Off the beaten path. We found it from a travel app after foregoing a large but empty truck stop. We found the food to be very satisfying. I had a Buffalo Chicken Pizza which was better than I expected from a real Italian place. We were here just before Christmas. The cute little downtown, Christmas music from the local radio station, and quaint family Christmas decorations made it ridiculously honey. Just what we needed in the middle of a long trip. read more

Waterloo Ny The Best pizza pie in 100 miles! The food here every dish Ive had has always been amazing. You won't be disappointed in Waterloo! ... Geneva I didn't like and the attitude from staff when food was horrid wow! Glad Waterloo staff isnt like that then again never had my food order messed up in Waterloo, Staff so nice, friendly always helpful and a joy to eat there or take out. Best food in Area! And Im picky very picky not once was my food wrong or nasty. The waitresses are so amazing fast and always smiling That 20% + tip they deserve read more

I have now had my fourth bad experience ordering from here. Once was totally the wrong sandwich and I did call them. Then, 2 undercooked pizzas. Decided to give them another chance and spent $16 on this supposed Philly cheesesteak. Almost no meat in a badly sliced roll that was dried out with just a streak of cheese. Won't be making the mistake of ordering here again. read more

Ciccino's Pizzeria - Philly cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Waterloo, New York

Well I can start this review waiting for my order. Was seated and passed by for about 15 mins from everyone of the help and finally someone volunteered to wait on us. So far service is a joke and it's really not that busy. Sent the prime rib back. Ordered rare and got well done and was told that's the rarest they have, wife got the chicken Alfredo and heavy oil I'm assuming. More people coming in but this night they failed very very well! read more

Ciccino's Pizzeria - Chicken Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Waterloo, New York

Bowl of Water logged pasta instead of olive oil and garlic sauce - please drain your pasta water next time and maybe use Kalamata olives versus canned black olives and artichokes? The rolls were almost $2 each and were drowned in oil/soggy. The hostess when asked what the best item and signature dish we shouldn't pass up tonight firmly told us "I don't know, I don't eat here" ..... wow. read more

See all

Lunch after golf. Had the Hawaiian flatbread and a salad. Good not great. Flatbread pizza had great flavor but was burned a little. It was quiet so service was quick and overall good. Nice spot, with an old Italian theme - will try again. read more

Ciccino's Pizzeria - Hawaiian flat bread bbq pizza - Pizza Near Me - Waterloo, New York

The hostess had the personality of a wet rag. The table was dirty that she sat me at and I had to ask her to wipe it down. The waitress was nice and attentive. The lasagna was average at best. Good size portions price point was right for the quality of food. read more

Wonderful! The food was delicious! Our waitress was phenomenal... she was the best and working the entire floor and the bar by herself!!! We were so impressed with her and our food. Great experience! read more

Ciccino's Pizzeria - Calzone, spaghetti with meatballs and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Waterloo, New York

Here in the area visiting family and I've never tried Ciccinos. So age dinner here I ordered the spaghetti with meat balls it also came with a side salad and bread everything was delicious the spaghetti wasn't over cooked and the meatballs had lots of flavor. The hostess and waitresses were friendly and tentative to my needs. read more

See all

We were looking for a casual pizza place with the typical Italian entrees. We found this place and LOVED it. We sat at the bar. First, the bread was good- and the tomato olive oil dip was out of this world!! I got the chicken parm, which came with a salad that was good. The chicken parm was awesome. Large piece of chicken good sauce and cheese coverage. The sauce is very good. The portion was two full meals for me. My hubs got a slice of pepperoni. Their pizza is a little thicker and chewier than I think of NY style, but it was tasty. They didn't offer a side Caesar so his salad was large and had a lot of red onions and black olives and the dressing was on the side- all unexpected on a Caesar salad. read more

See all

We have not been to this restaurant in a very long time. We had planned a visit to the local library to watch a show and this was a great spot to stop for lunch. We had a lots of leftovers! We enjoyed a chicken, Parm sandwich and two pizzas. The food was tasty, and the service was pleasant. read more

