Got to enjoy a Nutella bar and tried some of the small peanut butter buckeyes and cake cuties my husband got for himself. Very friendly service and the store was nice and clean too. read more

Chocolate in the Oven - Small pastry box we received our order in - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

See all

Stopping in here was one the high points of a weekend bike ride up the Canal towpath. They had me at "S'mores," but I also grabbed a Seven-Layer bar to go and enjoyed that one later in the ride. The S'mores Bar was just the right proportion of graham cracker pieces, milk chocolate chunks, and toasted marshmallow: Fresh, good texture, and great taste. The Seven-Layer bar had berries, white chocolate, and butterscotch, and tasted wonderful. For a bonus it held up well on the bike. At 10:00am on a Sunday, service was quick, friendly, and there was an excellent selection of baked goods and truffles in the cases. Whatever you're looking for will likely be here. Also. tip-of-the-hat for having a few outdoor tables and a bench to enjoy the fresh baked goods and people-watching for a few minutes. The bakery is only a half block from the bridge, and is absolutely worth a stop if you're hiking or riding up either side of the river and want a quick Sugar/Carbs fix. read more

Chocolate in the Oven - S'Mores Bar! Yes, it is as good as it looks. - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

The pastries and cookies are 4 star. The cakes are "good" and 3.5 star worthy. The place is overpriced as compared to other quality bakers - so 2 star there. Customer service is mediocre- not very flexible on requests - 2.5 stars there. Overall - 3 star. read more

Loved their Carrot cake and Almond Orange cake. Def trying it again. Such a great sweet place.

The smell alone is worth staying an hour! And good luck leaving without buying at least a dozen items. The Lobster Tails were amazing, the cupcakes and other pastries were equally as good. Cute little selection of candy and some gluten-free items. Staff was pleasant. read more

See all

Visited twice and loved each visit! Staff was friendly and the vibe was so welcoming. We will be visiting often, the treats are delicious! read more

Chocolate in the Oven - Desserts - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

See all

Chocolate in the oven is our go to for a treat! Their eclairs, rainbow cakes, chocolate bomb cheesecake and other pastries are the best around! It was a given that we would have Cathy and her amazing team make our wedding cake for our special day! It was beautiful and delicious! A special thanks to Dawn for her meticulous decorating skills! Check them out for your every day special treat or special occasion orders, you won't be disappointed!!! read more

Chocolate in the Oven - Wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

Wow! This place is amazing. My friends have been bringing me their goodies for years. Today I ventured there to order my daughters Birthday Cake. The owner was lovely. We grabbed a few treats to go as well as a latte'... this charming spot did not disappoint! Can't wait for our unicorn cake. Update! We got our Unicorn Cake. It was exactly as my daughter requested... a blast of rainbow colors and it tasted great!! Everyone was so impressed!!! I would definitely recommend! read more

Chocolate in the Oven - a variety of cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

See all

So three years ago I left the initial review and the owner contacted me through Yelp and basically said I was trying to be hateful for my description of the young woman as goth. Heavy makeup, dark clothes, shit kickers seems goth to me. Now apparently that young woman has apparently been getting a good laugh at my review. When you have children with severe nut allergies let's see how funny you think it is when you can't get the answers you need. read more

Chocolate in the Oven - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

Chocolate in the oven has a huge variety of yummy treats. It's hard to make a choice.

Best goodies oh my. The staff were very sweet and friendly but the sweets were sooo incredibly good it pains me that I don't live closer. We got a box with a cream puff eclair, truffles and these other bite-sized treats, and cheesecake cups. All of them were mouth watering read more

Happened upon this cute little bakery while in Milford today and so glad I stopped in! Bought a lemon bar, crumb cake slice, cream puff, sfogliatelle and anisette biscotti. All I can say is wow, all were incredible! I live 45 minutes away and would definitely make the trip back just to go to this bakery! Girl behind the counter was super nice too. read more

"chocolate in house" not if it is October, it is pumpkin in house. Came in looking for chocolate baked goods, walked out empty handed. I am sure it is a lovely local bakery, the photos look great, very nice woman, serious lack of chocolate despite the name. read more

Amazing amazing products! I love the location, the decor, and all of the products! For those who would like to treat themselves (and others! Chocolate in the Oven will not disappoint. I highly recommend this place! read more

This place is simply too good for Milford. Their cakes are phenomenal and have so many options to choose from and customize as well. I have yet to be disappointed with anything I've gotten from there. Thinking about it as I write this is making my mouth water in ecstasy. Seriously out of the whole town of Milford this place is the reigning king of delightful taste read more

Chocolate in the Oven is a top-quality bakery. Their display of desserts is mouth-watering, and browsing it to pick out a sweet snack is honestly a joyful experience. I've never ordered one of their cakes, but I've seen them being made in the back and they look absolutely stunning. I don't know the owner's name, but she is always kind and helpful. read more

This place is amazing and so refreshing. Staff are always at hand to answer questions. They're amazingly friendly and helpful.

