This is one of my favorite dessert spots in Syosset. Pros: + Amazing cupcake flavors - the peanut butter cup by far is my favorite + Cupcake smash is my go to by far + Great selection of baseline flavors + Rotating daily flavors too! I love that there are several seasonal ones + Friendly staff - generous portions Cons: - Limited seating inside IG: QueenOfAdventureNYC read more

See all

I love these cupcakes so much that I chose them for my birthday celebration this year. We don't live near here, but we happened to be celebrating with family on L.I. this year, and this is what I chose. Specifically, I ate 1/2 of the hot fudge sundae cupcake that I shared with my grandson, and I also had 1/2 of the peanut butter chocolate. Two excellent flavors. So much flavor and so incredibly fresh and moist. LOVE THIS PLACE !! read more

These are the best cupcakes I've ever had in my life! The icing is so fresh and the cake itself is so moist. The red velvet is definitely my favorite and a must try (not too cream-cheesy at all) All of them extremely good and they have daily specials as well. I personally think you don't need to get the cookie dough one (cookie on top was stale) or the hot fudge sundae was a bit overpowering (still good though), as some of those flavors can have a lot going on and be a little too sweet. You can't go wrong with the basic flavors. Peanut butter icing one and cookies and cream icing were excellent as well. I 100% recommend this place if you're looking for a great cupcake. PS, they keep fresh very well if you're looking to buy a couple like we did. read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

Excellent cupcakes! Ordered minis for my baby shower and did not disappoint! Super cute and delicious. Can do custom styles if needed. All of the guests loved them. Nice team of people in the shop. Thanks so much! Will use again. read more

I was in the mood for a cupcake so I decided to check this place out! When you walk in, there's an aroma of cakes baking. All of their cupcakes are on display and the inside is pretty clean. The cupcakes are $5 each if you pay cash but prices are discounted if you get six or twelve. My husband and I decided to get six for $28. My favorite was the Boston Cream! The vanilla cake base was soft and delicious. The three layered frosting was the best part! Smooth, creamy, and not too sweet like regular frosting. Definitely check this place out when you're in the area! read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Wedding Cake, Peanut Butter Cup, Boston Cream, Almond Fudge, Churro, and Confetti Chip - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

Got some yummy cupcakes for my bf daughter's birthday- so delicious!! I would 10/10 recommend - cupcakes fresh even at the end of the day! read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Yummy delicious fresh cupcakes - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

I ordered a variety of 25 cupcakes for a party. Each cupcake was moist and delicious! The girl helping me at the counter was very nice and helpful. The cupcakes were a definite hit! read more

Stopped in at one of my favorite cupcake stores on my way to see a sick friend. Each day there are a few new additions the core favorites. I love the lemon drop cupcake with the lemon tang. The young girl behind the counter was helpful and speedy with the order. The store is bright and colorful making it even more appealing. read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Storefront - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

I placed an order for 2 gluten free dairy free vanilla cake vanilla frosting cupcakes over the phone a day early (which they said is all the time they need) I go to pick up the cupcakes and they didn't have any ready and had no history of my order. Luckily they had some gf cupcakes in the back ready to be prepared so I was able to take those home and they were delicious. I decided to use this bakery 2 weeks later to place an order for 6 gf/df vanilla cupcakes for my gender reveal. They wrote down the wrong phone number for my husband and couldn't contact him that they ran out of the vanilla GF cake mix. He went all the way there to find out they only had one vanilla and 4 chocolate available. This is 2 times that they messed up our order. They are completely disorganized here and I'm really glad we did not give them our business for our entire gender reveal cake. If you have a specific order in mind for your event or just to enjoy a treat, take your business elsewhere where they can take your order correctly. read more

Great cupcakes and will definetly satisfy your sweet tooth. They also do cakes which look very pretty. Not the cheapest but definetly worth the money. I would recommend you give them a try. read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Cakes they make - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