See all

My second visit in 2 weeks. The first was not good. The second was dreadful. For a starter my wife and I had fried ravioli, onion rings and breaded squid. Whilst the portion was large, I do not expect cheap store bought food. If I wanted that I would cook it myself. It smacks of lazy chefs or incapable chefs. I then had the fish fry which was the worst fish fry I have had in the area. The portion of actual fish, not the batter, can't have been more than about 4 ounces. I think the fish had been frozen because it was tasteless, overcooked and dry. The batter was even worse. I can't be positive but it seemed as if it may have been bought in frozen and ready battered. The chef had broken the fillet in half after cooking which doesn't enhance the look of it on the plate. The fries were cheap frozen fries. My wife had a salad which she said was the best part of her meal. She then had the veal parmesan with fettuccine. The pasta was way overcooked, certainly not al dente. The veal was tough and chewy. With the meal a lump of indeterminate bread was served without the means to cut it. Just so amateurish. The service was average but no one asked about deserts. Not that we would have had one after what we had so far received. Nobody queried the amount of food not eaten. I would estimate that we ate perhaps one third of what was served. Now I accept that I am a fussy diner but I normally don't complain, I just never go back. But this was so bad I had to write a review. And I definitely won't be going back! Brian Carder read more

I have never had a bad meal from here! Workers are always friendly and helpful. Plenty of room for bigger parties. It's my go to place for pizza and Italian food. Highly recommended!! read more

Tonight I ordered a chicken parm sub and an antipasto salad. After all the times I have ordered from here this is the first time I was disappointed by my meal. The chicken was over cooked, and the sauce was on the side. The salad was just as disappointing. Lettuce wasn't cut or torn uo.had full leaves of lettuce. There was no cheese on it and only too meats. This was suppose to be an antipasto. Dressing,even though I shook it tasted of nothing but oil. I am so sad.​ read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. The food was under cooked. We got chicken wings and they were pink. We were sick all night, (vomiting and diarrhea) the prices are outrageous and it's not worth it. Never again! read more

Best pizza around and best fish fry around. I always get it delivered. Best delivery service too. Try the battered fish Friday night and write a review. Batter is scrumptious. Cooked perfectly! I'll be watching for your review! read more

Thursday August 13, 2020 Tony and I were in the area spending the night in Waterloo, NY. The hotel desk clerk recommended this restaurant and gave us really good directions. We ordered Beer and Pepsi to drink. We ordered a small pizza with Pepperoni, Mozzarella, onions and banana peppers and garlic rolls on the size. The food was okay nothing to get excited about. The waitress was too busy flirting with a couple guys at the bar to be attentive. Never asked if we needed refills on our drinks. It was okay, but when in the area again I will eat somewhere else. read more

See all

Ordered online thin crust with pepperoni and banana peppers. When we got to our hotel it was a thick crust with green peppers! It was stilll delicious! Just sayin you guys blew it! read more

I cannot sing enough praises about this restaurant. We go here often. Service and food are always superb. It's tasty. Visually appealing. Servers care. Check back. Just a great place. You are missing out if you have never been. read more

We came in on a Friday evening after calling hours with some family members and were seated and brought drinks and although the server was outstanding, service was a bit slow, especially for her to initially come to our table. She was sincere and apologized and was adjusting to the new tablets. She also had a very large party and several other tables she was handling on her own. I give her much credit and tipped accordingly. She also explained how she works days at the truck stop and how it's very different. The larger party also consisted of family members and our server was kind enough to compliment how well behaved all of the children were. I relayed the message to their parents and they were so pleased. I ordered the baked haddock special, my son the stuffed shells and my daughter the chicken Marsalo. Everything was wonderful. I was surprised at the cost of soda ($3.50) and desserts seemed pricey as well, but overall... dinner was delicious. We'd been here before and it brought back wonderful memories. read more

