If you're in Hicksville, this place is a must-visit! They…read morebake their thin, crisp, incredibly delicious cookies right in front of you. There's a brief wait while they prepare your order fresh, but watching them make your cookies is part of the charm. They have tons of great flavors and delicious drinks like hot chocolate to pair with them. Great vibe, fun experience, and amazing treats. Good luck keeping any left by the time you drive home!

We were driving around Hicksville killing some time between events and drove by "Thin Cookies"…read more Curiosity got the better of me and I made a U Turn and dropped in. Ambience - feels like a utilitarian kitchen or company lunch room. The kitchen is clearly visible in the open layout and you can watch the staff making the cookie dough. Food: we ordered the 6 cookie box. I asked for Peanut Butter, but they ran out. I settled for chocolate chip and Kit Kat. The cookies were all thin, leading me to think it would be brittle like a cracker. I was pleasantly surprised that they were so soft and chewy. Must be the butter! TL/DR: thin cookies creates small portion cookies that don't make you feel guilty when you eat more than one.

The staff here is very down to earth, friendly and helpful. The building itself is very easy to…read morefind, nicely decorated inside and (of course) smells great. It was also cool to see them making the cookies right infront of you! But you didn't read this review to find out about that did you? (or maybe you did) Cookies are the BEST I have ever had. Affordable and delicious. Also perfectly thin but soft too! I'm very glad that we made a stop here.

Cookies are always fresh and warm. Me and my daughter go here once a week and no complains.read more

The best Cookies hands down. Service is quick and efficient establishment is always clean.read more

Crumbl is another popular cookie shop that serves more than just cookies. Over the years their…read morerotating menu has now included other desserts in addition to cookies such as cakes, pies and brownie creations. Some flavors I find can be either hit or miss depending what it is. I recently like the Martha Stewart collection they released this week. There was a special deal they were also giving out two chocolate chip cookie thins for free. The thins were perfectly soft and chewy. Just enough saltiness to the sweet. The coconut layer cake had light fluffy layers like a cloud. It was just enough sweetness with layers of light creme and shredded coconut and toasted coconut on top. Service from the employees is usually good. They greet every person who enter the store saying welcome to the store. So always a great customer service experience.

Their Rainbow cookies are so delicious, I have brought them to bring to people's houses and for…read morethe holidays. Everyone really enjoys them. Their pick up process during the holidays is very efficient. It makes things easier.

The hype is real! We were finally able to stop in after two years of talking about it. We came on a…read moreSaturday. We were lucky enough to get a spot right in front even with the street ahead being closed for a carnival. It's smaller inside than I thought it would be, but there were only a few people inside at the time. The line moved quickly with the friendly and helpful staff. Everything has a rainbow cookie base. The rainbow cookie mix is great on its own. Whether it was donuts, cookies or cheesecake, everything was amazing. We got a little bit of everything to try. My two favorite were the black and white cookie, and the pignoli cookie. We were far from home so we were unable to buy the ice cream. I will definitely be buying it my next trip. Five stars!

Warm, fresh donuts with fun toppings and friendly service. Always a sweet stop, Will be back.read more

I decided to redeem my birthday donut today and was so excited! I got the strawberry confetti…read moredonut. The service was extremely fast. My app had logged me out, so I couldn't show the cashier the offer on my screen, but she quickly looked up my number in her system and saw that I had a free donut in my account. I was very happy! The store was clean, and the service was incredibly fast. I got my donuts within two minutes or less. It tasted absolutely delicious! Decidí canjear mi dona de cumpleaños hoy y estaba súper emocionada! Pedí la dona de 'strawberry confetti' (fresa con chispas). El servicio fue extremadamente rápido. Mi iPad había cerrado mi sesión y no podía mostrarle la oferta en pantalla a la cajera, pero ella rápidamente buscó mi número en su sistema y vio que tenía una dona gratis en mi cuenta. ¡Me hizo muy feliz! El lugar estaba limpio y el servicio fue rapidísimo; me entregaron mis donas en menos de dos minutos. ¡Estaban absolutamente deliciosas!

This is one of my favorite dessert spots in Syosset…read more Pros: + Amazing cupcake flavors - the peanut butter cup by far is my favorite + Cupcake smash is my go to by far + Great selection of baseline flavors + Rotating daily flavors too! I love that there are several seasonal ones + Friendly staff - generous portions Cons: - Limited seating inside IG: QueenOfAdventureNYC

I love these cupcakes so much that I chose them for my birthday celebration this year. We don't…read morelive near here, but we happened to be celebrating with family on L.I. this year, and this is what I chose. Specifically, I ate 1/2 of the hot fudge sundae cupcake that I shared with my grandson, and I also had 1/2 of the peanut butter chocolate. Two excellent flavors. So much flavor and so incredibly fresh and moist. LOVE THIS PLACE !!

The owner Mike and his staff went over and above to make sure their delicious cookies were…read moredelivered to dear friend in hospice I would not hesitate to order from this store again.

One thing I love to do is review food, and Amelia's Bakehouse is a new favorite of mine…read more I went in today and tried several things off the menu, including a turkey and Brie sandwich, four empanadas (three buffalo chicken and one Smashburger), two warm chocolate chip cookies, and a hot latte. They were even nice enough to throw in a few extra things on the house. Everything was so good -- super flavorful, tasted homemade, and fresh. Mike helped me with my order and was very detailed and helpful when describing each item. The ambiance was warm and cozy! I can't wait for my next visit.

Always remember as a kid going to Milleridge Bakery and getting a lemon meringue pie…read more It was the best on the planet. I was in the area and decided to stop and see what they had too offer. The store is tiny and not much of a selection to choose from. I got an apple turnover which looked pretty good. The store was old looking and a bit rundown. The staff were friendly and helpful. Unfortunately the apple turnover was yuk!! The crust was way to thick and did not taste good and the apples were not great tasting as well. I might go again but definitely would not get an apple turnover.

It's always a joy to pick up a few bakery items to bring home after a feast at the Milleridge Inn…read morenext door. Located in the small village alongside it that features some boutique shops it's a nice way to walk around and try to digest the massive brunch I just consumed. The cinnamon rolls are delish! As are some of their pies and specialty baked goods they make here. Grab a few snacks to bring home and enjoy with some coffee while reminiscing about the gluttony you experienced earlier in the day.