Awesome baked good made on the premises. Owner is very nice and accommodating. Amazing cakes too! The focaccia bread is to die for on Sundays. Easy order on-line. You can't beat it! I highly recommend this bakery! read more

I've used Chocolate in the Oven for a few special events, and each time everyone raved about the cake. The owner created a beautiful tiered cake for a 50th birthday party in varied shades of pink and white, with a mocha filling. Stunning and delish! read more

Chocolate in the Oven - Chocolate layer cake with mocha filling. - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

Just randomly stumbled across this place today, with a friend. It was one of the best ice cream/gelatos I've ever had ! The strawberry cheesecake was amazing & my friend had the peanut butter Oreo. We loved it. Thank you !! :) read more

I frequent this bakery often cause they have outstanding Americanos and amazing baked goods!...I ordered their Christmas cookie platter to bring to a holiday party and it was absolutely beyond perfect it was such a big hit and it saved me from making something They are so accommodating and kind and their baked goods are top notch!! read more

Charming place; makes a delightful cappuccino and love their desserts--especially the peanut butter chocolate buttons

Had dinner across the street and came over for dessert. The owner was sooo nice and helpful. We had a big group and she was happy to have us. Lobster tail was the best I have ever had. I have had them from philly to the north end of Boston and this hands down was the best. I hope the area recognizes what a jem this store is. read more

Great little candy store that has great coffee. My coworker goes to get coffee all time their. That is how much he likes it

Everything done with love...it say I need to add 59 characters. I assume I was too brief...how am I doing? Look like I made the required amount. read more

Everything in this bakery is delicious along with an excellent staff that's ready to serve you. The cakes, fruit tarts, backeyes, etc. are the best I've ever eaten anywhere. I can't say enough about the treats here. read more

Heaven. Smells literally like chocolate in the oven when you walk in. You won't know what to choose b/c everything looks fantastic. I noticed they had their Italian rainbow cookies for sale--but they also had home made Italian rainbow cookie *ICE CREAM*. They had fresh, amazing looking lemon bars--but they also had lemon bar ice cream! Needless to say, these 2 flavors in a cup for me were perfection! Each flavor had not only a good base, but chunks of their amazing fresh baked specialties in the ice cream. --So good!! So creative!! Brava!! read more

Lots of yummy looking deserts but I paid $3.50 for 1 linzer cookie. I have never paid this much for 1 cookie. Seems like alot for just 1 medium size cookie. Will probably visit again but try a different item. read more

I can't say enough about this place. My grandson was coming to town and requested very specific details about what he wanted in a birthday cake (chocolate cake, peanut butter filling, peanut butter icing). They nailed it. And it tasted even better than it looked! The Pokémon cookies were a hit as well! read more

Chocolate in the Oven - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

I have celiac disease so it's great that there are many gf options at this stylish bakery. Personal favorite are the almond encrusted dark chocolate dipped almond horns. Sublime! Plus, Cathy and her staff are always friendly and fun folks to visit. read more

Both the brownie and cream puff my husband and I tried from here were delicious! We planned to save some of it but it was too good not to eat the whole thing! The store owner was very friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend this to anyone in the Milford area! read more

Love this bakery, everything is amazing. Cathy is wonderful to work with! My favorites are the mini cheesecakes, and it's a fan favorite with everyone in my house too. Dangerous but delicious!! read more

Awesome yummy place! Stopped by one evening and got a brownie! Brownie was gone before we hit the car!!!

What an adorable shop. Stopped in and purchased some buckeye ice cream. Oh my word, it was fabulous. Giant chunks of buckeye and perfectly sweet. We also were to enticed by the baked goods not to grab some. We got a s'mores bar and peanut butter cookie and did not regret a single bite. A wonderful stop for sweets and ice cream. read more

Well just had my first cake from here and no joke was one best I have ever had real butter cream icing perfect flavor and the cake was amazing section was incredible texture and taste will definitely get my cakes here going forward outstanding!!!!!!! read more

This place is amazing. I called about two weeks ago to request a cake for my sister in law's baby shower. The only problem was .... I needed to pick it up Christmas Eve. I spoke with Cathy (the owner) who assured me it was no problem. The other issue was I was from out of town and would need to drive it 2.5 hours from Milford. Cathy was great to communicate with, texting me pictures of what ideas she had based on the description I gave her (woodland themed). We ended up with a vanilla cake with chocolate ganache as one layer and the other layer was a chocolate cake with cookies and cream (a customer favorite). I picked up the cake without a problem - it was ready and waiting for me at 10 am Christmas Eve as promised and it made it to the shower in one piece. Cathy even gave me extra white chocolate in case pieces fell off in transport (which didn't happen). It was a HUGE hit at the shower!! Everyone raved about the design and the taste was awesome. The vanilla layer was delicious, but that chocolate layer was ommgggg and the cookies and cream filling - to die for. I would go back to Chocolate in the Oven in a heartbeat. So easy to deal with and phenomenal product. The store is adorable. Everything smells like heaven. I should have ordered cookies, too, because they looked awesome. Thank you again to Cathy and her team for pulling off what felt like it was going to be the impossible task. You saved/made the day! read more

Chocolate in the Oven - Bakeries Near Me - Milford, New Jersey

What a find! Chocolate and peanut butter pastries were pure heaven. Light smooth and creamy. In addition we tried the Nutella homemade by owner ice cream. Deliciousness! The owner is very friendly and answered all questions. Will definitely go back anytime in the area. Way better than Frenchtown desserts! read more

Love this place! So far my favorite is the banana pudding - it's crack! So addictive! They made Irish soda bread for St. Pats. I walked into store and another customer turned to me and said taste the soda bread sample....it's the best soda bread I have ever had....I did and she was 100% correct....it was the best soda bread I have ever had too. St. Pats was a week later so I didn't buy it figuring I would get it the following week. I got to my car, the caraway hit and I immediately went back to purchase a loaf. I ate some, froze the rest and served it at St. Pats dinner and everyone raved about it. I also served, to more rave reviews, a chocolate pudding pie I ordered from Chocolate in the Oven (my Dad's favorite dessert). It was decadent. Absolutely delish with a graham cracker crust and dollops of whipped cream. Highly recommend Chocolate in the Oven!!! Note....call ahead if you want to try the banana pudding....it's not a daily item. read more