Ciccino's Pizzeria - Baked Haddock - Pizza Near Me - Waterloo, New York

See all

We wanted pizza and wings so bad and were a little apprehensive based on the reviews. But let me say we loved their pizza and the honey garlic wings. We ordered the small 14" pizza for the two of us and still had half a pizza to take home. We had a choice of Sicilian style, thick crust--or Neapolitan style, thin crust. We love thin so Neapolitan it was. Our server was friendly and efficient. The wings were hot and juicy, but not greasy. So good! My only con was we weren't offered a drink menu. I wanted wine and asked for a drink menu. She said, " Well what do you want?" I settled for the house red which later I saw was a box wine sitting on the bar. I love my wine and would have probably ordered a nicer Cabernet. I could have insisted to see the me menu, but I didn't. This place is definitely 4 star worthy. Glad we came! Parking on the street is parallel only. Didn't see if they had their own private parking but I imagine they do. read more

See all

This was pretty good! The ambiance ot Ciccino's is lovely, it's a friendly welcoming atmosphere wnd overall grand. The waitress we had was polite, fun, and very helpful! The food was great as well there's just a substantial amount of food to the point where I couldn't finish it! All in all a good experience, thank you for the food! read more

On our first visit, we ordered a pizza in this casual dining restaurant. It was very good and we decided we would come here again on our way back from wine country. We go at least once a year. On our second visit, we stopped in a little earlier, so that we could enjoy a full meal. The hostess, Payton, was a sweetheart. Our server, Crystal, was very attentive and accommodating. I didn't know which wine to order, and she gave me some samples to taste. I ended up ordering a bottle of Cavit Pinot Noir, which was perfect for dinner. Generally, I am not impressed with most restaurant's Italian sauce. Until my husband passed, I used to make my own from scratch from a recipe his mother gave me (which she got from her mother-in-law ). So, when I say, the sauce was amazing, this is unheard of high praise from me. Payton told us that the sauce IS homemade from scratch. I asked if they sold it by the jar, that's how great it was. Unfortunately, that is not an option. I had the Trio Italiano, so that I could taste more than one dish. Everything was delicious and the portions were huge. My friend had the Vodka Rigatoni. It came with the house salad. She really enjoyed hers as well. We both had a lot of leftovers to take home. You can't beat the price either. The total before tip was $67.48. Needless to say, I left a hefty tip for all the wonderful service. read more

Good pizza. We got the pickle pizza and the margarita pizza. Nice crust. We also ordered the garlic knots which I wouldn't recommend, very oily and seemed reheated but cold in the middle. The place was well staffed. read more

Waterloo is my hometown but I moved out West and have not visited for 10yrs. The very first place I wanted was here! NewYork Pizza here I come! My Son picked it up as takeout so I can not comment on how the staff was for that. As always the Pizza was delicious so no complaints in that department. I returned with my best friend for Prime Rib on a Friday Night for Eat In Dinner, prior Prime Rib here has always been the very best in the area as was the staff. Our waitress was not hospitable at all, she took our order, delivered our order and then never checked back until she seen that we were just sitting there no longer eating. It was not even a busy night. The Prime Rib was horrible! It had no flavor at all, no spices, no au-jus. We had Fettuccine as a side and that was delicious. Our bread was cold. Our bill was almost $70.00 and we left half of it on our plates. I returned on Monday with my Son as he was wanting Fettuccine Alfredo and although I was hesitant it was what he wanted so I returned. That meal was much better, we both had Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo and side salad. Our waitress was attentive and my final experience was a good one. So may it was a fluke or just a bad night but I still think when I go home to visit again I will stick with just the pizza. read more

See all

I came from California to visit family in the area. We decided to have dinner here. From the time we stepped inside the door until we left, everyone was friendly and courteous. The food was wonderful and the servings were large. We even took leftovers home. The staff and the owner even handled a difficult situation with grace and dignity. I look forward to my next visit with my family and coming back for another meal. read more

We came for dinner, sat us in the corner, had no drink menu to offer, my husband asked for a drink and he was told he had to wait until they set up a party. He waited and watched as the other table was getting served. He asked again for a refill. Watch as the table after us recived bread. Here we sit waiting. No salad no bread , no service. We will head to the bar in the back next time. FNA best bar in town! read more

