Honestly, I have never had better pizza than I had tonight! I am a garlic lover and the sausage and salamis were just perfection on the Cirellos special. We just don't feel like you can do better in Corvallis for pizza! We have been coming here since it opened but tonight's pizza surpassed all others. read more

Good pizza but the wait is horrific. This is the third time and it was not a charm. We waited for over 1 and 20 minutes for our pizza

So tasty! Happy hour is a great deal on beer and cider! The Rinz is my favorite pizza!

Best pizza I've ever had. I don't get the bad reviews. The pesto sauce is amaze! And they have roasted red peppers that are made authentic Italian style. Love love love love love love read more

Cirello's Pizza has a friendly atmosphere as soon as you walk in the door. Great pizza.can taste the quality.

Great pizza. Love that the deliver outside of Corvallis. They don't skimp on the toppings, the crust and sauce are great. A definite favorite!! read more

Great pizza. We got 3 different pizzas and they were all good. Call in order was ready on time. Friendly staff. Will most definitely be coming back. read more

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!!!!!!! everyone that works here is super cool and they take time to meticulously craft the perfect pizza experience.

Best lunch special on spaghetti! Friendly staff and good beer on tap plus I'm watching sports. It doesn't get any better!

Great pizza with fresh toppings. Reasonable price. Staying at a hotel, they deliver.

I really liked the salad bar and pizza square special. The pizza square came with 2 toppings, I got broccoli and feta. The broccoli was plentiful but it could have used more feta. the salad bar was small but full of everything I liked, I even discovered that pineapple on a salad is pretty awesome! The regular pizza I tried wasn't amazing but it was good enough to come back. read more

Best pizza in town, with provisos: the crust is, and has always been, unpredictable. Often soggy. It has the best flavor of any pizza joint in town's crust, but depending on the toppings chosen (beware the mushrooms and peppers! Aiiiieee!) and the length of time the pie is left in the box, you may end up with a squashy mess. HEARSAY TIME: I have heard the owner is lax about his "organic and local" ingredient claim. Not cool if so. But unless things have changed drastically, they still make their dough and sauces from scratch, with nothing synthetic or pre-packaged used. You can't say that about most places these days. Despite the "crust sog" factor, if I order pizza from anyplace in Corvallis, Cirello's is the only place I'll call. read more

In fairness the pizza deserves 5 stars, but the rest of the operation is such a letdown that others should be warned before making the same mistake. read more

My favorite pizza place in town. It gets docked a star though because they only do delivery after 5pm. I have yet to eat at the restaurant, but the pizza is some of the best I've ever had. The staff aren't super friendly, but not to the point that they're rude. read more

Very nice people, great pizza. I like the fact the pizza is consistently delicious. It's never hit or miss-it's always spot on and great! The staff always make us feel welcome. My child has autism (dining out can be hard for ASD families) but we feel comfortable and welcome at Cirello's. read more

Best pizza In town. A large Wiley's, Add fresh tomatoes is the perfect pizza. Great place.

I have eaten in almost every pizza house in Corvallis, and Cirello's is by far the best there is!!! The people are always very friendly there and helpful and the pizza is always hot and fresh crust. They have so many different varities to chose from and will make any combination you want. They also have a great salad bar and now offer pasta dishes that taste like homemade. And I am a full blooded Italian!!!! I would recommend Cirello's to anybody that lives in Corvallis and wants a great pizza or pasta. You will go back again and again read more

Ever since Cirello's moved to a new owner, things have been looking up. The pizza is obviously great, the lasagne (though for the lazy) is amazing. What a deal on Saturdays! The only thing that could make this place better is if it can grow. Let's see a Cirello's in Albany, in Salem, even in Portland! read more

it's really perfect place to eat Pizza and there're plenty of pizza kinds and Salad. Also people who work there are great and nice.

The pizza was fantastic at this location. The prices are higher than other pizza places but the sizes are huge in comparison plus the quality of the ingredients are much better. Staff were pleasant as well; no complaints. read more

Flavor good, delivery time acceptable, crust - like wet felt. After refrigerating and putting individual slices in the toaster oven, crust got crispy and good. But right out of the box, expect all your toppings to be in your lap! read more

After reading some posittive review, we gave this place the very first try last time. We ordered Pineapple Express medium. That was really good. Good flavor, good crust, and good topping combination. We enjoyed our order a lot until today we reheat the three slices of leftover pizza. My son found a hair mixed in the sausage. That was really yucky! Really disgusting! We hope we could have seen that hair before we ate it! Wear your hair net when you bake! We don't like any extra flavor Please! read more

I know that I'm spoiled by the east coast, but if someone is going to say their pizza is "New York style," you would expect they would deliver a better crust. read more

My family has tried nearly all the pizza places in Corvallis and this one definitely takes the crust. Great pizza crust and sauce and they don't skimp on the toppings. We eagerly look forward to our return. read more

Continue to please! While American Dream makes some wonderful pizza the RJC from Cirellos is the best pizza in Corvallis.

