The gold standard for New York City bagels is that they be boiled before baking and that they be hand-rolled. The New Bagel World in Central Valley comes close to making authentic tasting NYC bagels, even though they're not hand-rolled. I come here for bagels and spreads but the shop has wide range of other options including omelettes, breakfast wraps and wraps, paninis, heroes, salads, and, of course, coffee and tea. One thing I particularly appreciate is that they make fresh squeezed orange juice. Not surprisingly, they carry a full line of Boar's Head cold cuts and cheeses. The store is relatively small and at times can get very crowded. There are a few tables so you are better off buying food to take out. I'm pretty fussy about bagels and I'm glad there is finally one nearby that I enjoy. read more

See all

$7.50 for the most pathetic bagel breakfast sandwich. One egg, barely any meat. Place is not the same. Do better!

I've been here a few times and the service and food seems to be hit or miss. It was a big miss this time. Cashier was unfriendly and I seemed to be a burden to them. Food was terrible. Bacon and hashbrown were not cooked. Price was a little steep to keep taking chances with the food quality. Unfortunately this will be my last time here. read more

Bagel World - Bobo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Central Valley, New York

See all

This is a bagel with lox that cost 13.49. Totally burnt and the lox is as skimpy as you can get. What a waste this was supposed to be my breakfast/lunch to get through a long shift read more

Bagel World - Bagel with lox - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Central Valley, New York

See all

Bagel World is our go to!! Polite, quick, and delicious! Always friendly!, Service is always great!

I love the remodel, it looks amazing!! best bagels and always friendly service! always have a great variety

Got the whole wheat bagel, it's a bit thin. Had a subtle sweetness that I liked. Plus it's only $1 and you get a free bagel if you buy 6! Super friendly employees too. Wish they had vegan cream cheese but I just order it toasted and put it on when I get home. read more

AMAZING SERVICE AND HOSPITALITY!! The bagels are amazing but the customer service was extremely professional and truly kind. I plan on stopping next time we visit New York!! read more

See all

I can't believe this place is 2.5 stars! Bagels were amazing! They had a gluten free option for me which was a life saver! 10/10 read more

Bagel World - Sausage egg and hash brown. With gluten free bagel! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Food is mid. But the employees are rude with an attitude for 0 reason. Tried this place 2 times bc I thought maybe the first time was just a bad day but nope... theyre always grouchy and unpleasant read more

The service is horrible. The Spanish lady that works. There is doing you a favor when she serves your food she has a very bad attitude will never be back. read more

I'm from out of town so it was my first and only time here but it's great! Fast and friendly service, yummy bagels and only about $12 for 2 bagels with gourmet cream cheese, a chocolate milk, and a tea. I would definitely recommend! read more

Bagel World - Bagel with Chives Cream Cheese - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Central Valley, New York

Tried calling multiple times to order for take out no one answered and at some point someone picked up and disconnected the phone? If you're not there to work, what are you there for? Went in to order instead and there were 4 people "working" there and the place wasn't busy -ordered an overpriced chicken Caesar salad and noticed when I got home they put no croutons lol waste of money since it is super overpriced and the service could be better, don't bother! read more

Amazing breakfast wraps and sandwiches. Great food and service!

Bagel World served me probably the best bacon egg and cheese I've had in a _long_ time. The food was hot and tasty, and the staff at Bagel World were kind and super friendly. Can't recommend this place enough! read more

Awesome bagels and breakfast sandwiches/wraps that come with a coffee! Friendly staff and great selection of cream cheeses and bagels read more

Bagel World - Bagels are fresh everyday & super delicious! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Central Valley, New York

See all

Dependable convenient and good fast service. I just wish they would make more French Toast Muffins. Omg they are soooo good. Please don't go buying them all out after reading this. Save me one read more

Went here today to pick up breakfast for my family. The female who was either the owner or manager was so unbelievably nasty to her staff. I watched in disgust as she talked down to them, coached them on what they were doing wrong in front of other employees and customers. Frankly she made me so uncomfortable. I will travel to route 17m which is further to avoid supporting this nasty women's business. I truly feel bad for her staff, they deserve a better environment to work in and not to be disrespected and treated so poorly. read more

I was excited when this opened since the one in Monroe is so good. To my disappointment, the workers here are ALWAYS rude. I also find it slightly overpriced. read more

I am impressed with bagel world! The previous reviews on this page are surprising to me. I ordered an italian combo on a bagel (boars head meats, fresh bagel) and it was delicious and was made in a very timely manner. I pass this deli 5 days a week and never thought to try it until today. I'll be back! read more

The service sucks someone always has a attitude ... I give up on them I drive out to Chester how sad is that!

