys

3.9

(69 reviews)

The cheesesteak was fine, a little fatter then other cheesesteak but the bread is top notch so is…read morethe amount of meat and how it's all chopped up. Wish it was a little leaner. I kept getting big stands if fat in each bite, kinda ruined it for me.

We decided to try Doughboys for dinner. We had three different pizzas and they were all delicious…read more The service was very good. It looked like they are either creating a dining room or remodeling the current dining room. Will definitely go back, hope to see more people in the dining room.

Belo Pizzeria

4.4

(39 reviews)

This is one of the best vegan pizzas I've had in a long time. Great crust. Amazing sauce. Like…read morereally amazing, best I've had in forever. The place is super clean and everyone was so friendly. Indoor and outdoor seating. Ample parking. If they were closer to me, I'd go all the time!

Just got that familiar pizza craving and pulled off the road. Amazing pizza. Nice clean place…read more Friendly service. Decent music and a good selection of beverages. Specials too. Yes I would come back too.

Giannis Pizzeria

3.8

(75 reviews)