I did not personally get to visit this location. Our friends came over and brought us these delicious treats. I will be honest i rarely order a cupcake at a bakery because most or the time they're either too dry or the icing is too sweet. Not here!!! I wanted to try them all! Super fluffy. The icing light really whipped and not super sweet. Perfect amount of crunch. I will definitely be coming here to get a cupcake!! read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - My friend brought these over. Amazing - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

The best cakes I've ever had in my whole life! I have never ordered a cake blind. I ordered last Tuesday for my daughter's 14th birthday. I searched online for a cake shop near her birthday party location for a convenient pick up. The cupcakes were chocolate with strawberry frosting. I ordered a small heart cake as well. The cake is so fresh and TASTY! OMG! The cake was soft and moist. But the taste! Holy cow! The perfect chocolatey flavor. Not too sweet. It was perfect. I live 45 minutes EAST and I will travel here just for their cakes! So worth it! read more

See all

Love everything they make here absolutely delicious always bring them Upstate for the family to enjoy now that the holidays are here. Definitely going to be purchasing more highly recommended coming here if you have not tried it! read more

I was on the way home from Huntington and craving something sweet , I decided to check Yelp and see if I can try something new that was on the way . Found small cakes in syosset , put the address in my GPS and drove over . Nice big parking lot . When we walked in we were pleasantly greeted and started looking at all the goodies , first I have to tell you guys .. this place is so freaking cute ! Lots of pink , very cool decor , I absolutely love the boxes ! I can't wait for someone's birthday to come so I can order a cake from here ! They have a nice amount of ice cream flavors , cupcakes even gluten and dairy free cupcakes . They also have very cool birthday candles , sprinkles, candy bars (fruity pebble, s'mores & cookies n cream) ,lollipops , gourmet popcorn . I think they sell shirts too ( see attached pics) We ordered cookies n cream ice cream and coconut , I'm a coconut freak and this was sooo good it had coconut flakes in it but what I loved the most was the texture , my daughter liked her cookies n cream as well . We also ordered a vanilla gluten & dairy free cupcake, it was super fresh , moist and delicious! Seriously though , I can't wait to order a cake from here and looks like my birthday is coming up next read more

See all

Had someone bring me cupcakes from small cakes the other day and thought they were so good. They were perfectly sweet and really hit the spot. I personally rip the bottom off of cupcakes then put it on top to make it a cupcake sandwich (which I highly recommend). I'm not sure what other unique flavors they have there but the ones I have pictured were all really good! Would recommend this place for a sweet treat read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

the personalized chocolate chip cookie cakes are delicious and so filling! while the pricing of the cupcakes is a bit high, i also find that they tend to be too high in their frosting to cake ratio, prompting me to no longer purchase them. with that said, the cakes serve soo many people and are a great investment for college acceptances/graduations with the personalized option! i had one made for my brother's acceptance to LOYOLA MD, and one for my graduate school attendance at Columbia University. the shop itself is very clean and smells delightful upon entry! read more

See all

I stopped in last weekend to pick up some cupcakes on my way to brunch at a friend's house. This place has a really cute setup with a great selection & they sell ice cream too. Staff was friendly & helped me decide what to pick. They were a big hit- everyone loved them! With tax, it's about $5 per cupcake. Definitely worth it- they were delish! Birthday cake flavor was my fav. I definitely recommend you stop in & try them! read more

The cupcake smash is such a sweet satisfying treat for a warm day, absolutely enjoyed it! The cupcakes are moist and taste great. I just recommend more cupcakes with fillings. Can't wait to come back and try more! read more

See all

Went a couple times after school to grab a cupcake after finals or something Solid cupcake I'm just not a huge cupcake person read more

The red velvet cupcake was really good. Fluffy and moist at the same time. Would recommend.