I've been here three times. On none of those occasions have the bagels been fresh. A fresh bagel should not be chewy or hard to bite into. It doesn't appear that they make them fresh daily. There is another location with the same, who's bagels are consistently fresh; or at least they taste fresh. I was excited to have a bagel place close by but I rather take the drive instead of getting day old bagels. If you've just opened an establishment, it should be top notch. Make only what you think will be sold. If they are fresh maybe consider a different method because the bagels are not well made. I hold the standard high...no matter where you are in NYC, you can typically find a good bagel place. This wouldn't even compare. read more

I've given them a few try since they opened & I just can't anymore. The bagels are made at the Monroe, NY location & brought over, so you are getting day old bagels. I've ordered breakfast sandwiches from them & have had to ask them to melt the cheese onto the taylor ham. If I don't they just throw a piece of cheese after they have cooked the ham. Today I decided to grab lunch from them & the roll is stale, the lettuce looks old & the tuna has to much mayo. During their peek times, there are too many people behind the counter & they are tripping over each other. This review it JUST for the Central Valley location. I've never had an issue with the Monroe location. read more

The best bagels in the area You can tell a lot about how a bagel is going to taste by the way it pulls apart. These bagels remind me of some of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn. Fresh and hot are always the best way to eat them. My favorite flavors are egg and super egg. Their mini bagels are excellent - just wish they made mini egg bagels too. We buy their cream cheese because it's much tastier than what you can buy in the local stores. The staff is polite and attentive and the store and display case always spotless. read more

Amazing bagels!! Small space and ordering was a little confusing but bagels there deserve 5 stars!

This place is soooo overpriced! An egg salad wrap costs the same as a roast beef wrap. The bagels are not that great. They consistently make mistakes when ringing you up always in their favor. What a rip off. Stay away. read more

Staff is always friendly and the bagels are nice and fluffy. I love the sesame bagel here

I will not go back. The people who work behind the counter are extremely rude. I politely asked to go over my receipt because it was quite confusing. It listed items that I did not order. The woman I spoke to was unbelievably rude. Where do they get these people? They need serious customer service training. read more

Bagels are fat and doughy, not the way a bagel is supposed to be. Help can be personally cleaner

Bagels are not the freshest, salads don't look great or super fresh I wanted to order egg salad and whitefish salad and lox on a Sunday morning but saw the salads in the case and passed. When you go to a bagel store and pay a premium you want the salads to look fresh the looked slimmy you also want the fresh bagels if I wanted almost fresh ones Ill go to ShopRite. They use acme lox out of a package. I saw the girl weighing out 1/4 packages there. She was putting in bits of lox not slices into these pre made packages no slices not a fresh salmon .If I got a premade lox package like this I wouldn't be happy I 'll pass. I got 2 sesame bagels plain and a everything bagel toasted with butter $5.20 for this . If this was a good bagel shop I have no problem paying but imo its not. To bad cause the area could use a top notch bagel shop not mediocrity. Never had there eggs sandwiches they have a very small griddle where the make eggs . Been there a few times and I haven't been impressed. I give it one star cause I don't think its good sorry. If you need bagels go to Jay's deli down the road there ok there and half the price. read more

Very overpriced. Went in for breakfast and ordered a $5.79 bacon egg and cheese bagel (yeah, I know, almost $6 for a breakfast sandwich). I was asked what kind of bagel I wanted, and I asked for an Asiago bagel. When it comes time to pay, the screen at the register says $5.79 sandwich, and $1 custom item. I asked what that was, and she said it was because of the Asiago bagel. I pointed out that it is not noted on the menu, nor did she tell me it was extra. I've ordered a dozen bagels there many times, and was never charged extra for the Asiago bagels. Why is it more when getting an already overpriced sandwich? Almost $7 for a breakfast sandwich. read more

Sandwiches and combos are delicious! Bagels are great too! Favorite sandwich is chipotle chicken panini! Staff are very courteous and friendly! read more

This place is overpriced for food that comes out raw. The whole chain of Bagel World's is like this. Please save your money.

Overpriced for a wrap or bacon and egg sandwich. I love the Mexican wrap however, the past two times I've ordered it, it's a wrap, however not the description on the menu. The Mexican wrap is sausage, scrambled egg, cheese, peppers, and jalapeños. However, the past time I got this wrap and this time it's been a weird combination of peppers and chicken. The last time it was just eggs and avocado with hot sauce and salsa. The Mexican wrap is good as is on the menu. If the deli does not have the ingredients at that moment then the customer should be informed. read more

I got a bagel with cream cheese and a Starbucks Frappaccino and they charged me for a Smoothie at $12! The clerk shoved the receipt in the bag and pushed it at me. I thought the price crazy so I looked at the receipt and saw that he didn't ring me up for what I purchased. When I told him that he overcharged me he actually said, "Yeah, I thought that was too much"! He had to call someone else to come fix it and when I asked to see the credit receipt I was told to check my bank account on my phone and was then ignored. The young man did apologize, but I was very off put by not being allowed to see the credit receipt. I used my debit card from a credit union and some transactions don't show up for a couple of days so I could not verify my credit. I've had other instances at this place that I was not happy about but I overlooked them, trying to give them a chance. I will not overlook this instance and I will never go back there. Check your receipts if you go! read more

I went in to the store today to buy my grandson a rainbow bagel. He eats it plain so I didn't get anything on it. I gave him the bagel and then went to pay for it. I was charged $2.50 for this bagel. I was in shock. I paid for it but thought what a rip off. I see in these yelp photos the bagel are $1.00. I am furious someone would do this. I would never go back here. read more

it's so sad. we have had great bagel places in CV in the past. i was a faithful customer. but this place, ew. it just looks dirty. behind the counter, the servers seem very confused, and the cashier is surly. bagels are stale, the fillings look crusty. the coffee constantly runs out, and the tea is never refilled. so why? why should i patronize this place? we have a lovely bakery down the street that's pristine and always incredibly clean. you can see the kitchen from the counter. it's disappointing that the simple task of making and serving bagels is seemingly so complicated. limit your menu, keep your coffee hot and ready, and your condiments refilled. there's really no excuses unless you just don't really care. read more