My fiance and I went there today. We had terrible service. Despite the fact we were the only people in there and we were happy find our favorite beer on tap, the person taking our order wanted nothing to do with us. We ordered the lunch special with a mini pizza and salads. Shortly after sitting down with our salads he informs us the oven was never turned on that day, so unless we want to wait an additional 40 min just to get it heated up, he was going to refund our money. Sorry no pizza...at a pizza place! Well...okay, but we are hungry. Do you have any thing else? Did I have to ask? geez... We decided we would share some pasta. Spaghetti with meat sauce. Nothing special let me tell you. The only reason I'm giving them any stars at all, is because they have our favorite beer on tap, and the pizza is decent which I know from previous visits. I just wish I could get some better service... I don't even feel welcome when I go in there. read more

I though the salad bar was refillable, but according to the brusque man making the pizza it isn't. So I paid almost four dollars for the smallest bowl I've ever seen in my entire life. It was less than half a cup of salad, I seriously thought they were joking when they said you could only go through once. We won't be going back ever again! read more

I think Cirello's is the best pizza place in Corvallis (this is declared after extensive taste testing). I really like the crust and the sauce, which is a little spicy and definitely not one note like most pizza sauces. They also have a great toppings selection. I usually prefer customizing my toppings but I actually like the suggested pies at Cirello's, especially The Rinz. I've only gotten take out so I can't speak to the atmosphere or service, but the cashier and whoever answers the phone are friendly. read more

Customer service is horrible! Ordered delivery explained the location Comfort suites (Albany) "guy say's no problem we deliver there all the time it will take about 45 minutes and the cost is also 45.00. So we wait almost 45 minutes to the tee. The phone rings the guy says I'm knocking on your room and no one is answering. We tell the guy try again we are here and we are hungry. A couple minutes later the phone rings my wife answers my wife ask are you sure you at the right location so she repeats the guy says we don't deliver there. So after hanging up we call the actual business and my explains the guy who took the order said no problem. This time the guy says oh, he must have made a mistake. That's it no apologies nothing just a basic suck it! read more

I cannot get enough of Cirello's pizza. My husband and I used to eat here ten years ago when we were students at OSU, even though it wasn't really a college hangout, and it still isn't, but we think the pizza is the best in town. Whenever we are back in town and in the mood for pizza, this is our go-to. We used to order a Foghorn with pepperoni and would wake up still tasting garlic the next morning (a good thing in my opinion!) Now we usually order the Rinz and add bacon- the bacon is nice slices rather than bits, the herb-salted crust is amazing, and the generous scoops of fresh ricotta are a delicious texture. The prices are a little high for pizza, but I feel like the quality can't be beat and is worth the premium. Their happy hour prices are also the best in town and they have a great selection of local beers (and 2 Towns Cider!). read more

I got a mushrooms and olive calzone and for the time I took to eat it everything was right with the world. Perfectly cooked, just the right amount of fillings and cheese. It was only $8.50 and fed me for two meals. I got it to go and everybody was cool during my interactions, and it was ready literally to the minute they'd said it would be. Place is dated but I was there for the food. read more

Bad pizza, unless you really like Papa John's. Nothing original here. Really deserves a one star but Yelp won't allow me to post it.

Tastiest pizza in town. I like a three topping of Sun Dried Tomatoes, Onions, and Provalone Cheese, while my wife prefers The Ventian (kalamata olives, green olives, feta, chopped tomatoes). Tasty "medium" thickness crust --heftier than "New York Style" but not "Deep Dish", "Chicago Style" or "Sicilian" -- with good flavor. Specials five nights of the week (not Friday or Saturday). They deliver. A few good beers on tap, a few in bottle. Friendly service. Pity they're in an anonymous strip center. read more

Yucky pizza. If you've ever had Pizza Mondo or Cibellis Pizza from Bend, you know what 'NY style pizza' should be. This place is severely lacking in flavor and quality. Soggy, nasty pie was delivered. Yuck. read more

my gosh this place is slow!! went in on a Sat evening without a big crowd present, and it took an hour for the order to arrive. ok taste and all, but expensive and slow made this my last visit ever this establishment. read more