I went to Smallcakes after a friend told me that there was a new cupcake shop in the area. As soon as you walk in, you are greeted with smiles and a warm hello. The place is very clean. I saw all the cupcakes displayed and they looked almost too pretty to eat. I was so tempted. I decided to get the Wedding Cake cupcake. I'm a big almond fan. This cupcake is make of almond cake and almond frosting. Yum! A dream come true. Me and my friend decided to also get a dozen. Yippeee. They also give you a loyalty card that gets punched with every single cupcake you buy to get a free one. Who doesn't like loyalty incentives. They also had ice cream and I was offered to try it. I tried the Cookie Monster and decided that I'll definitely be back for it. I didn't want to have sugar overload lol. I come back every other week to treat myself. I highly recommend it, you won't be disappointed. read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

See all

This place is amazing. I am very picky when it comes to my sweets especially cupcakes. Trust me when I say this place makes amazing cupcakes. From the frosting all the way to the cake part. Delicious! I am currently obsessed and order a batch almost every week. They are always so fresh too no matter which day of the week I order. I can't wait to have a cake made by them! I'm bummed I didn't try this place sooner. read more

I have been dying to come here forever and I wish it didn't take me so long. We stopped in here after our baby had a little photoshoot in the area and it was amazing. We tried the ice cream and brought home the amazing cookies that are basically like a sandwich of deliciousness (cookies & like frosting as a filling) I've been thinking of this place since we went so I'm sure we'll be back soon. Cupcakes are calling me! lol read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

I don't know why I avoided coming here for so long. It seemed like just another chain dessert store that would have mediocre desserts that cost a fortune. Well, I was wrong. Very wrong. The cupcakes here are amazing! The flavors are different and all sound just as good as the next one. Their cupcakes are moist and super flavorful - I've yet to have one that wasn't good. If that wasn't enough, they also have ice cream. Unique flavors and your basics, they have you covered. If that still isn't enough, they can make cupcake shakes and you can have a cupcake topped with ice cream. I've had them all and they are all to die for. I'm mad at myself for not coming here sooner, but also glad i waited because I'd really be here all the time. A little pricey to be coming everyday, but it's your average dessert pricing. Worth the price, everything is delicious! read more

I had creeped on Smallcakes on IG for quite some time before I finally visited Smallcakes and couldn't resist a post on their rainbow cookie cupcakes. My bestie whose super into rainbow cookies was visiting from Florida so I quickly called and requested the last 2 remaining cupcakes. On my way home from work, I pulled into Smallcakes and was greeted by 2 friendly young girls. They had my order ready aside so I paid and they explained the rewards program where you get a stamp per cupcake purchased, once you reach 12 cupcakes you earn a free cupcake (not hard to do). I have since visited Smallcakes a few times, and have tried the Nutella, birthday cake, hot fudge sundae, and the rainbow cookie cupcakes and have yet to try something I didn't love. These cupcakes are hefty, I split a cupcake and even half a cupcake is a decent indulgence! See pics attached, because they're a real beauty even when cut straight down the middle. Needless to say, I'm very impressed and look forward to their specials that change weekly. To date, my personal faves have been the hot fudge sundae and the rainbow cookie, but I am looking forward to seeing a comeback from the Cookie monster cupcake and giving that a try. I highly recommend Smallcakes, these cupcakes are irresistibly rich. read more

See all

I love the cupcakes from here but the manager was extremly rude and inconsiderate. The image on the cookie cake printed unclearly and bad quality. The manager refused to believe so, very strange because on instagram their photos the the cookie pies look great, unfortunately that wasnt the case for me. read more

The cupcakes were absolutely delicious. They are full size cupcakes, i thought they sold mini ones from the name. But each cupcake i picked up was wonderfully moist and full of flavor. My favorite was the peanut buttercup cupcake. The lady that helped me pick was so sweet too. They also sell homemade ice creams, which are fun and whimsical. read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

Ambiance/wait staff- this is a great little cupcake shop! It's clean and the case of cupcakes is neat and inviting. They even have sparkles on the walls! They have a clean bathroom and seating for about 6 people. The counter help is very patient and kind. Food: I bought a box of 6 cupcakes. They were ALL delicious! I bought the banana snickerdoodle, salted caramel, cookies and cream, s'mores, Reese's peanut butter cup and one that looked exactly like a hostess cupcake. They were amazing!!!! The cake was moist, the combos were creative and the icing was sweet and delicious. Even two days later the cake was moist! I could not believe it! They give a punch card out and you get a punch for each cupcake you buy! They have specials each day of the week! And they even have homemade ice cream! I will definitely be back! Yummm! Happy snacking! Nicole read more