See all

Ordered a dozen of chicken wing for takeout in Geneva branch not Waterloo and always love Chicken wings from Cicino but why would I got one wing that looks like somebody has already took a bite with a bit of ranch dressing mixed in my box. It got me sick all evening to think about this and very disappointed and no more chicken wings from Ciccino especially the one in Geneva. read more

One waitress covering the entire restaurant was too busy to meet the needs of all. We ordered the appetizer sampler and glad that's all we ordered. Some of the chicken fingers looked like they had been bitten into by someone. It's possible that they broke in the cooking process but a good chef would never serve those. Overall not a great place based on that. read more

Good for peanut allergy. Our daughter is Ana to peanuts and was able to eat the cheese pizza safely. We are from Buffalo so I'm a little biased on my pizza and wings. The thin crust is decent and the charred bbq wings. Good for food allergy parents visiting the FLX. We read more

Some of the best chicken wings in New York, hands down. I don't even waste time ordering much else. My standard order is a dozen buffalo wings and a couple of the garlic rolls. Simply perfect. There's plenty of space for large groups, and the decor is nice and relaxing. The menu is broad, and the prices are fair. I don't usually make it to dessert, but there are lots of great choices there too. I've been coming here for years, and highly recommend the food. The service is occasionally slow, which is my only reason for the four star review. read more

Ciccino's Pizzeria - Mild Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Waterloo, New York

I got a pizza from this place tonight and it was absolutely amazing. The service was extraordinary. Each member of the waitstaff made me feel welcome. Counter and pizza looked like it ran efficiently. Congrats to the whole staff and establishment read more

Great small town Italian restaurant! The atmosphere was welcoming. The baked ziti was delicious and the portions are generous. Definitely a place I would return to when we come back! read more

Some things are good but we usually have some type of problem with the food when we have it delivered and the prices are ridiculous.

Everyone has their own personal "favorite" pizza. This definitely wasn't my favorite, but it might be yours. What really got me was the price. $4.54 for 1 slice of chicken wing pizza. The price is reason enough for me NOT to go back. But maybe you think it's worth it. Who knows til ya give it a try. read more

Classy place with incredible food! If you want a terrific lunch on the way up to Niagara Falls this is the place to stop!

I stopped here for dinner with my husband and son for the sole reason that we were passing through Waterloo on a Monday night after a long road trip, and were so famished that we vowed to eat at the first open restaurant we came upon. We ordered drinks, an appetizer sampler (choice of 3 out of several options -- we did fried mozzarella, onion rings and calamari), a large pizza for the guys, and greens 'n beans for me. The restaurant was clean and cozy, with semi-rustic decor and an attractive stone fireplace. Our server was friendly and attentive. She memorized our order rather than writing it down, which always makes me nervous especially when the order is complicated by things like pizza toppings, but everything came out just as ordered. The appetizers were cooked to crispy perfection (no rubbery calamari, exploded mozzarella or burnt onion rings) and arrived to the table quickly. My greens 'n beans were billed as an inexpensive side dish, but the portion was huge, and it arrived with several pieces of unadvertised crusty bread that were perfect for soaking up the broth. My husband and son enjoyed their pizza (half for dinner, half for breakfast the next morning) and found it on par with our favorite hometown pizza place. Overall, an excellent experience! read more

The food was excellent, but the staff was even better! My husband and I had been sampling as many wineries as was feasible during our 24-hour pass through Waterloo, and the bar tender and our server both helped me find just one more local wine to try (it was delicious!). Both were very personable and we enjoyed the relaxing atmosphere. My husband and I both got soup and salads, and they were prepared with fresh ingredients and really hit the spot! read more

I ordered a steak salad for $20.95, requested it be cooked medium rare. It arrived with the meat being completely cooked and gray, like it had been boiled in water. I would've been embarrassed to send that out as a chef so my assumption is that they really don't give a damn. Didn't say anything because I didn't want to make a fuss and our group had time restraints. read more

Stopped on for a quick lunch. Antipasto and pizza. Antipasto was very good. Better than others I have had. You know it's a decent Italian place when you don't have to ask for the Parmesan cheese for the antipasti. Pizza was really good. A small mushroom and sausage pie. Good crust. They use a nice dough. It's all in the dough for a good pie. read more