See all

Heaven in a cup! It's ice cream on the bottom, a cupcake smashed inside and then ice cream on the top again. It's absolutely sinful and totally worth it! Can't wait to go back! read more

I haven't been into cupcakes for a while but my friend and I stumbled upon Smallcakes while looking for a dessert spot. All the cupcakes looked beautiful. We got the red velvet, peanut butter cup, chocolate cream, and a brownie. Every single one was incredibly moist and delicious. read more

Just found this little gem! Picked up some cupcakes, which were absolutely delicious! Can't wait to go back!

Today I took the ferry from CT to Long Island. Surprising my son for his birthday. I bought cupcakes from the famous Sugar Bakery in East Haven. As soon as I got onto the Ferry I forgot to bring the cupcakes. I searched the internet. Found Small Cakes in Syosset. Seriously the BEST cupcakes I have had in my life! Super moist and light. Decadent and perfect! We are now a follower.. We can never go elsewhere.. read more

Best cupcakes ever. We are obsessed. They are just as good 3 days later. Always so consistently good!! read more

See all

Stopped in as we needed cupcakes for a graduation party. Service was slow as a girl Was on the phone and saw us but didn't acknowledge us when we came in (continued talking and turned her back). Another girl came out twice to stock cupcakes and didn't even acknowledge us or ask if we'd been helped. (That was all of 5min.) Finally a guy came out and helped but again, didn't greet us or ask if we'd been helped. Strange. Nonetheless, pretty much got 1 of everything (peanut butter cup, fudge sundae, hostess cake, birthdayl cake, red velvet, lemon, etc). Once there, everyone one enjoyed and got what they wanted! All tasted great! -1 for the weird unfriendly service read more

We just stopped in for ice creams and I wouldn't say they have the most unique flavors but were different. We did try some and were not that impressed. A pint comes with 4 flavors and we decided to give it a shot. Usually, pints are completely filled if we get anywhere else but here, they measure exactly 4 scoops and we found it to be too expensive for the portion. Maybe a good place for cupcakes but not for ice cream. read more

This place is heaven on earth for the ice cream n cake lovers ... from the decoration to the taste to the cleanliness of the place is just outstanding... I tried the New York cheesecake ice and red velvet ice cream . I never tasted anything so danmm good in my entire life .. the cupcakes are so fresh the cupcakes decoration are like an OMG moment . Who ever created that place god bless your soul ... go over there n try for your self I guarantee you you will not regret it.. the only thing is The guy over there was a bit overwhelmed but I understand his frustration Cause he was picking up the phone n he helping people in there .. I will be back for some more ice cream read more

See all

Smallcakes Syosset came to the rescue and delivered an amazing experience in a short turnaround time. A super easy ordering process for a custom cake. The staff was welcoming and excited for the cake theme. The cake was amazing, funfetti cake and cookies and cream filling, and was the talk of the party. I cannot thank Smallcakes Syosset enough. They did an unreal design and surpassed my expectations! read more

I placed an order for my birthday, and smallcakes was amazing. I had difficulty deciding what to get cakes, cupcakes, or minicupcakes, and they were so patient every step of the way, whether by call or by email. The owner kept me updated with pictures, and was very efficient. I ended up getting mini cupcakes in the shape of a 17. They even offered to add sprinkles at the top without me asking- and it added a beautiful touch to the cupcakes! read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Custom Mini Red Velvet Cupcakes - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

This place is so cute and the cupcakes were delicious!! I got the lucky charms, lemon drop and Peanut Butter Cup cupcakes and we all loved them! I will definitely be back. Their flavors change everyday so I definitely need to try the s'mores next. read more

Smallcakes - Syosset - Cupcakes Near Me - Syosset, New York

Delicious, light, moist cupcakes. Red velvet was my favorite one but they were all beautiful and tasted as good as they looked!